Every overseas-based Socceroo should be an A-League guest player

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

Paramount has reported that around 568,000 Australians were tuned in at 4am to watch the Socceroos qualify for the 2022 FIFA World Cup.

In what I had never previously considered a ‘timeslot’, the Socceroos won the ratings by the length of the straight, with potentially even more people joining the broadcast later on and catching highlights and mini-match content throughout the remainder of what was a thrilling day for Australian football.

No doubt Paramount and Network Ten executives had broad smiles on their faces, with the eyeballs glued to their platforms vast in number and a small portion of that long-term investment made in the Australian game having been returned.

It was a stark contrast to the most recent A-League competition, where viewing numbers were underwhelming at best, with the app causing many subscribers problems in terms of accessing the content and maintaining a reliable stream.

My domestic 5G connection is incredibly reliable, yet often throughout season 2021-22, I was left staring at an irritating buffering symbol, with anecdotal stories from other fans suggesting more than the odd individual gave up altogether.

What the numbers do show is two clear and well-known realities.

Firstly, the Socceroos have a massive following and pull an impressive audience whenever they appear on the world stage.

Secondly, the chasm between Australian football fans’ eagerness to watch the national team and their desire to tune in to the A-League on a regular basis is vast.

In fact, I’m searching for a word that exceeds vast!

(Photo by Mike Owen/Getty Images)

Therein remains the challenge for the A-League’s owners and the people now charged with investing in and leading the domestic league into a new era, with Network Ten as a keen and willing participant hoping to benefit from the shrewd decisions made by those with a significant investment.

Perhaps it would be a different story if the Socceroos themselves were all playing in the A-League. Pleasingly, the majority are superior to that level and playing abroad. Of the starting 11 that took to the field against Peru, just Mathew Leckie could claim to be a current A-League player, with only goalkeeping hero Andrew Redmayne, Jamie Maclaren and Craig Goodwin featuring as domestically based talent.

Yet could the fact that the majority of Graham Arnold’s squad cut their teeth in the A-League provide an opportunity to connect the Socceroos and the A-League Men more tangibly, via simple club association and guest appearances?

Awer Mabil forged his reputation in Adelaide, Kye Rowles, Trent Sainsbury, Tom Rogic and Mathew Ryan on the Central Coast, Nathaniel Atkinson at Melbourne City, while Aaron Mooy, Danny Vukovic, Adam Taggart, Mitch Duke and Riley McGree have passed through multiple Australian clubs on their football journeys.

Aziz Behich used both Victory and Melbourne Heart as stepping stones to his international career, and Kenny Dougall has strong ties with the Brisbane clubs he played for as a young man.

Aziz Behich for Australia (Photo by Koji Watanabe/Getty Images)

In 2016, Football Australia announced changes to the guest-player rule that allowed clubs to sign “high profile players” for an entire season outside of the salary cap restrictions. It was that rule which brought Tim Cahill back onto Australian shores for his stint at Melbourne City.

A quick tweak of, or appendix to, such a rule could see each club associated with overseas-based Socceroos and therefore permitted to bring them back for a guest appearance where suitable.

International breaks, the limited game-time sometimes afforded our players, and the demand for solid minutes when returning from injury all provide situations where the chasm between A-League fandom and the successful brand that is the Socceroos could potentially be bridged.

Just imagine Mabil and McGree turning out in Reds kit for a guest appearance, Mathew Ryan between the sticks at Central Coast Stadium with potentially Sainsbury and Rowles ahead of him, or Aaron Mooy bossing a Wanderers midfield with Mitchell Duke up top.

Socceroos like Martin Boyle, Harry Souttar and Ajdin Hrustic, despite having no direct links to A-League clubs, could also be wooed by them, with guest appearances becoming the norm and providing immense interest and quality to the competition.

Of course, there could well be some concern expressed by the high-paying owners of the teams at which our boys ply their trade week to week. Yet does the $140 million made available to A-League owners via private equity firm Silver Lake not enable a small financial carrot to be dangled in order for Australian fans to see the Socceroos on home soil just a little more often?

I can think of a heck of a lot of less effective ways to spend what would be a small portion of the new funds available.

I’ve no idea whether this idea is absurd, ingenious or simply unrealistic, yet as Paramount’s viewing figures remind us yet again of just how strong the Socceroo brand is, the gulf between it and A-League support needs to be bridged.

Perhaps reconnecting our Socceroos with the domestic league would result in a much-needed boost.

Were it to prove sustainable in the medium term, it could also provide a model for other leagues around the world experiencing a chasm between club and country.

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-06T17:17:44+00:00

Joshua Makepeace

Roar Rookie


I love this idea! It would just do good, good for the fans, good for the clubs and good for Australian football in general. I'm not sure if the players would want to do this, but even if a few joined the A-League then it would be great.

2022-06-27T04:07:51+00:00

AxeMaster

Roar Rookie


The Paramount+ app is complete garbage. Easily the worst app on my Samsung and I wont be subscribing again.

2022-06-24T03:04:03+00:00

Football is Life

Roar Rookie


yep, UHF is very susceptible to weather conditions, the high the bandwidth, the more fragile it gets.

2022-06-24T03:03:08+00:00

Football is Life

Roar Rookie


Stu, I am the first to admit that I get cranky sometimes, but if you want respect you have to earn it, and launching unwarranted missiles is not going to get you any respect. Just ask Vladimir

2022-06-24T02:39:57+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


Totally.

2022-06-24T02:09:40+00:00

Newy

Guest


I like the idea Stuart, good thinking. Is it logistically feasible or financially viable? I don't know either.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:52:52+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Probably best not to call me naïve, especially when it wasn't really about developing local players and/or our proximity to Europe. But hey! Whatever floats your boat.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:50:24+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


What can I say? Whacky and zany idea. :laughing: :laughing:

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:49:44+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Small payment to parent club. Each club 2 associated players at max. 12 clubs $100,000 budget per season. $50,000 for each visit. Total spend $1.2 million. Small portion of the $140 million from Silver Lake. Worth investing in my view.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:45:45+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Hard to know which one was the worst. A tough race.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:45:02+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Hopefully we see some change. Kevin Rudd is winding up as we speak.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:42:05+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I hope you have had a chance to read 'Be my guest' by Jason Goldsmith and Lucas Gillard. It looks deeply into the guest player role over the years in Australia and is well worth the time. I agree that seeing the players is paramount. Worth investing in in my view.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:39:43+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


The opening point is valid, yet I can't help but think a small portion of the $140 million could be used to ease the clubs' concerns. Tough for Hrustic and Ryan I know. But for many of the others, game time is often inconsistent. A quick trip here during a window or when recovering from injury might be exactly what they need and a benefit to the club. I know, I'm mad, but we need ideas. Thanks for your always balanced and fair commentary. It is in stark contrast to some of the nastiness I took yesterday! Cheers.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:35:38+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I’m pretty sure it is my 5G, gets very sketchy with high wind or cloud and the tower is fairly close-by. By who would know? All a bit hit and miss sometimes.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:33:20+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


That is the issue FT NSD, but with players needing a hit-out whilst coming back from injury or spending many minutes on the pine (as many of our boys do), would some clubs not actually be able to use it to their advantage.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:31:38+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


It is a very sad, moving and detailed story. Has been written about extensively as well.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:30:48+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Exactly, we need ideas, no matter how mad they may seem. I honestly think this could work, with only players like Hrustic in bigger leagues potentially creating issues in terms of permission to return to Australia. Most should have no problem.

AUTHOR

2022-06-24T01:29:05+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Yes. And I would suggest each game with a Socceroo back for a visit would drag a few extra in. Small outlay to parent club, timed right....it could actually work IMO.

2022-06-24T01:16:07+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


While I'd love to see some Socceroos players come back for stints in the A League, I'm fairly sure they'd make very little difference to TV audiences, with small bumps to stadium attendees. Most of our players aren't big names and the players certainly aren't the reason the public love our national team. It's what they represent and the importance of the matches being played that gets people tuning in.

2022-06-24T00:51:21+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


No Craig Johnston's club Liverpool told him they wouldn't pay his wages if he went to play for the Socceroos. As a result of that Craig Johnston wanted the wages he would lose to be paid for him to play Australia in the Scotland match. The wages were more than the amount the rest of team combined were being paid so Arok couldn't afford him. Arok still had Kosmina ,Soper when Krencevic and Mitchell went to Europe,he also managed to get them back in the Socceroos when they made trips to Australia. Patikas, Kalantzis, Hristodolou , Arok never got to use his Greek based players apart from Patikas occasionaly.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar