How do you drag the Wallabies from the gutter to the Lions in 2025? You harvest the pick of the NRL crop

By J Joseph / Roar Rookie

So South Africa has become the undisputed world champion, winning the Rugby World Cup for the fourth time.

Pretty impressive since they were not welcome to attend the 1987 and 1991 events. Still, that situation has now resulted in a Springboks team that is truly representative of a diverse culture that is the rainbow nation.

As far as I can tell, rugby in South Africa does not have to compete with rugby league and Australian Rules (obviously) for their player pool. Yes, there is soccer, but this attracts a largely different skill set and, dare I say it, mindset, to that of the rugby player.

Of all the teams making the quarter finals of RWC 2023 rugby league is at best peripheral, although Fiji rugby would be richer with an infusion of the league players who play in the NRL competition.

All the Pacific island teams would benefit by having local players from the NRL, not to mention those who now play rugby internationally for other nations.

But, here we are in Oz with a relatively small pool of players, traditionally drawn from privileged private schools. What can we do? I know, bring back Eddie — no, we tried that.

Penrith’s Nathan Cleary scores the match winning try in the 2023 NRL Grand Final. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

I have a much better plan. Practise being a republic. Bring in a tyrannical President who can pass sweeping, illogical and binding laws for the good of the people.

Use our rich heritage in this sphere of operations (stay with me here). We have some outstanding candidates who are itching to get back into public life. The list is unlimited. Former leaders in Victoria, Western Australia, New Zealand come easily to mind.

Next, get some (sports) scientists on your payroll to prove that rugby league is a major contributor to climate change. These scientists will prove that rugby league players are more likely to drive cars with high fuel consumption, and drive them in such a way as to cause the Antarctic ice sheet to melt in the next two years.

Also, league players eat far too much red meat, which, as we all know, contributes to intolerable levels of methane in the atmosphere, causing a rise in temperature of at least one degree Celsius every ten minutes. And, they are far less likely to install rooftop solar panels than other members of the sporting community.

Give the scientists a brief time frame to prove these irrefutable facts (two weeks should be enough) and then issue a statement that 97% of the scientists agree that rugby league is a major contributor to climate change. The science is settled. Anybody who disagrees is a dinosaur.

The decision of the President is “that there will be zero men and women playing rugby league by 2025”. Boom.

So now the stage is set for a rugby renaissance. The challenge will be – who shall the Australian selectors pick for the 2025 Wallabies team to play the British and Irish Lions?

Taniela Tupou rumbles donwfield against Georgia. (Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)

Let’s start with which Wallabies will stay on. The current Wallaby tight five may have to remain. It is doubtful any league players could or would want to start in the front row. Without at least a year in the Blades Front Row Academy they would be monstered in five minutes by any international pack in the scrums, rucks and mauls.

They would be useless in lineouts and restarts (although in the latter they may not look out of place with that level of incompetence). Also, most league players would be the incorrect shape for the front row — simply not squat and fat enough. I would love to see Payne Haas, Thomas Flegler, Junior Paulo and Harry Grant join the Academy, and maybe Tino Fa’asuamaleaui (although Tino might be better suited to the second row).

Make sure of your place in the stands to see the British and Irish Lions in 2025. Tour packages on sale now at Wallabies Travel

So, for now, Angus Bell, Taniela Tupou, Allan Ala’alatoa, Blake Schoupp, James Slipper and Pone Fa’amausili will have to hold the fort until the Blades Academy students graduate or new blood is found.

Are there any obvious league players for the second row since it seems you need to be about two metres tall? Ross Lane, Tino (above) and Pat Carrigan come to mind, but are there others? Again, education would be needed at Eales, Harrison and Partners. For now, we will have to work with Will Skelton, Nick Frost, the Arnold brothers and Matt Philip.

There are league players who would, with the correct guidance, be more comfortable in the back row with Rob Valetini. Certainly my top pick would be Cameron Murray, who has rugby in his background and would mimic the performance of the original ‘mister perpetual motion’, Ray Price.

Angus Crichton representing Australia at the 2022 Rugby League World Cup. (Photo by Naomi Baker/Getty Images)

Rugby Australia has their sights set on Angus Crichton, and there is no doubting his ability. He also has a rugby background and may well be a hit.

There are other candidates such as Liam Martin and Isaah Yeo from Penrith, Patrick Carrigan and Lindsay Collins, all of whom would be energetic and resolute defenders, as well as creative with the ball.

The backline is another matter altogether. I would scrap the whole Wallaby backline apart from Marika Koroibete. The rest of the incumbents are either inconsistent or pedestrian. The fullback would be James Tedesco (kicking skills would need serious attention) and joining Koroibete on the wing would be Valentine Holmes.

A centre pairing of Bradman Best and Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow would provide spark and power, with Kotoni Staggs on the bench. Nathan Cleary would control the game at 10, and Nicho Hynes would learn the halfback role relatively quickly.

You could throw the very competitive (and annoying) Cameron Munster into the game at some point. Other Wallaby backs might be considered as bench players: Tate McDermott, Carter Gordon, Isaiah Perese, Len Ikatau and Mark Nawaqanitawase.

And the coach? Wayne Bennett, of course.

The Crowd Says:

2023-11-13T06:13:01+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Ha ha ..No not RG ......My current favourite player ...But we will see ..Who knows maybe the next coach wont get what the next coach wants as easily as Eddie did .Remember the Gitau Law hasnt been revoked yet ....

2023-11-13T06:01:33+00:00

Revok

Roar Rookie


JS well it`s up to William to make himself available for more tests. Join a super rugby club. He refuses to. And from what i saw from his 7 tests this year reaffirmed my opinion that he is just a pumped up media pin up boy because he is 145 kilos and plays in a winning French club. You have 5 locks superior to William, Klein, De Jager, Rudophus Gerharus, Mostert and Eben. Noice comments from Faf, a true cheeky champ, he was just being generous as Skelton wouldn`t lay a hand on him as he is slower than a slug stuck in peanut butter. Okayyyyy, we`ll give you William, can we have RG.?

2023-11-13T05:01:47+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Dont think he has had much chance yet ..In european Club Rugby he is acknowledged and respected as a beast . A while ago Matt Gitau interviewed Faf de Klerk ..Asked him who is the most feared player he has ever played against ..Remember he has played against the likes of Bakkies Botha and Eben Etsebeth…..He didnt hesitate ..Will Skelton ! His answer ..And that was well before Eddie selected him ..Will brings that element of intimidation and presence that every team needs ..Has skills too….But he needs at least a year in a settled team ..A few months not nearly enough time ….Also dont burden him with the Captaincy …You already have a ready made World class player and Captain in Hooper ..Why try reinvent the wheel ?

2023-11-13T03:14:26+00:00

Revok

Roar Rookie


"Very strong pack especially if Skelton is a permanent fixture" Disagree, he has done nothing in gold to warrant any praise.

2023-11-13T03:09:13+00:00

Revok

Roar Rookie


"They would be useless in lineouts and restarts (although in the latter they may not look out of place with that level of incompetence)" The above hasn`t stopped the complete flop Willaim Skelton from being gifted a gold jersey.

2023-11-12T06:49:37+00:00

3 R M

Roar Rookie


Everyone is taking this way too seriously. But if you could pick the eyes out of the nrl to play a game of rugby this would be the way I'd go Props the two biggest with the best ball skills and the ability to offload with multiple players trying to stop them who are trained to combat offloads Big Reg and junior Paulo (massive motors) The hooker I went for payne hass He doesn't stop and has a great carry. He's elite with ball handling so like most people he could throw a ball in a line out. And he is just on the borderline for size for an international hooker Second row is a bit iffy but I'll go for big billy Kikau and Heilum Luki Luki has eales like metrics in speed, jumping and power. He's a bit small but extremely athletic. Blind side breakaway would be Talakai Openside is Murray Locking it up (every put on the head protection) Big Nellie Harry Grant for half back The big Chin Clearey dominating at fly half With the complete all round game Lattrell at inside centre he kicks and kicks ar$e when he's not suspended. We may as well partner him with Fighton they are mates and both strong ball carriers, jack kicks as well and would be good on the blind side wing but I went with Critter because of his speed versatility and kicking Open side wing would be The Hammer And for fullback it's the human pinball Munster with his massive boot and ball play. And it would only cost rugby Australia around 13 million..... That's 20 million on the Chief Joseph rate BTW.

2023-11-12T05:16:32+00:00

Footy Franks

Roar Rookie


No you invest in Western Sydney rather than Melbourne.

2023-11-11T03:16:30+00:00

Odi

Roar Rookie


Nz v AUS 36-0 and you pick Teddy at the back Go back to Nimbin,

2023-11-10T03:32:40+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


Thanks mate.

2023-11-10T02:28:46+00:00

Redcap

Roar Guru


What a peculiar article. It did remind me of something, though. Rugby union a basket case due to its own mismanagement. Check. League ascendant. Check. We're not quite in a world war, but nor are we that far off. Check (sort of). A hypothetical autocrat president (I'm not sure that author understands what a republic is, BTW) who decides "that there will be zero men and women playing rugby league by 2025”. Check. Did the author intend to invoke 1940s France, or is that just where fifteenists automatically go in their fever dreams?

2023-11-10T00:53:45+00:00

MattTheContrarian

Roar Rookie


Wahahahaah! Yes, love it, Smash 'n Grab 2.0. Cos the first time it worked. So well. So damn well.

2023-11-09T23:07:11+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Can’t see that happening unfortunately. He grew up a Dogs fan, plus he wants to be the man, rather than being 4th on the pecking order. But yes you’re right.

AUTHOR

2023-11-09T22:53:46+00:00

J Joseph

Roar Rookie


Great point

AUTHOR

2023-11-09T22:52:31+00:00

J Joseph

Roar Rookie


Thanks for the correction. Mahoney at half would be interesting, but he needs to back to the Eels for his own sake.

AUTHOR

2023-11-09T22:49:30+00:00

J Joseph

Roar Rookie


I see. Sorry to annoy you.

2023-11-09T21:55:41+00:00

Tony Dargon

Roar Guru


Bring back Eddie in January 2027 I say

2023-11-09T21:28:00+00:00

MattTheContrarian

Roar Rookie


Took the words outta my mouth. Yes. Please. Put a bunch of leagies in and win the world cup. Even Eddie wasnt that brazen.

2023-11-09T11:03:11+00:00

Busted Fullback

Roar Rookie


I’ve sort of read this and come to two conclusions. 1) This should have been submitted to the Dad Jokes section of the Roar; 2) Any idea that any (number of) RL player can help the Wallabies was answered the other day at the RL Pacific Championships ...NZ 30-0 Aus.

2023-11-09T09:31:17+00:00

Arcturus

Roar Rookie


The Wallabies will still lose. Rugby Union favours sides that play 10 man rugby and can kick penalty goals. Sweeping back line movements are an anomaly. NRL players won't make any difference.

2023-11-09T08:56:53+00:00

Returned Son

Roar Rookie


Logged in just to say this.. No.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar