FLEM’S VERDICT: Cummins will learn from declaration error but rain was reason Aussies didn’t win Test

By Bowlologist / Expert

Pat Cummins is still learning the ropes of being captain and I’m sure he will regret declaring a little bit late but that wasn’t the reason Australia lost the fourth Test.

Cummins was superb on day five with his bowling changes, his DRS reviews and his own performance. Those two in-swinging deliveries which got rid of Jos Buttler and Mark Wood were insane.

As I wrote after day four, I thought it was “an unnecessarily late declaration” to wait those few extra overs after Usman Khawaja got his century but if we had good weather throughout this Test, I think the Australians would have won comfortably.

We lost seven overs due to wet weather today and that would have been enough to get the job done.

The coach, Justin Langer, would have had a say in the declaration as well but Cummins will learn from this. It’s another experience for him to go through.

What I found really exciting was that we got a glimpse for the first time with a fast-bowling captain that with the game on the line, we had someone who could grab the ball and win the game for his team with his bowling.

He doesn’t normally swing the ball too much because seam movement is his strength and he doesn’t get too many LBWs because he doesn’t bowl full enough but those two batters – Buttler and Wood – had zero chance against that kind of delivery.

When the game was in the balance, he stepped up and almost got us over the line.

All in all, another tick for Patty, I reckon.

Even though he had to miss a Test himself and Josh Hazlewood only played the series opener, the fast bowling cartel stocks have risen this series with Scott Boland, Jhye Richardson and Michael Neser emerging.

Boland could almost win player of the series. He’s equal third on the wicket-taking list despite only playing two Tests with 14 scalps at 8.64, one behind Mitchell Starc and another from first-placed Nathan Lyon. If he takes another bag I could see him ending up with the Compton-Miller Medal around his neck to go with the Johnny Mullagh one he received after his debut at the Boxing Day Test on his home deck in Melbourne.

He’s Bowlo the Bowling Machine. You set him on the same length at 135km/h and just watch him hit the same spot over and over again with just enough seam to worry the batters.

At 32, he reminds me a lot of Stuart Clark who also had to wait a long time before he got his chance at Test level and then thrived for a few years because he had a lot of experience under his belt.

He also had a bouncy, accurate stock ball and if you’ve got that, you’re going to get wickets at Test level.

Lyon didn’t quite bowl us to victory but I like that quicker ball he’s developed – he got Ben Stokes in the first innings with it and it skidded through to dismiss Dawid Malan today, rolling out up to 10km/h faster.

I’m not sure if Starc is going to be right for the fifth Test, he’s looking a bit tired and if Richardson is over his shin problem, then you’ve got a readymade replacement.

It’s not often as a fast bowler that you get to play all five Tests and in a condensed schedule like this, it might be better to rest him but Starcy has earned the right to decide himself whether he thinks he’s not cooked.

Wait until a day or two before the game and ask him what he reckons. He was player of the series in the live Tests before this one but he wasn’t at his best in Sydney.

Cam Green backed up his 74 yesterday with another promising effort with the ball. His yorker to get rid of Zak Crawley was a beauty.

Wow. Just when you think what else has he got, he pulls out a fast in-swinging yorker.

Alex Carey dropped another one so it seems he must have some sort of technical issue when he dives away to his right but we’ve got a few subcontinent tours to find out more about him. He’s a sweeper with the bat so I think he will do well over there batting at seven.

For England they’ve got to find a replacement for Jos Buttler who’s going home with his busted hand. You can’t play Haseeb Hameed so unless they want to bring Rory Burns back in, they might as well move Malan up to opener so they can find room for Ollie Pope and Sam Billings.

Pope brought a lot of energy and enthusiasm when he subbed in as wicketkeeper in the second innings and Billings has been brought into the squad so you might as well give him a go with the gloves and see what you’ve got with him now that you’ve done that.

Crawley looks like he could be a find for them with his 77. He didn’t let the Aussie bowlers dictate play to him, Like Stokes and Bairstow in the first innings, he looked to score against them. They’re too good to keep waiting and waiting for bad balls because you could be waiting all day.

You’re not going to wear them down so you have to manufacture some aggression if you’re going to get runs against them.

England can be proud with the fight they displayed to save the game.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2022-01-11T11:48:29+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Ok.

2022-01-11T11:02:56+00:00

Capt Jack

Roar Rookie


Carey is a batsman wicket keeper in that order - he definitely ain’t the drummer in the band ????

2022-01-10T22:40:26+00:00

Andrew

Guest


This is not white ball. On an up and down fifth day pitch - 2 new balls available. History of test cricket does not lie. Also factor in this batting line up.

2022-01-10T21:53:58+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


good call, I'd forgotten that.

2022-01-10T13:27:48+00:00

Capt Jack

Roar Rookie


I agree it was the missed chances not the timing of the declaration however the fumbled take by Carey from Lyons throw into his gloves at the base of the stumps that had Barstow well out of his ground also needs to be mentioned.

2022-01-10T11:05:40+00:00

Rob

Guest


Not really fair to compare Lyon to Indian spinners but for instance Ashwin has taken 5 or more in an innings 30 times from 83 Tests. Then you can say in the right conditions on day 5 a half decent finger spinner like Border 7/46, Clarke 6/9, Root 5/8 can clean up? Lyon just hasn’t got it in him and I’m not sure he has learned any tricks or situational smarts to take wickets.

2022-01-10T10:35:35+00:00

Rossi

Roar Rookie


If only Punter had Pups tactical mind or vice versa. Chappelli was before my time, AB was captain when I started following cricket as a kid.

2022-01-10T09:50:40+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Like people who own boats can't ride bikes, People who can't spin leg spin off

2022-01-10T09:09:44+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


Ah well...........perhaps it all came down to a sticky bail earlier in the game.

2022-01-10T09:08:19+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


As it was though - with all the damp weather conditions - the pitch wasn't breaking up so for Lyon is was going to rely on bounce and......the one going straight on? I felt the choice to bring back Starc to blast them out was slightly wishful thinking and reeked of impatience...........rather than 'relentless process'. Boland had got through Bairstow and was only given one over after that..........the irony is it feels like he's the leader of the attack right now. It's interesting when things play out in real time but as both Cummins and Starc have appeared tire and look ragged in this game - - the emergence of Boland has arguably come at the best possible time.

2022-01-10T08:46:11+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Good point.

2022-01-10T08:28:15+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


Theres a reason players don’t get to decide if they’re playing or not

2022-01-10T07:05:25+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


I'm extending to him the same chances as Pat.

2022-01-10T06:36:20+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


@DingoGray: I thought he’s kept quite well to Lyon this series, but they’re likely to spit up a bit more on some sub-continent pitches, so it will be interesting how he goes there. If the pace of the fast bowlers is an issue for him, perhaps he’ll have some reprieve in Asia where the ball holds up a bit more.

2022-01-10T06:19:12+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Yes, but by this stage of your career, with this many matches behind you, your not likely to be improving your skills much further as a keeper. I don't know whether part of the issue with his drops and not going for them is the pace of the bowlers he's facing consistently? I don't imagine he would have kept to too many 135kph+ bowlers for South Australia? Chadd Sayers wouldn't crack 130? He will have in short form for Australia, but that's a different beast in terms of the way the bowlers bowl; certainly can be more focused on being balanced to go to the off side as not much is targeted towards leg side.

2022-01-10T06:12:42+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


And the reasons why they are not in my Top 5 Post WWII.

2022-01-10T06:06:40+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Tests are, well, tests. They're the pinnacle (but l know you know this)

2022-01-10T06:03:29+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


That'll give him time between the close of his innings and before keeping to solve world peace.

2022-01-10T05:32:29+00:00

badmanners

Roar Rookie


He could open as well.

2022-01-10T05:18:58+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


This total doesn't include scores over 300 to draw, tie or lose. Which is about another 50 instances.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar