A grand NEW flag! Melbourne claims first AFLW premiership in thrilling grand final

By Tim Miller / Editor

Foundation AFLW club Melbourne have at last claimed their first premiership, holding off minor premiers Brisbane in a thrilling grand final to end women’s football icon Daisy Pearce’s long wait for the ultimate glory.

Despite a Herculean performance from the Lions’ defence led by Shannon Campbell (19 disposals, eight marks), named player of the match in a losing side and exhausted to the point of vomiting immediately afterwards, the Dees held the favourites goalless for the final three quarters, atoning for their loss to Adelaide in last season’s grand final in April this year.

Humble as ever, Pearce could only praise her teammates following their triumph, reiterating her discomfort with the Dees’ journey having become as much about ‘doing it for Daisy’ as about team success.

“I’ve felt uncomfortable the whole time, the narrative, it being about me, I feel like that’s a glorified thing that happens outside of these four walls,” she told Channel 7 amid the post-match celebrations.

A packed crowd at the controversial venue of Brighton Homes Arena in Springfield was treated to a captivating match, with the final scoreline not doing justice to the frenetic pressure, exceptional defending and constant desperation featured by both sides in a grand final worthy of the name.

A heroic last quarter from Kate Hore was the catalyst for the Dees’ victory, but attention will also turn to a contentious decision to not award the Lions a 50m penalty after Alyssa Bannan tackled Dakota Davidson following a holding the ball free kick.

Such a result looked unthinkable after the Lions slammed on the first two goals of the game and looked set to do what they have done to all but one opponent (Richmond) throughout a dominant AFLW campaign.

A nerveless Davidson set shot was quickly followed by another to Cathy Svarc, the Lions dominating territory with seven o the first 10 inside 50s – and making it count.

Just as symbolic were a pair of defensive efforts at the other end of the ground, Campbell comprehensively beating the great Pearce in a one-on-one contest deep inside 50, before being one-upped by teammate Nat Grider, whose goal-saving chasedown on Megan Fitzsimon was the stuff of instant grand final folklore.

With a solitary behind to their name at quarter time, the Dees seemed thoroughly outclassed despite holding their own against Brisbane’s powerful on-ball brigade: it wouldn’t take long, however, for them to flip the script.

Led by Eliza West (19 disposals) and ruckman Lauren Pearce (17 hitouts), the Dees enjoyed territory domination of their own in the second term, surging to a 16-10 lead in the inside 50 count.

All that was holding them back were Campbell and company, Irish recruit Blaithin Mackin’s goal their only breakthrough of the term as the Lions held firm in defence.

Every chance became a premium, and a bad miss from spearhead Tayla Harris in the opening minutes of the quarter looked set to bite. As did injury woes; Lions captain Bre Konan sending a shiver through the Brisbane camp by limping off with an apparent knee issue midway through the term.

Heavily strapped, Konan would return to start the second half, but her influence on the rest of the game was noticeably inhibited by the knock.

Continuing on their second-quarter surge, it would again be all Demons in the third term. Once more, the Lions’ defence held sway against the onslaught, conceding just one goal – but Harris’ major from point blank range was at least enough to put Melbourne in front for the first time.

A strong Davidson mark on the stroke of three-quarter time gave the Lions hope of snatching back the lead, but the set-shot miss would leave them two points in arrears at three-quarter time. With scoring having slowed to a trickle amid suffocating pressure, it might as well have been twenty.

As it stood, the Lions were unable to trouble the scorers in the final term, managing only three inside 50s as the Demons tackled like maniacs to deny the powerhouse any freedom of movement.

Even Dees hard nut Karen Paxman felt the pain, smashed in a contest just moments after returning to the field and limping off in the arms of the trainers.

Perhaps the Lions’ final true chance of forcing a win arrived via a Davidson holding the ball free kick on Mackin, running the winger down on the half-back flank. Having heard a call of play on, Bannan dashed like mad across half the field, tackling the Lion as Mackin stood mystified on the mark.

However, there would be no 50m penalty, which would have taken Davidson within two kicks of the goals; the umpires ruled that one of them had duped Bannan by not awarding the original holding the ball, enabling the Dees to breathe a sigh of relief.

In the end, the siren only arrived to end one final Dees attacking charge, a Fitzsimon snap coming within metres of the goals as the siren sounded. But not a single person wearing red and blue cared in the slightest.

The Crowd Says:

2022-11-29T05:28:51+00:00

Mark Baptist

Guest


Another option with conferences is this: Going to 21 teams, you can work with three conferences of seven which allows for 24 games in the AFL (each team in your own conference twice, all others six times every seven years - three home and three away) and 20 in the AFLW (each team in your own conference twice, all others four times every seven years - twice home and twice away) with two byes: for the avoidance of doubt, this fixture eliminates pre-season games. As for having 21 teams, I'll go with adding Tassie, Canberra and a third WA team (apologies to Freo and the Eagles on this). As for the finals series, I have the two lower ranked second-placed and third and fourth-placed teams play each other in Week 1 (Pre-Elimination Finals), with the winners of these matches joining the three conference winners and the best second-placed teams in the Final Eight (with first-placed teams and best second-placed being ranked 1st-4th and the second/third/fourth-placed teams being ranked 5th-8th based on record) as we have now. Yes, this setup may have an odd number of teams and rolling byes, but this works just as well.

2022-11-28T06:06:46+00:00

Vicboy

Roar Rookie


One team handled the wind better than another. Shannon was BOG, but West was super important, continually winning the ball in the packs. Bodey’s quietest game for the year - usually reads the ball so well- also a factor.

2022-11-28T03:15:39+00:00

Mark Baptist

Guest


I believe 2023 may prove better for St Kilda, Carlton, Sydney, and West Coast - I believe some measures of resilience, patience and gratitude will be in order for these clubs (these qualities worked for Melbourne and Daisy Pearce, as Sunday demonstrated conclusively). Also, with conferences - I believe these will be returned in the AFLW (introduced in the men's comp) when we go to 20 teams (as Gil put it, "we couldn't sell a 20th place team if we tried") and will be on a geographical basis, which they should have been to begin with. If you ask me, we can work with four conferences of five - names can be debated here - which easily allows for 23 games in the AFL (each team in your own conference twice, all others once) and 18 in the AFLW (each team in your own conference twice, all others twice every three years - once at home and once away) with one bye: for the avoidance of doubt, 18 games is the AFLPA's target for the AFLW season by 2026. As for the finals series, I have the two best third-placed teams play the lower two ranked second-placed teams in Week 1 (Pre-Elimination Finals), with the winners of these matches joining the four conference winners and the higher two ranked second-placed teams in the Final Eight (with first-placed teams being ranked 1st-4th and the second/third-placed teams being ranked 5th-8th based on record) as we have now. If I'm not mistaken, you have minimal chance of two teams in the same conference playing off in the AFL/AFLW Grand Final.

2022-11-28T02:37:15+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


You'd expect high intensity in a grand final. The problem is that the skill base can't handle the intensity; I don't know how many times the players kicked directly to the opposition, missed handballs etc. That's what stops them from clearing the ball from a pack; their skills aren't clean.

2022-11-27T23:45:14+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


Low scoring as it was, I still enjoyed it, and I'm not much of an AFLW watcher. The intensity level was pretty high throughout and both defences were really strong.

2022-11-27T20:23:19+00:00

Wayne Kerr

Guest


Melbourne’s victory sums up why big changes are needed in the AFLW. They had an easy draw, because the AFL wanted the team of the establishment to win a flag. Every team must play each other for it to be a fair competition. If the AFL can’t get everyone to play each other once, then the conference system needs to be reinstated. Conference A would be Brisbane, Melbourne, Bulldogs, Collingwood, North, Richmond, Geelong, Fremantle, and Adelaide. Conference B would be St Kilda, GWS, Sydney, Carlton, Essendon, Hawthorn, GCS, West Coast, and Port. At the moment the competition is unequal, and clubs like St Kilda, Carlton, Sydney, and West Coast face years in the wilderness.

2022-11-27T19:49:29+00:00

G money

Roar Rookie


unwatchable dross

2022-11-27T19:36:54+00:00

Gyfox

Roar Rookie


It was great to see the game at the new Lions Football Centre. A very impressive facility.

2022-11-27T11:07:30+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


It's a very Red n Blue year Norwood West Perth Casey Demons AFLW

2022-11-27T10:27:23+00:00

berrlins

Roar Pro


few have done more for AFLW than Daisy I'm glad she got a flag there are few more deserving. Brisbane didn't seem up to it apart from the defense.

2022-11-27T09:14:02+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


That was an awful marquee game for womens footy. 4 goals kicked in an hour of footy.

2022-11-27T08:26:38+00:00

Ian_

Roar Rookie


I thought the Dees dominated all but a few minutes in the first quarter. They were almost invariably first to the ball and the Lions were hanging on grimly in defence, which kept the game close.

2022-11-27T07:06:17+00:00

mrl

Roar Rookie


2 all…what happened to extra time and penalties!! When it’s hard to score its more likely there will be a close and thrilling final few minutes. Enjoyed that, well done ladies. Played hard and with intensity. Deserved a larger venue!

Read more at The Roar