2019 AFL Power Rankings: Round Nine

By Liam Salter / Roar Guru

Another weekend past, another lot of voting completed, another Carlton capitulation viewed. Here’s this week’s rankings. Not a whole lotta change in them this week.

Last week: 1

Did what most expected, and I see precisely no reason to drop them down. I get this niggling feeling that Geelong are gonna drop one soon, though. But I can’t imagine it’ll be the Suns next week.

Last week: 2

Thank the lord for that final term, hey? Collingwood’s list oozed talent when they demolished an otherwise strong Saints side in a half-hour of footy that put the result beyond doubt. Steele Sidebottom never seems to age.

Last week: 4

I’m honestly kinda mad they didn’t win by 100 points. Nevertheless, they looked stellar for a majority of the clash, and it’s wins like these that are an asset in what will inevitably become a hard-fought shuffle for ladder positions come the later rounds of the season.

Last week: 3

It’s another chapter of the middling season the Eagles are having. They deserved the win, don’t get me wrong, but play the kind of football they were displaying in the first three terms against higher level competition and they’d have lost. Big challenge next week against the Crows.

Last week: 7

The victors of what I’m confident in declaring the weekend’s best game by far. Had to dig deep in the latter stages – Adelaide were never just going to go down quietly. Brisbane look finals bound, but I’m hesitant to declare them crossing that hurdle just yet.

Last week: 5

Ouch. Agonisingly close. But it’s hard to be too disappointed after a closely fought game like that which reaffirmed both teams’ finals potential.

Last week: 8

Hot damn. Richmond looked ferociously good at times on Sunday, and proved to the competition that even with injuries, they won’t stay down for long. Couple that with Dusty returning to form, and their next few opponents – Essendon, North and Geelong – should be nervous.

Last week: 6

That was… a game of football. Fans attending a soaking wet Adelaide Oval probably wished they were elsewhere for periods of the clash, but their team got the job done. Not a game that’ll be replayed a whole lot.

Last week: 9

Started brightly, fell away badly. That description isn’t unique to the Hawks this week, but it’s apt nevertheless. Being two down on the bench didn’t help either, with their most pressing concern being Ben McEvoy’s injury.

Last week: 10

Gotta admire any team who can stick with Geelong at GMBHA Stadium, but the Dogs were outclassed late. Not a bad effort, but not a great one.

Last week: 11

It was not a good game of football, and the Dons had to withstand a mild Fremantle fightback, but it’s a win nevertheless. Essendon’s team is talented, no doubt, but a big challenge comes their way on Saturday: a durable and oft-brilliant Tigers side.

Last week: 13

Without a doubt my favourite part of their clash came in the first minute, when debutant Robbie Young went on a blistering run to send to ball to Josh Bruce, who nailed a goal. It epitomised the Saints’ flair – when they display it. The game ended poorly, but the Saints are a genuinely better team than what they constantly display.

Last week: 12

I long for the high-scoring, brilliant Fremantle side to come back. There’s something almost endemic within the club of late. Next weekend’s game against Brisbane is a huge clash. Lose, and Freo’s season takes another step towards oblivion.

Last week: 14

I was beyond impressed with their first half wherein they were entirely in the game, but the Suns were ultimately overrun by the Power. There are things to take out of it, but ultimately it’s another loss in a season where they’re accumulating way too many of them.

Last week: 15

They pulled a Labor. Had it in the bag, then fluffed it badly. Very badly. A brutally disappointing trip to the west for the Demons.

Last week: 17

Well, they won down in Tassie. But not before somehow holding off a furious Kangaroo fightback. So, they’ve got three wins for the year. Where to now?

Last week: 16

Gotta admire the final-term resurgence, but it’s difficult to suggest either Sydney or themselves would be expecting any sort of broader resurgence.

Last week: 18

It’s remarkable that after facing a 74-point deficit at half time, they ‘only’ lost by 93. They were accurate, at the very least. But ultimately this was a pathetically terrible performance.

The Crowd Says:

2019-05-21T09:44:03+00:00

Duckworth-Lewis

Guest


Aaron Rich flicks the switch every Friday on Fox FM.

2019-05-21T09:26:06+00:00

13th Man

Guest


Essendon were absolute rubbish on Saturday night.... just that the Dockers were even worse. Two very average football sides played a very average game. Don't see them getting anywhere near the 8 in all honesty.

2019-05-21T09:21:41+00:00

13th Man

Guest


No one is being tough enough on Freo! Reality is this side has fallen in an absolute hole over the last three weeks and they were absolutely dreadful on Saturday night. Don't be fooled by the close margin, the umpiring got us that close. Only two teams would of lost to Essendon the way they are playing right now; Freo and Carlton. Face facts, they are a putrid football side that is poorly poorly coached. No pressure is being applied by the media and Ross will keep his job even though I see this talented group of players going absolutely nowhere under him. We've got an 800k a year forward (Hogan) that is unfit and cannot mark or kick the football. We have a very good player (Walters) diving and staging for free kicks. We have a brownlow medallist that can't hit a target (Fyfe). Our one player that is head and shoulders above everyone else (Mundy) is almost 35! Putrid team and it's all down to the Coach! I'd rather have Brandon Bolton than Ross Lyon right now! Gutless, Putrid, Boring football and he is doing absolutely nothing to change it! I'm over it!

2019-05-21T03:38:15+00:00

Peter the Scribe

Roar Guru


Gilligan is from an island

2019-05-21T03:36:11+00:00

Maurice

Guest


Tuff love it works with my kid. Lobb needs to sit in the forward line. Darcy in Ruck and get rid of McCarthy and Cox.

2019-05-21T02:42:57+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


You’re right about birthplace to a point. Gale would be a deserving option. But being a person predisposed to the development of non Vic states even at the expense of some the old VFL community is critical.

2019-05-20T23:16:17+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


I mean 2018.

2019-05-20T23:15:38+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


That's my point. Place of birth doesn't prove anything. I think it will be Brendan Gale. Tasmanian.

2019-05-20T22:54:06+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


And he is a smart man for sure. Just no presence in the AFL community outside Vic and so far up the locals and local media that he would be a shoe in for the AFL Executive Toenails award.

2019-05-20T22:28:42+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


Cat I agree on flicking the switch. For years when Tigers were average I would see us just fall short of teams like Geelong or Saints (if we weren't getting flogged) and think of only we had a bit of luck here or there. Then come 2017 I had some nervous moments, but in the H&A just say back knowing we would win in the end. Such a different experience.

2019-05-20T22:21:48+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


Gil is not from Victoria.

2019-05-20T22:18:48+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


Agree Richmond should be a higher, but just a swap with Adelaide would satisfy me. I'm not sure why you keep saying it is a week season, Anon. Maybe it is just pretty even.

2019-05-20T11:22:12+00:00

George Apps

Roar Rookie


Or maybe book an appointment with a psychiatrist who specialises in groups.

2019-05-20T11:14:23+00:00

George Apps

Roar Rookie


You obviously mean "not cut out for it".

2019-05-20T11:12:28+00:00

Howie

Roar Pro


Even as an Eagles supporter I think the Eagles are ranked too high here. So far its been the Cats then daylight then maybe Pies then maybe Tigers?

2019-05-20T10:35:41+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Only obfuscating according to your narrow constructs, Cat. 'Flicking the switch' happens in far more circumstances than you'd have us believe simply to suit your own narrative. I don't know why you are bothering either, I'm over it.

2019-05-20T10:27:50+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Agree with all of that. Perhaps wishful thinking but maybe we can be your new nemesis. We'll know more in a few weeks I suppose but the real heat comes finals time.

2019-05-20T09:39:42+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


Yep, understood, but a long time entrenched in the swamp now. Still, I may be underestimating him, might actually steel the resolve to truely shape this, ahem, national comp.

2019-05-20T09:33:45+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


Brian Cook is the man, a true West Aussie !

2019-05-20T09:32:08+00:00

michael RVC

Roar Pro


Yes, good option, excellent even; but no one better? Nope. Criteria number one - not from Victoria.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar