Why Melbourne should get their titles back, and other criminal enterprises that should be reinstated

By Dane Eldridge / Expert

The Storm have always exhibited remorse when it comes to their eye-watering cap rorts of 2010. In fact, they routinely mention it every year at their anniversary celebrations for the ’07 and ’09 titles.

But this contrition did not shackle Cameron Smith from recently floating a proposal to have the club’s squashed trophies reinstated, an idea that was widely condemned until it upset Paul Gallen.

Smith claimed that if other clubs could self-report inadvertent breaches and retain their trophies, then Melbourne should also be afforded the same leniency for nothing more than simply pushing print twice on a photocopier.

And why not?

When you think about it, Melbourne’s industrial-scale fleecing was actually just a small rounding error that fortuitously secured the organisation the most talented crop of our generation, and only for a decade or so.

People make out their pre-meditated deception for advantage amounted to cheating, but really, it was more like an out-of-luck talent agent dialling the wrong number in 2005 and reaching the Kardashians, then securing them with watercraft.

So I’m with Smith. Let’s reinstate the Storm’s soiled titles. And while we’re there, bring back these rorts too.

Darcy Lawler and the dodgy 1963 grand final
Whether or not Lawler fixed the Wests versus St George decider will never be truly known, not at least until Graham Annesley’s next Monday mea culpa. But if he did, why the stigma?

Whichever way you look at it, Lawler could’ve been biased because he was morally pliable and pathetically enslaved to money, or because Ricky Stuart was owed a square-up from last week after blowing up about “47 texagrams.” Either way, partiality in officialdom should be embraced.

That’s because The Bunker costs the NRL $2 million and still can’t guarantee full accuracy. Someone like Lawler can provide 100 per cent certainty, and at no more than one down payment of 10 pound thrippence.

The Bulldogs and the Oasis Development
The Bulldogs massacred the salary cap in 2002, and were duly slapped with a 37-point deduction and a premiership the following year.

Their plan was cunning, with a deeply intricate web of financial chicanery employed which saw funds allegedly siphoned from the ill-fated Oasis Development directly in to Braith Anasta’s wallet.

This was eventually revealed as one of the game’s greatest scandals, when it was later realised this money should’ve gone to Johnathan Thurston.

Either way, this project was again unearthed by pesky journalists, so it should never have been dismantled. In fact, no bust like this should count unless achieved red-handed by the game’s officials. Financial malfeasance should be like a forward pass.

Cronulla’s doping program
Forget what the doctors and the lawyers say; why not legalise dangerous systematic doping regimes like Cronulla’s from 2013?

Paul Gallen. (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Not only can you finally put that dormant garden shed to good use, there will never be another undetected public urination when footballers are peeing neon.

Granny-gate
The decision from Queenslander Nathan Fien to trick his way in to a Kiwi jersey by lying about his grandma was one that dumped untold shame on the international game. On the other hand, anything that sends more Queenslanders away from Australia has to be a good thing.

Dave Smith and John Grant hire luxury cars to travel from boardroom to toilet
Remember when the calamity capers of head office were unnecessary expenditure on hire cars and forgetting players names, and not grand scale cover-ups and forgetting players names?

Rugby league would give anything to have John Grant and David Smith back on board. Not only did their tenure boast a record of zero Snapchat scandals, they were known for funnelling the game’s revenue to where it was most needed: premium upholsterers.

Sure, Grant and Smith would breathlessly spruik Benji Barba and the Manly Seagulls, but not because they were overwhelmed running the most volatile basket-case known to man, but because they were preoccupied picking the sedan or the coupe.

Having two administrators fund their crippling addiction to luxury vehicles with a TV deal and passing on costs through expensive meat pies may harm fans, but its not like they forgot Laurie Nicholls was in heaven now.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Souths on tour
Whether whisky-punching in Arizona or deploying a lewd selfie in New Zealand, the Rabbitohs are the market leaders in transgressing offshore. If you’re going to cop a massive fine, why not take your pants off somewhere with a beneficial exchange rate?

Parramatta
The crooked Eels management have earned a reputation as rugby league’s mafia, except only its decade of rackets have run at a crippling loss.

Despite illegally splashing on wages, laundering revenue and fleecing membership counts, the only table they club has topped is an ASIC watchlist for corporate liabilities.

Brad Arthur tries to squint the pain away. (AAP Image/Brendan Esposito)

They were initially hovering around the top four, but surged to the minor premiership after wilfully investing in Anthony Watmough.

Manly’s 1990 empire
We’ve reinstated some truly evil criminal enterprises here, but you have to draw the line somewhere.

The Crowd Says:

2019-03-22T11:01:55+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


No that's One Nation, Jay and "Cardinal Sin" has been locked up with Rolf Harris and Bill Cosby in the Michael Jackson wing of the Juvenile Justice Correctional Facility.

2019-03-22T10:47:05+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


No mate, that wasn’t crooked. What was though was giving them cars, boats and other cash incentives “off the books”, keeping two sets of books and making key players sign two different contracts. Try that BS in the real world with the ATO and you will end up in Alcatraz with “Cardinal Sin” as a cuddle buddy.

2019-03-22T09:40:21+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


It’s good to see a Sea Eagles fan finally come out of the closest and express some “Manly love” for the Eels. eels47, mighty and billy will have tears in their eyes because of your sentimental gesture. Perhaps you can get together over a beer and relive the old Sea Eagles vs Eels TV ad from the 80’s and sing “I feel like a Tooheys or two”. LOL

2019-03-22T06:41:16+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Dane you had me at "anything that sends more Queenslanders away from Australia has to be a good thing". LOL Now let's call it a day, wrap up this dying competition before it becomes an even bigger farce and declare the South Sydney Rabbitohs the winner with 21 premierships not out after being saved by the third umpire late in their innings. I mean even test cricket pulls up stumps after 5 days and calls an end to a series after 5 tests so 111 years has been a great innings! ;-)

2019-03-22T06:32:41+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


eels47 after a 33 year drought and no sign of a cloud in the sky or a silver lining on the horizon, when someone offers you a premiership you take it!

2019-03-22T06:10:13+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


Sorry I may have been a bit over the top. It's just that we have just spent an off season of negativity so I was so happy when we get some great footy and some positive things to write and read about. Dragging out the negativity and cynicism really got to me. Sorry.

2019-03-22T03:12:29+00:00

E-Meter

Roar Rookie


You've been served Dane.

2019-03-22T01:00:43+00:00

eels47

Roar Rookie


As much as I would love another premiership (33 years and counting is a long time between drinks), Parra can't be awarded the premiership. NRL isn't a "first past the post" competition. There are so many things that were affected by Melbourne cheating the cap, not just Parra on GF day. Sure, and asterix in the history books looks bad, but it isn't as simple just giving it to the loser on GF day.

2019-03-21T22:48:28+00:00

Superspud

Roar Rookie


This is a poor article. Poor timing not the slightest bit funny or original-at least the first bit that I actually read wasn't. It may have had some relevance 2 weeks ago but this well is dry.

2019-03-21T22:48:18+00:00

Big Daddy

Guest


Noel or Peter. And let's not forget Kevin Humphreys.

2019-03-21T22:09:05+00:00

kk

Roar Pro


Hi Dane, Tempting smorgasbord of events from yesteryear featuring 'forward passes' from the 'morally pliable'. Please tell us more. Wonder how long Kelly would stay on the paddock today if Lawler had the whistle. The foundation of The Storm remains one of the most exciting events in Rugby League. Had they been justly granted a reasonable 'behind enemy lines allowance' the salary cap may have been adhered to (without committing fraud) and their premierships intact.

2019-03-21T21:46:18+00:00

Sam

Guest


16 year olds? More like 18-20 yr olds, the Storm certainly helped turn them from first graders into rep stars but they played no part in their junior development.

2019-03-21T21:35:58+00:00

Gray-Hand

Roar Rookie


Maybe not, but they were definitely superstars when the outright fraud was being committed. And that fraud was committed in order to keep them at the club.

2019-03-21T21:00:45+00:00

Jay Wright

Roar Rookie


The Storm have lead our children into the ways of sin and enternal dam nation.

2019-03-21T20:47:58+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


"Melbourne’s industrial-scale fleecing was actually just a small rounding error that fortuitously secured the organisation the most talented crop of our generation, and only for a decade or so." Yeah right, cos Smith, Cronk, and Slater were already super stars when they came to the club as unknown 16 year old kids. What a crooked mob the Storm were to take those young boys and turn them into the best players of their generation.

2019-03-21T20:31:59+00:00

AE47

Roar Rookie


Won’t happen, you need to just move forward and accept that the “owners club” cheated got caught. What you should be arguing is for Parra to be awarded the Premiership. How shallow to suggest poor melb be reinstated there dirty trophy ahead of a club and fan base that has done more for this comp than melb ever will, furthermore take all your super league junk and go form your own comp! There’s enough left to create another comp that just like in 1997 will prove far greater than the plastic alternative

Read more at The Roar