'We can't be naïve': Tahs give Tane contract update as 'forgotten man' looks to jog memories

By Tony Harper / Editor

Waratahs assistant coach Jason Gilmore says emerging No.10 Tane Edmed wants to stay at the club, but admits he remains ripe for poaching by another Super Rugby outfit.

Gilmore was asked Thursday about Edmed’s contract situation and his battle for supremacy in the No.10 jersey with Ben Donaldson at the club.

Earlier in the season the presence of Donaldson was seen a potential barrier to Edmed signing a new deal but an injury to Donaldson opened the door and his teammate has taken full advantage.

While Edmed’s quality is clear, what isn’t is where he will be playing next season.

“Tane wants to stay,” Gilmore said. “Obviously we can’t be naïve to other clubs coming in with bigger offers and promising starting positions. But I think he’s mentioned he wants to go somewhere where he’s going to get developed and I know he’s happy here.

“We’re certainly keen to keep him. It’s a little above my pay scale in terms of the dollar figures and where that’s up to but I know he’s happy and we’re keen to keep him.

“How we get that done behind closed doors, that would probably be for other blokes to speak to.”

What Gilmore can relay is the training ground tussle between Edmed and Donaldson.

This week Donaldson has been slotted in at No.15, with Alex Newsome moving to No.13 to replace the injured Izaia Perese.

Gilmore acknowledged it might have been easier to bring in veteran Jamie Roberts as a straight swap for Perese, who is only an outside chance of returning in the finals.

“It was a tough one,” Gilmore said. “Donno was probably starting to get into some good form off the bench. He’s a forgotten man a little bit – he was in good form until he got injured and Tane’s been playing good footy.

Tane Edmed (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

“We wanted two ball players on the park still because [Lalakai Foketi’s] running game is staring to pick up at the moment.

“By having those guys at 10 and 15 just gives us two options to play both sides of the field which we’re hoping the boys will do well. “

He backed Newsome to make an impact as a Perese replacement.

“Nobby’s probably our smartest defender,” Gilmore said. “Izaia gives us that physicality and speed but Nobby’s just really smart in that outside centre channel. It’s not an easy one to defend and he’s done it before and we know what we get with him.

“It gives us stability through the centres and two ball playing options having Donno on the pitch.”

Gilmore said Donaldson had reacted well despite his inability to win back the jersey he lost through injury.

“All the boys, attitude wise there’s no dramas,” said Gilmore. “If they’re not starting or they’re off the bench they’re all rowing the same direction.

“He knows Tane’s been playing good football and it’s good for the squad – it’s competition. It drives Donno to train harder to be better and drives Tane so that he keeps his jersey.

“The two boys are going head to head at the moment at training and Tane’s just taken his opportunity. It’s not that Donno has played poorly. The side’s got good rhythm, there’s a combination that’s being built.

“Donno has been really patient but he’s hungry and wants to get back on the park and start. It’s probably not his preferred position but with the injury to Izaia it gives us the option to bring Donno back into the starting team.”

Meanwhile AAP reports Gilmore has picked up a new part time gig as Australia A with a team to compete in the Pacific Nations Cup this July in Fiji.

While the Wallabies take on England in three Tests in July in Perth, Brisbane and Sydney, a development squad will play three matches against Test line-ups from Samoa, Fiji and Tonga.

Rugby Australia boss Andy Marinos says the return of Australia A is a way to get more high-level rugby into Super Rugby players, with the National Rugby Championship (NRC) no longer in place.

Australia A played regularly between 2000 and 2008 – even recording a surprise win over the 2001 British and Irish Lions – and has been considered a launching pad for Test careers.

“Our High Performance review highlighted a relative lack of game time for the younger, developing professional players in our system,” Marinos said in a statement on Thursday.

“Alongside working on competition structures that can help to alleviate this relative lack of game time, one of our priorities has been to re-establish Australia A to provide additional top-flight matches.

“This will help to develop a deeper squad of elite players, as well as giving players some representative experience to take back to their Super Rugby Pacific clubs – which can only be a good thing for Australian rugby.”

The concept will also provide another level of experience for emerging coaches with Gilmore named to head the side.

Brumbies attack coach Rod Seib, Reds defence coach Michael Todd, and Rebels forwards coach Geoff Parling will be Gilmore’s assistants.

Selection in Australia A may affect players with multiple heritage as under World Rugby rules a senior team captures eligibility.

This would affect players who wish to make themselves available for selection for another country before next year’s Rugby World Cup in France.

Match schedule: 

Australia A v Samoa on July 2 in Suva

Australia A v Fiji on July 9 in in Lautoka

Australia A v Tonga on July 16 in Lautoka

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-05-20T11:28:47+00:00

Tez

Roar Rookie


Better defence, better kick from hand, better game awareness than Harrison ..... I am not saying the Tahs need to get rid of Harrison. What I am saying is that Edmed and Donaldson give more upside than Harrison, so if one has to go then imo it is Harrison .... mind you he is under contract

2022-05-20T08:24:12+00:00

AndyS

Guest


I share the hope Brett, but can't help wondering whether it is the same old management churn. I'd feel a lot more confident if they could have explained what's changed since they cut Aus A last time, and why now is the time as opposed to any time over the last ten years. Otherwise, are they just grabbing at old ideas for lack of new, and will they be congratulating themselves in a couple of years time for their courage in again cancelling an unnecessary expense?

2022-05-20T06:04:04+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Terry how could Rennie have known that Donaldson would get injured and Edmed would come in and play as well as he has? You cant name people in a squad if they havnt shown anything.

2022-05-20T06:02:21+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Agree. Lock them to RA with min $$ contract ( say 70K ) then let them negotiate with the Sr sides for positions. If they want to leave early thats no probs but RA get a transfer fee.

2022-05-20T05:58:36+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Reece goes OK...

2022-05-20T02:11:07+00:00

Shano

Guest


I haven`t seen anything from Donaldson .What makes him so special?

2022-05-20T01:37:56+00:00

Terry

Guest


Rennie looks like a drongo now. He has Donaldson in his Wallabies squad but does not have the far superior Edmed. Hopefully Rennie punts the over rated Ben who has done nothing in two years and gets Edmed in there.

2022-05-20T01:06:07+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Haha! He’s a good ‘un. Paddy missed kicks so he is out as Ginger 10 Man. Rhys P not picked by Pivac. so, it’s Tane at the top!

2022-05-20T00:49:21+00:00

Paul D

Roar Rookie


He’s off to Northampton

2022-05-20T00:05:26+00:00

Frankly

Roar Rookie


James Ramm maybe?

2022-05-19T23:53:19+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Well spotted Nicko

2022-05-19T23:42:34+00:00

Nick Maguire

Roar Rookie


Mr Leg, also good for Samoa, Fiji & Tonga. Developing the region and our neigbours can only be good for all.

2022-05-19T22:59:11+00:00

Oblosnky’s Other Pun

Guest


I think he’s big enough for 10, but so many fullbacks (and even wings) these days are well over 190cm, big and powerful. I think a player needs to be truly exceptional to be a small fullback this day and age. I would rather see him playing 10 somewhere. That said we have exceptions like Cheslin Kolbe so perhaps he proves me wrong.

2022-05-19T22:56:09+00:00

Hazel Nutt

Roar Rookie


Hopefully it will serve as a bit of a backup for the Kerevi law and COVID risks, with test ready players able to step up when issues arise like the withdrawal of the Japan based players last year. A solution to a different problem in my mind.

2022-05-19T22:48:44+00:00

Hazel Nutt

Roar Rookie


Harrison does some of the job really well, but by and large they seemed to be the tasks the position shares with the fly half role. Same reason Giteau was only ever a part time fullback. To me Harrison looks far from a dedicated fullback, and I would prefer the Tahs developed a permanent fullback rather than trying to make space for all their fly half talent. Nawaqanitawase would be my pick, now that he's added a little aggression to his game. If that means losing a fly half to a team who needs him more, and there are clearly depth issues in that position at the Reds, Brumbies and next year the Rebels, then so be it!

2022-05-19T22:35:22+00:00

JC

Roar Rookie


Harrison (and Donaldson) are already contracted. Edmed is the only free agent after this season but you can’t have him either. Reds have got Creighton and Lynagh coming through, both very talented.

2022-05-19T20:39:40+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


The A team idea is great but if Marinos wants more rugby at a higher level for developing players he needs another tier below Super rugby. This will help 23 - 30 players but it won’t create depth. I like the idea and I’m not naysaying it, I just don’t think it’ll provide the experience Marinos says is missing.

2022-05-19T19:53:39+00:00

Bobby

Roar Rookie


The best way to retain young lads is to "contract" them on an initial 5 year deal from age 18. Minimum deal with performance bonuses ( number of caps, say 5, 10 and so on). At 23 most players are showing their value ( or not) and go on the free market with negotiated contract terms ( maybe 1, 2, 3 etc years and at market price). If an 18 year old refuses to sign the initial 5 year deal, then see ya later.

2022-05-19T19:34:32+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Good spot Paul. These ideas, that utilise already sunk costs, seem to be small but important innovations. More juice squeezed out of the Tier onion so to speak. Not every non-capped squadee will remain uncapped before late ‘23. We need to keep prospects running warm, building combos and giving incumbents hit outs when returning from injury.

2022-05-19T15:55:03+00:00

Francisco Roldan

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the report Tony...! I had no news of the victory of AUS A vs BIL. But that shows the importance of a second team in talent evaluation and development. In Argentina we have Jaguares XV competing in the "Super Liga Americana de Rugby" against franchises from Brazil, Uruguay, Chile, Paraguay and Colombia. But apparently, Jaguares XV is serving to make talent visible for European teams instead of retaining and developing the depth we need in Los Pumas.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar