NSW Blues Origin 1 team: Expert reaction, every selection analysed

By Daniel Jeffrey / Editor

Brad Fittler has revealed his Blues team for Origin 1 after a weekend of injuries to what seemed like every halves contender – plus a few more other handy players – in the state.

Here’s how each selection in the squad stacks up.

Josh Addo-Carr
The NRL’s fastest man isn’t in the same great form that he was this time last year, but there was never much doubt he’d be in the squad for the second year in a row. Addo-Carr’s pace down the touchline and elite finishing ability provides the Blues with a constant attacking threat, and there’s every chance he’ll be in the mix for leading try-scorer this series.

(Photo by Michael Dodge/Getty Images)

Nathan Cleary
The Panthers halfback is awfully lucky to be selected after his side’s wretched start to 2019, but with injuries to Mitchell Pearce, Luke Keary and Adam Reynolds made him the last half standing – even if the latter was cleared of a serious injury. Still, maybe Cleary will benefit from playing under a better coach than his dad, and his performance against the Eels on Thursday indicated his form isn’t as bad as his club’s.

As one of the strongest defensive halves in the game, Cleary’s defence won’t be a worry, but he’ll need to influence the Blues attack far more than he did last year, when he finished the series without any tries, try assists, line breaks and line break assists.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Damien Cook
Cook would have been one of the first names on the team sheet. His pace around the ruck gave Queensland headaches all through 2018, a trend we can expect to continue this year – he’s currently head, shoulders and torso ahead of everyone else in the NRL for dummy half runs. With the Maroons struggling in the hooker department, expect Cook to exploit that weakness and give the Blues a real edge in a key position.

» Full State of Origin teams

Boyd Cordner (c)
In Cordner, NSW have one of the best skippers in the business. The Roosters second rower captained his club, state and country last year with plenty of success. He’s one of the most consistent edge runners in the game, capable of chipping in with the odd try here and there, and is a reliable defender too. Was immense in the series-clinching Game 2 win last year.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Nick Cotric
It’s always been a case of not if but when Nick Cotric makes his way onto the State of Origin stage. With just two tries and five linebreaks to his name heading into this weekend, 2019 hasn’t been Cotric’s best, but he’s always looked capable of handling the jump to Origin. He’s also been defending better this year than ever before – his tackle efficiency is up ten per cent from last year – something which no doubt helped sway Fittler.

Angus Crichton
Crichton has been used less as a damaging edge runner this year with the Roosters than he was last season with the Bunnies, but his defensive impact has changed little. That won’t concern Fittler too much – Crichton averaged 30 tackles a game last Origin series despite coming off the bench, and he’ll be asked to play a similar role once again.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Tyson Frizell
One of many to be hit by the injury bug this weekend, Frizell will have to overcome a nasty head knock and concussion to be fit for Game 1. If healthy, the Dragons second rower is an automatic selection, having looked at home in his Blues jersey since the day he put it on. Boasts great speed and footwork for a forward, and his efficiency in defence is something coaches dream of.

(Photo by Robert Prezioso/Getty Images)

Payne Haas
Haas is comfortably the most exciting selection of this squad. The Broncos youngster is averaging more than 30 tackles per game at 92 per cent efficiency, is second in the NRL for post-contact metres per game, and has been going for nearly 175 running metres per game. While his inexperience is a red flag – he’ll be making his Origin debut with just ten NRL games under his belt – the 20-year-old offers everything you want from a bench forward.

(AAP Image/Brendan Esposito)

David Klemmer
A mad wrecking ball of a front rower, Klemmer is at home in Origin. Currently leading the NRL for post-contact metres, his aggression in attack and defence is going to be tough for the Maroons to contain.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

Latrell Mitchell
A drop in form which has coincided with speculation about his future was never going to stop Latrell Mitchell from suiting up for the Blues, particularly when you consider New South Wales’ horrid lack of depth at centre right now.

The Roosters star showed last year he has a penchant for stepping up onto the big stage of Origin, dominating his clashes with Maroons stalwart Will Chambers. Mitchell will be the biggest threat to the Queensland defence, so his form will dictate how Game 1 – and the entire series – plays out.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Josh Morris
Morris is a reliable defender, but this is a safe and uninspired selection from Fittler, particularly when you consider Queensland no longer have as much of an attacking threat in the centres with Greg Inglis retired. Won’t let anyone down, but it would have been nice to see Jesse Ramien given a nod instead.

Cameron Murray
Here’s someone playing well beyond his age right now. The 21-year-old Murray is having a phenomenal year for the table-topping Rabbitohs both in attack and defence. He’ll be asked to fill the void left by Jack de Belin, a tough ask for a youngster, but considering his output this year and his history as a captain in age-group footy, he’s more than capable of stepping up. Looks a player who’ll be around Origin for many seasons to come.

James Tedesco
There was never any doubt about Tedesco’s place in the side. Clearly one of the best two fullbacks in the competition, he was outstanding for the Blues last year, impacting the game on both sides of the ball. His battle with Kalyn Ponga is going to be a highlight not just in 2019 but in many series to come.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Jake Trbojevic
Trbojevic epitomises the ‘cut em in half’ approach to tackling. The best lock forward in the NRL, he’s going to have a more significant role to play for the Blues this year with Jack de Belin ineligible for selection, and it’s hard to imagine him handling the responsibility with anything but aplomb.

Paul Vaughan
One of the best-performed props in the NRL over the past few years, Vaughan is a consistent performer who, despite the Dragons’ shaky start to the year, has actually improved most of his statistical averages in 2019. After barely cracking 80 minutes of gametime in his three Origins last year, Fittler would be well served to give Vaughan more of a run this series.

Cody Walker
Here’s the main beneficiary from Luke Keary’s injury. Walker’s been in fine form for the Rabbitohs, his running game and ability to find the try-line both significant reasons why Souths find themselves atop the table. Will challenge the Maroons defensive line on his own, but Walker is also more than capable of providing for his teammates, as his excellent linebreak and try assist numbers show.

Jack Wighton
If there was a most improved player award in the NRL, Jack Wighton would be one of the favourites for it right now. In fine form for the Raiders, he can cover just about every backline position off the bench bar halfback, and is an excellent choice to fill the bench utility role with incumbent Tyrone Peachey out of form.

The Crowd Says:

2019-05-29T13:50:35+00:00

Joe

Guest


And yet Rugby League in which he earns his hundreds of thousands cam from across the sea? Brain fade moment ....

2019-05-29T10:00:19+00:00

DENNIS HATTON

Guest


The media has stated that Cody Walker has declared that he will not sing the national anthem. If this is the case, then he should not represent a State of this Nation. He is simply looking to stir trouble. He should stand down or be benched for 80 minutes. Then not selected for Game 2. If you don't acknowledge this nation, then go away! Did Inglis, Thurston or Mitchell etc. make such a statement? They proudly played for their State and Nation and made no radical statements. Walker has a "chip" on his shoulder that is too huge to accept as a representative player. Bad pick after the event.

2019-05-29T04:20:31+00:00

steveng

Roar Rookie


This is a very good blues side and good luck to them but and except for one thing (as it’s panning out and its so unfortunate) that Cody Walker will remain silent during “Advance Australia Fair” national anthem! This is a very disappointing thing for me (being a Bunnies fan and die hard supporter for over 50years) when we’ve had so many great and champion indigenous players, that this issue never came up throughout their years and never throughout rugby league, I thought that rugby league was bigger than that and has ‘dodged every bullet’ in this regard (not like the AFL) and at South Sydney! Very disappointing that Cody has taken this path and has used rugby league for a political purpose!

2019-05-29T04:01:31+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


It is. You could argue it's about respect and Walker would argue the same point in return. I don't think anyone can be forced to respect an institution that you don't feel represents you. I can see both sides and it doesn't offend me because it doesn't effect me if any of the boys choose not to sing.

2019-05-29T03:06:02+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Hmmm... can be seen as very divisive and doesn't matter if one agrees with the song (I personally prefer another option) it's still the selected country anthem and ignoring it during an event can be offensive.

2019-05-29T02:07:21+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Mal has already stated that he is ok with the indigenous blokes remaining silent if they feel the song is offensive or doesn't represent them. I tend to agree. The song itself refers to Australia as Commonwealth, refers to the bountiful gifts from the land and "those who’ve come across the seas" yet no reference to the people here 50,000yrs before anyone else.

2019-05-29T01:07:25+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


"Nat wanted to have a stats trade off..." No mate, all I said is Munster is leading the Dally M pts (leading into the last rnd). You went stats crazy trying to justify Walker. Then you claim a "check-mate" on a stats battle you invented and I didn't have right of reply. Banter includes back-&-forth, not just make s.h.i.t.e. up and sign off my man. If Keary is fit, Walker may have a utility bench place. Cleary was always going to get picked and Keary is the current Aust half and had form much longer than Walker's cameo's against average teams this year.

2019-05-28T23:04:37+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


It's all good, Rellum. It wouldn't be Origin week if we didn't rattle each other's cages a bit. Nat is on board, so climb aboard the Origin banter train, "Choo Choo". LOL Cody Walker was the first of the halves to be picked and still would have been irrespective of the fitness and availability of ANY other player. That was my point, until Nat wanted to have a stats trade off between Walker and Munter... and lost! Bahahahahahahaha

2019-05-28T23:03:02+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Just a thought, Origin is supposed to be a trial for national team. If Cody Walker refuses to sing the anthem I wouldn't be picking him to play for Australia and by default, not the Blues. It's one thing to protest in an indigenous game, quite another to refuse the anthem of the team you are playing for.

2019-05-28T08:12:55+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I was just commenting on why he wasn't picked. Didn't mention anything else

2019-05-28T05:33:06+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Checkmate? Bahahahah you rattle off a couple of stats generated from playing bottom half teams and call that check-mate! Even you could rack up some quality stats against the Engadine Dragons u6 comp but there not the ones that will win you an Origin. One has done it before and the other should've been Maloney.

2019-05-27T08:01:35+00:00

Chad

Guest


No Pearce is leading check again

2019-05-27T07:08:15+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Ah, that old chestnut? ;-) Walker is currently only 4 points adrift of Munster on the Dally M Leaderboard and gaining ground fast while Munster is going backwards. Thanks Nat, but I'll go with Johns and Locky and their assessment of Walker as the best player in the game ATM. Just compare their stats on NRL.com and see for yourself. The records don't lie and they paint a pretty clear picture of who is on top at present. Tries: Walker = 11 (1st in the NRL) Munster = 5 (22nd) Try Assists: Walker = 8 (7th) Munster = 5 (21st) 4 on personal stats Linebreaks: Walker = 8 (7th in the NRL) Munster = 5 (33rd) * Sam Burgess (20th), Cam Murray (21st), Damien Cook (22nd) and Campbell Graham (23rd) ALL ahead of Munster! Line Break Assists: Walker = 8 (4th) Munster = 4 (21st) 3 on personal stats Tackle Breaks: Walker = 42 (13th) Munster = 33 (30th) Player In Support: Walker = 133 (14th) Munster = 116 (26th) Forced Dropouts: Walker = 6 Munster = 4 There is ONE stat that Cam Munster leads Cody Walker in... Missed Tackles Munster = 28 (39th) Walker = ?? (not in top 50 so less than 26) Source: https://www.nrl.com/stats/players/ Shall we call that checkmate, mate? ;-)

2019-05-27T05:55:43+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Yet Munster tops the table in Dally M pts this yr.

2019-05-27T05:03:19+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Not on Walker's 2019 form. So far this year (according to retired legends of the game, including Darren Lockyer) Cody Walker would get the Gold medal outright with Keary getting the silver while Mitchell Pearce would be lucky to get the bronze ahead of Nathan Cleary who would get the "Tin medal" in 4th place. So clearly, if anyone is a "Steven Bradbury" it's Nathan Cleary. Including QLD halves, on form, NSW still have the top 3 medal placings.

2019-05-27T04:55:55+00:00

Kathryn

Guest


Tommy was the player of the series last year. As soon as he's fit he'll be back in the side.

2019-05-27T03:44:39+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


"QLD got desperate enough...", wouldn't you consider Walker the Steven Bradbury of NSW halves?

2019-05-27T00:00:38+00:00

Harvey Wilson

Roar Rookie


Cleary did a Bradbury in this one. To be fair, he didnt do much last year. He was there on the field, but didnt have influence on the series. How can Reynolds (now fit) not be picked?

2019-05-26T23:43:33+00:00

cob

Guest


Haas played his best game last week and another good game this week so not sure Freddy would be to worried about how he's handling Ramadan.

2019-05-26T23:13:51+00:00

Papi Smurf

Roar Rookie


Your concern for our Blues players is touching Rellum but remember, even DCE got another chance after being privately blacklisted when QLD got desperate enough and now he is your "golden haired boy". Glass houses, Rellum.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar