Many Super returns: The NRL players heading north to revive their career or cash in on one last contract

By Tony / Roar Guru

Every year a large contingent of NRL players, both established stars and wannabees, leave the NRL for the English Super League seeking either the opportunity to improve or just to prolong their playing careers and earn a few more dollars.

Some even discover a distant relative and end up playing for England, Scotland, etc.

The Super League is awash these days with former NRL players, and for most, it marks the last stop of their careers, with only a very few returning. This year was no exception, and here’s a team of NRL players who have headed north already or are on their way in 2024.

I wonder if we’ll see any of them again in the NRL?

1. Moses Mbye (St George Illawarra to St Helens) – Mbye is a very experienced and versatile player, and at 30 years of age, should be a great success at Saints. Look for him to appear in the Super League Dream Team in 2024.

2. Jayden Okunbur (Canterbury-Bankstown to Hull FC) – At just under 2 metres tall, nearly 110kg and with a good turn of pace, Okunbur has all the physical attributes to have enjoyed more success than shown in just 45 top grade games across five seasons with the Dogs.

3. Peta Hiku (North Queensland to Hull Kingston Rovers) – If any player’s career kicks on after making the move to the UK it will be Hiku, a vastly experienced and often underrated performer who will appreciate the slower pace of the game in the northern hemisphere.

4. Paul Momirovski (Sydney Roosters to Leeds Rhinos) – Five seasons, four clubs, 60 games and one premiership. It’s been an interesting journey for Momirovski, who is a very effective centre at his best, and he should be a hit in the UK.

5. Lachlan Miller (Newcastle to Leeds Rhinos) – I hope the English players do their homework on Miller, because if they give him even the slightest bit of space he’ll be gone in a flash. He’s my early tip for Super League leading try scorer for next season.

6. Jayden Nikorima (Melbourne to Catalans Dragons) – Nikorima has spent the last seven years trying to make it in the NRL, and with just nine first grade games to his name in that time, he probably can’t do any worse in the Old Dart.

7. Matt Frawley (Canberra to Leeds Rhinos) – Frawley is another honest toiler and good club man who can be very effective on his day, and his move won’t hold many surprises for him as he spent a season with Huddersfield back in 2019.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

8. Luke Thompson (Canterbury-Bankstown to Wigan Warriors) – To say that the English international’s time in the NRL has been disappointing is an understatement, as poor form together with ongoing injuries saw him play just over 40 games for the Dogs over four years. Not a good return on their multimillion-dollar investment.

9. Kruise Leeming (Gold Coast to Wigan Warriors) – Yet another Englishman returning home after failing to make an impact in the NRL, Leeming is a far better player than he showed in his time with the Titans.

10. Herman Ese’ese (Dolphins to Hull FC) – 2023 was probably big Herman’s best season in the NRL since he debuted way back in 2015, and he has both the size and ball-playing skills to be a success in the UK.

11. Tariq Sims (Melbourne to Catalans Dragons) – Soon to turn 34, surely this will be Sims’ last hurrah, and although he’s lost some of the fire of his heyday, any playmaker with an ounce of sense will be looking nervously over his shoulder as they get the ball away.

12. Lachlan Fitzgibbon (Newcastle to Warrington Wolves) – Fitzgibbon has been a great competitor for the Knights and it was a big surprise to see him head to the UK. The Knights’ loss is the Wolves’ gain.

13. Bayley Sironen (NZ Warriors to Catalans Dragons) – Sironen is a versatile forward and has been in the best form of his career during his time with the Warriors. He looks to be another player who will prove to be a success in the UK.

14. Jack Murchie (Parramatta to Huddersfield Giants) – At 26, Murchie is a relatively young player who still has time to make his mark in the top grade. He’s a better player than the 45 first grade appearances across six years in the NRL would suggest.

15. Franklin Pele (Canterbury-Bankstown to Hull FC) – This 22-year-old colossus is going to surprise a lot of opponents when he runs out against them next season. At over 190cm, weighing in at 130-odd kilos and with a good turn of speed, he’s going to become the wrecking ball in the UK. Just keep him away from the buffet.

16. Zane Musgrove (St George Illawarra to Warrington Wolves) – Big, lazy and with more baggage than a Greyhound bus, Musgrove will most likely disappear off the radar.

17. Thomas Mikaele (Gold Coast to Warrington Wolves) – Now make up your mind Thomas. The big bopper left the Tigers to join Warrington midway through the 2022 season only to return to Australia and the Titans in early 2023, played just one first grade game and then returned to Warrington. Confused? I don’t blame you.

The Crowd Says:

2023-10-12T10:24:11+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


Wests Tigers are always looking for a new coach to sack. He will land there and be exiled a few months later, half a million to the good

AUTHOR

2023-10-12T03:07:38+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


All the more reason to get them to the UK ASAP

2023-10-12T02:44:11+00:00

langparker

Roar Rookie


Geez, if I had to coach that backline I wouldn’t be planning for anything that looked like 80-90 metre attacking plays from their own end, have to be the slowest & least imaginative set of backs from 1 to 7 inclusive. As for the pack, it’s a bit better but several loose cannons there who would likely spend a bit of time on the sideline suspended (looking at you Luke, Tariq & Zane).

2023-10-10T10:27:08+00:00

Dionysus

Roar Rookie


I am surprised that a spell check picked that up !

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T07:03:15+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Cheers mate. I do enjoy the ESL games I watch. Players sure do play a lot of games over there

2023-10-10T06:48:47+00:00

ScouseinOz

Roar Rookie


Enjoyed the article. I think you are right about the salary cap. Less of the Aussie or NZ Internationals will head over at the end like they did in the 2000s. There's the salary cap difference and also the RLPA insurance stuff for injuries at end of career. It's not worth leaving the NRL at the end now. That said, even though the player pool is inferior to the recent past, the coaching in the ESL is probably the best it has been in many decades. Luke Thompson will have a much better coaching staff at Wigan than he ever did at the Bulldogs. Wigan have Jai Field and Bevan French in their 20s and they are great with the extra space in the ESL. Probably better than Matty Bowen in his 2 years at the end of his career. That's how I optimistically see the (financially limited) competition as a Wigan fan.

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T06:35:13+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


They've been travelling okay in recent years

2023-10-10T06:30:03+00:00

ScouseinOz

Roar Rookie


Catalans used to be the magnet for NRL players that were sent to detention until 2017. Willie Mason is very candid about the attitudes. They nearly got themselves relegated in 2017. However, when McNamara came he in he got a few of the Wigan players in like Tomkins and McIllorum and some other Northerners and I think they work as hard as any of the sides in the competition. It's not a holiday anymore, but just a better place to live.

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T06:03:30+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Thank god for spell check - I originally had "old tart". :laughing:

2023-10-10T05:45:57+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


L'ancien dart?

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T05:42:56+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


You have now

2023-10-10T05:00:23+00:00

Dionysus

Roar Rookie


"6. Jayden Nikorima (Melbourne to Catalans Dragons) – Nikorima has spent the last seven years trying to make it in the NRL, and with just nine first grade games to his name in that time, he probably can’t do any worse in the Old Dart" The Old Dart usually means England, I have never seen it refer to France.

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T04:45:45+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Maybe, they've got rid of a few, primarily dead weight in my opinion and haven't signed any forwards to my knowledge. No doubt Gus has a cunning plan.

2023-10-10T04:16:53+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


I didn't realise Luke Thompson had left the Dogs. Aren't they a bit light on for forwards for next year?

2023-10-10T01:35:27+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


Leeming's definitely a talent, but he can't tackle to save himself. While he fitted in quite well at the Titans in that regard, I suspect Des has other ideas.

2023-10-10T01:32:18+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


Good call.

2023-10-10T01:22:18+00:00

Nick Maguire

Roar Rookie


Phil Gould of course

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T01:14:26+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


I think they may already be on Hamish's shopping list

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T01:13:10+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Surely Hook's coaching days are over

AUTHOR

2023-10-10T01:10:50+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Albo, have you seen some of the former NRL players still going around in the ESL? Most of this lot will look like development players by comparison :happy:

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar