Bruno bags four, Irankunda can't hide emotions as Reds slip again, Western in crisis

By David Shilovsky / Expert

Plenty happening, as always, across another great weekend of football action. Here are your A-League Round 7 talking points.

Clinical Roar condemn Reds to back-to-back defeats

Ross Aloisi’s plucky, young and bloody exciting Brisbane Roar side are up to second on the A-League ladder. When the older Aloisi brother took on the role he promised to return Roar to the pointy end of the table, but few expected him to do it this soon. Despite the Reds’ first-half dominance, Jez Lofthouse opened the scoring with a deflected effort before Jay O’Shea’s composed spot-kick sealed the three points.

With Sunday afternoon’s victory over Adelaide at Coopers Stadium, Brisbane are already at 57 per cent of their total wins in 2022-23 – in nineteen fewer matches. Plenty of coaches can talk the talk, but Aloisi is more than backing it up with a tremendous start to the campaign. The Aloisi Derby beckons next week and it’ll be a different challenge going in as favourites – can they keep the winning streak going against a desperate Western United team?

Adelaide’s inability to capitalise left Carl Veart very displeased with his side, and it was all too much for Bundesliga-bound Nestory Irankunda who left the field in tears as he was yanked before the hour mark. There’s absolutely no doubting Irankunda’s talent but especially on a day when he’s drawing a blank, as are his teammates, the defensive side of his game will be scrutinised and it was not up to scratch.

(Photo by Graham Denholm/Getty Images)

It will be another learning moment for the 17-year-old, who also let his emotions get the better of him in the Original Rivarly a few weeks ago – earning a red card in the process.

I’ve always found the dynamic between Irankunda and Veart interesting – but who really knows what it’s like behind closed doors? I wonder if Veart went with the hairdryer treatment, or putting an arm around the kid on Sunday?

Victory pass WSW test – just

Melbourne Victory’s visit to CommBank Stadium shaped as a classic and, despite sweltering conditions in Parramatta the two sides put on a very entertaining game. In the end Tony Popovic got the best of his old mate Marko Rudan thanks to Bruno Fornaroli’s brilliant four-goal haul. Valentino Yuel notched a goal and assist for Marcus Antonsson in a fruitful cameo but it wasn’t enough for Wanderers.

Fornaroli is showing incredible form, perhaps enough to earn himself a seat on the plane to Qatar for Australia’s Asian Cup campaign. He’s feeding on the service provided by the likes of Jake Brimmer, Daniel Arzani and Zinedine Machach as that Victory frontline hums along. Popovic’s side are one of only two teams – along with Macarthur – still undefeated seven rounds into the season.

Western collapse as pressure builds on Aloisi

Already in a tough spot to start the season, things have gone from bad to worse for Western United and manager John Aloisi. After missing the top six in 2022-23, United were due for a bounce-back campaign but it has all gone horribly wrong, with the latest defeat a 4-0 capitulation at the hands of Central Coast, which the coach described as “the worst performance since I’ve been at the club.”

I can’t argue with that statement, considering the absolutely embarrassing defending on show in Gosford on Friday evening. Tom Heward-Belle was hung out to dry and didn’t deserve to cop four goals, keeping the scoreline down with some quality saves.

Aloisi’s persistence with the old-school 4-4-2 formation doesn’t seem to suit many of his charges, and especially not Daniel Penha, who is looking like a shell of his former self. Penha, a natural attacking midfielder in the mould of Macarthur’s Ulises Davila, has instead been deployed out wide and is struggling to make an impact on his side’s fortunes from the wing.

We’ve seen other managers dismissed for similar results in recent times, so the question becomes, can Aloisi survive?

Jets take flight as Nix suffer first defeat

Leading the league after an undefeated start, few would’ve predicted anything but a Wellington Phoenix victory over the struggling Newcastle Jets. However, from the early stages the Nix didn’t look up to it, conceding twice in the first half and then immediately after the restart in a shock 3-0 loss.

That’s not to take away from Newcastle’s excellent pressure and clinical finishing – they deserved the three points on the back of excellent showings from Clayton Taylor and Apostolos Stamatelopoulos.

(Photo by Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

It’s been a difficult start to life in the Hunter for new Jets boss Rob Stanton, with just one win in their first six fixtures prior to this round. Ownership issues continue to plague the club, and obviously nothing will be sorted in that area until the new year, but hopefully sooner rather than later.

Stanton does have some promising young talent at his disposal, including the mercurial Archie Goodwin, who managed some minutes off the pine on Saturday evening. But challenging for a finals place will be a grind for the former Sydney FC assistant, as the squad is in the bottom three in the A-League on paper.

For Wellington, the trend of dropping points to sides in the bottom half of the table continues. It’s something that affected the side under Ufuk Talay, and whether it’s an issue between the ears or otherwise, they will need to learn to put away the weaker sides in the competition – especially on their home patch – if they’ve got top-four ambitions in 2023-24.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Quick hits

-Perth Glory seem to have regressed from last season, currently sporting a 1-1-5 record. There’s still time for Alen Stajcic to turn it around, but to keep touch with the finals places Perth will need to start getting some wins on the board soon.

-Promising defender Kealey Adamson this week joined Macarthur. The 20-year-old, who impressed in the Sky Blues’ Australia Cup-winning campaign, is another talented youngster let go by Sydney FC, following the likes of Calem Nieuwenhof and Marco Tilio.

-Mathew Leckie’s great form may actually come to hurt Melbourne City, with the winger surely set to be selected for the Asian Cup.

-It was a family affair at Allianz Stadium, Jake Hollman getting the better of his brother Corey with the opening goal in a man-of-the-match showing. Sydney fought hard but couldn’t overcome the loss of Andrew Redmayne, who was sent for an early shower when Matthew Millar’s strike hit his arm outside the penalty area.

The Crowd Says:

2023-12-11T12:55:11+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


not sure there's a professional sportsman/woman anywhere who doesn't need a psychologist on occasions.

2023-12-11T09:00:21+00:00

Brisbanefan93

Roar Rookie


I wouldn't be surprised if Parson was moved on in January or wants to leave. His been selected over a McNichol, Cahill, Brownlie in recent weeks. Clearly ross either doesn't rate him or his work ethic in training is poor. Not sure if we need a CB personally depending on neville injury status. Trewin, Neville, Aldred, Reardon & Nikolovski ATM. Unless we are going to upgrade a starter not sure we really need to add another one. Its an area that will need serious looking come end of season however.

2023-12-11T07:41:13+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


The injury thing is worrying, especially knee surgery for Hore, that pretty much ends a season if it’s anything other than a quick tidy up of cartilage.

2023-12-11T07:37:30+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


It’s a tough one. With players fit our Midfield is as good as anyone, there’s only Parsons that’s badly out of sorts and he should improve. The defence probably lacks a CB, and the attack lacks depth - or at least experience - but yeah, someone that can play across all three would be a good move.

2023-12-11T07:35:12+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


Burke-Gilroy has been little short of sensational since he returned, but sadly he's got a lingering injury and yet to get through the first half. Let's hope he's fully fit soon, and Hore too, apparently in for knee surgery. They've copped some injuries, need more players across the park.

AUTHOR

2023-12-11T07:14:55+00:00

David Shilovsky

Expert


I'm not sure about his mental state, but he is playing an immature game on the pitch. In that sense he does need to grow up.

2023-12-11T06:49:24+00:00

TheSecretScout

Roar Guru


there is a lot going on behind the scenes at adelaide currently, im not sure if you've noticed but people who are either employed or close to the club (eg myself, robbie cornthwaite) previously had free reign to write and say whatever we wanted without any repercussions coming our way. djite has publicly spoken out about certain situations (and a lot of our conversations in private echo certain things that have been said nationally.) what i will reiterate some comments ive made over the past few years that have upset a lot of people when it comes to african teenagers. *theres a reason why victoria (which has the largest african population in australia) is producing so little footballers with african heritage compared to a small city like adelaide *theres a reason why Caucasian football players (who generally are nowhere near as athletic as african teenage) are able to run out full matches when they are 15/16 year olds *what i mentioned above goes into training. *mentality is very different as well *african teenagers face 2 things which Caucasian football generally do not face as for events of the past 24 hours with nestory, the media and 99% of fans have got it wrong - he doesnt needs a psychologist, he doesnt need to 'grow up' (to a degree yes, but not the way people are saying about him

2023-12-11T06:27:01+00:00

Brisbanefan93

Roar Rookie


I don’t see us signing an experienced 9. Maybe someone who can play across the front 3 but more likely a depth like a-league player striker like a DWH or Ruhs (not suggesting them just the first names off the top of my head)

AUTHOR

2023-12-11T06:07:52+00:00

David Shilovsky

Expert


Thanks mate, I did pop in one line about Redders down the bottom but it didn't seem a big talking point in the context of everything else happening. Personally, I think he got what he deserved under the rules, but you bring up an interesting point.

AUTHOR

2023-12-11T06:05:47+00:00

David Shilovsky

Expert


The Cove have really been bringing the atmosphere this season.

2023-12-11T05:58:46+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


I think you’ll find they’re backing away from those comments with each passing match. The comments ahead of the Adelaide game were about being active in the window (which was new) and I can’t remember the words they used but as I said above, I bet they’re wanting someone that can finish … that may be a 9 or a 10, and it may be to start alongside Waddingham or replace him - either way I don’t see it as a threat to Waddinghams future, they’ve clearly set their stall out to develop him and given his form form so far he’s one of the few players guaranteed to be here next season. (But they could also be looking at signing a defender, seem to have injuries galore there).

2023-12-11T05:32:36+00:00

Chopper07

Roar Rookie


I agree in regard to Lofthouse, he doesn't seem to have a football brain and at times runs around like a headless chook. Waddingham will be a top investment by Roar as he has all the attributes but needs better service and that is where selections like Lofthouse let him and the team down.

2023-12-11T05:21:59+00:00

Brisbanefan93

Roar Rookie


Ross mentioned on a recent interview with SEN or 4BC that he and management have agreed to not sign a striker as it would hurt Waddingham development and his very happy with his performances. So doubt we will sign an experienced striker came January

2023-12-11T05:00:05+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


I agree. Needs time snd he should be learning heaps out of this.

2023-12-11T03:18:06+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


first season, age 18, expectations should not be too high. He's been thrust into the starting lineup, not the plan.

2023-12-11T03:15:44+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


should add, my primary assumption is that the executives will remain for a few years

2023-12-11T01:42:42+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


I recon Roar management thought City and SFC would run away with this season but are now looking at a 1/4 complete season and daring to dream - “we could win this?” (Which I think is optimistic still but Ross impressed more and more each week so who knows). The Management tone on signings has changed in recent weeks and it looks like they’ll be trying to sign someone in January, it’s traditionally the easier window to sign someone as there’s short term deals to be done. My bet would be they want someone who can score and either complement or replace Waddingham in the starting XI. It’s hard to be sure he’s developing until the output improves imo - it’s another game where he only had one crack at goal

2023-12-11T00:30:19+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


I agree it was red. I also see your point about tactical fouls worsening. I hate seeing games ruined with players being sent off for “minor” incidents.

2023-12-11T00:09:06+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Secondary assist on his own goal. Goal. Assist for earning the penalty. Chances created well one of the missed Miluesnic one on ones was his through ball. It was on TV as well so no excuses to not having Paramount Plus. I dont get it who are these mysterious Roar fans that are fans of Lofthouse but thought he had a bad game on what forum?

2023-12-11T00:06:55+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


don't. The last thing Roar needs is to be overrated and expectations set way too high. Adelaide were a bit average, so too Wanderers last week. Roar will be top six, fair expectation, but they won't be grandfinalists just yet, depth alone and injuries will keep them out.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar