If England call stumps early, it's time to revive Australia A

By David Holden / Roar Guru

If a humbling Ashes defeat in Melbourne wasn’t enough, England also have to deal with a COVID outbreak within their squad. At this stage, their tour from hell continues.

However, if their COVID cases spread further within the extended squad, enough may finally be enough.

Sydney and Hobart cricket fans would rightfully be upset. However, after over 25 years in the wilderness, it could be time to bring back Australia versus Australia A.

In the summer of 1994-95, the Benson and Hedges one-day series (how times have changed) featured Australia, England, Zimbabwe and Australia A. As it would happen, Australia and Australia A took part in the best-of-three final.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

In England and Zimbabwe’s defence, both Australian teams had more than a handy line-up.

A top six of Michael Slater, Mark Taylor, the Waugh brothers, David Boon and Stuart Law featured in the Australian team.

Ian Healy was behind the stumps and two of Australia’s best bowlers, Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath, were also in the national one-day line-up.

They would go on to beat Australia A 2-0 in the final series, as you would expect.

However, Australia A unearthed some players that went on to much bigger and brighter things. Matt Hayden, Justin Langer, Ricky Ponting and Michael Bevan all had long careers for Australia.

(Photo by Hamish Blair/Getty Images)

Of course, if England were to pull up stumps early, there would be some issues with BBL rescheduling. It may be easier and perhaps more logical to just release the Australian Test players back into the BBL.

However, so that we could experience two more Test matches, which should be higher quality, we should be pushing for Australia versus Australia A in Sydney and Hobart.

Australia A beat the England Lions earlier in December. The line-up was:
Bryce Street
Henry Hunt
Matt Renshaw
Nic Maddinson
Usman Khawaja
Mitchell Marsh
Josh Inglis
Michael Neser
Mark Steketee
Mitchell Swepson
Scott Boland

It’s a strong XI. Street and Hunt are both young batters with big futures in front of them.

I also highly rate Matt Renshaw and he was very unlucky to be dropped from the Test team in the first place.

Khawaja and Maddinson have been scoring plenty of runs at Shield level and Mitchell Marsh, in his current form, would score plenty of runs in any format.

Josh Inglis was close to beating Alex Carey to the vacant keeper position at the Gabba, while Neser and Boland have both experienced Test success this summer.

At the risk of alienating every Victorian I know, I still don’t think Boland’s 6-7 gets him a spot in Australia’s best XI. It does however underline Australia’s depth.

(Photo by Daniel Pockett – CA/Cricket Australia via Getty Images)

Jhye Richardson probably knocks out Mark Steketee and Mitchell Swepson will get a taste of Test action in the near future, quite possibly in Pakistan.

This is a side that would beat a number of international teams and England would likely be included within that bracket.

Would they beat Australia?

George Bailey would certainly hope not and I’m sure he would be right. Australia would win, but we’d be unlikely to see any matches finish within seven sessions.

Like most Australians, I’d like to see England get through the next two Tests and show a lot more fight, although the 5-0 result is still appealing.

If the worst-case scenario happens though, and one or both of the remaining Tests are cancelled, you could do a lot worse than revive a once-used concept.

The Crowd Says:

2021-12-31T16:09:20+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


In the test team over Starc, Hazlewood, Cummins and Pattinson? Nah

2021-12-31T16:08:15+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


All those guys you name aren’t openers. Street is

2021-12-31T16:01:26+00:00

Gee

Roar Rookie


Only expect the Australia vs Australia A concept to come back if the later white ball matches vs NZ & SL are cancelled. Non Foxtel viewers are very much a secondary concern to CA.

2021-12-31T00:26:21+00:00

ColinT

Roar Rookie


“ At the risk of alienating every Victorian I know, I still don’t think Boland’s 6-7 gets him a spot in Australia’s best XI” Hey, don’t worry about alienating us, we’re used to it. It is easier to get a camel through the eye of a needle than a Victorian into the test team. No matter how good. By the way, Boland won the 2018-2019 Sheffield Shield player of the year with an average of 19.66. So his current performance is not a flash in the pan. He would probably have been in the test side years ago if he came from NSW. You know it’s true.

2021-12-30T23:48:13+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


That's why AMD's the Big 2 v Little Guys is a good resolution. It gives a clear demarcation for supporters and has a number of current test players in both sides.

2021-12-30T23:27:11+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


My New Holland test XI: 1. Henry Hunt 2. Bryce Street 3. Marnus Labuschagne 4. Sam Whiteman 5. Cameron Green 6. Travis Head 7. Alex Carey 8. Jack Wildermuth 9. Michael Neser 10. Jhye Richardson 11. Mitch Swepson

2021-12-30T23:23:23+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Agreed to makeup of the Australia A team could easily be up for grabs, but the basic concept's right.

2021-12-30T21:39:59+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


My dream. NSW & Vic have always disdained the smaller states. ——- Imagine the tests between the two. And SA & WA would get in behind Qld with RL and vice-@-versa with AF. Ofc we’d have Tas and NT. The little guys strike back.

2021-12-30T14:08:16+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


Phillipe, Jewell,Ward and Cartwright are doing better than Street. Averaging high forties. Slot them in.

2021-12-30T05:38:33+00:00

Short Arm

Roar Rookie


Won't happen unfortunately as the selectors would veto it, as it could get a bit embarassing for all. As what happened all those years ago, the likes of Hayden & Langer showed up Tubby & Slater. Also, the crowd cheered more for the A's.

2021-12-30T00:34:08+00:00

Linphoma

Guest


At least the fixtures would be competitive.

2021-12-29T23:21:04+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


Trouble is, they wouldn't be official test matches, but there is a potential solution. Queensland, WA and SA - the states who provided the bulk of the most recent Australia A team - secede from the Commonwealth, with the ICC to hastily ratify the new test playing nation of New Holland. I mean it wouldn't be that different to how it's worked for the last two years and New Holland could always rejoin the Commonwealth later, although WA might take some persuading. :happy:

2021-12-29T22:33:51+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I think this is a great suggestion David. it makes sense for all manner of reasons. If England withdraws thanks to covid, Cricket Australia would be down tens of millions in lost revenue from all sources. Cricket fans, especially in Australia would miss their yearly dose of Test cricket, but a couple of games against an in-form team like Australia A would keep us interested & happy. The Test team also doesn't have any more Test cricket till the Pakistan tour in March and we've seen what can happen with guys who aren't playing red ball cricket regularly. And.... it gives us all a chance to look at the next wave of potential Australian players. Hopefully they have as good careers as the guys you named from that Aussie A side in the '90's.

Read more at The Roar