The Roar's top 50 NRL 2019: 20-11

By AJ Mithen / Expert

As I said yesterday, the new NRL season can’t get here fast enough.

That said, us footy fans have to have something to do in the off-season, so today we’re continuing our countdown of the top 50 players in rugby league.

In this penultimate edition, we look at the players from 20-11. They rank among the best in the game, but for whatever reasons are just outside that top echelon.

Click on the following links to check out players 21-30, players 31-40 and our list of players 41-50.

20. Greg Inglis (South Sydney Rabbitohs)
It may be somewhat of a shock to some to see Greg Inglis at number 20. His career has been sometimes exciting, sometimes dominant but always must-watch. 2019 will be Inglis’ 15th season in the NRL and he’s cemented a place as one of the game’s greats.

After a dry period of try scoring in the last few years (bar 2017 when Inglis was injured), last season the centre found his way to the try line again, crossing ten times. His ability to hit up in defence out wide and in the middle when it’s needed has been a key feature of Souths’ recent improvement.

With Wayne Bennett at the helm, who knows how to get the best out of his superstar veterans, it’ll be interesting to see what 2019 has in store.

Greg Inglis of the Rabbitohs (Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

19. Shaun Johnson (Cronulla Sharks)
Mercurial, game-breaking and maddeningly inconsistent. Shaun Johnson has been the best player in rugby league and he’s been the most invisible player in rugby league – sometimes in the same game.

There’s no doubting his immense talent. He can sniff a line break better than most, he knows where to put himself to make the biggest impact and his decision-making when a try is on offer is second to none. With his move to Cronulla he’ll be even more dangerous behind the likes of Aaron Woods and Andrew Fifita.

Does he have anything to prove? You betcha. He’ll be leaned on to be a driving force behind a team that may have off-field troubles but still has a roster capable of winning it all. Can he carry them with him?

18. Tom Trbojevic (Manly Sea Eagles)
Ah, Tommy Turbo. Burst onto the NRL scene in 2015 flying past hapless defenders grasping at dust like Wile. E. Coyote reaches out for the Roadrunner.

Trbojevic has quickly settled down to business and his business is tries. Scoring tries, setting up tries, making line breaks that lead to tries, you name it. If there’s four points to be had, chances are Tom Trbojevic will be involved somewhere along the line.

We did have to ask though – was he more than speed and flair? Where’s the substance? Those questions were answered during the 2018 Origin series, his first real test in an intense pressure scenario. Queensland targeted Trbojevic under the high ball dozens of times and Trbojevic stayed solid, eventually forcing a change of approach before making his impact up at the other tryline.

He’s maturing as a player, he’s incredible to watch and he’s only 22. He’ll be fun to watch for a long time.

Tom ‘Trytime’ Trbojevic of the Blues scores a try (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

17. Josh Hodgson (Canberra Raiders)
Personally, I had Hodgson in the top ten because once he’s arrived in the NRL he has quickly become one of the game’s elite number 9s. He’s a little under the radar in the nation’s capital but he’s a phenomenal talent.

The fact that Hodgson has been named co-captain at the Raiders alongside Jarrod Croker shows how highly he’s regarded. If you want an example of his influence, see how Canberra floundered in attack during the first half of 2018 without Hodgson after he tore his ACL in the 2017 world cup.

When Hodgson returned he played 11 games and racked up nine try assists and seven line break assists. Damien Cook, the popular choice as the game’s best 9, had eight try assists and nine line break assists in 25 games.

Hodgson has a canny kicking game, knows when to pull the ball in and steal some ground and has solid defence. He’s my best hooker by a mile, but this is a combined list so I will support him in the top 20.

16. James Maloney (Penrith Panthers)
He just wins, that’s what James Maloney does. Any club he goes to plays finals and wins. He takes on the defensive line more than any other player (115 times in 2018) and it’s almost a weird feeling watching him do post-game interviews without his head strapped or a nick around his eyes.

Maloney cops a lot for his defence, or apparent lack thereof. He misses a phenomenal amount of tackles but that can be misleading as he still slows up the runner.

But his influence on the field cannot be denied. Whether he’s at five-eighth or halfback, Maloney controls the tempo of his team’s attack to great effect and he’s a fantastic teacher for his young padawan Nathan Cleary.

James Maloney of the Panthers. (AAP Image/Michael Chambers)

15. Boyd Cordner (Sydney Roosters)
Premiership captain. Origin winning captain. Boy Cordner’s an inspirational leader, a fixture in the game’s best teams. But for some reason Cordner still doesn’t float everyone’s boat. His efforts in the 2018 State of Origin shut quite a few critics up but there’s still a few battlers out there who can’t understand what Cordner brings to the table.

Cordner’s a consistent performer who plays a role in his team that he’s perfectly suited for. He’s a strong runner and solid in defense who covers a number of positions across the defensive line.

His leadership and organisation are also obviously respected throughout the league.

His work is not flashy, it’s not fancy. But it’s damn effective and it’s what every club needs.

14. Roger Tuivasa-Sheck (New Zealand Warriors)
The reigning Dally M Medallist is one of the most exciting talents in the game, able to destroy defences from anywhere on the field. He busts tackles, he makes metres, he runs kicks straight back down his opponent’s throat and he’s a constant attacking threat.

After his bad knee injury in 2016 ‘RTS’ came back better than ever and he’s grown into the captain’s role under coach Stephen Kearney.

Tuivasa-Sheck is the Warriors’ first Dally M medallist and he’s still only 25. We’ll be marvelling at him for a while yet.

13. Nathan Cleary (Penrith Panthers)
In Cleary’s three years as in the NRL the Penrith halfback has not missed finals and he’s also the reigning State of Origin winning halfback. Not bad for a 20-year old. He’s an exciting talent whose decision making is highly regarded across the game.

New South Wales coach Brad Fittler has described Cleary as his long term Origin halfback and he’ll be the better for his 2018 experience in the game’s hottest cauldron.

Nathan Cleary of the Panthers (Photo by Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

For the first time in his career Cleary will be under the spotlight – from Panthers fans who want him to take their club to the next level, and from the rest of us who want to see how he’ll go being coached by his dad…

12. Jake Trbojevic (Manly Sea Eagles)
Trbojevic the elder is somewhat of a quiet achiever. He churns through metres and nails his tackles. His 967 tackles last year was fourth in the competition and a career best. Trbojevic has been improving every season since his debut.

He’s a leader at his club, has played for his country and delivered great performances for New South Wales in the State of Origin arena. The personification of the phrase ‘built for Origin’.

All things going well, Jake T will play his 100th game for Manly in Round 6. He’s only 25, a local boy on the threshold of a fantastic career. I’m very interested to see how he thrives under prodigal Sea Eagle Des Hasler.

11. Andrew Fifita (Cronulla Sharks)
He’s rough, he’s tough and he’s definitely an acquired taste. If he was on your team you’d love him but he’s not, so you probably hate him. Andrew Fifita is a genuine superstar when he’s on his game, arguably even the game’s best forward.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Fifita’s best outings stand out so much he cops a bit of flack around consistency and his apparent love of giving away penalties. But it’s worth remembering Fifita led the NRL in offloads (82), he busted 117 tackles (4.5 per game, third in the NRL and most by a forward) and he made 1.1 kilometres after contact last season from a league-leading 435 runs.

He’s a durable attacking weapon opposition teams struggle to contain who has won grand finals and Origin games almost singlehandedly. If he’s switched on, there’s not a lot your mob will be able to do about it.

The Roar’s top 50 NRL players (so far)
50. Elliott Whitehead
49. Dane Gagai
48. David Fusitu’a
47. Adam Reynolds
46. Blake Ferguson
45. Tyson Frizell
44. Tariq Sims
43. Cody Walker
42. James Roberts
41. Josh McGuire
40. Ryan James
39. James Graham
38. Andrew McCullough
37. Reagan Campbell-Gillard
36. Josh Jackson
35. Luke Brooks
34. Matt Moylan
33. Wade Graham
32. Josh Addo-Carr
31. Viliame Kikau
30. Ben Hunt
29. David Klemmer
28. Luke Keary
27. Anthony Milford
26. Mitchell Pearce
25. Martin Taupau
24. Michael Morgan
23. Jesse Bromwich
22. Daly Cherry-Evans
21. Angus Crichton
20. Greg Inglis
19. Shaun Johnson
18. Tom Trbojevic
17. Josh Hodgson
16. James Maloney
15. Boyd Cordner
14. Roger Tuivasa-Sheck
13. Nathan Cleary
12. Jake Trbojevic
11. Andrew Fifita

Check back tomorrow as we reveal 10-1 and crown the best player in the NRL today.

The Crowd Says:

2019-03-05T00:41:42+00:00

The Sponge

Roar Rookie


Ill take all of those 10 players (20-11) anydayoftheweek. And as for comments on Boyd being overrated, I was unable to watch World Cup 2017 final against poms but was not surprised it was a tough low scoring match 6-0 in which Boyd Cordner was the only one who crossed the line.

2019-02-22T00:39:00+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


This little discussion is already making me keen for State of Origin :-)

2019-02-21T23:04:56+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Got me there !!!

2019-02-21T21:35:06+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


And your comp would be the QLD Cup. Where did the Australian rep players come from before the Broncos came into the competition? NSW or QLD? Enough said. Don't take everything I post too seriously. If more QLDers had a sense of humour like Kevvie "That's in QLD" Walters this site might sound like the Caxton after a maroons win. IF that's a good thing. LOL Granted QLD has had a golden era with some of the best players to have ever played the game playing for QLD... even if some of those should have been playing for NSW. LOL

2019-02-21T20:36:22+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Hodkinson and Reynolds...!

2019-02-21T20:33:53+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


That’s a really interesting way of looking at it. It probably sways the debate the way of players who are capable of brilliant moments than the consistent week to week players.

2019-02-21T15:03:38+00:00

Rob

Guest


I expect to see Cronk and Keary in the top 10 now.

2019-02-21T15:00:46+00:00

Rob

Guest


As we are approaching the pointy end of the experts top 50 it's becoming apparent the selection panel have not watched a lot of football IMO. If James Graham is currently ranked higher than Jai Arrow, Papalii or TPJ in the market place I'm not a good judge. Also I suspect Ash Taylor is not even considered because he plays for the Titans. Ash Taylor finished 3rd on try assists whilst Cleary was 19th. Ash Taylor was 3rd in kicking metres whilst Cleary was 19th. These lists are very subjective and obviously in this case the team a player is playing for and media hype south of the Tweed have a big impact on who's rated a good footballer.

2019-02-21T13:32:30+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Without the QLD players over the past decade or more you would have had to call your comp the Intrust Super Cup.

2019-02-21T12:43:30+00:00

Busty McCracken

Roar Rookie


Haha thank god for that. Thought your blue and white goggles had turned you delusional for a moment there Haha

2019-02-21T09:01:07+00:00

Sydneysideliner

Roar Rookie


The reigning best player in the league is the 14th best player in the league?

2019-02-21T08:35:30+00:00

max power

Guest


except that he isnt the first backrower picked

2019-02-21T08:18:14+00:00

Sean Ticehurst

Guest


Nathan Clearly? Really? Honestly his defence is solid enough bit his running game wasnt great and his kicking game was serviceable. Nathan Cleary should be around 40. He hasn't actually achieved much from my point of view. In a couple of years maybe..

2019-02-21T05:57:52+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Stats . Shamatz . He missed a third of the season with injury and Origin duty. He was #1 halfback with State of Origin wins last year ! Not too many halves in recent decades have done that outside of Cronk or JT ?

2019-02-21T05:33:14+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


You can add me to that count BA, and not just because he's from Roosters. I thought he was a bit lucky to make it into SOO again, wasn't in good form. I still shake my head over the penalty try in game II last year. 188cm, 108kg solid second rower, at speed, runs into stationary, 178 cm, 88kg halfback.... and gets absolutely poleaxed... He should be getting an academy award to go with the MOM.

2019-02-21T05:15:04+00:00

kk

Roar Pro


Hard to disagree with your elite group, AJ. Sadly, I fear the playing days of Inglis are numbered and Fifita is hobbling around on one knee. I doubt if we will see much of either this season. There is a possibility that Shaun Johnson may not yet play for Cronulla due to the salary cap enquiry. Where he ends up will be a mystery. I rate Jimmy Maloney alongside Clive, Changa and Lurch as my favourite players of alltime. He will always be top 17 in my book forever. I am tipping his combo with Cleary will be the standout success story of the season. Word for group of 10 Rugby League players? Leaguetet!

2019-02-21T04:24:19+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


:-) Hand on heart I think he’d be lucky to make the top 200 at the moment. Hopefully he can turn it around but it seems less and less likely...

2019-02-21T04:00:58+00:00

john

Guest


I know this list is made by combining 5 different lists together, but how Keary get's ranked at 28 and Cleary at 13 just boggles the mind. Was Russell Crowe secretly part of the panel of judges?

2019-02-21T03:57:41+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Gore and Mithen at 50% of the panel couldn’t possibly allow Whitehead to be considered a better player then Paps or Tapine at club level....surely..

2019-02-21T03:52:36+00:00

John

Guest


He could be the reincarnation of Vanilla Ice.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar