ANALYSIS: Why the Wallabies' breakdown woes could be helped from outside their own camp

By John Ferguson / Expert

The Wallabies loss to Fiji was owed to the islander’s ferocity and clinical execution at the ruck. But, let’s be clear, Wales is not Fiji and luckily for the Wallabies, Wayne Barnes isn’t Andrew Brace.

The Fijians played to Brace’s whistle far better than the Wallabies did, but there are things which Barnes won’t call that his international colleague was more than happy to penalise.

The Wallabies conceded five penalties for holding on at the ruck in the 30th, 36th, 57th, 60th, and 71st minutes of the game. This stat will not re-occur because Barnes will be officiating.

However, the Wallabies were clearly afraid or incapable of sticking their heads in the ruck to pilfer.

The only two Wallabies who won turnover ruck penalties were replacement inside centre Lalakai Foketi and utility Ben Donaldson.

That stat alone should make the backrow of Tom Hooper, Fraser McReight and Rob Valetini hang their heads in shame.

However, to the point, Barnes, wouldn’t have allowed Levani Botia’s steal in the 30th minute.

In the following clip are four pilfer penalties where the Wallabies were penalised for holding on.

The first two are instances where play should’ve continued or where the Fijian could’ve been penalised, the second two are perfectly fair steals.

As seen in the first clip, Botia has his hands on the ground ahead of the ball and when the Wallabies players hit him, he rakes it back.

The second clip shows the Fijian player get no lift on the ball and then is cleared off the ball just after he gets hands on it.

Barnes is known to allow the play to flow, and he won’t be as whistle happy as his colleague.

Barnes is much more concerned with seeing an actual lift and, if it occurs, he will usually allow the play to flow from the turnover.

The first four clips in the video show Barnes waiting to see a lift and he waits until either a subsequent error has been made or a breakdown in the contest to blow his whistle.

The fifth clip shows that Barnes will allow the play to flow once the pilfer is successful.

Finally, and, perhaps most crucially, the last clip in the sequence shows Tonga captain and ex-Chiefs player Ben Tameifuna attempting a jackal, his hands are on the ball, but he gets no lift and, therefore, despite arriving late, the clearers clean him out and Barnes awards no penalty.

This is also not to take away from Fiji’s dismantling of the Wallabies.

Simon Raiwalui tailored his team’s performance to its strengths which just happened to be the Wallabies’ weakness, the attacking breakdown.

The absence of Taniela Tupou and Will Skelton were fatal blows for a game which would be decided by power, and the Fijians won it without contest.

Despite Warren Gatland re-invigorating this Welsh side, they lack the bulk, size, and power of the Fijians, particularly in the tight-five.

The Wallabies are more than capable of outplaying and outmuscling the Dragon’s upfront even without their two biggest strike weapons.

Wayne Barnes’ desire to keep the game moving could help the Wallabies. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Wales’ young captain Jac Morgan is stoic but is a few steps behind the man called ‘The Bulldozer’ (Levani Botia).

The Wallabies should control the breakdown because even without their captain and the Tongan Thor, they’ll have a bigger pack than Wales.

Once this is sorted, the backs are well placed to power over their Welsh counterparts.

Nick Tompkins is not a Josua Tuisova and despite being a bigger man, neither is George North. That Welsh centre combination will find it difficult to get over the gain line.

The loss is simple to understand, the Wallabies lost the contact area, therefore they were stressed into conceding off-side penalties aplenty (4) and breakdown infringements when arriving at the ruck (4, not including holding on).

Forwards like Hooper, McReight and Richie Arnold went missing for much of the game in attack, while backs Samu Kerevi and Marika Koroibete were leaky in defence.

Some of Australia’s most talked about names and most talented youngsters were simply not good enough in a game where excellence was required.

While Angus Bell, Nick Frost and Mark Nawaqanitawase continued their impressive run of form, the engine room for the Wallabies was lacking effort, execution and grunt.

Summarised, the Wallabies were unable to adapt to the circumstances and change their ways during the game.

Even the likes of James Slipper, Kerevi and Koroibete were unable change the narrative with their experience.

Wales won’t be a physical prospect like Fiji was and that point cannot be understated in what it means for the Wallabies’ chances of success.

Barnes will officiate with an eye for flowing rugby, which will suit the Wallabies who will likely welcome back inform Tate McDermott as well as human wrecking ball Pone Fa’amausili. Both are crucial for the Wallabies chances of success.

From losing the wrecking balls to losing the plot when the heat came on, the Wallabies must lift for the do-or-die clash with Wales in Lyon on Monday 5am AEST, they must also play to tune of Wayne Barnes.

The Crowd Says:

2023-09-23T09:18:31+00:00

Josh

Roar Rookie


I have yet to see Kellaway have a bad game for the wallabies, Bell has taken a massive leap and Kerevi does need serious minutes under his belt. Agree with all your comments.

2023-09-22T07:42:51+00:00

RD

Roar Rookie


Perfectly put “ Wayne Barnes isn’t Andrew Brace”. This guy Brace seems to be on the same mold as Andre Watson from the past. Know it all, whistle happy. Kills the game. Barnes is the best referee. He keeps the game flowing. He referees to the spirit of the game and law.

2023-09-22T07:39:57+00:00

Dida

Roar Rookie


Un-penalised I meant obviously.

2023-09-22T06:52:25+00:00

Bentnuc

Roar Pro


Yeh fingers crossed! Hopefully a bonus point win with no bonus point to Wales :stoked:

2023-09-22T06:00:28+00:00

Wizz

Roar Rookie


Swinton or Holloway may have been okay replacements if we lost couple of ball runners which turned out we did..

2023-09-22T05:06:18+00:00

Wooliej

Roar Rookie


And yet Valentini was penalised. I don’t think we can tackle and pilfer some structure though.

AUTHOR

2023-09-22T03:58:44+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


They all tackled well but only Valetini carried regularly and well. But none got a pilfer and do inside backs did, that was my point there. It's similar if a flanker had kicked more 50/22s than the backs, should be their area of expertise and why you pick a 7/6.

2023-09-22T03:35:04+00:00

HiKa

Roar Rookie


Fair points emphasizing again that Brace is an awful referee and the TMO, McNeice, probably isn't up to it either (he was also TMO in Fiji's first match against Wales). On the Frost incident, it is fair to also note that the pass into Frost was deliberate and unnecessary, so it is arguable whether a team deserves to be allowed to play advantage when they choose to draw the penalty that way. On the Arnold incident, you are correct and thank you for not saying he played the ball back (as so many have) since he played the man on the ground while off his feet - which is undoubtedly a penalty. Now, how many rucks are there in each match where players who are off their feet play their opponents? Just another area that is routinely ignored by referees (supposedly for the sake of 'letting the game flow') and now it has showed up in big moment in a big match. And imagine the focus on that decision if Fiji were beaten by Australia? (See also my pet peeve of hookers standing in the field of play when throwing into lineouts - clearly illegal and always ignored.) I will still maintain that, taken as a whole, Fiji got the run of decisions from the ref around the breakdown, but Australia were not good enough and Fiji were the deserving winners.

2023-09-22T02:46:06+00:00

Wooliej

Roar Rookie


I really think McReight is being under appreciated. He adds balance and consistency to the back row. Some assist for him to pilfer and do his job would be good.

2023-09-22T02:38:18+00:00

Wooliej

Roar Rookie


You say the back row should hold their head in shame, but watching the game it doesn’t appear that they were that bad. It seemed like our whole structure was out done.

AUTHOR

2023-09-21T23:43:52+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


I did think about the pros and cons of Barnes. I wouldn't mind sacrificing the try resulting from Arnold on the ground for two to three less penalties because 18 is way too many in any competition at any level. It could also allowed us some continuity. Fa'amausili and Bell should get us over the gainline as well as Kerevi. Kerevi is seriously under the microscope this week. Kellaway is essential.

AUTHOR

2023-09-21T23:41:54+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


I did think of this Kai Levuka, I wouldn't mind sacrificing the try resulting from Arnold on the ground for two to three less penalties because 18 is way too many in any competition at any level.

AUTHOR

2023-09-21T23:39:44+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Cheers Betnuc! Love hearing any feedback from readers, but positive stuff on a Friday morning hits all the sweeter! Hopefully we get a result on Sunday night!

AUTHOR

2023-09-21T23:38:58+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Cheers pm! Always appreciate your reads and comments!

AUTHOR

2023-09-21T23:36:26+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


When I heard this I could hear a groan from Lord Laurie Fisher and the earth rumble slightly as he fell to his knees. Hearing that was like "no one is responsible for anything" the merry-go-around just goes on.

AUTHOR

2023-09-21T23:35:06+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Exactly Guess in terms of seizing on the ruck in the Fiji. But I didn't want to dwell on the Fiji game for that game's sake, I wanted focus on what could change and could bolster the hopes for Wallabies fans for Lyon. But like you my thoughts during the game and very much since has been "why wouldn't they adapt and pilfer in the same fashion?" I suspect it was fear from the contact zone, I hope I am wrong, because if that's true then these guys are not up to international standard. It is a dark hole indeed, hopefully the night is darkest before the dawn :rugby:

AUTHOR

2023-09-21T23:30:53+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


No worries Wizz I feel you!

2023-09-21T21:37:47+00:00

Kai Levuka

Roar Rookie


Oz to win. I’m more certain of this than I was of Fiji beating the Wallabies. As a Fiji fan I was more afraid of Oz than Wales.

2023-09-21T21:36:12+00:00

Kai Levuka

Roar Rookie


On the flip side Wayne Barnes would probably not let the Wallabies play the ball while on the ground …

2023-09-21T21:18:37+00:00

Tim

Roar Rookie


Great article Johnny, hopefully the new Donaldson/Kellaway/McDermott combo addresses the lack of tactical flexibility and execution we saw against Fiji. Also, keen to see Pone Fa'amausili flatten some dragons!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar