Tane's got game: Will Edmed keep Tahs' No.10 spot as 'a few more nerves' kick in for Kiwi clashes?

By Tony Harper / Editor

Tane Edmed looks set to get the first crack at No.10 for the Waratahs against Kiwi opposition despite the return of fellow Tahs young gun Ben Donaldson for Friday’s opening match of the Super Round in Melbourne.

While Tahs assistant Chris Whitaker wouldn’t be 100 percent definitive when asked about the hot compeititon for the spot this week, he hinted that Edmed, 21, had done enough to force Donaldson to return from the bench against the Chiefs.

Whitaker said Will Harrison, the third of the three promising young fly halves at Darren Coleman’s disposal, would not be considered as a starter at 10 this weekend.

“Last year it was hard to get guys in the squad because we had so many injuries,” Whitaker said.

“This year there’s so much competition which is good. The five-eighth spot is one of them.

“We’ve got three young 10s who are all fighting for positions.”

He said that ahead of the team’s first training session in Melbourne, Edmed and Donaldson had their hands up for the No.10 jersey.

Tane Edmed (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

“Every week is a blank slate. Tane has played a few games in a row now quite well so it’s going to be tough to bump him out of that spot. I’m not giving too much away but it’s going to be hard to make too many changes there.”

Whitaker said the team had been going to school on the Chiefs by watching videos of their recent games against Crusaders and Hurricanes, but had ignored the Blues’ 25-0 win over them as they felt the Auckland side was too different in style to the Tahs for it to give them pointers.

“When we were watching the game last night Michael Hooper pointed out that these guys are very similar to the Fijian teams, just a lot more structured. They have the danger of the unstructured play, turnover ball, counter attack it’s where probably they’re the most dangerous and you just can’t turn your back on them.”

Defence has been a cornerstone of improved performances by the Tahs and Whitaker is hoping it stands firm this weekend.

“It’s probably lucky we played Fiji twice because our game plan kind of suited that game – not opening the the game up too much, playing to our strengths, not letting them into the game. Hopefully it holds us in good stead.”

There is nervous excitement with the Australian Super teams this week as they prepare for their first trans Tasman challenges of the year.

“It’s almost like a benchmark to see how we’re going,” Whitaker said. “The [Aussie] guys know each other, so you go into those games and you kind of know where you’re at.

“Against the Kiwi teams, there’s probably a bit more anticipation, a few more nerves, just that uncertainty of how you sit and how our style of footy is going to stack up against them.”

This week is important for the Tahs but, Whitaker says, “for Australian rugby as well.”

“We’ve got to compete and we’ve got to win some games that’s for sure.”

Waratahs forward Hugh Sinclair is feeling the rise in excitement levels and believes his team can cope with the pressure.

“There’s no denying the fact the Australia record against Kiwi sides is not great but there’s just 15 blokes on the field, you’ve just got to do what you’ve got to do take some confidence from the last eight weeks and play like we want to play,” said Sinclair.

Preparing for an increase in tempo and intensity has been the team’s focus.

“They love quick ruck speed so you’ve got to slow that down,” Sinclair said.

“We’ve been able to do that against the Aussies teams and Fijians but it’s a different beat against the Kiwi sides.

“Last year we weren’t as strong defensively so we’re really looking forward to testing ourselves. Slow the break down and their counterattack is next level so when we’re kicking  don’t give them time and space.

“The Kiwi sides play a more clinical version of how Fiji plays – they like to throw the ball around, but their scrum lineouts and mauling is better. It’s a different beast around the breakdown, ruck speed all that stuff. We’ll be prepared.”

Edmed is singing from the same song sheet.

“The thing about the Kiwi teams, especially the Chiefs, is that they thrive on that unstructured attack – they love that turnover ball, and they take those opportunities really quickly,” he said.

“For us, it’s trying to minimise those opportunities and just play our game and try and keep the game in control.”

Similar conversations are happening for the Queensland Reds ahead of their clash with the Hurricanes on Saturday.

“It’s a different brand of rugby we’re going to be playing,” said centre Hamish Stewart.

“It’s a little more upbeat, up-tempo – we’ve got to be on our toes. We’ve been training that this week and we’re looking forward to it. They’re a class team, all Kiwi teams are but we’re ready to bounce into them.”

Stewart said the squad had been buoyed by the return last week of Suli Vunivalu after a long injury absence, and were eager to set him loose on Kiwi opposition.

“Suli makes an impact wherever he goes,” Stewart said. “He’s a quality player, he’s a freak and it’s good to have him back in the team.

“He’s an elite player in the air and we’ll look to utilise that against the Kiwi. We’re looking forward to exposing him against some of the smaller blokes – letting him run over people. “

The Crowd Says:

2022-04-20T15:24:42+00:00

Francisco Roldan

Roar Rookie


I risk my own list only up to the third position, expecting some surprises from MOA. 1- BLU | 2- BRU | 3- CRU

2022-04-20T15:20:13+00:00

Francisco Roldan

Roar Rookie


How are you RugbyTryLover...! I think that the Kiwi teams are specialists in the execution of unstructured play, and we can see it reflected in their effectiveness. The ratio between a team's total attacks, including turnovers, and breaks generated, shows them to be clear winners. We will have a very interesting Rd.10 to analyze.

2022-04-20T08:01:30+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Whitaker isn't going to say anything else and I would expect they'd try but the reality that we will have less to spend on a promising 10, given we have two already on the books, will bite sooner or later I'd think

2022-04-20T05:43:52+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


:laughing:

2022-04-20T05:10:47+00:00

Markus

Roar Rookie


Jez we couldn't possibly be statist. I myself even have a friend from NSW!

2022-04-20T02:56:17+00:00

Matt

Guest


Tahs have so much depth in every position. They will finish top 4. 1 Blues 2 Crusaders 3 Brumbies 4 Waratahs 5 Chiefs 6 Hurricanes 7 Reds 8 Highlanders

2022-04-20T01:46:55+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


I think the comments from Whitaker are very obvious they are working to retain him. The other two are only signed through next year. The place most in need of another young 10 is the Brumbies but if you are already in the top 2 at the Tahs, why go be second at the Brumbies? Especially when as they repeatedly tell us they hate NSW?

2022-04-19T23:45:44+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


That team selection is my guess as well Paul.

2022-04-19T23:14:46+00:00

Rugbytrylover

Roar Rookie


The key this week will be to maintain our much improved defence and be clinical with any kicking we do. The Kiwis love an aimless mis directed kick from which to counterattack. I too feel that Coleman will reward Edmed for his consistent showing .. Donaldson may struggle to get back on bench if they feel that Harrison can cover 10? Coleman is building a strong culture and rewards performance as he showed by moving Gamble to the other side of the scrum when Hooper returned. Marky also worries me in defence but he has definitely improved. Good coaching? The Tahs can definitely win this one.

2022-04-19T23:13:19+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


There are certainly other teams that need a 10.

2022-04-19T23:09:30+00:00

Rugbytrylover

Roar Rookie


Agreed, because I think he is better suited to playing from the back.

2022-04-19T21:41:31+00:00

Greysy

Roar Rookie


Yeah I have this issue every time I try and log in. Regularly have to refresh the page like 4 times before it comes up unobstructed.

2022-04-19T21:39:28+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Tane is best ginger 10 in the world. Ihaia, Rhys, and Paddy: stand back.

2022-04-19T21:07:05+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


So not just me.

2022-04-19T21:04:53+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


I like the language coming from the guys, and how keen they are for this.

2022-04-19T20:44:44+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Is it just me or are Tah players speaking with more insight? Ed Ed has surprised me. Even errors accounted for, he has been excellent. Happy for WillnBen to usurp him, but it will improve the Tahs when that do. Coleman’s rising tide is lifting all boats. Don’t expect a win over the Chiefs, but if their ruck intensity lifts simultaneously it could happen.

2022-04-19T12:23:11+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


Good point. Ads cover login fields too.

2022-04-19T12:04:36+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Are the Eds aware that the latest ad banner covers the details of replies when selected? The number of ads is becoming a real pain

2022-04-19T11:54:28+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


Still missed a few tackles but agree he’s improved. He does look more confident. Good aerial skills. And he has worked on his ball security too!

2022-04-19T11:38:56+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Donaldson has looked the best when good but he's taken some awful options at times. I'm most impressed with Harrison's improvement this year. He is way more confident with attacking the line and offloading. And his experience last year means he makes less errors

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar