September comes early for Melbourne and Collingwood in blockbuster finals preview

By Avatar / Roar Guru

The finals have come early for both Melbourne and Collingwood on Friday night, with their ladder positions meaning that if the finals were to begin this weekend, they’d be contesting a qualifying final at the MCG.

Going into Round 21, the Dees and Pies sit in second and third place on the ladder respectively, with the latter having won their past ten matches in a row to prove themselves as the real deal under rookie coach Craig McRae.

Last Saturday afternoon the Pies survived yet another close match, edging out Port Adelaide by a goal at the MCG to shuffle closer to securing a double chance for the third time in five years.

It was their fifth straight win by a single-figure margin. They’ve come back from 26 points down to defeat North Melbourne by seven, survived a scare from the Crows to win by five and had Jamie Elliott kick the matchwinning goal against Essendon in Round 19.

The win over the Bombers very nearly didn’t happen, as Harrison Jones had the chance to complete what would’ve been an epic comeback victory for his side in the final minute only to hit the post, after which the Pies produced the passage of play culminating in Elliott’s winner.

McRae’s efforts in lifting the Pies back into the finals are to be commended given the mess predecessor Nathan Buckley left behind, with many predicting at the start of the year the club would even fall as far as winning the wooden spoon for the first time since 1999.

(Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

There was also the overseas drama involving forward Jordan De Goey, who sat out their Round 15 clash against GWS in order to clear his head.

Their impressive form has many declaring them genuine flag contenders, and there is the chance that they could better their 2018 effort in which they fell just short of a record-equaling 16th premiership when they lost to the West Coast Eagles by just five points in the grand final.

They will fancy their chances of an 11th-straight win when they come up against the Dees, who appear to have overcome a rough mid-season patch during which they lost five of nine matches, including three in a row at the MCG in Rounds 11 to 13.

For the second time this season Simon Goodwin’s men headed west, back to the scene of their premiership triumph last year, and again returned east with the points courtesy of a 46-point win over a disappointing Fremantle side last Friday night.

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

There had been some questions raised about their desire to defend their flag, especially with the lure of doing so in front of their fans at the MCG, after a form slump that had seen them lose to the Dockers, Pies, Sydney Swans, Geelong Cats and Western Bulldogs.

There is also speculation surrounding forward Luke Jackson, who has been linked with a return home at the end of the season. If he does leave the club, it would leave a hole in the Melbourne forward line.

But they could be starting to return to top form with the finals just a month away. This Friday night’s clash against the Pies is the first of back-to-back home matches against huge Victorian oppositions before they wrap up with a trip to the Gabba to face the Brisbane Lions.

It will also be the first time the two sides meet on a Friday night since 2007, at which point the Dees were about to slide into a decade-long oblivion while the Pies were four years removed from back-to-back grand final losses to the Lions.

For the Dees a victory will be paramount to ramping up the pressure on the top-placed Geelong Cats, who have a very soft run home and are poised to claim the minor premiership for the second time in four years.

The stakes are higher for the Pies, as they would have the chance to move up to second on the ladder but would have to pray for an unlikely Cats form slump and also win their final two matches to finish on top for the first time since 2011.

They still have to play the Sydney Swans next weekend in a match that could well decide which of them finishes higher on the ladder, before a final-round MCG blockbuster against the Blues in the penultimate match of the regular season.

What Craig McRae’s men have achieved this year has certainly not gone unnoticed, but they could emerge as the team to watch in September should they complete the double over the Dees this season, which would be a first since 2009.

As for the Dees, it’s crunch time as their premiership defence starts to ramp up a notch or two.

The Crowd Says:

2022-08-07T05:42:34+00:00

Mitcher

Guest


I would say you are displaying excessive pride in yourself if you take pleasure in the pain of others when your own pain is so close at hand your own pain is so close at hand C’mon mate. Find a life

2022-08-06T04:50:53+00:00

Lew

Guest


The "clearly more talented Dees just can't beat the Pies!

2022-08-06T04:48:26+00:00

Lew

Guest


And add Dees twice to that, that is 1st and 2nd.

2022-08-05T05:46:36+00:00

Chris M

Guest


Thanks, George.

2022-08-05T05:15:16+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Your not reading what I write. Your guessing what I think. I explained above why the Magpies and Blues are different topics. I am not angry about any football side, ever. A strong tone may be used, but usually to be provocative or in jest. But the Pies, most weeks I have been rooting for them. I will against Melbourne. But I still think they are in for some beltings, pre finals. And Mason is challenged.

2022-08-05T04:17:59+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Well 7 of 8 finals sides won’t win Yattz so you have a fair chance in saying we will bomb out. I rate our bottom 5 players so much I couldn’t tell you who they would even be? I think we have a few elite and are very even after that. Might be why we have won so many close ones. Give me their names and I’ll give you honest feedback. You’re very angry of late and your Pies comment was out of character if you don’t like the word strange.

2022-08-05T03:39:43+00:00

The real SC

Roar Rookie


Tonight's match will be a Top 4 or a Top 2 showdown. At the end of the day, it will all come down to percentage. Craig McRae has managed to turn things around for the club after a dismal last year (with the departure of coach Nathan Buckley). I am thinking that Collingwood will win tonight and they are playing good footy. Melbourne started off well winning the first 10 matches, but losses to Fremantle, Sydney and Collingwood, Geelong and the Bulldogs have dented their Top 2 hopes.

2022-08-04T22:04:39+00:00

Yattuzzi

Roar Rookie


Not nearly as bizarre or strange as insulting people about oneism because you disagree. Calling people strange is also out of Realist and maybe Don’s playbook. If it walks like a duck, it quacks like a duck, maybe it lives under a bridge. Carlton are like Old Croghan man. Risen from the mire, the bog of low ladder positions and wooden spoon clinging to them, pulling them down. They should celebrate their achievement. Collingwood, are referred to in a different sentence as they are a different topic. To help, the differentiation, I have given them a new paragraph. One year out of finals is hardly thirty years in the wilderness. Whether they met good teams at their weakest, some teams choking or a fortunate roster of weak teams and home state games, they have made finals and may even get the second chance. But they are strung together with blue tack and string. Their bottom five players don’t rate. They will be found out pre finals and belted into 2023.

2022-08-04T22:01:39+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Macca pies were given a favourable draw cause they finished 17th last year. They didn’t envision in their wildest dreams top 4 calculations. Good luck to them & when finals start a new season dawns, good luck to blues as well. :thumbup: Also if the dogs make the finals which is unlikely l hope they obliterate all & sundry :stoked:

2022-08-04T21:48:58+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Virgil the all time chokers of the last ten years or so is the Mighty Home & Away Kings :laughing:

2022-08-04T21:20:41+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


Very true, but for all those teams to have their day against the Pies seems more than coincidence

2022-08-04T21:19:11+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


” When they have shown the can regulalry compete with the best teams on the big stage and dominate the lower teams.“ As for beating top 8 sides, as I said the next 3 weeks will tell.

2022-08-04T16:51:32+00:00

Crock' O' Clock

Roar Rookie


The only thing to cure happiness, is a good dose of Macca! :laughing:

2022-08-04T15:27:21+00:00

Griffo 09

Roar Rookie


Perhaps. Or is it the opposite sometimes? Anyway, the point being, I think it's just a Carlton-Collingwood thing.

2022-08-04T14:24:06+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


Dam thats good. Any chance another draw seems collingwood likes keeping them close.lol.

2022-08-04T13:55:23+00:00

Virgil

Roar Rookie


Jamie Elliot is 70 dollars to kick 5.

2022-08-04T13:33:27+00:00

AdamDilligafThompson

Roar Rookie


I tipped Melbourne but im not exactly confident. If collingwood run at them and attack they are every chance I reckon too.

2022-08-04T13:12:34+00:00

George Apps

Roar Rookie


Very well said Chris, you nailed some of my thoughts about the Woodsmen. Macca enjoys being contentious - ignore him - I usually do.

2022-08-04T13:04:40+00:00

Virgil

Roar Rookie


I thought it was Geelong that normally got found out in finals?

2022-08-04T12:59:55+00:00

Virgil

Roar Rookie


:laughing:

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar