Don't blame Latrell for picking the Koori Knockout over the Kangaroos - ask why the Roos brand is so devalued

By Mike Meehall Wood / Editor

If you follow Steve Mascord on social media – and if you love rugby league and don’t, you’re missing out – then you might have noticed one of his characteristic posts this week.

It was an intervention around Latrell Mitchell’s injury-enforced absence from the Kangaroos squad, a move from which he has been criticised given that he also played in the Koori Knockout over the weekend without apparent issue in his injured finger.

“Is this the time to remind everyone players used to have to front up to a medical if they were picked for rep duty and only the team doctor could rule them out?” wrote the legendary league scribe.

“Yes, even if it meant a wasted plane ticket. Dale Shearer once bluffed his way onto a plane despite not being picked!

“Also telling that back in the day we had Wayne Pearce and Wally Lewis showing up to medicals in failed desperate bids to get INTO these teams and now we have guys opting for a rest or to play in an amateur knockout or even box instead of going to the medical.”

Steve might have stopped short of blaming anyone, but plenty more would point at the Australian Rugby League Commission (ARLC) themselves and wonder if they have devalued the Kangaroos to the level that even their own players don’t really care that much about playing for them.

Latrell was as proud a tourist as anyone last year, but he had to be convinced to get on the plane by coach Mal Meninga. Nathan Cleary, too, excelled at the World Cup, but found it easier to say no this time around with injury. 

South Sydney, Mitchell’s club, were quick to point out that the demands on his injury from guest-starring in a friendly tournament were a little different from over a month of training and then playing in Test football. That’s correct.

It’s worth querying, much as Mascord did, how the level of value has changed. Were this seen as being as important as Origin or the NRL finals, he would have played. That’s the level the Kangaroos should be at.

For plenty of players, of course, international footy is more important than ever: it’s just that they don’t play for Australia. 

Stephen Crichton turned down a Kangaroos call-up to line up against them for Samoa. Plenty of others since 2017 have done the same for Tonga and other Pacific nations in the recent past.

The argument that representing your heritage and giving back to those that have given you so much is hard to ignore. It’s the same reason that Mitchell and so many other Indigenous stars attend the Koori Knockout.

But it’s undeniable that the green-and-gold does not have the lustre it once had, and it’s not just the players.

Many fans have lamented how difficult it has been to actually buy a replica, when once, they were the last thing one saw before getting on a plane at the airport. 

Cameron Murray. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images for RLWC)

Get out at Auckland – or Manchester, Madrid or Milan – and the first thing you will see in the duty free will be, along with the booze, perfume and cigarettes, the jersey of the local sporting pride. Not in Sydney.

There has been argument, for many years, that everyone else is the problem, with the Australian public losing interest in one-sided matches come October and November. 

But with a programme that features New Zealand and a resurgent Samoa, both of whom gave the Kangaroos great opposition 12 months ago – indeed, the World Cup semi with the Kiwis was one of the best games in years – that doesn’t really work.

30 years ago, the competition in Test football was demonstrably weaker than it is now, with the Kangaroos losing four matches in the entire 1980s and winning 90% of matches from 1980 through to the Super League War.

On top of that, they can play more games against a greater variety of nations, rather than the two that they played for almost all of the 1980s and 1990s outwith the 1995 World Cup.

Yet the brand of the Kangaroos is lower than it has ever been. Where once they were rugby league’s equivalent to the Harlem Globetrotters or All Blacks – when they thrashed everyone in 1982, attendances actually rose – now they barely get on the field.

They haven’t played Great Britain or England at all since 2017 and have abandoned their stronghold in Sydney entirely, with just three games in the last 15 years in the Harbour City.

Much as many don’t like any sniff of Sydney bias, it is undeniable that the bulk of Australia’s rugby league media lives in Sydney. 

Reputationally, a succession of short-term, sensible decisions to move games to Townsville, Melbourne, Wollongong, Perth and Canberra have seen Sydney removed as an international venue, with a cumulative effect that has severely weakened the brand.

Remember: no game in Sydney means no training in Sydney, which means no media opps: this week, the Kangaroos are in Airlie Beach, close to Townsville where very few journalists will be there to cover them, meaning the build-up will be much more limited. 

If you want to build hype, then it helps to be close to where all the media are. The Kangaroos have played more games in Leeds in that time than in the world’s biggest rugby league market.

Again, this isn’t always the fault of the ARLC: the Queensland and Victorian governments have paid good money for international games, including the upcoming Tests, to be played in their states. 

Australian “Team of the Century” members Andrew Johns, Wally Lewis and John Raper at the Sydney Cricket Ground in 2008. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Sydney attendances have long been an issue, with 21,000 and 25,000 at the last two Tests. It might have been a different proposition for Australia v Samoa at Commbank Stadium in Parramatta, given the size of Western Sydney’s Samoan community, but that’s a risk and Queensland came with the cash to mitigate it.

Dollars from the state governments is likely to cover the costs and turn a profit before attendances even enter into the discussion, and Destination NSW, the local tourist body, was unlikely to stump up to host games largely attended by people who already live in NSW.

The World Club Challenge, which brought 1,000 fans over from the UK, probably looks like the better use of their funds, or attempting to draw thousands of out-of-town and out-of-state soccer fans for the A-League Grand Final.

Rugby league in Sydney is booming, however, and it might be worth the ARLC’s time wondering why they can’t sell out Kangaroos fixtures without government backing. 

Given the talent on display and the potential for excellent footy, a venue like CommBank, if not even the larger Allianz or Accor Stadiums, should be well within reach.

The CBA farrago didn’t help, either. With games announced relatively late in the year, fans were unable to plan for fixtures and, crucially, neither were players.

New Zealand lost key figures due to injury (inevitable), but also pre-arranged marriages, with Scott Sorensen, then attending other people’s weddings, like Kodi Nikorima, who will be at his brother’s nuptials as best man. 

One suspects that, had they known when games were played, they would have rescheduled for dates that didn’t clash.

We’re now a step away from what Gaelic football fans are used to, where players can be listed as injured, but also simply ‘Australia’, if they’ve moved here for a year, or ‘work’, if they had a more pressing professional engagement than the the last bastion of elite amateur sport.

Even as a hard-nosed international footy head, it’s hard to argue with blokes who get battered every week from pillar to post each week wanting a bit of time to themselves, and indeed, doing a little to re-right the work/life balance that they are forced to heavily distort between February and October. 

It’s not for nothing that every player thanks their families for the sacrifices made right between God and the boys in their acceptance speeches.

It’s even harder to do so the year after a World Cup on the other side of the world, where the likes of Sorensen spent six weeks this time last year. 

The withdrawals can become a cycle, too. Latrell doesn’t play, which makes the Pacific Championships look worse, and then Joseph Suaalii, Jarome Luai, Shaun Johnson and Jason Taumalolo don’t play either, which only devalues it further.

Were Kangaroos games on a par with Origin – as they once were – then doubtless the vast majority of call-offs would be busting a gut, as Wayne Pearce and Wally Lewis once did, but make the squad. Now, it’s a lot easier to stay home. 

The Crowd Says:

2023-10-12T08:55:06+00:00

jimmy jones

Roar Rookie


ya dreamin champ

2023-10-12T06:12:44+00:00

Full Credit to the Boys

Roar Rookie


Hi Snowy. Interesting. On my last day in Alice I met a young man who was ateacher at Areyonga. I've spent most of my time in Hermannsburg but have experience of Areyonga, Santa Teresa and some in the PTY Lands. The situation in Alice is really concerning. I still took a group there in May which was safe, but we kept close to the protocols in Alice. We still managed to explore some incredible country and connect with the mob in Hermannsburg and Santa Teresa. It looks like the people that brought us weapons of mass destruction, Trump, Brexit, the Big Lie, Robodebt are controlling the narrative. Frightening and sad.

2023-10-12T04:52:37+00:00

Heyou

Roar Rookie


It seems we both lived and worked in some of the same areas way out bush. I started out in Brewarrina NSW and we went on to Areyonga, Neutral Junction, Tennant Creek and Darwin areas in the NT. We gained family among the clans and we all feel we were enriched by our experiences. The elders valued education and wanted their young people to retain and pass on their language and culture, including their written dialects, whilst also developing the skills and knowledge to deal confidently within the non-indigenous world. As an educator back then I learnt more than I taught in some ways. Things have changed of course, as things have also changed in the wider society. We got our first computer in a school back then but it remained hardly touched as I came from zero experience with technology. I was poorly equipped to make good use of it. We were still using radio phones and a light plane brought our mail in a canvas bag. I had to get on the radio each day to talk to the Dept of Ed and the many other remote schools educators out west . The people know what is needed. Best listen to the elders and the conscientious women to know what will make a positive difference. Things have deteriorated it seems - from Alice Springs, outwards from there - in a wide circle. Certainly I’m off track regarding this discussion but it’s good to to ‘talk’ with you about shared experiences even if mine were so long ago.

2023-10-10T03:12:20+00:00

Full Credit to the Boys

Roar Rookie


Hi Snowy. Yes, we get so swept up in ideas like patriotism forgetting the MO of the dictator is usually wrapped in that exact . I'm no historian but i think the idea of a nation state is relatively recent, and loyalties to clan and 'the mob'far more meaningful for Indigenous. I remember talking to some Arrentre people about a particular project with me waxing lyrical about how beneficial it would be for Aboriginal people. They looked at me like I was an idiot. These remote people were interested in whether they would get a sealed road, and whether funding for their Rangers program would be installed after the intervention, or whether they could get to visit family in jail. Grand national aspirations were not part of their daily life.

2023-10-10T00:06:13+00:00

Heyou

Roar Rookie


Fifteen years for me. I understand exactly what you are saying. Your response reminded me that it’s been a long time since I along with my young family worked among the various tribes way out bush here and there, and I forgot to take these things you bring up into consideration. Sing the anthem, don’t sing the anthem. It’s a personal thing. It’s how you understand the place you call home. Being Australian might one day be a matter of unity bringing the indigenous communities and the rest of we long and short term immigrants to this land together as one. Sadly It’s not a dream I can see becoming a reality in my lifetime. I see things from many sides. Thank you for reminding me of these salient truths. I can hope that our national team members will play footy for their nation, tribe, clan, skin family, teammates, coach and supporters. We love it when they give their all for whatever part of this island Australia they call home.

2023-10-08T21:40:06+00:00

jimmy jones

Roar Rookie


Gd point about 'fair' with the undertones.. We'd always sing the anthem on Monday mornings at school and I'd always thought of the Sydney show when we sang fair, as if it was a big party here.

2023-10-08T14:52:36+00:00

Nico

Roar Rookie


Yeah having St Helens over for this year’s preseason really added to the spectacle, you could see how much it meant to the St Helens boys mixing it and getting on top of their Aussie counterparts in what would have been otherwise run of the mill preseason trials. People bemoan the decline of the English game but when you look at the ill-fated ’97 WCC, St Helens despite being English champions were getting spanked by the 50 against the Broncos. In ’23 St Helen’s were undefeated against NRL clubs. Imagine what the English clubs could manage with similar funding to NRL sides. Would be great to see an expanded format with possibly Wigan and Catalans included

2023-10-08T07:47:31+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


I deliberately worded my comment the way I did. As a sneaky way of saying how poor the reconciliation efforts have been in Australia. :thumbup:

2023-10-08T06:57:20+00:00

Greg

Roar Pro


The Maori singing the NZ anthem has little to do with how Aboriginal people should feel about our anthem. First as you say NZ has done much more for reconciliation and the God defend New Zealand has both a Maori verse and no racial undertones. Advance Australia Fair however has racial undertones. Fair has the multiple meaning of fitting/appropriate, lightness in colour as well as equitable. Given the song was written at the height of political advocation of a white Australia it is highly likely that the song was written as a deliberate play on the word fair. This is supported with all the pro-British rhetoric in the additional verses. Why would an Aboriginal person want to sing it?

2023-10-08T06:43:55+00:00

Short Memory

Roar Rookie


The issue is not lack of pride in his country Tony. Quite the contrary.

2023-10-08T06:31:46+00:00

jimmy jones

Roar Rookie


they can have summer night games in Canberra or Melbs haha

2023-10-08T06:30:26+00:00

jimmy jones

Roar Rookie


That would be unreal, especially if the English cricket team were here for the summer coinciding with the Lions.. can tour the whole east coast from Townsville to Melbs. Or if its easier have 3 or 4 of the top Super League clubs down here against the top 4 in our comp.

2023-10-08T00:23:01+00:00

KillaKanga

Roar Rookie


Now that's a new one I haven't heard but I'll sure as hell steal it from you Tony :laughing:

2023-10-07T22:10:09+00:00

Tony Dargon

Roar Guru


It's what was in the picture that was the problem, plus the resultant negative publicity.

2023-10-07T21:54:48+00:00

Maxtruck

Roar Rookie


Holmes put a picture in Instabook, an online version of a note on the wall outside the post office. Holmes also copped $50K in fines. JAC's incident was in front of thousands of kids and broadcast nationally

2023-10-07T21:47:43+00:00

Maxtruck

Roar Rookie


Edwards was a half back before joining Penrith and came into 1st grade as a winger

2023-10-07T09:09:40+00:00

Col in Paradise

Roar Rookie


The Poms would melt playing here in January/February!!!

2023-10-07T04:26:55+00:00

Full Credit to the Boys

Roar Rookie


Hi Snowy I worked for many years in Aboriginal Australia. One of the things I understood at the end of that experience is that indigenous people don't have a working understanding of 'Australia'. They are intimately attached to the clan, to kin, to ceremonial brothers and to skin relationships. Beyond that they identify with tribal group such as Pitjantjarra, Arrentre etc. The notion of a nation state that we all sing to because we are so 'proud' is simply not deeply embedded in their culture. When that nation state essentially conquered a land they called terra nullius, you can understand the hesitancy. Many Aboriginals have played brilliantly for Australia, but I think they are playing for their family and their 'mob' which is the team rather than a land that is girt by sea. They also played because they love the game. Regarding singing the national anthem, if that is a sign of great patriotism I'd point to the fact that Nazis proudly sang Deutschland Deutschland, that Trump's goons screamed USA USA, that far right and far left organisations drape themselves in patriotic pretence. Singing the national anthem isn't of itself a sign of patriotism but has often been an expression of hate.

2023-10-07T01:25:09+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Just a shout out to every league supporter. Keep your thoughts & prayers going for Nathan Merritt. The former South Sydney wing / fullback great. He collapsed when visiting an aunt in Sydney evidently. A week after playing in the Koori Knockout. He’s on life support in hospital & he’s only 40 years old. All the best wishes for you & your family Nathan .

2023-10-06T23:54:58+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Umpire Dickie Bird , said ‘I have to live here’ , after one of his early questionable performances as an umpire. England versus Australia.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar