NRL NEWS: Annesley angry over bias claims, Keary wowed by Walker, Anasta blames Storm for Munster dramas

By The Roar / Editor

Graham Annesley has angrily refuted claims that the NRL’s lower-ranked clubs are treated poorly by referees and never get the rub of the green.

Officiating has been back in the spotlight from round one this year, when Gold Coast coach Justin Holbrook claimed his side did not get the favourable calls big clubs did.

North Queensland counterpart Todd Payten also made the same claims after his team’s round-five loss to the Sydney Roosters, amid regular debate from former players in media.

But in an unprompted eight-and-a-half minute monologue at Tuesday’s weekly media briefing, Annesley made clear there was no proof of bias from NRL officials. Instead, he argued poorly performing teams were often penalised more than opponents and at times deliberately slowed both the game and ruck.

“The teams at the top end of the ladder … they control the ball. They spend long periods of time in possession,” the NRL head of football said.

“The teams at the other end of the ladder, they’re spending much more time defending. You’re much more likely to concede offences when you’re defending. You’ll be offside more, you’ll be committing offences in the ruck. You’ll frankly be trying to slow the ruck down.

“We all know that that’s a tactic in our game to try and slow the good sides down.

“So these things do become a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy.”

Annesley also argued officials did not have time to consider matters like penalty counts or ladder position when making rulings, and that there was never a pre-conceived bias.

“I just wanted to be very clear here: the process that the match officials go through … in making any decision is based entirely on what they see,” Annesley said.

Meanwhile ,Annesley defended a decision not to hand Newcastle a crucial late penalty for offside in their loss to St George Illawarra from the penultimate kick-off, claiming it was line-ball call.

But he did state there had been bunker inconsistencies in the Roosters’ win over the Warriors.

Annesley was unimpressed the Roosters were handed a ruck penalty late in the game while the Warriors were denied one for a similar infringement earlier.

Both decisions were made by the bunker after a captain’s challenge when knock-ons were called on-field.

Walker wows Keary with skill

Luke Keary says he’s never seen an NRL playmaker as gifted and as confident as Sam Walker, describing the five-eighth’s natural instinct to attack without fear as an exceptional quality.

Walker’s off-the-cuff style is born and bred because his father Ben and uncle Shane once coached Queensland Cup side Ipswich with a focus on attacking with freedom and taking risks.

The Sydney Roosters have four wins to start the season with Keary adjusting to the shift to halfback to accommodate Walker at five-eighth.

Walker is 19 years old but the UK-born playmaker demonstrated his wares in the Roosters’ gritty win over the Warriors on Sunday when he kicked five goals, scored a try and picked up all three Dally M points.

Keary likened Walker to a young Johnathan Thurston and said he relishes playing with the teenager.

“I haven’t played with a half with (his) skillset and talent,” Keary said.

“I think he’s been blessed with the family he’s grown up in; around his dad and uncle who coached that Ipswich team, which we all know had a different style of footy.

“He’s grown up around that environment where he’s been able to express himself and play free-flowing football.

“The mindset he goes in with is definitely rare.”

While the pair’s combination is still growing, Keary said he admired Walker’s ability to take a risk and brush himself off if it didn’t come to fruition.

“You want a kid with confidence like that,” Keary said. “You don’t want to go the other way where you’re trying to instil confidence in him.

“He’s going to take the game (on) and you’ve seen that in big moments.

“My job is to kind of help control the team a little bit and let him do his thing when he’s feeling it and he’s on.”

Keary and Walker will face St George Illawarra on Monday in the club’s traditional Anzac Day game and the Roosters halfback rated the contest as “the biggest club game of the year”.

(Photo by Robert Cianflone/Getty Images)

Anasta puts Munster circus on Storm

Cameron Munster’s manager Braith Anasta believes the Storm have only got themselves to blame for the ongoing speculation around the star five-eighth by prioritising the re-signing of three other players ahead of him.

Munster, who is not off contract until the end of next year, recently knocked back an extension offer from Melbourne who finalised upgraded deals for teammates Harry Grant, Jahrome Hughes and Xavier Coates.

With speculation mounting that several clubs, including Newcastle, North Queensland, the Roosters and Gold Coast, are likely to be interested in Munster along with the Dolphins expansion side, Anasta denied on NRL 360 that he had been shopping his client around.

He said Munster’s form on the field was driving up his value and he did not need to put any feelers out to prospective clubs. Munster is understood to have rejected an offer from the Storm around $750,000 a year because other teams would stump up seven figures each season for his services.

“He’s not being shopped around. Have you watched him play the last seven weeks? You don’t need to go and chase [clubs],” Anasta said.

“We’ve got the Dolpins involved, which is a new club, a new franchise. The rules are the rules, whether it’s Cameron Munster or anyone for that matter in the competition you can talk to clubs you just can’t negotiate [a contract]. 

“Now the problem here is the Melbourne Storm wanted to re-sign the four players.

“They said they want to extend and upgrade the other three but extend and lower Cameron’s wage for the next couple of years so they’ve made that public and they’ve put that out there so we, knowing Cameron’s in the best state mentally and physically, knew he’d play really well this season, we said no.

“What that’s done is brought attention now more to Cameron’s performances on the field from clubs and it’s the Melbourne Storm who have actually put that attention on him.”

Munster tore the Sharks to shreds in a dominant performance to lead the Storm to a 34-18 victory on Saturday night. He will be one of the first players picked for Queensland in this year’s State of Origin series and is likely to be the Kangaroos’ five-eighth for Australia’s end-of-season World Cup campaign.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Manly boss throws weight behind US game

Sea Eagles owner Scott Penn wants next year’s proposed “round zero” game in the US to become an annual part of the NRL calendar.

The ARL Commission is considering a plan to stage a match in Los Angeles next year a week before the rest of Round 1 kicks off.

Manly and South Sydney, given their ties to Hollywood stars Hugh Jackman and Russell Crowe, are the likely teams to take part in the match if it goes ahead.

The historic fixture would be played a week before the rest of the first round so that the two teams would have sufficient time to return to Australia and acclimatise before their next match.

“There’s huge interest in NRL over here in the US. Rugby league continues to grow and expand over here,” Penn told the Sydney Morning Herald.

“Anyone I show it to over here they think, ‘Wow, that’s amazing. They don’t wear pads and helmets’ – it’s really the last bastion of gladiatorial sports.”

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-05-13T04:23:03+00:00

Slammin_Sam

Roar Rookie


ask Adam Reynolds about loyalty...they wouldnt be able to spell it the dark streets of Redfern.....but i did see George Piggins pop in for the first time in 20 years...theres the thanks you get for saving the club.....what were saying in that glass house of yours... ask George about loyalty.....

2022-04-23T22:39:01+00:00

Wayne Turner

Guest


GA can be angry as he likes. But the refs do favorites the teams expected to win. However,the refs don't do it as cheats,they do it subconsciously,and don't even realise it. This is the fault of the NRL,and the rules of the game.In fact the changing of rules,in recent seasons has made this issue worse egs: 6 again - So subjective,and add to that refs do not have to explain why they gave 6 again,and hence are not held to account.In fact, often teams that should get 6 again, don't either. 6 again should be scrapped.Also,sin binning has become a joke.Top teams tend to get players put on report,but not sin binned.Cause again,the NRL has made it too subjective.Sin binnings should be changed to ONLY professional fouls,not head highs - Head highs can be dealt with after, penalties only in the game.Except of course if any player is dumb enough to do two head highs in a game,they get sent off.

2022-04-22T01:14:41+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


Oh yes, it's certainly not an exercise in shoulder rubbing for the sake of it. I really struggle to see the overall benefit

2022-04-22T00:31:59+00:00

astro

Roar Rookie


https://www.rugbyleagueeyetest.com/2022/04/20/does-ladder-position-dictate-the-number-of-penalties-conceded-by-an-nrl-team/

2022-04-22T00:31:05+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


Adam, probably because guys like Penn, Jackman and Crowe can get in Vlandys ear and also in it means a nice all expenses paid trip to the states for various NRL officials and CH 9 hangers on .

2022-04-21T10:12:47+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


No one is saying the referees go out there nto favour top sides against lower sides but it does happen. I've followed league ince te early 60s andthe rub of the green does go to the sides higher on the ladder. It happens.

2022-04-21T07:52:16+00:00

Greg

Roar Pro


I very much agree that the refs suffer from confirmation bias and that the Roosters as one of the better teams are one of the beneficiaries of this. I don't however it is as prevalent as fans have made out it is this week. I'd note that us fans similarly have just as much confirmation bias as the referees. We expect to see Roosters/Storm etc get favorable outcomes so we note them when they occur. We aren't looking for similar favorable outcomes for lower ranked sides so we don't take as much notice when they also occur.

2022-04-21T07:46:10+00:00

Greg

Roar Pro


i'm very much on the side of there is clear confirmation bias but it isnt as simple as counting ruck speed. The time to hold down is determined by which one of the 5 (from memory) different tackles types that was made. Case in point Tedesco was penalised (and many wanted sin binned) for a tackle that would of been about 1.5seconds before Fonua-Blake tried to play the ball. I actually thought Tigers got far more calls their way late in the game, but very few their way in the first half.

2022-04-21T06:34:26+00:00

Magic Lyrebird

Roar Rookie


It would be a really simple exercise for Annesley to back up his comments with some data. If the reason that lower-ranked teams are penalised more is only because they spend more time defending, then the ratio of tackles made per penalty/6-again conceded would be the same for all teams, regardless of whether they are high- or low-ranked. The fact that Annesley hasn't even bothered to get that data shows how cursory the scrutiny of refereeing is.

2022-04-21T02:14:17+00:00

Poss

Roar Rookie


The Chooks arn't the only club to poach good players? They look after their players while they are playing & set them up for after their retirement .Who wouldn'twant that? Brandon Smith (the block of Cheese) was praising them for being a great & caring club...

2022-04-20T20:32:47+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


You haven’t answered my question at all… you’ve danced around it and completely avoided it… Anyway, I’m not really sure what you’re asking but I’ll try. I think I remember the game you’re talking about. Souths were up 10 or 12 to nil or so and Penrith ended up running them down and winning 25-10 (or 12)? Is that the one? I don’t remember Bennett’s comments after the game and certainly not as any grand “unmasking” or “damning revelation” as you’ve put it. Don’t most teams use blockers to stop defenders getting to their kickers? Weren’t they both chipping at each other in the media through the season? Don’t most coaches do that? I’m not being obtuse. I just don’t remember the Bennett / Cleary comments as being anything out of the ordinary that I was supposed to be concerned about. Not sure how unconscious bias applies to the Cleary / Bennett “feud” in the media Do I think Penrith get the inside running from refs? Of course. That’s the whole point of the article. I don’t think it’s a conspiracy though. I also think Souths get the benefits of confirmation or unconscious bias as a top team… don’t you…?

2022-04-20T18:12:11+00:00


Penalties versus Bunker Calls and 50/50 calls...I think you will find the Storm and Roosters have remarkably high stats in their favour -- these are where it counts. Penalties in the modern game are often breached on purpose. Take Tedesco....professional foul , penalised, but stays on the field!!!!!

2022-04-20T18:01:57+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


So no NRL official should have any non-official contact with the game? I am not implying that. Referees could come from RL families and often played and have family members who played. Col Pearce was the referee of the 1955 final series where Souths won all their finals games in controversial circumstances. It is the reason why Saints captain coach Ken Kearney coached from 1953 to 1961 but not in 1956. Alan Clarkson and Col Pearce were regulars on Controversy Corner with Rex Mossop (Manly), Noel Kelly (Wests) and Ferris Ashton (Easts).

2022-04-20T17:43:11+00:00

Get_real

Roar Rookie


It could be worse Mick Ennis could start pushing Munster's cart as well droning on with his made up words "magicistical play"!

2022-04-20T17:40:58+00:00

Get_real

Roar Rookie


Makes sense, especially with Keary's concussion issues in the past seasons & the Roosters hard luck with medical retirements.

2022-04-20T17:39:11+00:00

Get_real

Roar Rookie


It is hard to keep a Foxtel subscription while so many of their employees have dual roles & are not professional enough to be unbiased. Munster should be the last thing Braith is commenting on. Munster may even be better with a full time manger the likes of the orr brothers etc, they could maybe get him a gig at South Sydney they have need for competition at 5/8, their young fullback Blake Taaffe looks the goods so it Munster would have to be in the halves.

2022-04-20T12:58:31+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I read your post. But it didn’t answer my question (not that you have to) and neither does this…

2022-04-20T12:57:21+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Now I answered your question, you answer mine. I think Wayne Bennett’s unmasking of Ivan Cleary’s tactics of manipulating the referees and the media in the post-match press conference was a pretty damming revelation at the time. It wasn’t until after Bennett played that card that the referees started clamping down on the Panthers illegal blocking tactics to give Nathan Cleary a tactical advantage in his kicking game. Why were you never concerned about that? Unconscious bias?

2022-04-20T12:54:45+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


I hope that you weren't being ironic Rob.

2022-04-20T12:52:27+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


So you skim-read my answer TB. I'll sum it up then in two of the sentences from my previous comment. "I couldn’t answer that consciously." and "I never said it didn’t."

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar