Another Australia collapse highlights value of Rogers

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

The value of Chris Rogers’ dour efforts was again highlighted last night as Australia’s top order crumbled against the West Indies in the second Test in Jamaica.

The tourists were 3-22 in the 11th over before Michael Clarke was handed a reprieve by a no ball from Kemar Roach.

The West Indian firebrand had pouched the most elementary of return catches after Clarke aimed an ungainly leg-side flick at a delivery which stopped in the tacky surface.

FULL SECOND TEST SCORECARD

It was a gargantuan let off for Australia. At the time, the Dukes ball was hooping through the air, deviating off the seam and, on occasion, leaping alarmingly from a good length.

Jerome Taylor was amid a phenomenal spell of five overs, five maidens, 2-0. First drop Steve Smith was scratching around at the crease like an old chook.

Had Clarke departed at this juncture the Windies may well have managed to roll on into the Australian lower order by lunch.

This may seem alarmist in retrospect but, for those who were watching live, it appeared to be a distinct possibility.

Certainly, if not for Roach’s foot folly, Australia could easily have found themselves in similar treacherous territory as they lurched into in the first Test.

At Roseau, a familiar pattern was followed as Australia’s top seven faltered, leaving the side in a cricketing crevasse at 6-126.

The boys in baggy greens are fortunate that they have a lower order capable of carrying out successful rearguard actions in such circumstances. They have done so with great frequency over the past three years.

While it is highly valuable to have such a capable lower order, becoming reliant upon them to any degree is fraught with obvious risk.

Against weak sides like the West Indies, Australia may not be punished for the failings of their top seven.

The story would likely be very different though in the upcoming Ashes against a more talented side which revels in home conditions.

If England are to regain the Ashes, it will be on the back of incisive efforts from their pacemen, in particular veterans James Anderson and Stuart Broad.

It was their ability to carve through Australia’s top seven in the last Ashes in England which erased the admirable efforts of the Aussie attack.

Both Anderson and Broad, especially the former, are more comfortable and more potent with the Dukes ball.

They will fancy that they can blast holes in Australia with the new pill as they did regularly in the past two series.

There is no Australian batsman better equipped to quell the influence of that pair than the vastly experienced Rogers, who has missed this current series due to concussion.

The left hander has played far more cricket in English conditions than any other member of the Australian side.

He’s also passed fifty in his past six Test innings. And, most pertinently, he has a magnificent record against Anderson and Broad.

In the 2013 Ashes, Rogers fell six times to off spinner Graeme Swann. But he dominated the English quicks, scoring 272 runs from them at an average of 90.

The English pacemen tried all manner of tactics to try to unsettle Rogers but none bore fruit.

In true old-school opener style, Rogers has the ability to soak up the best a paceman can hurl at him.

He is happy to weather these torrid spells, looking ungainly in the process. His lack of ego and infinite patience facilitates this.

Once the clouds part, so to speak, he is primed to exploit his hard yakka. Rogers would have been the perfect player to try to halt the momentum of the Windies in the first hour last night.

His replacement Shaun Marsh failed again and is watching his Ashes dream slip through his grasp.

Cavalier opener David Warner undoubtedly will be relieved to see the return of Rogers, who has been a steadying influence throughout the period in which his career has progressed at a frenetic rate.

The value of Rogers is not to be underestimated.

The Crowd Says:

2015-06-15T02:47:59+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Outscored Warner, Clarke and Watson... ...you don't like 69?

2015-06-15T02:22:59+00:00

dan ced

Guest


Century in warmup match, bugger all in the two real games. Same old story. No excuses.

2015-06-14T22:25:01+00:00

josh

Roar Rookie


and you sand the ones on the edges

2015-06-13T03:38:38+00:00

Gav

Guest


I like it. Retain Vogues in the middle order and drop S Marsh when Rogers comes back in.

2015-06-13T01:48:53+00:00

BrumbyJack

Guest


He might not get the chance Ronan if we enforce a follow on... I'm a big fan of Shane Watsons bowling in English conditions, and in the last Ashes series there he built plenty of pressure for the attack to benefit from. But surely his batting is now under the microscope more than ever throughout his career? Do you have his last 12 month test batting average?

2015-06-13T01:07:06+00:00

Jimmy

Roar Rookie


Yep, it's gotta be time to blood some unrealised potential coming out of the grade comp

2015-06-12T14:12:33+00:00

Nudge

Guest


Reckon Root failed in his last test Jimmy. Get rid of him for the ashes as far as I'm concerned

2015-06-12T13:48:51+00:00

Ram C. Khanal

Roar Rookie


Yep, trying to execute instant heroics is costing Warner and the team, someone just need to tell him that he is not Maxwell-like player.

AUTHOR

2015-06-12T12:46:58+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Brumbyjack, the answer is "one". Marsh has the second innings in this Test to do something extraordinary or his Ashes dream will dissolve. As much as I like to watch him bat (he is very aesthetically pleasing) I have never been convinced he is a Test player. And if he's going to flourish at Test level at this point I think it's at 5/6 not up top.

2015-06-12T11:06:56+00:00

Timmuh

Roar Guru


He seems to struggle most on slow decks. If there isn't pace onto (and coming off) the bat he just doesn't seem to adjust at all. That said he did score runs in the UAE against Pakistan so he CAN do it - he just does't seem to do so often enough. He probably is one of those guys who suffers from the death of having multiple lead-in FC tour matches.

2015-06-12T09:23:28+00:00

BrumbyJack

Guest


Ronan how many more chances does Marsh get?

2015-06-12T09:13:31+00:00

Chancho

Roar Rookie


hahaha there you go again, letting 'facts' get in the way of a good story

2015-06-12T08:47:31+00:00

Robbo

Guest


LRF, Did you see the ball that got him out in this match and did you see the ball that got him in the first innings in the last match? Were you watching, I doubt it. Because if you were watching you wouldn't have wasted your time with your utterly stupid comment!

2015-06-12T08:35:30+00:00

Peter

Roar Rookie


Re Klinger, if we can have a series of short term replacements the quality of Rogers and Voges I'd be more than happy.

2015-06-12T07:45:34+00:00

Sanjay Poojar

Guest


Sachin would hav no problem on dis wicket. Warner is finish West Indies to win an crush Aussie cheat

2015-06-12T06:49:02+00:00

Don Freo

Guest


Bucky's dad played for NSW but came to WA to run the WACA. Bucky was raised, educated and taught to play cricket in WA.

2015-06-12T06:45:44+00:00

Jameswm

Guest


I think the baggies breathed a bigger sigh of relief when Clarke started heading back to the middle.

2015-06-12T06:42:30+00:00

soapit

Guest


must be ronan. unlikely to have two different players with the same name playing tests for aus so close in time dont you think? he sure did well in that series.

2015-06-12T06:36:25+00:00

deccas

Guest


That is exactly my suggestion.

2015-06-12T06:31:43+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


"When was the last time we had a really solid opening partnership." 4th test against India, so exactly two tests ago Warner and Rogers opened the match up with a 200 run stand from memory. So yeah, 2 games ago we had an amazing opening partnership.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar