West Coast crowned 2018 AFL premiers in all-time classic grand final

By Stirling Coates / Editor

West Coast are the 2018 AFL premiers, after emerging five-point victors in one of the best grand finals we’ve ever seen.

The winning play saw a magnificent intercept mark in defensive 50 from Jeremy McGovern set the Eagles off in motion, before an ice cool Dom Sheed slotted a difficult set shot to be the unlikely hero.

More AFL Grand Final
» BUCKLAND: West Coast change everthing and win it all
» Five talking points from the match
» WATCH: Video highlights from the match
» West Coast Eagles player ratings
» Collingwood Magpies player ratings
» Best and funnies tweets of the grand final

Jack Darling threatened to be the villain after he dropped the easiest of catches unmarked in the goal square with only a minute left on the clock, but his blushes were saved after Luke Shuey cut off the kick-in just outside 50.

After the Pies got off to a blistering start, West Coast spent the better part of two quarters getting themselves back into the contest, levelling the scores at three-quarter time to set up a thrilling finish.

It was Collingwood who got off to the dream start in the last quarter, with Brody Mihocek and De Goey splitting the middle with not even a minute on the clock to put the Pies back out by 12.

The twists and turns didn’t stop coming, however, with a Nathan Vardy set shot goal from the ensuing centre stoppage pulling the margin back to an even six points.

Mason Cox bobbed up for his second goal of the game to give his team some breathing room but, just like that, Josh Kennedy responded with his third major to make it five once more.

Liam Ryan hit the post twice – once from a miracle snap and once from a set shot – to trim the margin back to three. Kennedy, too, had a chance to put the Eagles in front, but his set shot from right on the arc was punched through.

The weight of entries had Collingwood under enormous pressure, but West Coast couldn’t land the killing blow. An errant kick in defensive 50 gifted Chris Masten a set shot, but he also couldn’t guide it through the big sticks as the margin was reduced to just one point.

Collingwood had their time in the sun, with an obvious and correct score review calling back a goal, before two shots from Cox and Taylor Adams failed to trouble the scorers.

They still had the ascendancy as the clock wound down, but they were left to rue being behind at the final siren despite leading for the overwhelming majority of the game.

Luke Shuey was awarded the Norm Smith medal after a blistering effort that saw him rack up 34 disposals, 19 contested possessions, nine clearances, eight tackles, eight inside 50s and a goal.

Among the Eagles best as well were Josh J Kennedy (18 disposals, 11 marks, three goals), Dom Sheed (32 disposals, eight clearances), Jeremy McGovern (nine marks, six rebound 50s, nine one percenters) and Tom Barrass (17 touches, 10 marks, 13 one percenters).

Collingwood were led admirably by Taylor Adams (31 disposals, nine clearances, two goals), Adam Treloar (26 disposals, 11 tackles), Chris Mayne (15 disposals, 14 tackles) and Jordan de Goey (13 disposals, three goals).

The Magpies were ferocious at ground level, winning the tackle count by 32, but they couldn’t shut down West Coast’s aerial game plan, conceding several uncontested marks around the ground and not being quite able to withstand their opponents’ extra 15 inside 50s.

Earlier, Collingwood were served an almighty omen prior to the game, with their banner totally disintegrating in the MCG wind before the team took to the field.

Shannon Hurn won the toss and elected to kick to the city end of the ground but, while his side had a few chances early, it was Travis Varcoe who kicked the first of the match with a cool shot from 35 out on the run.

It got even better for Collingwood thereafter, with two great crumbing goals to Jaidyn Stephenson – one after a simple dropped mark by Thomas Cole – putting them 17 points up. When Jordan de Goey broke two tackles in the forward pocket to snap a fourth goal, it was alarm bells in the West Coast box already.

So out of sorts were the Eagles, that it took Willie Rioli more or less accidentally treading on the ball on the goal line for them to finally put a major on the board. But they found themselves back in the game soon after, with Kennedy’s snap from the pocket getting them back under three kicks at the first break.

It was an almighty arm wrestle in the second stanza, with both sides absorbing incredible amounts of pressure as time-on came on before a goal had been scored. Jordan de Goey broke the deadlock with a super kick from outside 50, but the Eagles hit right back through Mark Hutchings.

West Coast finally grabbed some ascendancy after Luke Shuey’s excellent snap saw them close within 12 points but, despite some good chances late in the quarter, the margin remained just that at the long break.

Shuey was putting his name in the Norm Smith conversation at the break, with 18 touches, six clearances, five tackles and a goal, while Chirs Mayne’s 11 touches at 100 per cent effectiveness were proving more worthwhile than the stat sheet suggested.

It was the perfect start to the second half for West Coast, after a decisive clearance and successful Josh Kennedy set shot within 40 seconds got them back to within six points.

But, after being unsighted in the first half, Mason Cox emerged to take a strong mark on the lead and slot the chance to re-establish the breathing room.

The match kicked into another gear, with Jamie Cripps and Taylor Adams trading goals, before a golden opportunity went begging after Scott Lycett missed a very easy set shot.

Lycett redeemed himself, however, with a smart centreing kick to Jack Darling in the square helping them trim the margin back to six points once more.

Thing truly got turned on their head, however, after a dreadful kick in defence from Taylor Adams gifted Elliot Yeo a set shot – which he duly converted to give the Eagles their first meaningful lead of the afternoon.

Both sides peppered the goals to level the scores and, although Will Hoskin-Elliott had a chance to put the Pies ahead with a set shot after the siren, his kick from just outside 50 fell short as the sides headed into the final break at 55 apiece – setting up an all-time classic of a final quarter.

West Coast Eagles – 2.2 | 4.3 | 8.7 | 11.13 (79)
Collingwood Magpies – 5.1 | 6.3 | 8.7 | 11.8 (74)

Goals
Eagles: Kennedy 3, Rioli, Hutchings, Shuey, Cripps, Darling, Yeo, Vardy, Sheed
Magpies: De Goey 3, Stephenson 2, Cox 2, Varcoe, Hoskin-Elliott, Adams, Mihocek

Disposal leaders
Eagles: Shuey 34, Sheed 32, Hurn 21
Magpies: Adams 31, Treloar 26, Crisp 25

Attendance: 100,022

The Crowd Says:

2018-11-04T01:57:22+00:00

EaglesMan

Roar Rookie


Well thats not our problem, you are correct the teams can only control what they can control. The umpires calls or non-calls not our problem. How about the holding the ball for Howe? or Howe almost ripping Jack Darlings's arm out in the third quarter 10 metres in front of goal. If we are going with non-calls lets include all of them shall we

2018-10-04T09:25:22+00:00

AnonymousHacker123

Roar Rookie


The eagles will win again!

2018-10-02T16:14:38+00:00

Charles

Roar Rookie


I disagree with your view that the umpires favoured West Coast. Firstly, the Maynard non-call is debatable and certainly not clear cut. There is a good argument there was nothing in it. West Coast only received 13 free kicks for the game. Collingwood received 17 free kicks. My view is that WC were particularly harshly done by in the second quarter. In no particular order, here are some decisions that weren't paid to WC during the game: - Howe dragging the ball in right in front of WC goal. Any other game this is paid 9/10 times. - Ryan being yanked backwards by the jumper in a marking contest on the wing. Maybe Langdon. No free. - Shuey being tackled around the neck and face on the wing by Cox right in front of an umpire. Shuey in no way ducked. No free - a howler. - Darling having his arm pulled out of it's socket in the forward trying to mark the ball with his left arm. - Sidebottom galloping over the WC goal line to rush a behind. If that wasn't why deliberate rule was brought in I'll go he. - Last quarter Cripps has a mark at CHB, Collingwood player runs right through the protected area, so close Cripps could have touched him. Nothing. - Just before half time Kennedy lays a brilliant tackle on the boundary at half fwd, Collingwood player has clear prior, nothing. That is seven calls against WC that were probably incorrect.

2018-09-30T12:18:48+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


2005 needed a Ashley Sampi free to be paid

2018-09-30T04:41:51+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


The Lions did it with virtually half the side carrying an injury in 2003. Voss had bone rubbing on bone in his knee. Collingwood went in with the extra rest having beaten Brisbane in the QF. Brisbane had to travel interstate for the prelim. Travel back to back weeks, significant injury toll, had lost to Collingwood on the MCG three weeks early, and blew Collingwood off the park GF day. Brisbane were the best.

2018-09-30T00:55:26+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


Shoudy.

2018-09-30T00:55:05+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


Shoddy, all very good examples. You may not see 2012 the way I do, but that was one for the ages. 2006 just needed to run 1 more minute.

2018-09-30T00:53:28+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


The first sentence is silly, you would be virtually alone in that view.

2018-09-29T20:54:57+00:00

IAP

Guest


That's just the standard of footy nowadays Anon.

2018-09-29T20:53:05+00:00

IAP

Guest


That about sums up my thoughts as well.

2018-09-29T13:53:19+00:00

The Hilderbeast Hitlary Clinton

Guest


Typical whinging Trumppuff in action, Collingood has had the best run from the umpires all season. The best team won even without NicNat, Shep and Gaff.

2018-09-29T11:50:03+00:00

The real SC

Roar Rookie


It was a thrilling match that I have seen in my whole life, as West Coast Eagles powered home to a 4th flag. West Coast became the first non-Victorian team to win more flags. The Grand Final thrillers that I have seen were the 2005 and 2006 AFL Grand Finals. 2005 was the most entertaining Grand Final that I have seen when during the final quarter, West Coast were in the hunt for the flag. Down by 4 points, Dean Cox kicked the ball to the forward line but Leo Barry snatched the mark during the final seconds of the match. The swans got home by 4 points in a nail biter. The ratings went above the roof with 3.391 million metropolitan viewers watching the match live on TEN with more than 5 million Aussies nationally. 511k people watched it in Perth. The 2006 AFL Grand Final was another thriller with West Coast and Sydney meeting again back to back. WOW! This was the best rivalry in the 2000s decade. The Eagles started off well but during the final quarter they felt a bit tired as Sydney Swans raced down during the final 6 minutes of the match. During the 29th minute, the game was a one-point margin. The West Coat Eagles got home by a point in a nail biter. How good was that? The ratings was slightly lower than the 2005 grand final but still had over 3.1 million metropolitan viewers watching on TV. More than 500k people watched it in Perth. When you see that there are nail biting matches, this shows that there is going to be a lot of interest during that match.

2018-09-29T11:49:40+00:00

Howie

Roar Pro


Ditto but 99.9% they are better than me

2018-09-29T11:07:52+00:00

Bruce

Guest


2003

2018-09-29T10:40:51+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


The Eagles could have been 5 goals better - but Kennedy missed a couple, Ryan wimped out, Venables got in Kennedy's way, Cole dropped an simple enough mark back with the flight etc etc. I'm not sure any of that had much to do with the venue/state.

2018-09-29T10:27:23+00:00

anon

Roar Pro


2005 and '06 were a blight. 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 were better matches, but this was one of the better ones today. For most of the day it felt like a match played in the middle of July between two mid-table teams. There weren't many passages of brilliance -- apart from the passage that resulted in the Sheed goal of course. That will be replayed for decades. West Coast probably should have wrapped it up early in the 4th quarter. They completely dominated the second half. West Coast's extra rest throughout the finals seemed like a big difference. Collingwood were barely able to run the match out.

2018-09-29T10:26:15+00:00

Doctor Rotcod

Roar Rookie


Oh yes.Eagles vs Geelong 1994. That was a thrashing.

2018-09-29T10:02:03+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


As always, you have the teams back to front. The Pies wore black and white.

2018-09-29T09:59:14+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


2012 easily as good

2018-09-29T09:53:14+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


Seriously - you can't blame the umpies one way or the other - - they just seriously let the game 'go' a little too much. That said - I would've paid the block on Rioli for Sheeds mark. But - I would've paid a heap of frees against Crisp for holds on Darling and frees against Grundy on almost anyone in the boundary throw ins (early on anyway).

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar