The Perth Test pitch is a minefield

By Ronan O'Connell / Expert

Australia are in a strong position in the second Test after getting an even spread of batting contributions on a precarious Perth Stadium pitch offering sharp seam movement and major variations in bounce.

On a day when the new pitch played a lot of tricks, with some balls shooting through at shin height and others exploding up at the batsmen’s heads, Australia did well to edge to 6 for 277 at stumps.

The perilous state of the deck was highlighted when well-set Marcus Harris was dismissed by an innocuous delivery from a part-time spinner made unplayable by the surface.

Batsman Hanuma Vihari, who had taken just 22 wickets in eight years of first-class cricket, rolled out a gentle off break with his second ball.

Landing slightly short of a length it was the kind of delivery a batsman would reasonably expect to come through at about bail height.

Instead it leapt off the pitch in extraordinary fashion, leaving Harris fending at just below shoulder height as the ball lobbed off his glove to slip.

Harris had earlier seen the other side of this Jekyll and Hyde pitch when a short-of-a-length delivery from Indian quick Mohammed Shami shot through at just above ankle height. On many other occasions the Indian pacemen got deliveries to bounce far higher than the batsman could anticipate.

It’s not just variable bounce – there is also extravagant seam movement on offer in Perth. With the second new ball Umesh Yadav and Jasprit Bumrah got several deliveries to turn like Shane Warne leg breaks.

One Bumrah delivery to Pat Cummins seamed away by an incredible 25cm – more than double the width of a cricket bat. Another seamed by 22cm past the edge of Tim Paine and then flew over the wicketkeeper’s head for four, despite being well pitched up.

Then, as if to underline its unpredictability, the Perth pitch sent the last ball of the day skidding at ankle height into the front pad of Cummins, who narrowly avoided being LBW.

Australia may well have been dismissed before tea had India not bowled so poorly in the first session. Perhaps overexcited upon viewing the green pitch, the visiting seamers bowled far too short before lunch.

As a result, Australian openers Marcus Harris (70) and Aaron Finch (50) were able to leave too many deliveries. While Finch’s half-century was scratchy, Harris’ knock was sublime.

In defence he played the ball late, under his eyes and with soft hands. In attack he was decisive and discerning.

Playing just his second Test, Harris was impressive in the way he waited for the Indians to stray into his hitting zones before unfurling his most adventurous strokes.

It took a ridiculous delivery from Vihari to dismiss him. One of the most subtle yet significant features of Harris’ knock was his strike rotation. Regularly he dead batted the ball into gaps and then scampered through for a single.

Marcus Harris of Australia raises his bat on reaching a half century (AAP Image/Richard Wainwright)

The same could not be said of first drop Usman Khawaja. The left hander has always been over-reliant on scoring boundaries and India have brutally exposed that weakness.

Khawaja, quite incredibly, has scored 41 runs from 205 balls in this series. Because Khawaja does not naturally look for singles, when he is being denied boundaries by good bowling it is easy for dot balls to pile up and pressure to mount.

That was just what happened yesterday as he crawled to 5 from 38 balls before trying to release the tension with a cut shot, succeeding only in edging behind.

When Peter Handscomb followed suit, edging a cut, Australia had lost 4-36 to slump to 4-148. India were cock-a-hoop and the pitch was their best mate.

Then Travis Head (58) and Shaun Marsh (45), two of the most heavily-criticised batsmen in the country, halted India’s momentum with a pivotal 84-run stand.

By the time Marsh was out trying to cut Vihari Australia had moved to 232, which already looked like a competitive score on this tricky pitch.

Head also fell to a needlessly-aggressive shot, caught at third man attempting to blast the second new ball through the off side. That should not distract from the fact that, just seven innings into his Test career, Head has now played three hugely valuable knocks in challenging circumstances.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

First he made 72 from 175 balls on debut to help Australia save the first Test against Pakistan in the UAE. Then he again made 72 – more than double Australia’s next-highest scorer – in the first Test against India after coming to the crease at 4-87.

While those two knocks were patient, grafting efforts, Head yesterday played with greater flair. It was a reasonable approach on a pitch where no batsmen could ever be truly comfortable.

If Australia can add another 50 runs to their total this morning, and edge up to 330, India will have a mountain to scale.

The Crowd Says:

2018-12-18T12:29:01+00:00

Insult_2_Injury

Roar Rookie


Do you mean - not a chance, Bumrah's action is as clean as it gets, or a sarcastic; not a chance Bumrah's action is as clean as it gets? Either way bowlers are allowed more flex now purely because of slow mo replays second guessing what a chucker is.

2018-12-17T21:34:50+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


A minefield? Come on Ronan...... It's been a very good Test Wicket. Scores of 320, 280, 240....It's the way Test Cricket should work. Very entertaining game of Cricket on a good Cricket Wicket.

2018-12-16T23:03:38+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


The pitch has been great as far as the balance between bat and ball

2018-12-16T06:27:28+00:00

John Erichsen

Roar Guru


The ball is certainly moving around and there is plenty of bounce as the Australian openers try and combat the new ball in their second innings. However, the pitch looks more consistent than it did it during the second half of the first day. An interesting and entertaining test pitch but the inconsistent bounce on the first day was concerning. Thankfully, it has settled some.

2018-12-16T02:37:16+00:00

Insult_2_Injury

Roar Rookie


Isn’t it brilliant, Ronan? A wicket which isn’t a benign road developed for a runfest. I always remember Steve Waugh’s mantra when Captain of Australia. Test cricket is an examination of players ability and temperament. India has attempted to take local conditions out of this series by refusing to play a night Test and therefore using a pink ball. That is galling enough as Australia attempts to keep Test cricket relevant and develop new avenues, however this whole pitch doctoring garbage is even more stupid as evidenced by Australia’s decision to bat and produce over 300 against a ball moving around and bouncing more like a WA pitch traditionally has. Test cricket isn’t about FIFO short form runfests on carbon copy pitches designed for ADHD viewers. Test cricket is about practising in local conditions and developing a technique to cope – and hopefully thrive – in new soil and atmospheric environments. Seeing both country’s bowlers exhibit skills rarely seen anymore has been a breath of fresh air for cricket and fans. Obviously the scorecards show those skills haven’t been insurmountable to the batsmen and they too can now be proud of developing techniques not required on flat tracks. It seems to me far too many in the media have forgotten that pitch curating is an art when providing a surface, with local attributes, to last 5 days. Next we’ll have drop in pitches being prepared in an indoor facility in SA and flown to the next venue to provide a runfest. This is a new venue and I commend the decision makers for producing a pitch that more accurately reflects the local characteristics.

2018-12-16T00:30:59+00:00

Cricket Buffet

Roar Guru


They did a lot of grinding. But Rahane showed that playing a few shots is not a bad way to approach things. Kohli was a rock for his 82 not.

2018-12-16T00:30:14+00:00

Cricket Buffet

Roar Guru


It's not perfectly flat but it played alright day 2. May be hard batting day 4 and 5 but calling it a minefield is maybe a little over the top. However did play better day 2 than day 1.

2018-12-15T22:57:16+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


They got more spectators there on Saturday than could ever fill the WACA. Just not 60,000 there.

2018-12-15T22:55:08+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Optical illusion. Wobble a biro and you get the same mis-perception. As many of the commentators have said, Bumrah has the straightest arm in Test history. That's the nature of a windmill action...a straight arm. It's where the pace comes from.

2018-12-15T21:28:19+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


"If you again observe you can see that Bumrah’s action is much better than Brett Lee’s." That's one of the most ridiculous cricketing statements I've ever read. And I say that as an enthusiastic non-fan of B. Lee, the most over-rated Oz fast bowler of my time.

2018-12-15T21:17:23+00:00

qwetzen

Roar Rookie


He has a Courtney Walsh hyper-extending elbow. Saul Goodman.

2018-12-15T04:12:59+00:00

Leftwhinge

Guest


Glenn McGrath's action was the biggest elephant in the room ever...look up spiral of silence! The cocking of the wrists and the elbow extension at the delivery stride was the most suspect ever. Nobody uttered a word because he was part of a dominant era for Australia.

2018-12-15T04:03:39+00:00

IAP

Guest


Brett Lee was proven to have a slight straightening of the arm via slo mo analysis. Not as bad Aktar though; he was a genuine chucker. I had another look at Bumrah today, and I retract my statement. His action looks fine.

2018-12-15T03:49:13+00:00

Damo

Guest


The kept the top tier open for the Members area

2018-12-15T02:48:48+00:00

Kangas

Roar Rookie


I grew up in the eighties and saw some awful pitches on day 1 of a test It’s not a terrible pitch , but challenging. The variable bounce wasn’t good, but not that much Whet I see is the Aussie’s having a turn to change this series today . If Australia win this day , they will win the series.

2018-12-15T02:28:17+00:00

Jason

Roar Rookie


I asked the question about Lee years ago. Both have a hint of a throw, gets too technical, fair bump play on.

2018-12-15T02:02:43+00:00

Haydos

Guest


Let's judge it on a 29C Saturday not a 39C work day.

2018-12-15T01:12:04+00:00

Jordan Klingsporn

Roar Guru


What i found weird was that in the news, they said they would block the top tier off. But i definetely saw people up there.

AUTHOR

2018-12-15T01:08:19+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


There were 22,000 people there on a work day, not a bad turnout.

AUTHOR

2018-12-15T01:06:43+00:00

Ronan O'Connell

Expert


Not a chance Bumrah's action is as clean as it gets.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar