AFL News: Players warned over high contact, Riewoldt blasts Saints, Ryder hit for six, Hayes banned, Rutten safe

By The Roar / Editor

The AFL has issued a warning players will no longer be rewarded with free kicks when they duck or shrug their heads in tackles.

The AFL has sought to clarify its position on head-high contact after heated debate surrounding young Collingwood dynamo Jack Ginnivan and whether he was being umpired differently to other players.

The league says a player with the ball, who is deemed to have a prior opportunity, and attempts to shrug, duck or lift an arm will be called for holding the ball.

Via a statement to clubs and the media, the AFL highlighted three examples, one involving Ginnivan, from rounds 17 and 18 to demonstrate players ducking or shrugging tackles.

The AFL admitted umpires incorrectly paid a free kick to Melbourne forward Kysaiah Pickett after he shrugged a tackle from Port Adelaide captain Tom Jonas.

“First and foremost, players attempting to win the ball must be protected and the onus on duty of care is on the tackler,” the AFL’s head of umpiring Dan Richardson said.

(Photo by Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

“However, having won the ball, the ball carrier has a duty of care to not put themselves in a position for high contact.

“Ultimately, the rules do not reward players for putting themselves in vulnerable positions to draw a free kick. 

“This is something we prefer not to see in our game at any level.

“We want to be clear, if the umpire believes the ball carrier is responsible for the high contact, then they won’t be rewarded.

“Our umpires strive to get every decision right, every single time, however there are instances where, just like players, decisions are made at full speed at ground level without the benefit of slow-motion replay.

“The health and safety of players is the primary concern of both the AFL and the clubs, and we will continue to work with clubs, their coaching panels, as well as players to ensure the safety of the game.”

Hawthorn’s Dylan Moore and Carlton captain Patrick Cripps (29 each) have received the most free kicks this season, followed by four players with 28.

Riewoldt blasts Saints

Former St Kilda captain Nick Riewoldt has lashed his old AFL club’s effort against the Western Bulldogs, accusing the Saints of again failing to stand up when it counted.

The Saints turned in a lamentable performance against the Bulldogs on Friday night, their 28-point defeat a flattering scoreline after a first half that included just 11 tackles.

It meant they missed an opportunity to jump inside the top eight, instead slipping to 10th as they look to play finals for only the second time in 11 years.

Riewoldt accused the Saints of failing to back up their words with action after suggesting tackling pressure would be a hallmark of their games this season.

“Eleven tackles in a half of footy … they talk about pressure, they talk about the value they put on pressure and role-playing, particularly in that front half.

“But they don’t value pressure like they have potentially in the past,” he told Fox Sports.

“The Western Bulldogs walk away from the game having expected a fierce contest, and they were never challenged, so I can’t explain it.

“I can’t explain what’s happened to a team that was 8-3 and has been able to reel off one win in the last six games.”

Former Melbourne captain Garry Lyon labelled St Kilda “an all-talk footy club”.

“We will talk, we will tell you this is what we are going to do and we don’t have the ability to go and act on that,” he told Fox Sports.

“That’s a damning indictment of a footy club.”

Riewoldt said a tactical ploy for the Saints to move the football slowly was “either a flawed strategy or non-adherence to whatever the strategy was”, adding they again hadn’t handled a big occasion.

The Friday night clash was an eight-point game, with the Bulldogs jumping the Saints into ninth position.

“It’s almost like what we saw, remember round one, when St Kilda came out in the first half against Collingwood, massive build-up, massive stakes, prime time and it was a passive, passive effort,” he said.

“Get the football, non-threatening, happy to just let the game flow out.”

Dejected St Kilda players walk from the ground after the round 18 AFL match against the Western Bulldogs. (Photo by Darrian Traynor/Getty Images)

Ryder season could be over

Star St Kilda veteran Paddy Ryder could miss the rest of the AFL season, casting doubt on his AFL future.

The dynamic ruckman hurt his calf late in the Saints’ disappointing 28-point loss to the Western Bulldogs on Friday night.

St Kilda on Monday confirmed Ryder would miss between four and six week after scans revealed damage to his calf.

With five home-and-away rounds remaining, the Saints sit 10th on the ladder and face an uphill battle to quality for the finals.

Though 34, Ryder remains one of St Kilda’s most important players and forms a lethal ruck combination with Rowan Marshall.

But out-of-contract and with a history of soft-tissue injuries, Ryder is no certainty to play on next year.

Having debuted in 2006, Ryder has played 281 games, including 38 for St Kilda after moving to Moorabbin from Port Adelaide ahead of the 2020 season.

Saints teammate Dan McKenzie has also suffered a calf injury and will miss up to six weeks.

Blues cop Hayes ban

Carlton have opted against challenging the two-match AFL suspension handed down to Will Hayes for the dangerous tackle that concussed Geelong’s Sam Menegola.

Hayes tackled Menegola to the ground during Saturday night’s clash at he MCG, not realising the Cats midfielder had already lost control of the ball.

There did not appear to be any overt malice in the incident.

However, Menegola’s head struck the ground and he had no way of protecting himself, which led the match review officer to his decision.

The incident was assessed as careless conduct, high impact and high contact. Menegola had to be substituted out of the match.

Former Western Bulldogs midfielder Hayes was playing his second match for Carlton – his first in the starting 22 – since being selected in the mid-season draft.

The 27-year-old had 23 disposals in an impressive display but will now miss matches against GWS and Adelaide as the Blues chase a top-four spot.

Menegola has already spent time on the sidelines because of concussion this year after receiving a head knock during a VFL match in April.

Meanwhile, Hawthorn midfielder Tom Mitchell has been offered a $1000 fine for making careless contact with an umpire during his side’s win against West Coast on Sunday.

Gold Coast’s Matt Rowell has also escaped with a financial sanction, copping a $2000 whack for a dangerous tackle on Jye Caldwell in their loss to Essendon.

Tigers duo sidelined

Richmond will be without Dustin Martin and Tom Lynch as they look to bounce back from consecutive defeats in their crucial match against Fremantle.

Martin and Lynch suffered hamstring injuries in rounds 16 and 17 respectively, and were sidelined in Saturday’s costly upset loss to North Melbourne.

Richmond had hoped they would be fit to return against the Dockers at Marvel Stadium on Friday night, but the Tigers on Monday put a line through the pair for another week.

In better news for Richmond, Ivan Soldo (thumb), Sydney Stack (fractured cheekbone) and Jack Ross (knee) are expected to be available for selection.

Young defender Josh Gibcus is a chance to play despite being substituted out of the Kangaroos loss with a shoulder injury.

Richmond (9-8) are clinging to eighth spot, having lost their past two matches by a combined six points.

They have lost three of their last four ahead of the meeting with fourth-placed Fremantle (12-5), who dropped a home game against Sydney last week.

And Adelaide teen Josh Rachele is expected to spend at least another week on the sideline nursing the hip complaint that has sidelined him since round 16.

(Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Rutten safe after Blues get out of rut

Essendon coach Ben Rutten feels his job is safe after a three-game winning streak that has revitalised the Bombers’ stuttering 2022 campaign.

While the club has undertaken an internal review, announced when they were reeling at 2-10, the second-year coach appears set to fend off calls for a change at the helm of the Bombers.

His side has beaten finals-bound Sydney, a COVID-depleted Brisbane and top eight-aspirant Gold Coast in consecutive weeks, and Rutten believed he’d shown what the Bombers could be capable of with him in charge.

“I’ve got a lot of belief about what this group is capable of, and we’re a developing group and we’re starting to learn about each other,” he said.

“And the last few weeks have been really important for us to get a bit of belief and a bit of confidence in what we’ve been doing.

“There’s a lot of work getting done that’s starting to bear a bit of fruit now, there’s always a bit of a lag effect when you start doubling down on a few areas, you don’t quite see the results probably for four to six weeks, potentially, after the fact.”

While acknowledging reviews can often spell the end of a coach’s tenure, Rutten said he’d rely on his continual dialogue with Essendon heavies to feel confident he was not in the firing line.

“I’ve got a really strong relationship with (football boss) Josh Mahoney, (chief executive) Xavier Campbell, (president) Paul Brasher, we talk weekly, a couple of times a week, and it’s really important we’re really aligned with what we’re doing,” he said.

“Certainly we weren’t having from a results point of view a season we liked and part of the process of getting better and continually defining your best is reviewing and making sure that we’re looking at all areas.

“My role is to support the players and continue to lead and direct the club … hold the vision. That’s been a really good learning period for me as a less experienced coach and we’ve put a lot of work in the last month to six weeks.”

Meanwhile, Rutten confirmed Essendon would offer captain and unrestricted free agent Dyson Heppell a contract, as the 30-year-old is linked to other clubs.

“We absolutely want him at our club next year, there’s no doubt about that,” he said. “I know ‘Hep’ is keen to stay, so it’s about getting the finer details sorted.”

Clubs told to lift COVID-safe game

AFL chief executive Gillon McLachlan says staying COVID-safe is just another area where clubs must be disciplined if they want to win a premiership.

The league is insistent it will continue to push through surging case numbers and won’t postpone even finals should a team be wiped out with a number of absences through health and safety protocols.

While a return to ‘bubbles’ and mandating other stricter procedures seems off the cards, McLachlan suggested clubs would take it upon themselves to minimise the risk if they wanted to contend at the back-end of the year.

“It feels there’s another surge going on now and we all know the steps we can do to protect ourselves, and I know the clubs know that and the players know that,” he told the Seven Network.

“It’s individual responsibility … the players need to live their lives but we all know this is a discipline and resilience competition.

“The most disciplined clubs are going to have the most players available and I think everyone understands that and I know the players do.”

Brisbane lost five players for their round 17 clash with Essendon and their club was locked down the following week, highlighting the impact the virus could have on teams potentially in finals.

Geelong coach Chris Scott admitted COVID-19 avoidance was “towards the front of the queue” of his club’s thinking.

“The AFL have given us some advice, at-the-margin type stuff like, which actually helps us,” he told Fox Sports.

“The AFL suggests we don’t have superfluous people in the rooms pre-game or post-game, it’s easy to say no when that advice has come from the AFL.

“We’ve got a responsibility to the community as well to lead and so what we’re saying to our players is you’ve got to take this seriously … 25-year-olds getting really sick at the moment who are vaccinated, it’s unlikely that’s going to be the problem, but the contagion is a problem.

Scott said teams would have to be ready for the challenges the virus could throw up and not be rattled when that happens.

“It’s very real for us, we could have no symptoms be COVID positive and not be able to play or not be able to coach,” he said.

“You’ve just got to accept that some curve balls will be thrown your way and then it’s a matter of not overreacting when they inevitably come.”

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-21T10:01:58+00:00

Kane

Roar Rookie


Yeah right. Obviously you're a do as I say not as I do kind of bloke.

2022-07-21T04:17:51+00:00

M. Rockatansky

Guest


Can't fully see the future, but if I squint just right, I just get a peek, and my eyes be sniffin 9th.

2022-07-21T03:43:28+00:00

O M

Roar Rookie


Thats right and no-one knows where that is yet, unless of course you can see the future! :stoked:

2022-07-21T03:42:31+00:00

O M

Roar Rookie


Neither have been fined so neither are guilty of staging, whereas McKay has and is!

2022-07-21T03:00:58+00:00

M. Rockatansky

Guest


Doesn't matter where they are now, its where they finish

2022-07-21T02:53:12+00:00

Kane

Roar Rookie


Actually I reckon Grimes has, but what's it matter if he's been fined or not? Doesn't mean he hasn't done it which he has on quite a few occasions and so has Jack. Whether you want to admit it or not is totally up to you but every football follower has seen it.

2022-07-20T22:44:52+00:00

O M

Roar Rookie


They're 8th.

2022-07-20T21:54:08+00:00

O M

Roar Rookie


No, Harry definitely stages. He goes all weak at the knees very easily and flops like a fish. As I said, have Grimes and Jack ever been fined?

2022-07-20T06:58:15+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Finally, so doe's this mean we can go back to the 2017 finals and null and void Shueys kick after the siren. Whoa hooo. Go Port. Winner winner chicken dinner. :laughing:

2022-07-20T04:04:37+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Mills get a lot of tackles which is great for fantasy scores

2022-07-20T02:53:06+00:00

Kane

Roar Rookie


You haven't seen them stage because you choose not to see it, a bit like most of your commentary on here. Has Harry staged? Yes he has but I think a lot what people see as staging with his is him just not being strong enough in the contest and getting pushed off the ball too easily rather than outright playing for free kicks.

2022-07-20T00:51:26+00:00

fabian gulino

Roar Rookie


Stkilda again failing when it matters up and down every year.they have to snap out of this trend,if they want to play finals anything soon.Nick Riewalt has e ery right to savage his EX club.

2022-07-20T00:13:00+00:00

M. Rockatansky

Guest


Nah, Ninethmond are back baby!

2022-07-19T20:56:09+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


Go straight to Mills if you can. He will be a more reliable scorer than Kelly, Warner and LDU.

2022-07-19T20:21:05+00:00

PeteB

Roar Rookie


If he was a key player Macca there would be an appeal for sure. Nothing wrong with the method. He wasn’t to know the ball had spilled free. Nothing more than a free kick there.

2022-07-19T12:56:04+00:00

Brendon the 1st

Roar Rookie


Fantasy league footy, last round, then finals

2022-07-19T11:36:10+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


I have no idea what you are on about Brendo but definitely get UDL in stat!

2022-07-19T11:32:41+00:00

Brendon the 1st

Roar Rookie


Mars bar every day

2022-07-19T11:21:04+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


“You ducked into it” has been a reason not to pay high contact since at least when I started playing junior football almost 40 years ago. The umpires won’t have too much trouble with spotting players doing “a Ginnivan” the arm will periscope, the legs will go limp and the head thrash back. If people are worried about the job getting too hard for umpires perhaps we should expect the players to stop trying to trick the umpires and put more pressure on them? We fine stagers, we not those who duck into tackles?

2022-07-19T11:14:04+00:00

O M

Roar Rookie


I haven’t seen them stage. Have they ever been fined? No. Apparently McKay has, and will be again if he continues with his fish flopping act.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar