The Swans have already won the trade period - and it's set them up perfectly for another crack at a flag

By Dem Panopoulos / Expert

The Swans clearly believe the 2024 flag could be theirs and have positioned themselves well with the signings of Brodie Grundy and Taylor Adams.

In isolation, knowing what we know of these two players at their peaks, the Swans have done well in handing over picks 33, 46 and a future second-rounder to secure the rights to these players.

James Jordon joined at no cost and is a handy addition, Joel Hamling too should provide competitive depth if nothing else.

The Swans themselves are a unique case study in the way they handle their list.

Clearly, the retirement of Lance Franklin frees up some cap space to be able to sign players, but coach John Longmire has never shied away from mixing his experience with youth, in order to bring his young players up to the level.

On face value, they’ve brought in three players who’ll be at least 30 years of age next season which in many other cases, would be seen as an act of desperation, but for the Swans it’s just topping up in areas of need.

Look at their best and fairest results – Errol Gulden won the award at 21 years of age while Nick Blakey (23) and James Rowbottom (23) rounded out the top three.

(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

Chad Warner (22) finished fifth and Logan McDonald (21) finished the season with the second-most goals for the club.

Therefore, particularly with Callum Mills under an injury cloud, the Swans couldn’t have done much better to efficiently address and solve some of their problems.

From the Grundy perspective, it’s been a couple of years since we’ve seen him at his best but the Swans have been begging for a follow-up ruck who can act as an extra linking player through the centre and occupy space to defend the transition.

Tom Hickey was good in the role when his body allowed him to be and was perhaps one of the more underrated rucks when given solo opportunities. Peter Ladhams, not so much despite having all the hypothetical talent to have an impact and the Swans having paid up for him. He has to curb his on-field indiscretions.

So it makes complete sense that Grundy would join in such a mutually beneficial move for both parties.

The Swans were ranked 11th for clearance differential and 15th for contested possession differential. Despite the solid work of Rowbottom and Luke Parker amongst others, being second to the ball at stoppages and not having a fully fit ruckman to body others in the follow-up saw the Swans struggle through the midfield.

Even if Grundy doesn’t reach the absolute heights of his peak, he’s one of the best contested possession-winning, clearance-focused rucks in the league who can help raise the base level.

Brodie Grundy. (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Recruiting Adams emerged from nowhere largely and we’ve since learned that discussions commenced the week before the Grand Final.

Naturally, with Mills’ injury and seemingly a midfield spot opened up, Adams would slot in there.

It’s hard to discount what the former Magpie vice-captain added to his former club on the half-forward flank as a rotating forward/midfielder though and what that can do for the Swans.

Sure, there’ll be spurts in the midfield and as someone who has averaged over five tackles and clearances over the last eight seasons combined, he again raises the floor of what the Swans can produce.

But in 2023, Adams averaged a score per game and finished with 25 goal assists in 23 games. He was rated elite for tackles inside 50 and score involvements, while the Swans were above average and average in each of these areas themselves.

With a proclivity to use Tom Papley at stoppages occasionally, and Isaac Heeney even moreso, the addition of Adams to that rotation is more impactful on the forward half and the way it stretch the forward 70 area.

More pertinently, Adams’ strengths as an inside midfielder aren’t dissimilar to what Rowbottom and Parker produce and his recruitment likely results in more direct swaps between the Parker and Adams inside the forward 50, which the Swans have been keen to explore for a while.

Crucially though, recruiting two veterans in this case will be used to improve the team overall while promoting opportunities for younger players, rather than taking them away.

Longmire loves giving deserving young players opportunities and the likes of Angus Sheldrick and Matty Roberts aren’t necessarily hindered by the inclusions. Grundy gives young midfielders more chances to win a contest, Adams’ unselfishness will put others first.

Jordon’s inclusion should see him get games, perhaps on a wing/midfield rotation with Gulden, and he’s a tidy, hard-worker who embodies the spirit of game that the Swans seek to put forward.

At time of writing, the Swans still have their first-round pick too – whether they split it to try get more points for academy graduate and Adams clone Caiden Cleary, or whether they feel adequately prepared for that remains to be seen, but the Swans have improved their list and depth to where 28-30 players can rotate through at senior level, a key feature of a premiership team.

Adams and Grundy are in different stages in their careers to their former selves that perhaps we reflect upon with rose-coloured glasses, but maybe that’s what gives them the added value that makes dispensing three mid-round picks worth it.

One needs a fresh change and a new environment, the other just wants to the chance to play their role and be the difference-maker he can be, and off the field; they bring experience, leadership and good vibes.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Swans have a list full of talented young players and veterans who know how to win.

With these additions, they add to their depth and on-field versatility that’ll make them hard to plan for.

These two players that made a name for themselves at Collingwood are more than just good value pick-ups in a trade market.

They’re two genuine pieces who raise the floor of a team that needs it, striving for consistent footy that can have them challenging for the grandest prize there is.

Shrewd moves like these win flags and the Swans have been efficient in reloading for the 2024 flag.

The Crowd Says:

2023-10-26T23:38:19+00:00

Ma3stro

Roar Rookie


Which is what I said, Bretto :stoked:

2023-10-16T03:17:39+00:00

Bretto

Roar Rookie


Not correct Knackaz, I heard a few people say - "Freo will not make finals next year".

2023-10-15T21:51:02+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


Actually I’d didnt it was elsewhere and in response to a slightly different point but will paste here intact as it has some nice data. The opinions are mine: —- to Emily2510 Kieren Briggs - princely pick 34. The new most underrated player in the comp Connor Idun - pick 61. (we love Connor because he personned the merch and meet the players stall at Homebush the day the Lions came and won in 19, he was great with our then new footy girls, we then saw him play the ressies at Henson later in the year and he remembered us. ) Cadman - not in the team. they traded for that pick 1 tho Bedford - pick 44 trade Hogan last chance saloon and pick 54 Riccardi - 51 Lachie Keefe - delisted free agency pick up Daniels 27 and Taylor 28 Lloyd - 26 in the rookies! yes they had a core of very early picks, including key positioners like Cameron and Patton. all gone. they have a great midfield core. but so do Carlton. all from early picks. it's necessary, but not sufficient. it's the baseline. but there's 23 players and 40 in the club etc what's happened I think is they finally have a way to play, the right leadership and culture, and enough guys in good form at the same time. Richmond 2017.... -- given the proven fail rate of top 10 draft picks, you could even argue that being given so many early draft picks actually weighed the odds against them. the smart thing they did was grab a few of everything, knowing they would need to trade some to keep topping up a list, noting that the "go home" factor would arise... Cameron, Shiel, Treloar, Patton, Tyson, Hoskin-Elliott, Corr, Plowman, Finlayson, Marchbank, Kennedy, Setterfield, Taranto, Hopper, Caldwell, Bruhn.. all gone, but the Giants keep rolling. 2 wins. 1 win. 6 11 16 15 13.5 13 8* 11.5 6 13 i reckon that's a pretty standard rebuild from bottom sort of trajectory, for an older established club who might have had a few rotten years, and got gifted early picks and even priority picks -- i still can't quite fathom why people are upset that the Giants didn't win every comp as some feared. have they underachieved or overachieved. for me, their good competitive position and sustained growth shows the AFL got it about right. those clubs who were down when the Coast and the Giants dominated the pool - well, at richmond, we found a way.

2023-10-14T09:49:19+00:00

Frodo

Roar Rookie


Geez, Donsy. You really got burned here, didn't you? Completely owned!

2023-10-14T09:34:11+00:00

Frodo

Roar Rookie


Well said, COB. Bravo.

2023-10-14T07:40:27+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Surely North have won the trade period by being gifted Pick 3 from the AFL (and by Essendon's manipulation). The AFL has to stop these rorts for average players. It's grossly unfair on the teams who have their picks shuffled back in the order who are not a party to the trade. First round compensation should be reserved for losing truly elite players - not just a senseless formula based on how much a club front-ends a contract. The AFL should have corrected this years ago. Hopefully North waste their pick 3 on another Will Phillips.

2023-10-14T00:32:52+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


Sadly, Franklin wasn’t a gun this past season though. The combo of McDonald, Amartey and McLean will do well, with the smaller players like Heeney, Papley, Parker and now Adams floating in and out of the forward line.

2023-10-13T22:01:26+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


Won’t happen. He loves playing with Naughton. Will get a new contract sorted well before the old one is done.

2023-10-13T21:41:17+00:00

Chanon

Roar Rookie


Dougie l can envision JUH a swan in 25’ & beyond.

2023-10-13T21:41:12+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


I listed all the pivotal non early picks a couple weeks back. Especially Idun. Won’t do it again

2023-10-13T21:40:08+00:00

Wikipetia

Roar Rookie


I’ll follow the Sun…

2023-10-13T21:36:51+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Love Tay PD. No ill will. Champion bloke.

2023-10-13T19:55:58+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


Excellent summary! If the Swans can avoid the injury toll of this past season they now look a very balanced team. The recruitment has filled the obvious gaps.

2023-10-13T19:54:33+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


It would have been quicker to say “I have no idea” you know…

2023-10-13T12:52:34+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Does that mean you no longer wish him all the best? :happy:

2023-10-13T12:50:53+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


In who's mind? :laughing:

2023-10-13T12:49:18+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Not true - Briggs has been a surprise and perhaps the coach deserves credit for him, but GWS other good individual performers are all high-end talent. It's just that Leon Cameron focused too often in big games on thuggery and downhill skiing instead of playing good hard, smart footy. Finally a coach is focusing on playing good allround footy and not pretending to themselves to be tough with cheap shots.

2023-10-13T12:41:08+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


I think all three are great additions. Hambling makes sense given the Swans struggles when Paddy McCartin was out of the side, and he is only out of Freo's team because you have a really good back six. Jordan is a promising young, smart, gutsy footballer who would be an asset to any team. Grundy could easily become a top 5 ruckman behind Gawn, English, Marshall and Darcy.

2023-10-13T12:36:32+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Well done Swans. I admire how you go about your business, on and off the field. But can you pricks please target Lobb instead of Naughton and Ugle-Hagan!

2023-10-13T06:37:09+00:00

COB

Roar Rookie


I wouldn't call Grundy a role player but even if he was I am happy to get 4 role players. Depth is probably more important than ever. Franklin won the Swans a heap of games but not a flag. Anyway I know you like to argue so I shall happily agree to disagree but hopefully I will want to revisit the topic in 12 months time.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar