The perception shift that's restored Glenn Maxwell's career

By David Schout / Expert

Few sports operate in such subjective spheres as cricket.

While the availability of statistics suggests ability is quantifiable, it’s naturally much more than that. Averages and strike rates reveal only so much to a selector, and their perception of a player is dictated by several other standards.

When that perception is unfavourable, however, shaking it proves more difficult than scoring runs or taking wickets.

For Glenn Maxwell, his ‘perception’ in Australian cricket – at least among those who really mattered – was at rock bottom at the beginning of 2018.

After his attitude was openly questioned by coach Darren Lehmann and captain Steve Smith, he was infamously told to ‘train smarter’.

The omission that followed (for the ODI series against England) surprised many, as selectors opted for fellow big-hitter Chris Lynn in the middle order. After Lynn pulled out of the series through injury, Maxwell’s recall appeared imminent.

But selectors pulled another surprise, this time including Victorian teammate Cameron White as the replacement. Lynn’s selection over Maxwell may have been line-ball, but their preference for White sent a strong message: change your attitude or you’re not getting picked.

It wasn’t the first time management made their displeasure known with the all-rounder. A year previous he was reprimanded and fined by the Australian leadership group for publicly questioning his batting position at Victoria.

Frustrated with a lack of opportunity, Maxwell’s off-the-cuff remarks about batting lower than wicketkeeper Matthew Wade weren’t well-received by Smith and Lehmann. For them, it confirmed their perception of him: talented and supremely skilled, but also reckless and undisciplined.

They were, like many other views in cricket, just opinions. Opinions that aligned – however unfairly – with Maxwell’s ‘bigshow’ brand. Despite publicly denouncing that tag at every opportunity, there’s still a section of fans who believe it’s self-labelled. Perception really can become reality.

While Maxwell couldn’t care less for the opinions of ill-informed fans, he had to care about the opinions of Smith and Lehman. His career hinged on them. Setting out to prove them wrong in 2018, a twist of fate (in the form of Australian Cricket’s biggest ever on-field scandal) would mean their judgment of him no longer meant anything, for they were out of a job.

Their replacements, however, perceive the Victorian in a much different light.

When Ricky Ponting was named as Australia’s T20 coach in February, Maxwell’s approval of the move was palpable. The pair had worked closely together at the IPL level and developed a strong relationship on and off the field. For Maxwell, someone had arrived in the Australian setup that understood him.

In an interview, he praised the former captain’s ability to “get the best out of players”. He immediately repaid Ponting’s faith and was named Player of the Series in the tri-tournament against New Zealand and England.

The key appointment, however, which has already proved imperative for Maxwell is that of Justin Langer. The new coach has a clear admiration for the Victorian, calling him “one of the most talented young players of the modern game” last summer.

And after it was revealed yesterday he would hold greater powers at the selection table, Maxwell’s career path has suddenly taken a turn. For once in his career, he’s a valued member of the side where his personality and style can shine.

(Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)

Langer was at pains to point out in his first press conference as coach that he “likes different people”.

“The ones I like the most are the ones who are a bit different”, the former opener said. “You’ve got to have some personality…and be comfortable in your own skin”.

That is Maxwell. To a tee.

When he wasn’t picked for the upcoming Australia A tour of India, some assumed he had been dropped. The September tour, after all, is seen as an audition for the two-test series against Pakistan in October and features the likes of Usman Khawaja, Matt Renhsaw, Mitch Marsh and Peter Handscomb.

But that’s not the case. He’s been told he can prepare in Australia for the Pakistan series, with the assumption he’ll be picked. He’s gone from international outcast to assured selection in very short time, and without doing much at all.

His IPL and recent ODI form, after all, has been moderate at best. An interview with Gerard Whateley earlier this week revealed the confidence Langer’s appointment has instilled in him: “There has been a lot of positive reinforcement that I didn’t need to go on that Australia A tour”, he said. “I think the main goal at the end of this is to have such a good 12 months that I can write my name on that (Ashes) team sheet in 12 months’ time”.

While his skill-set or overall form has scarcely changed in the past six months, a change in leadership has completely shifted Maxwell’s career path. Selection in sport is naturally subjective, but in cricket, it is amplified.

For Maxwell, recent shifts at the top have transformed things for the better.

The Crowd Says:

2018-08-03T08:50:57+00:00

Andrew

Roar Guru


I thought Smith's comments about Maxwell's training was bang out of order for an Australian captain, and an example of the immense hubris that would be his downfall a couple of months later.

2018-08-03T03:55:19+00:00

reuster75

Guest


It was very interesting listening to Dirk Nannes an ABC radio last summer talking about Maxwell and the time when Lehman and Smith had called his attitude into question after the remarks about Wade. He was saying that Victorian cricket side had a culture of honesty towards each other (in a respectful way) and so that was why Maxwell was often 'outspoken' as he'd come from that culture of complete honesty. So Nannes was saying that when Maxwell made that remark against Wade it was because he was giving an honest answer to a question which was the norm in Victorian cricket and he suggested perhaps that was misinterpreted by the powers that be in CA at the time. Langer was a no nonsense, call a spade a spade cricketer, so no co-incidence he's a fan of Maxwell.

2018-07-30T08:18:47+00:00

Timmuh

Roar Guru


Hussey always had a brain. Maxwell has the talent, but still can't be trusted in the long form.

2018-07-30T03:25:35+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


How old was Hussey when he came into the test team? Hmm. 30 wasn't it?

2018-07-30T03:24:25+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


But maybe he can change.

2018-07-30T03:20:04+00:00

Harvey Wilson

Roar Rookie


+1

2018-07-30T03:19:37+00:00

Harvey Wilson

Roar Rookie


Maybe Maxwell has reach his full potential? It was thought at the time Shane Watson failed to reach his potential and he was a similar player. Is the bar set too high? Maxwell is a very different player to those who can just sit back and grind out an innings.

2018-07-28T08:51:11+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


His talent suggests he still has plenty to offer, but his inconsistency throughout his entire career has been his achilleas heel

2018-07-28T08:46:51+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Spot on JayG. Maxwell has failed to reach his full potential

2018-07-28T08:45:16+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Hopefully Warner is kept away from all Australian squads. He is the face of the toxic culture that engulfed the Aussie cricket team and embarrassed our country.

2018-07-28T08:43:31+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Maxwell is almost 30. I feel he simply hasn't fulfilled his pull potential and has shown nothing but inconsistency throughout his entire career and that's on him, nobody else.

2018-07-28T02:54:58+00:00

JamesH

Roar Guru


Good article. There is nothing worse in elite sport than a coach who expects all players to conform to a particular style or mould. Just imagine if Andy Flower had been Australia's coach when Shane Warne was playing. Would he have gone the way of KP? Maxwell is probably destined to never quite get the most out of his talent, but that doesn't necessarily matter. What matters is what he can offer each side he plays in. He's the most well-rounded cricketer we have and even when he has an underwhelming series with the bat, he is capable of moments in the field or with the ball that can turn a game.

2018-07-28T02:19:20+00:00

JayG

Guest


Interesting article. My complaint with Maxwell is mainly that he is a massive underperformer for the talent he has. A change is Aus cricket leadership has renewed his career maybe but ultimately, only consistent strong performances will cement his place in the side - esp the ODI and Test teams.

2018-07-28T02:09:31+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


If there is one thing I have learned through playing and watching cricket is that first impressions matter. Those first reactions to a player are locked in and are very difficult to break. I think it is down to the intense political and competitive nature of the game played out in the self serving individual nature of the game. At least from junior rep cricket/grade and up.

2018-07-27T23:07:58+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Great read. Lehmann's insistence on picking untalented hacks who are "good blokes" was a backwards step for Australian cricket. Cricket really is an individual sport masquerading as a team game. It's a matter of picking the best 11 players available and the only team balance that matters should be a balance of skills, not personalities. Ponting may well be the person who turns around a decade of T20 ineffectiveness at the international level for Australia, although until we learn how to play spin you can forget winning a T20 world cup. Coincidentally that's one of Maxwell's strengths. Hopefully when Smith and Warner come back they are both kept well away from the T20 squad. We don't need them there anymore.

2018-07-27T22:50:24+00:00

RogerTA

Roar Rookie


And that's great news for Australia imo David. Nice read btw.

2018-07-27T22:33:36+00:00

Internal Fixation

Guest


Finally a good line of thinking from CA. I feel Smith’s treatment of Maxwell was actually worse than not controlling Warner. For one he got a nine month suspension and the other he gets kudos from many. Maxwell is exactly the player we need.

Read more at The Roar