Titanic Tahs and Reds derby begets a sentimental haze

By Matt Cleary / Expert

Once upon a time (it was 1976) there was a trippy, Italian claymation TV program for kids called ‘Il Rosso e Il Blu’ – ‘The Red and the Blue’ – in which a pair of shapeshifters made of clay would turn themselves into things and kill each other, at least temporarily.

And it remains, even today, a fairly funny bit of kit whether you’re seven or 37, and you might Google it for light entertainment purposes at your earliest convenience.

Saturday night’s Super Rugby Pacific round six fixture between ancient enemies NSW Waratahs and Queensland Reds felt vaguely similar for a Brumbies fan without a dog in the fight.

It loomed as an opportunity to be mildly entertained. It loomed as a chance to stroke one’s goat beard about implications for the first XXIII of Wallabies who’ll trot out against England on July 9.’

And it loomed as a chance to deride the walk-up starts NSW players appear to have into Wallabies jumpers, whatever their team’s ladder position, which is always good sport for ACTRU types for those blood oaths run deep. As the Mandalorian would tell you: this is the way. Even if – or even especially if – it’s bullshit.

But all that, er, stroking was out the window Saturday night when Queensland and NSW showed that 140-year-old ties run deep, too.

For this was no ‘trial’ – and it was more than mildly entertaining. Indeed it was a fine bit of kit – fast, hard, for sheep stations.

And by the end of the match, won 32-20 by Queensland, this Old Boy was feeling good, even sentimental not just for Australian rugby but for the greater game itself.

Pre-match that fickle mistress La Niña hurled great slabs of white water at Suncorp Stadium, a tropical downpour, it’s like there’s something up with the climate.

Yet the Waratahs first try, from a backline play begat and finished by halfback Jack Grant, featured both NSW wingers on the same left edge. Getting fast guys to the ball is a thing Robbie Deans would tell people. Darren Coleman knows it in his juices.

A rugby coach of mine from what feels like many millennia ago said the aim of a rugby match is for both wingers to come off the field rooted. Blowing like bellows.

Because if those guys have been running, chasing, spinning their wheels, you’re like as not to have played a fun and entertaining game of footy. And whether you’re in a pro league or Thirsty Thirds, fun rugby is the best rugby.

Coleman could tell you that, too. The Shute Shield golden boy appears to have imbued his charges to ‘play’ the game, to express themselves.

Yes, they could clean up a few things – they were pushed over by a seven-man scrum. But compared to last year they’re Rod MacQueen’s boys from ‘91.

Brad Thorn would call that ‘rugby’, too, though old gravel throat is not a man given to flowery platitudes for pinheads. At best they might get a grunt.

Because another rugby truism is that for every pure spiralling pill that sets free a runaway movement, a host of trolls have their face in the dirt.

The Reds hit back through a try by live-wire and excellent Tate McDermott – or as caller Sean Maloney, channelling Oprah Winfrey, called him “McDERmott!”

McDermott is the Wallabies No.9, for mine. Gots to be. Nic White is good, too. But McDermott is all-action. Reminds of TJ Perenara. Get him on, give him big minutes.

James O’Connor was all poise and precision. And he can run. He’s Australia’s 10. I’d like Quade Cooper in France, too. ‘Old’ is different today; 35 is the new 30, admittedly a thing I have made up. But fit enough is good enough. It’s like being young enough.

So Ben Donaldson can come to France, too.

Along with plenty of Reds, who played with 13 men for ten minutes and 14 men for another ten minutes. During this period they won a penalty with said seven-man scrum, under the posts.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Taniela Tupou is approaching John Eales areas for influence. Come at me, Twitter, I’m going with it.
The game was about attrition in parts – the weather saw to that. But so much was free-running footy.

Jock Campbell – nominally a winger because there was 14 on his back – was all over the place.

Jordan Petaia wore the No.15 and was barging flying wing man Mark Nawaqanitawase – who at match end was blowing like bellows as old coach said – into touch on the right corner flag.

So much to like: Jamie Roberts was the old bull in the No.12 outside fresh-faced fly-half Tane Edmed. Roberts has aligned himself with Warringah Rats, a club of people, a community. You suspect Coleman had fingers on this.

Immediately after half-time the Waratahs launched a raid right from kick-off that saw one of those aforementioned (greatest respect, and so on) ‘trolls’, Ruan Smith, make a less than one metre ‘run’.

Yet it laid a foundation for Grant to spin the ball back to Edmed who spun it right to fullback Will Harrison who launched a mighty left-to-right spiralling bit of kit out to Nawaqanitawase who set sail.

It was beautiful.

As an aside, there was a time rugby league players would turn their backs to the opposition to pass from the left to the right. It wasn’t until Ricky Stuart came from Queanbeyan Whites, a Wallabies Tour and three trials with Manly Marlins that rugby league – Wally Lewis included – saw the possibilities for left-to-right spiralling bits of kit.

Leaguies didn’t know you could do it.

Admittedly Stuart had practiced every day of his life with the more egg-shaped Adidas and Gilbert balls which were easier to fling than the pointier Steeden.

Yet Stuart took ‘rugby’ to the professional game and became the greatest exponent of kicking and passing that rugby league had ever seen.

A couple of plays after Petaia had performed his leaping ‘D’ at speed, Waratahs left wing Alex Newsome was midfield and flinging a right-to-left spiral ball just over Petaia’s leaping fingers.

It was a play that years ago wingers would not have ripped off because a) they were expected to just run and b) they would be on the wing.

It points, again, to Coleman imbuing his people with belief in their skills. To see the field as 120m x 70m of possibility and to ‘perform’, to ‘play’, to enjoy it.

Edmed won’t have enjoyed Campbell racing off with an intercept at the end – yet it showed that NSW will try to win through adventure.

And when Tom Horton scored at the death for NSW; and Queensland kept on playing past the 80th minute; this Brumbies and Australian rugby man tilted back a tinny and thought: the kids are going to be alright.

And so is rugby.

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-02T07:40:58+00:00

Terry OHanlon

Guest


Thorne must be a great coach as he dous not have one player who can consistently make the run on wallabies side yet he won the title in Australia last year

2022-03-29T08:01:11+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


G’day Mon, long time. I’ve got an idea that I’m going to put forward. (If you’re not part of the solution, you’re part of the problem.) Hopefully it will help get Hospital’s Cup a bit more exposure. Not too far away now with trials having started last week. Brings back memories but no desire to get into it again. For now, senior statesman of the game. :laughing: :laughing:

2022-03-29T07:16:20+00:00

Monorchid

Roar Rookie


G'day Busted. You're spot on, and so is JW. I spoke with Frank O'Callaghan a long time ago at Ballymore in the 1970s. He told me that he had to fight for every line of copy the editor would give him even back then. I've made similar comments like you both on these boards before. Australian and State rugby do nothing noticeable to promote the game. Web sites for clubs are hopeless. There's still a chook raffle mentality there. I actually get my press coverage of rugby here at the Roar. And you refer to the Qld Vs NSW games of old. Who can forget the chant of "We want 50" that fateful afternoon as the sun set in the west over the stand at Ballymore. It was standing room only. As you say, the gate for the recent game was pathetic. But the snouts in the trough won't care. Poor fella my Rugby.

2022-03-29T05:27:39+00:00

John Wagner

Roar Rookie


Correct Busted ! If it wasn't for Stan Sports (Live, Replays, Edited versions, and Highlights) we would know absolutely NOTHING about Club Rugby --- the Qld Hospitals Cup Matches are usually great to watch e.g. 6 tries to 4 etc.

2022-03-29T01:59:33+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


Cheers Matt.. :thumbup:

2022-03-28T18:57:35+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Matt, many here do not need to ask. I am a veteran cheerleader in the Quade camp. But the answer must be nuanced in the context of Quade’s stage of career, uncertain availability and our need to plan succession. I like Donaldson. He is rising. Also like Lolesio (so does Rennie). Very impressed with Tane Edmed? last game, And if the rumours are true that Campbell is being groomed by Thorn (McKay?) for 10, then he also may be a prospect. Time will decide for some in apprentice class. And timing. Our club had a fine 10 in the 80’s. I asked him how he went at Rep footy. He explained why he didn’t get much of a shot. “Well Melrose had the spot, maClean was there too, and while they had it, Ella rose. And that was it. Game Over”. It is not a given that every quality Super 10 will become a quality Test 10, let alone a World Cup winning one. (Cheika’s Foley comes to mind). Rennie and Co have sharper rulers than I do to run over each prospect. But we need at least two young ones plus Quade in the squad ready to accurately and creatively feed Krev and other big runners and chasers, with JOC in the squad as emergency cover. Fun article, by the way. Thank you.

AUTHOR

2022-03-28T18:22:12+00:00

Matt Cleary

Expert


Fixed that, thanks. Forgot about old Reuben.

AUTHOR

2022-03-28T18:17:03+00:00

Matt Cleary

Expert


Oh I wouldn’t say “brilliant”, Kiwi. But you are of course most welcome to! Ha. Goodonya mate. Yeah McDermott still has a few barnacles. But can’t fault his effort. He’s in the game, making things happen. You’ll get a hundred per cent from him.

AUTHOR

2022-03-28T18:14:29+00:00

Matt Cleary

Expert


Yep - not the other way, spiralling. Those old leather footies and the teaching of the time. Don’t know even if Ella did.

AUTHOR

2022-03-28T18:10:45+00:00

Matt Cleary

Expert


Who do you like at 10 for Wallabies? Quade? Donaldson??

2022-03-28T17:52:59+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


With all due respect, that’s crap. Wilson wouldn’t have changed the England result one iota

2022-03-28T12:29:14+00:00

cinque

Roar Rookie


Get your Kiwis right! For the umpteenth time, it's not Brad ThornE, it's Reuben Thorne. Sheesh.

2022-03-28T11:31:22+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Younger they may well be, but the Thornthink is older than the Tahtuff stuff that Coleman has pieced together in a few months. The Tah culture is newer. Anyway, whatever age they are, they failed to rock the Red boat when it was there to be sunk.

2022-03-28T09:31:51+00:00

Bentnuc

Roar Pro


Great read Matt :rugby:

2022-03-28T09:17:19+00:00

AJ

Guest


Wally did it right to left https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=osgpvSQKJAo

2022-03-28T09:17:00+00:00

AJ

Guest


So if you are a rugby person with a brain cancel your subscription to the Courier Fixed

2022-03-28T08:31:57+00:00

scrum

Roar Rookie


in Qld there is a clear bias against Rugby. League gets a minimum of 4 pages every day. Rugby lucky to get a small column twice a week. In the sports results today they published the results of every other code but not Rugby. I guess as a result of dumping Fox. So if you are a rugby person cancel your subscription to the Courier

2022-03-28T08:24:57+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


That may be true JC but in Brisbane there is no longer coverage of club rugby, or any other code for that matter. It’s as though amateur or grassroots sport no longer exists let alone deserve coverage. Perhaps it’s going to take someone, with the skills, to promote grassroots rugby through columns on the Roar.

2022-03-28T07:39:41+00:00

JC

Roar Rookie


It’s a symptom of the changing media landscape. Most rugby journos are covering multiple sports. We don’t buy enough papers or online subscriptions to pay for specialists. I think Georgina Robinson may be rugby-only (she broke today’s Force news) but obviously her focus is Sydney. In the Reds’ defence, they’d typically make players or staff available to the media a couple of times a week, put out press releases for news like Petaia’s retention, and there’s a post-match presser so journos do have the opportunity to ask questions.

2022-03-28T06:59:56+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


Valentini is playing ok, but HW has gone away to get in a solid pre-season, put on some weight and is now setting the standard. Just as requested by DR. So it will be interesting to see the response from DR and DMcK.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar