'Ireland is the new New Zealand': Top dogs and proud of it, the emerald isle is locked in passionate embrace of rugby

By Harry Jones / Expert

There was a small dog on a green in Dublin on Sunday.

The only one unleashed despite a sign: “All dogs must be on a lead.” She ran for a half hour, under benches, through legs, into flowers, around the open market, up to the walls of the old church, scampering next to a saggy pantsed guitarist playing the blues; and from time to time, she did confront other dogs.

All of them were bigger. Since they were all leashed, the smallest dog could start funny business with utter impunity. She was a whir of perpetual motion, returning only twice to a frowning man in a tracksuit who sat on a bench next to me and gave her a tiny snack.

She looked at me, gave my hand a quick lick, and tore off into the park.

In a way, the entire languid Irish assemblage was focused on one dog, the only animal life on the green which was free, or felt free.

You could not take your eyes off her.

Her energy (“feckin’ hair on fire” as her tired minder put it) made one think: “Was I once like that? Could I be again?” She was a bit of a hero.

Ireland’s rugby heroes have captured the eyes and hearts of their five million fellow residents.

A bit undersized, freed of Joe Schmidt shackles, doing rugby in a different way than the rest of the big dogs, and impossible to stop watching.

As I had strolled through the city on the day of the Grand Slam match against England, I was struck by how much more besotted the locals had become with their national team even in the four months since last I strode Lansdowne Road.

The island has rugby fever: their greatest team in any sport is here, now. Myths grow, like the harps and stones and saints and famines of yore.

Once a rich man told me: “If you get a lot of money, don’t think your IQ rose along with it.” But I forgot that, along with everyone else: when we succeed, we think we know better.

Ireland is the new New Zealand.

When I travelled to the North Island to watch the Springboks lose (2011) and then win (2018) I marvelled at the depth and ubiquity of Kiwi rugby love and nous. Nobody was immune from the feeling they knew better, and it was palpable how much they adored Richie and the boys.

An octogenarian who gave us tomato soup after a Waikato cave rappel and black water tube trip held forth on a dual playmaker system.

The giant in the morning market explained halfback play; when did he ever crouch at the base?

People who had never seen a scalpel articulated the reasons Richie’s foot was going to be fine.

And everywhere we went: rugby fields and rugby know how.

The Ian Foster saga and the Irish conquest may have taken some of the bloom off the Kiwi love affair with their All Blacks. I suspect that is just a blip and they will be back in full force in France.

But Ireland is still in an innocent phase. Famines form the lifeblood of Irish self conception.

At the game, when English fans would try to jump start their sour chariot, the east stands where I sat erupted with the song of the man who stole food to feed his starving family in County Galway and was sent to Australia.

Ireland rugby fans (photo by Getty Images)

The duelling songs told its own tale. This rugby feast is not the norm. The Irish have been drawn and “quartered” every four years. So no one is counting chickens or putting their eggs in a basket. But the Irish seem intent on grabbing every scrap.

The mobs outside the Shelbourne Hotel stood patiently in the soft rain for an hour; boys on dads’ shoulders to catch a glimpse of Dan and Johnny and Robbie and Hugo.

I had walked from the stadium (where a security man allowed me on the field for a few minutes if I promised not to take a picture) in the morning through the city and then reversed with the crowds after a couple of pints with a gregarious Irish stats guru at The Duke.

Smart and curious people in Ireland from all walks are drawn to rugby. All hands are on deck.

Poets find a way to wax lyrical about the newcomers to the team. Cab drivers like Igor and Jorge asked me shyly to explain the ruck and scrum. Historians are on the radio or TV articulating how this team fits the ethos of the history of the isle. Girls treat the starting hooker like he is a rock star. When did hookers become heartthrobs?

When the stadium opened officially at half past three, a stream of green clad fans filled the concourses.

England practiced on our end. Owen Farrell was the weatherman, detecting eddies of wind and shaping his kicks to Marcus Smith accordingly. Jamie George went seven for seven in a row, hitting the crossbar from 20 metres. Maro Itoje mimicked Jaco Peyper’s warmup, and then just copied it for real. The pied Peyper has that effect on lads.

The Aviva Stadium was provisioned with beer and flags; it is a minimalist place and one of my favourite grounds: nothing detracts or distracts.

Early it was that lines into the loos turned into illegal mauls (disconcertingly, as we were packed and shuffling like polar penguins, the man next to me announced to the melee that he had opened his fly “just to be ready when it is my time”) and I reached my dozenth Guinness before halftime.

England did what must be done to Ireland to have a chance; for a while. Squeeze, kick well, cover any break, and keep the attack narrow.

Manu Tuilagi seemed to have an edge on Bundee Aki in the early going. Loose balls were being collected by the visitors. Itoje had a couple of the best carries I’ve seen him do: using his weight as he always does on defence.

The Irish looked like a small pack. Mack Hansen was scooting around and back like a terrier on the green. The Dublin crowd applaud each catch and swerve as if it is a try.

Behind me, an Irish rain man was unerringly predicting each English action. But tellingly, he was unable to do so for his own team.

The red card was seen as harsh even by the partisans; Freddie Steward sent off for having an elbow rather than really using it.

Hugo Keenan has been the best fifteen in the competition, on balance, and ended up being the decisive player for a new reason.

It was nervy in the Aviva. The curry chips ran out during halftime. The W/C became a condemned place.

“They aren’t gonna just give it to us.”

But in this tournament, Ireland has solved every problem and in the second half pulled away with slick moves, an extra bit of motive, and finishing skills.

I came twice to Dublin in just a few winter months to watch the Irish reformation in person: off the ball resets, close enough to hear the back three calls, study Sexton’s choreography, and see if the pillar and post and pod are just the same but faster or if the setup for the Greens is substantively different.

The beers may not have helped my vision but maybe that is not the point. This team is more of a feeling than a techne. Yes, I saw Robbie Henshaw point out an exact spot for Hansen to occupy: not an obvious one. And the arrangement at ruck is noteworthy: arrival time and height preordained and pretty. Diagonals are inverted and the pods have more players.

However, those are all degrees and spectrums; the secret sauce is reorganisation. The scant time spent on the ground. Measure “total time spent by all players off their feet” and I am certain Ireland is the best by several nautical miles.

As it became certain the Grand Slam was secure, and for the first time in Dublin, with Sexton leading points scorer ever in the Six Nations, and Peter O’Mahony smiling on the sidelines to rapturous applause, the entire place turned into a middle-aged nightclub.

Even the start time (five o’clock) was perfect. As darkening skies came, a series of U2 songs had full audience participation, and it seemed nobody left at all.

Gold confetti on the pitch it was and a classy defeated but valiant George (when did hookers get classy?) walked around the entire field by himself applauding the Irish fans and receiving quite a response.

Aki is the clown of this squad, egged on by a beaming Sexton.

Sheehan leapt into the stands a few feet away from me to hug and assault and hug again a young man he knew quite well.

A helicopter flew over, but was not part of the plan; perhaps a weather copter taking the piss.

An hour after the final whistle, the stadium was not cleared out yet. The streets around were wet and full and frenetic and turning into spontaneous rugby matches.

Find your pub and stick, said some. Roam and stay on your feet: others.

I did a bit of both and finished strong.

There is not a bravado or triumphalism in Ireland over this feat. There is a cheeky smile and an all-in and a reality that the centre of the rugby universe is in Ireland and it is very green.

The Crowd Says:

2023-03-26T21:51:04+00:00

Intotouch

Roar Rookie


Actually that’s not really what happened. The biggest influence on what the IRFU did with professional rugby was the FAI. The IRFU was against rugby ever going professional because they saw what happened to soccer in Ireland when that happened. Celebrated, hugely popular clubs lost their best players to England, attendances fell massively and many clubs died a death and the sport became less popular than ever within a couple of decades. The IRFU once rugby went pro never even toyed with the idea of doing what the FAI did. They made the provinces the pro sides (they’d always existed) under their control from day one and refused any club permission to be fully pro. They copied the central contracts from NZ after a couple of years of top players leaving the provinces to play in the prem. They decided the limit on foreign players, invested in coaches and academies while Wales and Scotland invested in stadia. But nearly every decision the IRFU made was based on what the FAI did that failed.

2023-03-24T19:52:43+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


They went into the RWC ranked 1st. They lost to a team that has never made the REC knock out stage. Seems like choking.

2023-03-24T13:21:13+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


Cant say Id disagree with this. The main similarity for me is that on foot of professionalism the IRFU looked around to see what country structured their rugby landscape the best way to see what ideas they could take to drag the sport into professionalism. They chose to emulate some of the best parts of NZ rugby and how it is structured and then evolved it their own way from the introduction of the Celtic league. Irish rugby 25 years later very much has its own identity, an identity that other rugby sides are now looking at and asking themselves if we are on to something.

2023-03-24T13:20:29+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


— COMMENT DELETED —

2023-03-24T13:12:02+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


SA also finished 2nd in their pool and won the world cup. Losing to Japan I admit was bad but Ireland weren't ranked 1 when they played Japan nor NZ and the slide in form had begun well before the RWC. They lost all their warm up games too.

2023-03-24T09:28:39+00:00

Dida

Roar Rookie


Yeah I know it happens elsewhere. At least World Rugby changed the rules from 3 to 5 years residency. Look it’s probably just part of international sport these days, recruiting from ‘further afield’ seems to be part of the game to get the edge. I guess if a player is willing to pack their bags for another country and ply their trade for 5 years or use their ancestry for eligibility then that’s their choice.

2023-03-24T06:58:24+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


They played NZ because they finished 2nd after losing to Japan

2023-03-24T06:45:26+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


You would certainly hope so Henry. If they want to avoid NZ it would be a worry.

2023-03-24T06:45:10+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


Ireland lost their quarter final to NZ who were ranked number 1 in the world before that game. If rankings are so important, surely that was the expected outcome. Losing to Japan was bad though. NZ ranked 1 lost to England in the semis, was that choking? Im not sure as no one was heavy favourites for that world cup.

2023-03-24T06:41:10+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


As an Ireland fan I personally want NZ in the quarters as this is the team to beat for your first quarter final win. France at home would also obviously be a tougher prospect. Id imagine the Irish team would also relish playing NZ if they make it to the quarters.

2023-03-24T05:44:21+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


I might agree with you if it wasnt the case that NZ and Australia werent guilty of their own regular injections of foreign talent. There were significantly more residency qualified players in the NZ squad when Ireland toured there than there was in the Ireland squad for example. Change the rules by all means but you cant have it every way. Hansen was a guy on the fringes of Australian rugby with a Irish mother. I have no issues with him playing for Ireland. For me these pros on the fringes leaving NZ or Aus to revive their careers elsewhere is less cynical than the schoolboy poaching system prevalent in particular in NZ. Many of these players are the most talented of their age who have already represented their country underage. Sevu Reece, Tongan Thor, Frizzell and many more. I agree on Lowe, JGP and Aki. Maybe Aki less so as he has been in Ireland a decade but players like this are highly unlikely to play for Ireland again with the new 5 year rule and they make up a small contingent of a larger squad of some pretty strong Irish talent.

2023-03-23T21:15:51+00:00

Dida

Roar Rookie


My point is that it doesn’t work in the opposite direction, or very rarely. It still doesn’t sit right with me that a player who came through the system in aus or nz can a few years later be playing for Ireland or Scotland for example. Yeah ok, leave Bealham off the list, that’s fine. I’m just not a fan of changing allegiances at national level, especially when countries are actively chasing guys with ancestry. Lowe, Hansen, JGP, Aki…that’s a fair injection of foreign talent to be fair.

2023-03-23T18:30:05+00:00

WEST

Roar Guru


Looong way to go before they can be called the new All Blacks, Ireland is having good success past few years, granted. But to call them the new All Blacks, we’ll need to see them maintain or stay around number one for at least 20 years before I’d go that far. I’m not surprised, a lot of people are caught up in the excitement. But I wouldn’t go as far as calling them the new All Blacks. Not by a long shot! Given it took them over 100 years to actually beat NZ. But I’m a fan of Ireland, I’m actually liking more of what the French bring. Now that’s a team that has caused us far more trouble in the All Black history than a lot of other teams.. Ireland are riding the emerald wave currently.. But lose a few key players, Sexton especially. They’re not the same beast. Nice try though :thumbup:

AUTHOR

2023-03-23T16:00:58+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Thank you, Viking. Not many cities better to ramble for a weekend! And then, there’s Grand Slam on top of it.

2023-03-23T13:21:56+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


I would disagree that there are normally 5 Aussies and Kiwis in the starting 15. There are very rarely more than 3 in the starting 15. For the first four games of the six nations there were only 3 of Lowe, Hansen, Bealham or Aki in the starting 15. The average for the NZ tour was three starters. There was only one in the November match v SA and two v Australia. For the England game there were four for the first time in a long time. Lowe, Aki, Gibson Park and Hansen. In my view only Lowe, Gibson Park and Hansen are now first choice. Aki is behind Ringrose and Henshaw and Bealham is behind Furlong obviously. Ireland have lots of good wing options to compete with Lowe and Hansen too. Balacoune, Larmor, Earls, Stockdale, Conway to name a few. Bealham is an Aussie from an Irish family who is married to an Irish woman and has lived here for almost 15 years. He never played pro rugby in Australia so he is more a product of Irish rugby at this stage anyway. I know this is an Aussie forum but it is really exaggerated to comical levels in the SH in general the influence SH players have on this Ireland side. Also I agree Nucifora has been brilliant but Philip Browne the former CEO of the IRFU never gets the praise he deserves for the development of Irish rugby long before Nucifora arrived and also afterwards.

2023-03-23T11:37:10+00:00

HenryHoneyBalls

Roar Rookie


Thank you, nice to meet you. Yes Im Irish but born in Australia. Played grassroots Leinster club and schools rugby. Mullingar RFC (Schmidts club) and a well known rugby school in Leinster. Gave up after school as I hated tackling. :laughing:

2023-03-23T11:18:58+00:00

mzilikazi

Roar Pro


Thanks for the link, AC.

2023-03-23T09:40:01+00:00

Phantom

Roar Rookie


No perhaps about it.

2023-03-23T05:56:37+00:00

mzilikazi

Roar Pro


Just saw your comment HHB. I had not picked you are Irish, living in Dublin. Good to have someone in Ireland commenting. Armchair halfback is Irish too, but living in Australia. Are a few others who comment fromIreland, but not that regularly right now...Derm McCrum for example. Are you Dublin born and bred ? Do/did you play rugby ?

2023-03-23T00:49:52+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


You don't think going into the RWC ranked 1st in the world, then losing a pool game to Japan and bowing out at the QF stage is choking?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar