A lot going on in NRL round five. Injuries, suspensions, great performances and some, let’s say, less than energetic efforts. Let’s have a look at your weekly NRL talking points.
Have a breather, Latrell
“They’re both stupid things. You’ve got to be better, simple as that.” After another South Sydney debacle, going down 34-4 to the very impressive New Zealand side it was coach Jason Demetriou making this fair point about his fullback getting placed on report for a high elbow fend, then a lifting tackle.
Latrell Mitchell copped three weeks from the judiciary and was lucky to stay on the field. His season so far has been a hell of a ride. Maybe some time off will do him good, not that it might do Demetriou any good. The coach is in all sorts with his highly touted squad sitting bottom and with a points differential of -90 meaning they’re even further behind in the finals chase.
Another DCE legacy game
Daly Cherry-Evans is a highly polarising figure. Many love him, many don’t. If you don’t, you’re in an increasingly shrinking group. His 310th game broke Cliff Lyons’ Manly’s club record and DCE turned it on to celebrate, knocking over the Panthers 32-18.
Cherry-Evans has won a premiership and a Clive Churchill medal, a World Cup and many Origin series while he firmly changed people’s minds about his Queensland career. He continues to play at a high level. He’s a gem.
Points everywhere
The biblical, torrential weather across much of New South Wales on Friday meant you could be forgiven for expecting dour, error riddled football but we got the complete opposite – rampant attack, tries everywhere. It followed a belter of a game in Melbourne on Thursday as the Storm edged Brisbane 34-32. For all the points though we only had a couple of blowouts and somewhat quirkily, the Dolphins were the only winning team this weekend not to get 30 (they got 26).
New Zealand’s Wayde Egan. (Photo by Mark Nolan/Getty Images)
This was coming for the Bulldogs
It was a great win by Canterbury over the Roosters and it had everything. After blowing out to 26-0 it looked like the Bulldogs were going to rampage to 50, before stumbling and fumbling against 12 men, then 11. It genuinely looked like the Roosters had the game in hand halfway through the second half before Matt Burton secured the 30-26 result.
Where are things changing? It’s effort, and it’s structure starting to bear out with the talent they have. Let’s take for example their high profile recruit Viliame Kikau, who has been making half-breaks through the defence all year.
The Roar League Podcast is on YouTube! Click here and subscribe to make sure you never miss an episode
At Penrith, these were usually accompanied by a runner anticipating a pass. At Canterbury, they weren’t… until the last couple of weeks. It doesn’t always lead to a try, but it can be a lethal play. Kikau leads all forwards for line break assists and had another try assist for three on the season, already passing last year’s total and well on track to beat his season best of 10. His run metres are up by 32 a game on last year’s injury impacted season.
Viliame Kikau. (Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)
This is not to say Kikau is the reason for the improved Bulldogs play, mind you. He’s just a good example of how Canterbury’s attacking plans are starting to come together. The Bulldogs are second in the NRL for ‘supports’ and that flows to being third for both tackle breaks (160) and line breaks (30). They’re also second for dummy half runs.
Players in motion, at speed, understanding what they’re trying to do. Gelling the brand new squad is a bloody tough thing to do and there’s work left in defence because they miss too many tackles and give away too many penalties, but Cameron Ciraldo and his crew are making real progress.
Michael Jennings should not be anywhere near the NRL
Really didn’t like seeing Michael Jennings take the field for the Roosters on Friday night. He hadn’t played since 2020 because of a three-year suspension for drug use. Fine and fair enough to do your time and come back like Bronson Xerri did this week, but Jennings is a different case – on top of the drugs, some seriously horrible allegations (supported in court) of abuse and sexual assault were made by his ex-wife, to whom he was ordered by a court to pay $500,000 (which he hasn’t).
Did the Roosters really have no other squad options than to bring in a 35 year old with his putrid record?
It’s Jennings’ 300th game this weekend. It should not be celebrated. It’s shameful the Roosters wanted him and even more shameful the NRL approved his registration. Rugby league, once again aiming the shotgun at its own feet.
Scott Drinkwater makes a break. (Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)
You can only beat who’s in front of you
The Cowboys win again, the Dolphins win again, the Knights did what they needed to do to get two important points. Not a great deal can be drawn from who they beat – the Titans are an abomination in 2024, the Tigers are still learning what Benji wants them to do and the Dragons are also in a bad place.
Wayne Bennett’s men are also in heaps of injury strife ahead of a tough month – they’ve got Brisbane, Parramatta, Newcastle and North Queensland. Newcastle have the Roosters, Bulldogs, Dolphins then Warriors and North Queensland faces Parramatta, Cronulla, Penrith and the Dolphins. Get three (or maybe just two) of those wins, and the season is kept alive.
Good games this week
Some decent matchups arrive in round six but be warned – there’s a few with a high chance of being bludgers.
Thursday night the banged-up Roosters will head to Newcastle in an almost must-win contest. Friday’s early game is in Melbourne as the Storm host Canterbury, a game looking sneaky good. Primetime Friday is the Broncos and Dolphins, which will be a bit of fun.
Saturday starts across the ditch with a belter as the Warriors and Manly go at it. Manly have been great and horrible in even doses – let’s see how they back up from their great win over Penrith.
Canberra’s Ethan Strange. (Photo by Mark Nolan/Getty Images)
Parramatta then host North Queensland, a game which will test both. I thought the Eels had sorted some defensive issues this season, I was quite wrong.
Saturday night sees the beleaguered South Sydney up against Cronulla, who are rested off the bye but were hardly setting the world alight prior to that.
Sunday’s games are Wests Tigers and St George-Illawarra, and for the third week in a row, Canberra play at 6.15 Sunday night as they welcome Des Hasler and his hapless Titans. These are the sort of games Canberra drops – will the Gold Coast get off the mark?
Penrith get a week off.
Round 5’s random thoughts
- Maybe it was just the broadcast microphone positioning, but there was some serious crowd support for the Warriors in Sydney against the Bunnies.
- Shane Flanagan and Des Hasler are the ‘old school’ coaches brought in to make huge difference for clubs who need help. Currently their Titans and Dragons sit 15th and 16th with a combined 2-7 record and a joint differential of -133. Work to do.
- Wests Tigers’ gun new five-eighth Lachlan Galvin was out suspended this week, the first of a two-game seating for a hip drop tackle. This ruled him out of contention for the Dally M rookie of the year considerations. Is that harsh?
- Parramatta coach Brad Arthur had some curious comments about the 41-8 loss in Canberra, including “41 points I know isn’t great. But I don’t think it was effort-based or soft. I thought it was around the big moments which we didn’t nail.” Arthur also praised the effort of half Dylan Brown in a hopelessly outclassed side. Gotta look for the positives, I suppose.
- Big time refereeing complaints about Manly centre Tolatau Koula’s try to bust it open against Penrith, but the ball clearly goes backwards before he takes off with it. The problem for the rest of us is that we’re so used to seeing balls hit the deck and get immediately called as knocked on…
What’s caught your eye this weekend, Roarers?
Horses for Courses
Roar Rookie
The Queenslander in me says yes! But my Supercoach team says no thanks.
Gary Russell-Sharam
Roar Rookie
Yes I agree that Jennings should never have been allowed back on the field. He has done his time for the drug abuse but he has not done time etc for the other dreadful stuff. If league were as good as their word in supposedly treating women as equal they should never have let him back in the game. an appalling decision by the roosters to even give this a thought. I'm really disappointed in the Roosters as a team
Forty Twenty
Roar Rookie
How did Manly win? The Pennies could be past their peak . The way the Broncos forwards got on top in the G.F for a while is a bit like Manly's forwards at Brookie. It's been rare for any team to get on top of the Pennies forwards but it's starting to happen sometimes now and it could be a trend. Manly were at home and fairly healthy and the Pennies were a bit off for sure although they looked like cruising to a win early on.
Bernie
Roar Rookie
i think it's disgraceful. sure he's polarising, but seriously? every time he touches the ball? and i hate Souths!
Bernie
Roar Rookie
yes! thats exactly how i feel in the (extremely rare) games that Saints are well in front. irrational clock calculations ... sure, the other mob can run in three converted tries in last 5 minutes. the only way i can fully enjoy it is watching the replay.
Geoff from Bruce Stadium
Roar Rookie
I'm a Raiders supporter - no such thing as an easy game. Though the Eels game came close. Kept wondering if it was possible that they could score 5 converted tries in 10 minutes. :laughing:
Maxtruck
Roar Rookie
Hass Junior had a crack Sunday
AJ Mithen
Expert
Stop it, Geoff :laughing:
Geoff from Bruce Stadium
Roar Rookie
Hope your "These are the sort of games Canberra drops" reference to the game against the Titans on Sunday night isn't prophetic AJ. Hopefully Ricky can keep them focussed. The Titans still have some game breakers in Fifita, AJ Brimson and Jayden Campbell. They have to all click one day.
Maxtruck
Roar Rookie
Young Galvin should not worry about the Dally M sham awards. Last year, Ponga's win over Johnson looks like a Don King USA boxing result! And how did Turuva get 2023 rookie of the year after playing 3 games in 2022?
AJ Mithen
Expert
Apologies Andrew - wasn't going after you, more making a general statement cos I spend too much time on twitter!
Andrew01
Roar Rookie
Hey sorry, that's not fair. I'm not having a dig at Kasey Badger because she is female, and lord knows i have had plenty of digs at Klein in the bunker and on the field, and he isn't a female. But we already had the dubious penalty try call in the Cowboys v Dolphins game, and a couple of poor decisions - or poorly explained decisions last year. Last night, you had the Simmonsen hip drop which seemed pretty clear cut, as was the (i think it was Tapine) contact with Lussick before he got the ball, and the claim the ball was knocked on by Lussick - neither of which appeared to happen. Then you could make a case on a few other calls like the no try to Parra which was ruled a Gutho knock-on, which is often called a defender touching the ball as the player tries to pass, and the Levi try which still seems hard to digest - but i get that if one wanted to, they could justify the later two. I get it is hard for people to get experience in the bunker because it isn't used in other levels of the game, and as i say on the Todd Smith - Radley call, there are other people in the bunker. But i don't think we can say Badger is performing consistently in the bunker role. Disagree with my opinion, no worries, but accuse me of going after Badger because she is female based on one comment, that isn't warranted if aimed at me. And for the record, On the ground, I thought Belinda Sharpe did a really good job in really hard conditions on Friday night in Newcastle.
Albo
Roar Rookie
But he does seem to get injured a lot ?
Albo
Roar Rookie
I'm sure he has a crook shoulder. And is missing his combination with Cleary. But both him and the whole team are not fully firing as yet this season. I would say only Edwards, Yeo & Kenny are at their best so far.
Andrew01
Roar Rookie
Not saying Robson is doing anything wrong, and i guess he offers a little flexibility from an Origin selection perspective. But if we were drafting NRL teams from scratch tomorrow, I think any team would be nuts not to take Egan over Robson. He just offers multiple ways to threaten you out of dummy half.
Andrew01
Roar Rookie
Albo; Do you think Martin has been off this year, not just against Manly? I know he has had some hands issues on and off in his career, but handling and timing and general impact on games seems to be down. Still has his moments, but not as much impact and i don't think teams are marking him any different. I guess Cleary missing doesn't help him, but he just doesn't seem to be going that well at the moment?
Pomoz
Roar Rookie
"The ball clearly goes backwards". Yeah, of course it does AJ. Anyway, besides the fact it was a poor decision, it did not impact the result. Manly were too good. The Panthers look a bit busted up to me. Leota, Martin and JFH looked like they were underdone and still carrying an injury. Martin was carrying his arm by his side the whole game and kept missing tackles. It might have been better to let the young blokes have a run instead, they would still have lost but would have got an extra weeks recovery.
Nambawan
Roar Rookie
Very impressive performances by Manly and The Warriors last round. They play each other next Saturday in Auckland and as both teams play open football, and are chockfull of star players, the match-up should be a beauty. Just hope the NZ weather holds up. Whilst on Manly my main concern about them is about their current wings and dummy-half who may struggle to match their Kiwi opposites.
mushi
Roar Guru
With you on the Jennings decision. Where's Mitchell's elbow when you need it
Big Mig
Roar Rookie
Good point TB, I witnessed it firsthand at the game—Latrell orchestrates Souths' first try within five minutes. All looking good despite the crowd's boos, incessantly all directed at him from the onset (before any 'incident'), singling him out, no one else. It was a pitiful and shameful display from the crowd as happened against the Dogs last week, and the Chooks the week before that. Regardless of personal feelings towards him, it's just not a good situation. Hope he gets through it, League would be better for it.