Ignore the posturing, the Ashes really starts in a week’s time

By Paul / Roar Guru

Much has been made about the preparation England and Australia have undertaken for the upcoming Ashes series, but the reality is this is rubbish.

England pundits claim they have an advantage because they’ve played 18 Tests over the past couple of years and have forged a squad capable of winning in Australia.

The reality is their batsmen, apart from Joe Root, have made little progress in terms of their development, they’ve lost fast bowlers critical to their plans through injury and they have no settled spinner.

Australia, on the other hand, have not played any Tests since that series against India. Once again, many point out this is a negative in terms of preparation.

But with a settled side, bar two or three positions, I question whether more Test cricket was required, especially given the quarantine conditions that forced Ben Stokes to take a sabbatical from the game.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

So both teams need to ignore all the posturing that’s taken place until now and concentrate on getting themselves 100 per cent ready for the first Test, which begins in less than five weeks.

England are aiming to have two intra-squad matches before the first Test and there’s no doubt all of their likely Ashes batsmen will benefit.

For all the Tests they’ve played under Chris Silverwood, none have been on wickets remotely like Australian pitches – maybe with the exception of the South African series, but that was soon after the Ashes in 2019.

Most of the Test squad haven’t played red-ball cricket since early September, so again, they’ll welcome the chance to get some solid centre-wicket practice.

Bear in mind too, these practice matches will be the only games England will play before the first Test.

Ben Stokes (Gareth Copley/Getty Images)

Sure, everyone will focus on Ben Stokes’ return, but the Australian brains trust should be more concerned about how Haseeb Hameed, Rory Burns and Dawid Malan look.

They in turn will want to adapt their techniques to the higher bounce and less pronounced ball movement.

In the other camp, talk about an Australian possibles/probables game emerged. This was a critical element in Australia’s Ashes defence in 2019, so it makes sense to try the same approach again, especially given the disrupted year Australian cricket has faced.

I want to talk about those players who would benefit the most from this match the most and what I think needs to happen if this game takes place.

Tim Paine, the skipper, needs to first of all prove he’s fully fit and that means keeping wicket for as long as possible, both to the quicks and to the spinner.

Tim Paine (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

I also think he needs to get his captaincy head back in the game. It’s been a while since he actually had to make any on-field decisions and it would be good to make sure he’s sharp for the first Test.

On this forum alone, there are many who are questioning whether David Warner should be in the team, given his average run in the T20 World Cup.

He needs to take the pressure off himself by playing against the Australian attack and playing at least one long innings, i.e. more than an hour.

I also want to see the right-arm bowlers going around the wicket and really testing him out, just as Stuart Broad and co will do.

I’m sure the GOAT Nathan Lyon would be the first to admit he had a poor series against India and again, there are more than a few people asking whether he is still a force in the attack.

He needs to bowl a lot of overs with Pat Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc, to get back in the groove he enjoyed a couple of summers ago.

(Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

He’s a much better bowler when working in tandem with all of these guys. A large part of the reason why he’s not been at his best is because he’s not had them at the other end.

Marcus Harris, Bryce Street, Usman Khawaja or even Joe Burns – I have no clue which way the selectors will go with the other opener, but they need to see how candidates can bat with Dave Warner.

I’m a strong believer in batting partnerships, so selectors need to see Warner bat with the guy they think will likely open in the first Test.

I don’t think it matters too much how many runs are scored, but they must look comfortable at the crease and at ease batting together.

All other players will benefit from a hit out, but not necessarily in this type of match.

Steve Smith, for example, could simply play a Shield game to get his mind back on red-ball batting.

Others like Travis Head, Cameron Green and Marnus Labuschagne have already shown selectors enough to make a call on their positions, so selectors would not expect to gain a lot more insights from their participation.

As I said earlier, both squads need to forget about what’s gone on since they last met in an Ashes series and focus on getting everything exactly right for the game at the Gabba.

The team that wins that Test will gain an enormous advantage leading into the Adelaide and Melbourne games, so the lead-up matches these squads will play could well determine the outcome of the series.

The Crowd Says:

2021-11-05T01:57:39+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Yes. I was going to add, being forced to bowl a tight line is exactly what Starc in particular needs. One Red ball game for the quicks for the First Test will be enough. Five Tests in 6 and a bit weeks is going to be quite a workload. Which ones do you think can play in every Test?

2021-11-05T01:51:58+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


I think this T20 gallop might be just what they need. They are steaming in and bowling against some good batters, and mostly bowling test match lines and length. Never bowling more than 2 overs on the go. Very intense and high pressure situation, but no meaningful consequence. Rest for a couple of days then go bang. Haze especially looks cherry ripe. It's unconventional. But so (at the time) was Saintly grinding all spring in distance races like the Metrop then just cruising to the Cup after a stroll in the Cox Plate. If the miles are in the legs...

AUTHOR

2021-11-05T01:38:13+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


There's a bit of politics at play as well though. Australia has something of an obligation to send it's best players to tournaments like this. Our problem is that some of our best white ball players are also some of our better Test players. England don't have that problem, but both India & New Zealand do. All that said, guys at this level don't need a lot of innings to get their heads back into red ball mode. Totally different if the team was playing overseas, but coming home to Australia, they should be okay if they can get a a Shield game and an inter-squad practice match under their belts. I still think there's time for tjem to get

2021-11-05T01:26:42+00:00

DTM

Roar Rookie


NSW are now playing their 2nd game of the season and likely to have one more before the first test. That would have meant that Smith, Warner and Cummins could have had a few decent red ball hit outs before the Ashes. These 3 players are crucial to our Ashes campaign but not really that important to Australia in the hit and giggle cup.

2021-11-05T01:26:05+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Yes, I remember, no sixes, but anything out of the middle was either 1 or 4.

2021-11-05T01:20:40+00:00

DTM

Roar Rookie


I played at Moore Park (years and years ago). Not sure if it's the same now but then you weren't allowed to hit 6's. I scored 93 with 19 x 4's.

2021-11-04T07:10:51+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Actually my comment was meant for the Warne article Paul. But I was going to say that you may have a very good point that lots of cricket in biobubbles etc may not necessarily be a plus for England, or rather, the Aussies may be a bit fresher.

2021-11-04T07:07:15+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


I see that Harris ranked 6th in the County averages last season among those that played more than just a handful of games. I really don’t think strike rates are important for an opener. Don’t feel too confident about him, but those are promising numbers.

AUTHOR

2021-11-04T04:47:46+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


In one way India did themselves a favour by playing this "C" lineup. They were forced to give guys a game who they normally wouldn't have played and I think their success caught the Indian selectors by surprise. Sure they might have been Test match novices, but they were still quality cricketers, a fact most have continued to show in the Tests after that series.

2021-11-04T04:41:26+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


yes you could pretty much bank on him looking good getting to 20 (like Wade with 30) and then get caught nicking so credit where credit's due

AUTHOR

2021-11-04T04:33:28+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


"he (Warner) should be shown the curb and possibly have his test contract torn up." A tad harsh don't you think? In any event, the contracts Warner has is with Cricket Australia to play any form of cricket for a national team. All they have to do is leave him out of Test XI's then make a decision whether to renew his contract mid 2022. I also think you might need to clean that crystal ball of yours, Frank. Moeen Ali had a shocking tour of Australia 4 years ago and I don't think Leach will do a lot better. The poor guy hasn't played a Test since India which suggests the selector, Root or both have no faith in him. If Australia is 2 down come Boxing Day, I fail to see why the selectors would not make changes. Contrary to popular belief, no position in the team is sacred, especially when the Ashes is on the line. I can see Bailey easily putting guys out because he needs to show he isn't playing favourites. Thankfully we know this won't be Australia's problem but will be a huge issue for Root & Silverwood.

2021-11-04T04:13:45+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Batsmen-wise (top 6) it's really only Warner and Smith with the long break? Paine obviously has an injury break. Bowler-wise, breaks are good. Aus T20 bowlers probably need a good 10 days off, then a couple of innings + nets should see them right.

2021-11-04T03:32:23+00:00

Frank delosa

Guest


Hmmmm agree. The squad for the first 2 tests will be picked. On the law of averages, it means Warner and Starc will be picked. Fair enough but if they fail, particuarly Warner, he should be shown the curb and possibly have his test contract torn up. Paine will play the whole series regardless. He will be accentuate the poor batting by coming in when a captains knock is needed and end up needling a cheap 5-10 runs. Leach will dominate him time and again. If Mooen Ali (including hipster lumberjack beard) were still playing he would do it too. When AUS are sitting at 0-2 heading into boxing day expect the gloves to be off (pun intended) and no one will be safe from the selectors wrath. Problem here is that Bailey is too much of a good bloke to drop his pals from days of yore (Warner and co.). Enjoy the summer for it will be the farewell tour of Warner, Paine, Langer and possibly Starc.

2021-11-04T03:14:32+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Some first class b&st&rds. Brawls, needles and gravel were all common there in the 80s and 90s.

2021-11-04T03:09:05+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


I think it’s about time people like Warne stop saying that Australia lost to India’s C team last season. Five of the top six batsmen in Brisbane played against England or NZ in the Test Championship final (Rohit, Gill, Pujara, Rahane and Pant). The sixth, Agarwal has a Test average over 45. Two of the bowlers, Siraj and Thakur, played in India’s latest Test vs England. Sundar played a Test or two vs England in India. Of the remaining two, Saini is probably of B team standard and only Natarajan might be in the Cs.

2021-11-04T03:02:08+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Although he was at #3 most innings - but close enough to opening. But more to the point, when being dismissed after making big runs and time into the innings, still the same types of dismissal, so yes, clearly he's getting runs without taking risks through the air - or at least if in the air, doing it safely. And as you say, not getting out as he was in early Test days. I haven't seen any of his innings, but presumably the selectors/JL are across the analytics.

AUTHOR

2021-11-04T02:49:11+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I think Harris modes of dismissal is pretty much what I'd expect from an opening batsman. In theory, they're the ones most likely to face the toughest conditions, certainly in Australia, ie day 1 pitches, new ball, fresh bowlers,etc. What's nice with those numbers is, he's not getting out caught in that area behind point, which was a huge problem for him when he first came into Test cricket. Remember how often he'd get a start then throw it away with a slash into the offside. Ditto with Travis Head.

AUTHOR

2021-11-04T02:45:11+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


"This could be a silly comment, but Australia’s possibles/probables game could turn out to be hugely important in the context of the Ashes." Not in the slightest Astro. I genuinely think this is the critical game of the summer. The selectors will choose the Test squad, most likely for the first two Tests, based on that match, plus what ever form lines they think appropriate. Get it right, we're in good shape. Get it wrong..... I agree Warner might be a problem to replace but not so sure about Paine. If he has an ordinary first couple of Tests, I think the selectors can quietly suggest he announces his retirement. That way he can go out with dignity intact. Of course, that would depend on him agreeing to retire. It would get ugly if he's playing poorly and has to be dropped.

AUTHOR

2021-11-04T02:33:07+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


hi Peter, personally I'm a real fan of the long break for the players. We both know this Ashes series will be a huge mental pressure exercise and the strongest physically and mentally will have a distinct edge.

2021-11-04T02:30:57+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


One of the guys in our public service team was the only completely ambidextrous people I've ever seen. Could bat, bowl, throw (write, play tennis, etc) equally well with either arm. He once announced to the umpire mid-over - "changing to right-handed batting". The look on the bowler's face (a leggie) was priceless.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar