What AFLW Round 3 taught us

By Dem Panopoulos / Expert

Three rounds down and it’s obvious that the conferences are heavily skewed. That’s not all that became obvious in Round 3, as we look to unpack the teachings we were offered this week.

North Melbourne’s raid destroying the opposition
North Melbourne’s entry into AFLW saw it take the approach of raiding opposition clubs, signing many established players rather than going with young talent at the draft. Clearly, this has worked well for the Kangaroos, given they are undefeated with an astonishing percentage of 250.8.

The way in which the club has been able to move the ball fluently through the middle and hit the scoreboard efficiently has been impressive, largely attributable to the fact a large portion of their players have experience in AFLW.

The Kangaroos’ raid of Collingwood has had huge consequences for both teams and the competition as a whole. Given the Magpies’ issues in attack, compounded by the absence of Chloe Molloy, North Melbourne’s signing of its players has been made to look even uglier.

SEN sports writer Nic Negrepontis produced a stunning statistic on Twitter – Emma King, Jasmine Garner, Jessica Duffin and Moana Hope have combined for 10.8(68), while Collingwood as a team has scored 6.14(50) across the first three matches.

The Magpies haven’t had an appropriate opportunity to replace these four quality players which is a separate issue created by the expansion clubs joining, and it has left them uncompetitive in the third season of AFLW.

North Melbourne’s riches has fans in awe of an immediate powerhouse club, but it has come at a severe cost to both Collingwood and the competition.

Jessica Duffin of the Kangaroos (right) celebrates with Emma Kearney of the Kangaroosduring the 2019 NAB AFLW Round 01 match between the North Melbourne Tasmanian Kangaroos and the Carlton Blues at North Hobart Oval on February 03, 2019 in Hobart, Australia. (Photo by Adam Trafford/AFL Media/Getty Images)

Harford the entertainer
When Daniel Harford was announced as the new coach of Carlton in AFLW, he highlighted that his plan was to get the Blues “back on track” and to “steer things in the right direction.”

The first-round loss to North Melbourne in Tasmania doesn’t look as bad now given the strength of the opposition, and the Blues have been quite impressive in the following fortnight.

Carlton’s age bracket is good for a team looking to gain more experience and build towards sustainable future success, with the strong, core performers all having at least a decade of footy ahead of them.

Perhaps the best sign of Harford’s commitment to heading in the right direction is giving the starring role to first-round pick Madison Prespakis, who typifies the style of footy that will win Carlton a premiership sooner rather than later.

Coming off a 21-disposal, three-goal performance against GWS, Prespakis is a top-ten player in the competition already and will be the best player going around for a long time to come.

Bri Davey has found her groove in recent times, while the Blues have given 19-year-old Georgia Gee some more responsibility off the forward flank and on through central areas over the past fortnight.

Sprinkle a strong attacking mindset on top of that (averaging 54.5 points over the past fortnight) and these are exciting times if you’re a Carlton supporter. Coach Harford has long be known as an entertainer in the media, and it appears to be a source of pride on the footy field.

Anne Hatchard is the league’s most improved player
Understandably, Anne Hatchard may not be a household name at this stage of her career, particularly given she averaged the fewest minutes per game of any Crow last season (39) and received very little opportunity.

Three weeks into 2019, Hatchard is averaging 23 disposals, five tackles and four marks per game, becoming an integral part of Adelaide’s team having clearly worked on her fitness base.

The 20-year-old was a dominant force in the SANFLW, but always seemed to be on the outer for the Crows over her first two seasons, given her inability to have a true impact. 2019 has been her breakout season, however, and her career-high 27 disposals against Geelong in Round 3 is good reward for her hard work.

As a taller, bigger body, she is able to assert herself as a force to be reckoned with in the midfield, giving the Crows yet another unique asset. Hatchard was able to win five hitouts against the Cats as well, showing just how valuable she can be. While she isn’t a household name yet, it’s only a matter of time until she will be.

Brisbane’s defensive struggles
The Lions appeared to be certainties to top Conference B, given their grand final appearances in the first two seasons of AFLW and the strength of their list.

Having lost heavily to Fremantle (away) and Melbourne (home) over the past fortnight, it’s clear that the club is having difficulties in stopping the opposition from tearing them apart. Despite winning the tackle count against the Demons, there was a lack of general pressure overall around the ground by the Lions.

Jessica Wuetschner of the Lions celebrates a goal during the round one AFLW match between the Brisbane Lions and the Greater Western Sydney Giants at Moreton Bay Central Sports Complex on February 03, 2019 in Brisbane, Australia. (Photo by Chris Hyde/AFL Media/Getty Images)

Melbourne was able to go at 67 per cent efficiency for the match, and their inside 50 efficiency was 54 per cent, scoring 19 times from 35 entries. The Demons were able to manipulate Brisbane’s structure with good ball use, and Aliesha Newman was then able to run past the tiring Lion defence.

Things will only get worse for Brisbane from here as well. Leah Kaslar went down with a calf injury earlier in the game, and Sam Virgo ended the game covered in ice, having to be carried off with just five minutes remaining in the match. Both are key figures in Brisbane’s defence, both in their ability and sheer experience and leadership.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Neither player looked in a particularly good way, seemingly bound to miss matches. It leaves the Lions with a huge gap in their backline and could mean Kate Lutkins returns to a more defensive role, which would be a massive shame given she established herself as the best intercepting defender in the competition over the last 12 months.

The Crowd Says:

2019-02-19T09:02:52+00:00

Downsey

Roar Pro


I like the rapid pace of change. Got to keep it moving forward to avoid the risk of fading into obscurity. If the competition itself doesn't keep the punters engaged, an opportunity to express their vast learned opinions on all the changes will. A tweak to trading to minimise pillaging, and either a tweak to the conference system or simply a longer season, are needed for next year, but I'm looking forward to WC hitting the competition and stirring things up for this Freo fan.

2019-02-18T21:31:43+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Forget to say Macca, great effort by Carlton to get on the board.

2019-02-18T20:27:09+00:00

IAP

Guest


If they really want to be like the blokes that's the obvious next step.

2019-02-18T13:43:19+00:00

Raimond

Roar Guru


AFLW is a little too collegial. Needs more biffo.

2019-02-18T05:26:28+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


Yeah probably. But I reckon the whole blue print for the league was set out to create the competition first and then allow the talent pool to grow into all the nooks and crannies. This hothousing ideally creates greater focus and attention on pathways for girls and women to play Aussie Rules to (future) professional status. So this rapid expansion fits with that idea, growing the spots and wearing the growing pains, with the idea that the potential for rapid growth in available talent won't take too long to catch up. There's no other market with the rapid growth potential for future players than the women's game.

2019-02-18T05:06:51+00:00

Raj

Guest


I actually think the AFL has the right ideas but just didn't get the mix right for which teams are grouped together in the conferences. Shorter seasons are more interesting for fans and the players have really responded well. The standard is much higher than previous years. The BBL has really suffered from expanding the length of their season. They should've done the same as the AFL and expanded the teams and not the number of weeks of play

2019-02-18T04:45:30+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


For me I would think playing a proper 10 team 9 round season with a real final 4 for a couple of seasons and allow the standard to rise to closer to a truly elite sport would be much better for the growth than seeing the talent pool spread to thin and more 2 goal games.

2019-02-18T03:40:59+00:00

Dalgety Carrington

Roar Guru


I think they're rushing things for sure. The conference system is a sign of them trying to have their pie and eat it too, regards more teams with the same bite-sized season (they should really come under pressure to drop the conference system's role in determining finals spots). - With the expansion, the AFL should be careful with the number of concessions the new teams get, given a new team isn't coming in from scratch and get a better lay of the talent landscape than the founding teams had. - I think the AFL is willing to put up with the side effects in the short term, with the idea that with time the talent pathways will grow exponentially from greater representation and opportunities an expanded AFLW presents.

2019-02-18T03:29:50+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


I suspect it is more to do with the opposition. Teams know North are the best side in it and so they flood numbers back to try and get the game scrappy and keep the scoring low. However that style takes a lot of energy and when the ball goes back to the centre though the are able to open things up again. On Friday night with 8 minutes to go the score was 8-2, North goaled with 7, 4, 3, & 2 minutes to go, and kicked a behind with 6 minutes to go. That is quite the blitz, espeically considering the kicked just 3 other goals for the game (one of which was just 4 minutes of game time earlier)

2019-02-18T03:22:44+00:00

IAP

Guest


Was good to see Taylahh Harris go the shirt-front. There's not enough of that in modern footy. I couldn't believe all the GWS girls just stood there and did nothing though, and I can't believe she wasn't reported straight away.

2019-02-18T03:20:03+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


The irony is that Mo Hope was lost at Collingwood - this time last year she got dropped.

2019-02-18T03:15:07+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


#Macca Remember - North had the short turn around between round 1 Sunday down in Hobart and the round 2 Friday night, in the wet up in Sydney - then back down to Launceston. A lot of travel, a 5 day break and a big wet. They'll savour the longer break now to a Sunday late game. Tired legs I suspect.

2019-02-17T23:59:13+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


The positives of this years expansion seem to have been almost entirely lost by the AFL not expanding the length of the season and bringing in a clearly faulty conference system. If they don't address that bringing in twice as many new teams next year would have me thinking the spreading of the talent pool even further will produce more negatives than positives.

AUTHOR

2019-02-17T23:50:30+00:00

Dem Panopoulos

Expert


Absolutely, she was an absolute gem on the weekend. Tweeted a fair bit about her efforts but she has that perfect mix of height and genuine athletic ability. Will be a handful for opposition defenders.

AUTHOR

2019-02-17T23:49:36+00:00

Dem Panopoulos

Expert


I tend to agree, the expansion is happening too quickly and may create a situation where the gap between the best and worst stays large for a number of years. Don’t see the need to rush, but it’s going to happen, hopefully the positives outweigh the negatives.

2019-02-17T23:40:28+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


My original reply has disappeared into the ether. The short answer is yes. 1st quarter terrible, 3rd quarter bulldogs dominated, Munn's offspinner goal from the pocket was a little gem.

2019-02-17T23:34:21+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Yep. The first quarter was scrappy awful and Bullies went well in the third. Munn's dribbler off break from the pocket was the best goal of the match.

2019-02-17T23:26:20+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


Wasn't it closer to 5 goals in half a quarter but then also having 2 goalless quarters?

2019-02-17T23:18:31+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


North's Courteney Munn 4 goal debut was pretty schmick. Interestingly North, with their dominance and relatively high scoring are yet to crack 10 goals in a game. The 5 goal second quarter was pretty handy though. Good to see more goals in general from most teams.

2019-02-17T22:43:12+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


"The Kangaroos’ raid of Collingwood has had huge consequences for both teams" With the impact of this and Geelong so far only able to beat struggler Collingwood do you think it is wise for the AFL to proceed in introducing 4 new teams in 2020? To me allowing another crop of players like Prespakis (who have a stronger junior pathway into the league) to flow into the comp while there is still just 10 teams will be the much better option.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar