Have the Northern Hemisphere sides taken over the international game?

By Tim J / Roar Rookie

When I was a nipper at the age of 8 years old, I watched my first All Blacks game live in England.

Bleary-eyed in the early hours with my hot chocolate and four pieces of toast, I was wondering what style the men in black would produce.

They rucked the English back onside and came out with a close win. Being young and naïve I ran and woke my mother, saying, “We won, mum!”

Her reply: “Good, now good to bed and talk to me later.”

Since then I have watched every game when the All Blacks have played in the north, with appreciation of many players and tactics that the Northern Hemisphere have produced.

Many are saying that the Northern Hemisphere have overtaken the the teams in the the Southern Hemisphere, and the question comes up that the teams from the south are not at the same standard of the past.

I would say that it is a case of the North having closed the gap with a change of game style, and forward thinking.

Northern Hemisphere

England came to Australia under a lot of pressure after another average Six Nations tournament. Eddie Jones was under the normal level of scrutiny.

After the Wallabies came away with a deserved win with a good game plan in the first Test, England tinkered with their point of focus.

They put pressure on in the next two Tests and the Wallabies’ discipline fell apart, for England to take the series 2-1.

(Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

It was similar with Ireland versus the All Blacks, the Irish could see the weaknesses in the All Blacks’ play and took full advantage to deservedly win the series 2-1.

Wales had the unenviable task of playing the Springboks in South Africa with an injury-hit team. To their credit, they hung tough but the outcome was still what many expected! A series win to South Africa, but respect was earned.

Wales won the Six Nations and then injuries hit them hard, they cannot be disregarded for the Rugby World Cup next year.

France are playing a Kiwi style of game, with focus on the forwards, while having great hands including interlinking with the backline.

Ireland’s strength is the forwards and set pieces, but they also have a backline that can punish the opposition.

Both of those sides are deservedly the best two in the north currently, and they have built genuine squad depth.

Southern Hemisphere

Australia, who broke the run of loses to England in the first Test, just could not back it up but were still very much in the game in the next two Tests.

Discipline again cost them dearly and their game plan was not evident. It is difficult when you are struggling with no real leadership, to bring the players together.

Injuries affected them similar to how this affected Wales. When your playmaker is out and your leadership in the forwards is not there, it makes it extremely difficult.

Australia will have most players back next year which will add much-needed cohesion.

The Wallabies have a good draw and will be in the conversation come Rugby World Cup time, and the squad will be better for their experience from this season.

South Africa – write them off at your peril.

They have used this season to build depth and have now got a gun in Damian Willemse. He will be one of the stars in the World Cup.

Malcom Marx! What can one say? He just never relents and he does not have a bad game in him, he would the first pick for most if not all other teams.

South Africa are the defending world champions, and will be primed by the time the Rugby World Cup comes around.

New Zealand are just starting to build with more consistency in selections and a game plan that suits the players and their strengths. With Aaron Smith and Richie Mo’unga having built a strong relationship and understanding things are looking on the up.

(Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

Against Ireland one can only guess whether the series would have turned out differently if the right players were picked and played in their preferred positions. Also, the game plan that is working well now, one wonders how Ireland would have played against it.

The Southern Hemisphere sides are now building to next year with the End of Year Tours very close.

This will give us more answers while being aware that the teams will still experiment, I see that there is very little between both hemispheres.

Let’s just hope that it does not come down to the officials and TMOs to determine results come World Cup time, otherwise I will be eating more than just toast.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Roarers, who do you think is the favourite?

And a harder one: who will make the last four?

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2022-10-25T03:36:14+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


Australia have won the RWC, also lost to NZ in the final of the 2015 Tournament. So they have been past the QF.

2022-10-25T02:07:56+00:00

Kent Dorfman

Roar Rookie


yes, looks like private ownership's come back to bite them on the proverbial! Maybe now if the players are contracted to their relevant national RFU's then players will be made avail for internationals, Lions tours, RWC's etc

2022-10-17T16:15:21+00:00

Jim

Guest


IMO it looks like the ARU is perfectly capable of killing the game in Aus without any help from the Brits, Frenchies or any other country.

2022-10-17T09:31:45+00:00

ShaghaiDoc

Guest


The Choir Boys have never gotten past the QF's at the RWC and the sole purpose of a French RWC campaign is to beat New Zealand. I dream of a final with the AB's and the Tri-colours with both teams uninhibited by their coaches. I once had a chat with a Frenchman in Carrefours in Qi Bao (Shanghai), and I asked him why Kiwis were so popular in France and he said, "Because they play like us". We all see the world differently but he did mention that the Kiwis saved them in two world wars. Lol.

AUTHOR

2022-10-16T23:52:47+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


A great win for the women vs Wales yesterday OM, considering it had player’s in to give them game time.

2022-10-16T22:30:37+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


Perhaps Im just not understanding your criptic messages.

2022-10-16T18:55:27+00:00

scrum

Roar Rookie


Well Jacko you do have a high regard for your own infallibility .

2022-10-16T10:37:43+00:00

BeastieBoy

Roar Rookie


YES. They control the rules of the game to suit themselves. It has killed the game in Australia and relegated it to a minor sport. New Zealand will follow, but it will just take longer. Once League establish a second team in NZ and create a local derby, watch the further change.

2022-10-16T05:07:34+00:00

Virgil

Roar Rookie


Do they? Two clubs have just gone into administration and been suspended from the Premier League. It should be a salutary warning for those advocating private equity which is often just another debt which has to be repaid.

2022-10-16T04:56:42+00:00

RayinSydney

Roar Rookie


We are boiling this down now, we’ve established for you that it’s not the Kiwi coaches at issue, rather the Australian players that can’t be coached by Kiwis, and the NZ ‘teams’ who didn’t like it when Australians coached them has come down to Ali Williams leaving the Blues for Canterbury. For the last bit of your self dismantling of your own argument, please let us know what Ali Williams said about Nucifora.

2022-10-16T04:16:16+00:00

Paulo

Roar Rookie


Did he walk out? Or did his contract finish? He may have spent most of ‘07 riding the bench, throwing tanties about it, and then getting disciplined for it, so not sure this is a good example of what ever you are trying to prove? Ali Williams is a person, not a team, and clearly had issues bigger than the coach. Swing and a miss…

2022-10-16T03:26:11+00:00

OJ

Roar Rookie


Ali Williams walked out on Auckland to go and play for Canterbury

2022-10-16T01:29:44+00:00

RayinSydney

Roar Rookie


Cool, you’ve named two teams, what about the examples of them not liking Australian coaches?

2022-10-16T01:05:16+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


100% disagree.

2022-10-16T00:35:07+00:00

scrum

Roar Rookie


Just pointing out that you are a little inconsistent with your evaluation of the Refs effects on outcomes.

AUTHOR

2022-10-16T00:31:15+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


I was impressed by the ref in the OZ vs Scots game also. The mens refs could learn from her as she maintained poise and let the game flow!

2022-10-16T00:28:22+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


I dont really believe that. SA lost to NZ then won from 2nd in their pool. And NZ or France arnt going to lose to Italy, Namibia or Uraguay so they will all get to the 1/4s facing win or go out. Playing a 1/4 v ireland or against SA means you need to win against a top team. AS do they of course.

2022-10-16T00:25:17+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


But thats all just an opinion. There is no fact in it. Its all about Foster selecting or not selecting who you think should be there. He disagrees with your selections just as much as you disagree with his. Laugh all you like but he could well win the WC as HC. I cant think of another coach of the Abs who has had to endure the situation of covid so how are you judging? Every person on here comments how the NH has improved but you still blame foster instead of accepting that the ABs arnt currently 10% better than the opposition. We have a dam good shot at winning the thing. As good a shot as any other nation.

2022-10-16T00:14:06+00:00

Paulo

Roar Rookie


:laughing: wow… just… wow. I really hope you’re just trolling and don’t actually think that it is a massive conspiracy theory. Also, this is an Australian site for Australians, stop talking about Kiwis! :laughing:

2022-10-16T00:10:52+00:00

OJ

Roar Rookie


Auckland, Otago

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar