Should Eddie choose the Wright way or the Kellaway to play fullback for the Wallabies?

By John Ferguson / Expert

There are fewer than 100 days until the start of the Rugby World Cup in Paris. International teams are starting to take shape and players are making a last-ditch effort to be part of the 33-man squads

In recent years, the Wallabies have had very few players solidify their role in the first XV, fullback is no different.

The fullback is the all-seeing commander in the back field, who scans, taking charge when bombarded with high-balls and relays vital information to his playmakers. They area also the last line of defence.

Currently, it is a two-horse race for the Wallabies’ No.15 jersey. Tom Wright and Andrew Kellaway.

Wright has been in some deadly attacking form for the ACT Brumbies. Head coach Stephen Larkham has praised Wright’s leadership and his voice, both on the training paddock and in defence.

Down south, Kellaway has been a calming and stabilising presence for a young Melbourne Rebels team.

Wright is seen as the favourite, after two great seasons of Super Rugby Pacific and a solid Wallabies campaign in 2022.

His greatest assets are his ability to see space and attack it. Wright is one of the fastest players in Australia, pairing this with his vision he has been able to grow into a genuine second playmaker.

However, Test matches are a different beast to SRP. Teams have more time to analyse oppositions and better players are ready to exploit any weaknesses found.

Before proceeding, please note these stats are the latest available from Opta and Super Rugby Pacific where both the Rebels and Brumbies have been recorded (stats from after round 14).

The stats show defence is one of Wright’s glaring weaknesses. His defensive stats read as 26 tackles made, 12 missed and no dominant tackles.

A particular area of concern is his inability to make good defensive reads. He has now been gassed by two blind-side flankers and one halfback. Considering he has some of the hottest wheels in Australia, it is not a good look, and it that is only one aspect which is lacking in his defensive game.

Another more traditional aspect of being a fullback is kicking and taking the highballs. Wright has a decent boot on him and is learning quickly how best to use it. Highballs on the other hand, are not his forte and it must improve drastically before World Cup time.

Meanwhile, Kellaway made a great return from injury. His long looping arcs caused havoc for opposition. He is choosing when to inject himself into the play more carefully and this curation is leading to more impactful plays.

Kellaway is quickly becoming a genuine international utility player, having slotted seamlessly into the 11, 13, 14, and 15 jerseys for the Rebels and the back three for the Wallabies.

Kellaway is a safe option who also poses a genuine attacking threat. Kellaway is the more adept kicker out of the two, usually finding grass and relieving pressure.

He doesn’t shirk the tough stuff, and his defensive stats read as 26 tackles made, seven missed and four dominant tackles. He is tackling at 74%, which is not acceptable at international level, but it is an improvement on Wright’s 54%.

(Photo by Getty Images)

Running stats for the two players look as follows:

Player Minutes played Ball carries Carry metres Line breaks Defenders beaten Passes
Wright 871 130 1,419 11 35 93
Kellaway 586 78 732 6 28 44

Wright is getting his hands on the ball often, teams are kicking it to him, and he is doing plenty with it. He usually runs with the ball in two hands, looking for an opportunity to set-up the players around him. For metres carried he is at number one in the competition, and for defenders beaten he is at seventh.

Much of the same applies to Kellaway, with Kellaway making more metres, and beating more defenders per carry. Wright makes more line-breaks, and this is likely due to his change of pace. However, the numbers confirm that Kellaway’s timing of when to inject himself is making for greater impact.

There are other options for the fullback position, Jordan Petaia, Reece Hodge and Jock Campbell. However, Wright and Kellaway are the only two which add any real impetus to a high-powered Wallabies backline.

Whoever wears the No.15 jersey in Pretoria won’t necessarily wear it in France, but it will be a strong indicator as to who Eddie Jones sees as his front-runner.

Balance in the back three is vital so if you pick a defensive risk like Wright, you need a reliable Petaia or Kellaway on one wing as well as tireless Marika Koroibete ready to sweep and cover on the other.

If Kellaway is the man at the back, you can afford to have electric attacking weapons, but defensive liabilities like Wright or Mark Nawaqanitawase on a wing.

Picking the players to suit the game-plan is a truism, as for what that means for Jones and the Wallabies is anybody’s guess. But Kellaway is the more reliable choice and Australia has enough attacking-threats across the park to forego an out-and-out attacking weapon like Wright, for the security and poise of Kellaway.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2023-06-13T03:30:42+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Thanks so much Cassandra, as far as replacing Hodge goes, unless Kellaway can kick for goal 60m out and can hoof it equally far on the fly it would be difficult to replace one with the other. Hodge covers 10-15 at international, Kellaway covers 13-15. I think Hodge should be used as a 10, 12, 15 cover, while Kellaway will be the swiss-army knife for 11, 13, 14, 15. Both on the bench wouldn't be wrong either.

AUTHOR

2023-06-13T03:26:21+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Thanks for the comment Cassandra! As per my piece above, he is one of the fastest players in Aus, perhaps second behind Corey Toole, he has no excuse being gassed by a 6. He also tries to fake Robertson out, have you ever seen anyone do that? Reading is as important as being able to make the tackles when they matter, which he doesn't. Personally, being caught flat-footed at 15 is not an excuse I think Eddie would accept.

AUTHOR

2023-06-13T03:22:51+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Thank Ozinsa! I think fullback is all together a much more difficult role, there's so much evidence of this but specifically on defence more skills are needed. For wings, they usually have the sideline to show people to as well as having players on their inside so they can hold and wait for reinforcements or rush and close down the last man. At fullback errors are multiplied as you are the last line of defence but Wright's issues as outlined in the piece show he is not yet experienced enough to know how to defend at fullback, even starker yet lacks the physical nature to put his body on the line. If you want a look at this first hand just re-wtach the Hurricanes vs Burmbies game during the regular season, Wright's tackle on Asafa Aumua in the second half was beyond embarrassing he should have been penalised and sent off for no arms in the tackle and falling in-front of him. As far as form defensively on the wing, I think it's rather can you remember him having a good game as opposed to a bad game. Marky Mark is definitely improving.

2023-06-13T02:27:18+00:00

Cassandra

Roar Rookie


Great point about Kellaway's utility value, too, BTW. Maybe it's time to consider him for the utility role ahead of Hodgey?

2023-06-13T02:23:31+00:00

Cassandra

Roar Rookie


Thanks John, really interesting piece. However, I disagree that all three of those tries were Wright's fault and show a defensive weakness. The one against the Hurricanes on the weekend was a shocker. TBH, it looked like he just didn't want to put his body on the line, but the other two he was beaten by a pretty good change of direction on one and raw pace, whilst he was flat footed on the other. I don't think even Matt Burke could have stopped those. I think his positives at fullback definitely outweigh his negatives and his defensive weaknesses.

2023-06-12T13:57:48+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


This is a good read and a relatively good problem for Eddie. Marika, JP, MN, Wright and Kellaway are a strong set of back 3 players. Getting the balance right is Eddie's job. Was Tom Wright always a problem in defense? I can't recall worrying about him when he played as a winger. Likewise, Nawaqanitawase appeared to have found his feet defensively on the wing this year but has been shown up badly at fullback. Is the position a lot harder to play defensively?

2023-06-11T09:02:29+00:00

RURALOZ

Roar Rookie


Just saw Jock Campbell out kick Damien mckenize over the weekend. He was flawless in his execution of the game plan.

AUTHOR

2023-06-11T01:40:56+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Cheers Dean appreciate it!

2023-06-09T20:51:17+00:00

Cec

Roar Rookie


Definitely in the 33. His experience and influence will only help the younger boys. And you never know with injuries. Ask ABs Stephen Donald, having an off season bender then all of a sudden winning a RWC as third choice 10.

2023-06-09T05:05:24+00:00

MO

Roar Rookie


He may well miss the 23 but he has to make the 33

2023-06-09T03:18:30+00:00

Cec

Roar Rookie


I hear you but somehow I think Petaia will take up the utility mantle. Barring injury it’s likely Marika and Marky on the wings with Wright at 15. I can’t see Petaia being left out of a back three spot unless Kellaway is favoured there. I think Reece is a likely ‘shock omission’ from the 23 unfortunately.

2023-06-09T00:51:21+00:00

PeterK

Roar Guru


Kellaway adds a lot more to the attack from wing than f/b, wright conversely adds a lot more to attack from f/b than wing. Kellaway is a much better winger than f/b. Kellaways defence at f/b is not that good either.

AUTHOR

2023-06-09T00:34:55+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Cheers Yabbie!

2023-06-09T00:14:04+00:00

Hunters

Roar Rookie


That seems to ignore the success Kellaway has had at international level. To call him a club-level player...

2023-06-09T00:06:29+00:00

Hunters

Roar Rookie


Kellaway still adds a lot to the attack. So the difference on that is not tremendous. BUT defence wins games at the highest level, at least most of the time. Kellaway can sniff out space in attack but he can also read and react better in defence. (At fullback, unlike wing, Wright doesn't as often have the sideline as a defender.)

2023-06-08T11:36:09+00:00

Mactruck

Roar Rookie


He is one of EJ’s senior players. He’s on the plane

2023-06-08T04:53:04+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Wright at 13?!? Replacing Len Ikatau, one of the first Wallabies picked? Chopper, have you really thought his through?

2023-06-08T03:16:10+00:00

The Yabbie

Roar Rookie


Nice one JF. Against top tier nations Kellaway is the greater student of the game. Wright has some handy legs but when it comes to the chess playing stakes I’d prefer Kellaway’’s smarts defence and kicks to weights turn of pace.

2023-06-07T22:59:58+00:00

Chopper

Roar Rookie


I think the question is "should Kellaway be on the plane to France". The answer to that is 'No'. He is a club level player. Both Wright and Petaia are guine international standard players. For me its Petaia at fullback and Wright at 13.

2023-06-07T21:40:21+00:00

Dean

Roar Rookie


Thank you for the article John. You have addressed the most difficult position in Australian Rugby. Our lack of quality options at 15 is incredibly sad. What we would do for a certain ex Wallaby still playing in Japan, to be at 15! I would not call it so much as a 2 horse race, but a 2 donkey plod, between Wright and Kellaway. Sadly, they are both lacking immensely at 15. Both are good international wing options, but not worthy of the 15 jersey. Wright's inability in defence is too big of a deficit to overcome with his pace and slight of foot in attack. Kellaway may be slightly better in defence however, his link skills are not as good as Wright's. In lieu of the Japanese based player, perhaps Petaia or Hodge, if we could guarantee a fit QC for the RWC, maybe even Carter Gordon at 15. Sadly, the gap at 15 in Australia is more of a chasm the size of the Rift Valley.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar