Maguire bemoans 'cruel game' as Brimson strikes in final seconds to avert first tryless game of NRL era

By Mike Meehall Wood / Editor

Michael Maguire has backed his team to turn things around after they managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory on Thursday night, losing 8-4 to the Gold Coast Titans after a last minute AJ Brimson try.

The embattled Tigers coach described it as ‘a cruel game’, but was happy with his team’s commitment and contribution across the 80 minutes… bar, of course, the final 60 seconds.

“I’m actually proud of the players and how they stay at it and work,” he said.

“I’m really finding out a lot about my coaching and dealing with the players through these periods. I couldn’t be prouder – they’re rock solid.

“There’s a lot of hurt in the changing rooms at the moment. For 79 minutes we had it there but it’s a tough one.”

As the clock ticked over to the 80th minute, Michael Maguire’s men were 4-2 up and, just marginally, they might have been worth that lead.

But when your luck isn’t in, it really, really isn’t in. Toby Sexton dinked a kick towards the posts. It came down from the woodwork into the arms of Jock Madden, who fumbled the ball in his in-goal. Brimson touched down.

“Sometimes you get to find things out about the group and that’s why I said I’m enjoying coaching these boys, because they face adversity as a group and keep bouncing back to have another crack,” said Maguire.

“They showed how they can play there and if they do that over and over, they’ll get into a winning arena.

“There’s a lot being said around the club but internally, it’s very calm. I focus on coaching my players and turning up to go again.”

The late winner was a try borne from multiple incompetencies, appropriate for a game that was all set to be the first of the NRL era not to feature a try.

Despite their best efforts to lose, the Titans managed to win. For Justin Holbrook, that was enough.

“We expected a really tough game and got that tonight,” said the Titans coach.

“To find a way to win, I couldn’t be happier or prouder.”

The Gold Coast had endured a horror week in training, and gladly accepted the two points regardless of how they came.

“We had to come up with something,” said Holbrook.

“I’m not sure about getting out of jail, but once you do finally come up with something, I thought we deserved the win.

“I’m proud of the group. We had a short turnaround, four guys with COVID, one before captain’s run and one after, you can’t plan for that. Our facilities are underwater.

“At no stage did the players care about preparation, we were that confident and prepared tonight.

“It was a scrappy game all around but you can only play to the conditions and we came up with a win and that’s the main thing.”

Scrappy doesn’t do it justice. This was, as Dan Ginnane said on Fox League’s commentary, a game so forgettable as to be unforgettable.

By the time the half-time whistle blew on the Gold Coast, most of those in attendance had been praying for it for a long time.

The Titans and Tigers produced a half for the ages – in the worst possible way. Both teams were well off the pace, with only Corey Thompson coming close to a try; even then, he spilled the ball with the line begging.

With 37 minutes on the clock, the Titans decided to give it up as a bad joke and kick a penalty goal. Two minutes later, the Tigers did the same.

It was a fitting end: both teams admitting that no matter how they tried, they couldn’t score, well, a try.

The siren went before Luke Brooks put the ball through the posts, but even if his team had time for a full set, they wouldn’t have scored.

The Titans’ poison was errors: they made nine in the first half alone. That only tells you about the ones they dropped, however.

There were misplaced passes that went too high or behind their target, making life easy for the Tigers to defend. Holbrook blamed dewy conditions, but that seems far-fetched.

Erin Clark, the hooker, appeared to think he was playing halfback and continually slowed the play down by taking passes at first receiver, while David Fifita was starved of the ball on the edge.

He did get over in the first half, charging from a tap restart, but was held up.

A completion rate of 65 per cent over the course of the piece, with just one line break in 80 minutes, sums up the lack of cohesion in attack from the Gold Coast.

GOLD COAST, AUSTRALIA – MARCH 31: Luke Brooks of the Tigers is tackled during the round four NRL match between the Gold Coast Titans and the Wests Tigers at Cbus Super Stadium, on March 31, 2022, in Gold Coast, Australia. (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

For the Tigers, their predilection was for penalties, so many that Tyrone Peachey found himself binned for repeated offences. With ball in hand, they fared little better than the Titans.

If there had been any expectation that the coaches’ input at halftime would have changed the course of the game, it was quickly dispelled.

The Titans continues to pass to green grass regularly rather than sky blue shirts and the Tigers dutifully did their best not to ask any questions in attack.

David Nofoaluma, perhaps the most threatening man in a Wests jersey, did make one strong break on the hour mark but was dragged down by Tino Fa’asuamaleaui. Naturally, he lost the ball in the collision and it all came to naught.

It was very appropriate that the chance for the Tigers to take the lead came from a Titans offensive error.

David Fifita was stood in the line as Jamayne Isaako ran through, referee Grant Atkins called the obstruction and Luke Brooks did the rest.

With five to play, Moeaki Fotuaika was pinged for an interference penalty and Brooks extended the lead to four points.

There had been debate between Peachey and Brooks over whether it mightn’t have been a better idea to wind the clock down and make the Titans have to go the length to get the win.

The Tigers took the two, and paid the price.

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-03T23:05:18+00:00

William W

Roar Rookie


Brian Westlake, I call them Wests when they win and Balmain when they lose.

2022-04-03T21:37:33+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


The short kick-off is a worry but didn't come off this time. I would prefer trying to score a try or trap them in goal than take the 2 but either option has its risks and rewards.

2022-04-03T12:45:10+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


I thought taking the 2 was the safest option because there was a good chance the Tigers would get the ball back from the kick-off have a set of six and bomb or kick into touch. This would've given the Titans less time to move upfield and score a try. It was unfortunate for the Tigers the ball hit the posts and increased the Titans chances further.

2022-04-01T08:16:53+00:00

TIGERMIKE

Guest


Yes worst ever from a winning position so scarce it was

2022-04-01T06:41:28+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


To give the call to kick for 2 points, when they are parked on the opposition goal line and 3 minutes to go, then end up losing, he should have been sacked on the spot.

2022-04-01T03:13:19+00:00

steveng

Roar Rookie


Madge uses his usual excuses and doges the usual problems, he always builds everything up 'like he did at the Bunnies" when he was on his way out, with his usual 'well look at it' or and as he did post game, that he made out that the Tigers defence was blah blah and sensational without any flaws and the teams spirit and grit is out of this world? Which is nonsense, as its his fault, as he should have sent the orange man out and said to Brooks not to take the 2, that is what should have happened, as this is not Madge’s or Brooks’s first rodeo! Its inexcusable to kick a 2 pointer with 4min or less to go and then to give the opposing team an advantage for them to go back to your own 10m when you had a chance to score a try and waste the remaining time in the Titans 10 to 20m and win this game.

2022-04-01T02:40:04+00:00

TAS

Guest


On a positive note the Tigers for and against has improved.

2022-04-01T02:11:04+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


Good thing he plays in the NRL and can get away with it

2022-04-01T02:09:57+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


I agree. It's only the complete :rugby: :rugby: up of the players over the following 5 mins that was the issue.

2022-04-01T02:02:33+00:00

Randy

Roar Rookie


I don't mind Liddell, he throws more forward passes than a NFL quarterback though

2022-04-01T01:57:19+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


I think because their only other NRL quality players Leilua & Tuilagi are the current edge forwards. Garner has been in and out of that spot for few seasons now, unable to cement it as his. He should ask for a run in the middle third. There are heaps of opportunities there for a bloke willing to have a go !

2022-04-01T01:51:05+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


I don't disagree. While i think it is always risky to basically take points off the board, given both teams inability to move the ball up the field, i would have understood the tactic to just kick for touch and work the ball back to a corner. But the argument against going for goal, is losing field position and given they retained it, and because the things played out the way they did, you can't say - IMO - "it's totally Madge's fault".

2022-04-01T01:36:52+00:00

Randy

Roar Rookie


they aren't even close to the worst ever team....

2022-04-01T01:27:33+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Just watched the replay…you’re 100% right In my minds eye I had him catching it on the full off the upright… derrr

2022-04-01T01:25:12+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


Yes it was 1966 that Easts lost all 18 games. In 1967 after losing their first game to newly promoted Cronulla-Sutherland they made the semi finals with Jack Gibson the coach. It was the best comeback since Wests won the 1934 premiership after winning the wooden spoon in 1933.

2022-04-01T01:20:59+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


No doubt he's a lazy player but that's up to Holbrook to address that. He should be putting a rocket up Fifita and if that doesn't work drop him to Q Cup. The money Fifita's on is only justified to players like Turbo, Tedesco and the like, not some lazy forward who doesn't put in.

2022-04-01T01:04:24+00:00

Cam

Roar Rookie


Madge understands "player power" and will continue to pump the boys up. They have the Sharks, Eels and Rabbitohs next, I am keen to see what that interview looks like when they are 0-7. He is $1.02 to be the first NRL coach sacked in 2022.

2022-04-01T01:01:07+00:00

R N

Roar Rookie


That game was so bad it brought people together! A freind I haven't spoken to for a while called about 5 min into the 2nd half just to talk about how awful the game was. We spent the next 35min watching and laughing our rear ends off! We were in tears of laughter when the the Titans finally scored. Thanks Titans and Tigs for the NRL equivalent of Mac and Me!

2022-04-01T00:59:55+00:00

William W

Roar Rookie


It was in 1966 for memory but we all get the jitz of it, lol

2022-04-01T00:58:27+00:00

Cam

Roar Rookie


I keep hearing commentators bemoaning the fact that the Titans aren’t getting the ball to Fifita. Totally untrue, the problem is the bloke is too lazy to put himself in a position to run the ball. Example: about 10 minutes into the match vs Wests, Sexton goes left and has to cut Fifita because he is in a poor position. Kelly makes a half break and turns the ball back inside to where he expects Fifita to be supporting. Except Fifita was about 15m behind play walking, ball goes to ground, Wests knock it on. The bloke just isn’t motivated enough to put himself in the game for 80 minutes and I think he probably can do the same job in 40mins off the bench. Maybe even rotate him through the middle?? It probably wouldn’t look so bad if he was on $400k a year, which looks to be his value, but geez, the bloke is on $1,200,000 a season.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar