The A-League merry-go-round is in full swing

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

In case you have not noticed, much criticism is levelled at the A-League.

To many, it is a two-bit operation, lacking quality players, fans and real meaning. Personally, I disagree strongly, however, can also appreciate from where such assumptions and attitudes stem.

Yes, the top tier of Australian football remains hamstrung by a $3.2 million salary cap and lies at the mercy of hundreds of clubs across the globe without such restriction – clubs which are eager to pounce on anyone showing potential above A-League standard.

As a result, the Awer Mabils, Andrew Nabbouts and Daniel Arzanis of this world will continue to head off shore to follow their dreams; leaving behind a host of competent footballers yet few with the x-factor that those men possess.

Daniel Arzani during his time with Melbourne City. (Photo by Jason Heidrich/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

That leads to a constant recycling of local talent, with managers hell bent on unlocking the secrets to players who have had stints with numerous A-League clubs.

To fill the void created, Australian clubs seek out ‘experienced’ international talent to add to the depth of their squads.

Whilst each and every club wants a ‘name’ recruit, they are few and far between. For every Alessandro Del Piero or Keisuke Honda there are dozens of foreigners who come and go like ships in the night; some making a significant impact and others whose departures are almost unnoticed.

The 2019-20 season already looks like a continuation of the rather monotonous cycle, with the introduction of Western United providing the most significant point of difference, in a competition desperately requiring an injection of, well, anything.

Mark Rudan’s new club have recruited well and appear to have a nicely balanced squad that should be competitive from day one.

Andrew Durante has left his beloved Phoenix to join the new franchise after 273 matches in yellow. He will be joined in defence by Socceroo Josh Risdon, as well as Aaron Calver and Brendan Hamill who have left their Sydney clubs in search of a new challenge.

Max Burgess has also made his way across the ditch after a very promising debut A-League season with Wellington and with Connor Pain, Apostolos Stamatelopoulos and Jonathan Aspropotamitis, will look to provide the energy and creativity in attack.

Throw in one of the best goal keepers in the league in the form of Filip Kurto with a sprinkling of yet to be announced foreigners and United should enjoy some success in their inaugural season.

As fresh and exciting as all that is, the recycling and departures continue elsewhere. The list of international talent leaving is considerable. Ritchie De Laet, Keisuke Honda, Siem De Jong, Roy Krishna and Alex Baumjohann all depart after stellar A-League stints.

More alarming is the list of foreign ‘flops’ who leave their respective clubs. Jordy Thomassen and Ken Ilso never hit the heights in Adelaide, nor did Jair and Ronald Vargas under Ernie Merrick’s tutelage in Newcastle.

Reza Ghoochannejhad and Jop van der Linden were essentially duds in the championship-winning Sydney FC squad and Oriol Riera’s time had well and truly come at Western Sydney.

Then there are the recyclables; those likely to pop up with another A-League club, seeking opportunity number four, five or even six.

Roly Bonevacia leaves Western Sydney, Nathan Burns will potentially be looking for a gig after departing the Phoenix and Mitch Austin could be about to sign for his fifth A-League club after severing ties with Sydney.

Dario Vidosic might be sniffing around for A-League club number six and who knows where Baba Diawara, Joe Caletti and Carl Valeri may pop up after departing their clubs at season’s end.

There has already been a host of interesting signings made on the A-League merry-go-round. Luke DeVere arrives in Wellington for a fresh start after appearing out of favour in Brisbane, while Ruon Tongyik, Daniel De Silva (off-loan), Abraham Majok and Jai Ingham all arrive on the Central Coast as Alen Stajcic looks to build a competitive squad.

How will Alen Stajcic go with the Mariners? (Photo by Catherine Ivill/Getty Images)

Scott Galloway joins Melbourne City after a cracking season with Adelaide and Merrick picks up Matthew Millar and Nick Fitzgerald in what appear to be positive signings at the Jets.

Daniel Georgievski returns home to Western Sydney and late yesterday Roy O’Donovan was confirmed as new Roar player.

The biggest off-season news has been the unveiling of Kosta Barbarouses as Sydney FC’s star recycled recruit and Bruno Fornaroli’s move to Perth Glory.

Just a trickle of new international players are confirmed at this point, yet the floodgates will soon open. Ex-Cardiff City man Craig Noone joins Melbourne City and the Wanderers add Swiss goal-keeper Daniel Lopar, his countryman Pirmin Schwegler and pole Radoslaw Majewski.

Australians Dylan McGowan (Western Sydney) and a now 35-year-old Scott McDonald (Western United) return home after extended periods overseas.

Thus, the chameleon-like A-League is reborn yet again. It is the nature of the beast and won’t be changing anytime soon.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Now we await the announcements of the new foreign and marquee players; many of which will no doubt be destined for fleeting visits to our shores.

Round and round the A-League goes, where it stops nobody knows!

The Crowd Says:

2019-06-29T03:56:13+00:00

jbinnie

Guest


Rolland. - Under the present set up the 10 HAL clubs are entitled to have 4 overseas players signed (not counting the marquees). That means there are maybe 6 or 7 places available for local youngsters to fill, giving us "places" for 60 or 70 local kids to burst through to our top football standard. The blunt truth facing this fact that there is not an HAL club that doesn't address the allowance of overseas players and that poses the question ,"Why is this so?". Unfortunately when one analyses and gives an answer it can only be that our grassroots football is not providing the "goods" ', that is, better players than those imports. Stuart asks a question about a "roundabout " in player signings and there is little doubt he is correct but it appears to be a malaise right through our football as the recent appointments of coaches to other tasks also appears to be on the same roundabout. What all this points to is the lack of a true visionary in the halls of power,someone who can look at football playing and coaching records and change the status quo so that improvement is not only aimed at, but is guaranteed. In all my time interested in our game and heaps of differing administrations I find it extremely difficult to recall such a person in our high places. jb

2019-06-27T02:25:12+00:00

rolland

Guest


the sooner the A league becomes a 16 team comp the sooner our best young players will get a fair go .the merry go round of the same old and the even older imports and with such few clubs at this level make this league a joke .young Aussie talent gets ignored again and again .no wonder our national teams are such an embarrassment that includes the W league is in the same boat again so few teams in the W league its a joke such an exclusive comp why we need more teams for our local players to play in

2019-06-26T10:11:04+00:00

con

Guest


I hope that the FFA never ever give full independence to the A league ,they are greedy selfish and have ruined football in Australia , they spend our good money on foreigners and has-beens look at the rubbish imports this year only a hand full earned the high pay packet they get ,our young Australian talent is getting ignored and not given a chance our national team is weak , its a joke they now are trying to interfere in the second division pushing to put their reserves in there and turning the legitimacy of the second division making it into a JOKE ,if you football supporters cant see that than we got big issues as they will do as they please and with the weak FFA by l giving them a 15 year guaranteed stay in the A league is pathetic ,football all over the world is about competition amongst the clubs themselves, the strong survive the weak drop new clubs form and competitiveness is high and natural and healthy

2019-06-26T10:07:05+00:00

Redondo

Roar Rookie


I forgot! Still, I give him 3 months maximum before the Roar fans demand his head.

2019-06-26T08:02:25+00:00

Fadida

Roar Rookie


But, but, he played in the PREMIER LEAGUE!!!!

2019-06-26T03:43:08+00:00

Redondo

Roar Rookie


Awful signings and a novice manager - what could go wrong.

AUTHOR

2019-06-26T02:10:33+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


I have matches on my screen here in my office as I write each day. I get through 2-3 in a morning and then will sit down and watch 2-3 mini-matches between 4-6 when I sit down and have a rest in the afternoon. I thought everybody did this!

AUTHOR

2019-06-26T02:08:44+00:00

Stuart Thomas

Expert


Ever heard of the mini-match on Optus?

2019-06-26T00:48:50+00:00

Chen Yang

Roar Pro


I see yr point nate. Id just always take a former a league player over someone who hasnt played a league anyday

2019-06-25T23:40:06+00:00

Jordan Klingsporn

Roar Guru


He played LB a few times I thought.

2019-06-25T21:58:15+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Looks like they have already caught the number of Mariners supporters.

2019-06-25T21:55:42+00:00

Mister Football

Roar Guru


Kangas Stacks of players have turned out for 4+ clubs. Far too many to mention.

2019-06-25T21:30:40+00:00

Beach

Roar Rookie


These signings are poor League 1. Not even poor Championship. And McGing? Seriously? Alarming to say the least.

2019-06-25T21:08:36+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


We are in agreement here, just looking from opposite sides of the cup. Football is no different to any other place of employment. People don’t always choose the most suitable company to work for and they move around a fair bit before they find the right fit. On the other hand there are are employees that are “moved on” by employees as they find they are not productive or perhaps disruptive or do not fit the culture of an organization. My frustration is that clubs don’t pay enough attention to their recruitment program and that all adds to the recycling.

2019-06-25T16:49:03+00:00

Fadida

Roar Rookie


Roar are in for McGing. 9th place coming up

2019-06-25T16:39:55+00:00

Fadida

Roar Rookie


Agree. RoD is a good pick up if he keeps his head, but the rest of the signings seem seem to be following the philosophy of the NZ Knights; UK lower league rubbish

2019-06-25T13:36:03+00:00

Will

Guest


Give me a talented youngster with plenty to prove over an overage foreign player who is here for a pay check. Daniel Arzani is the main highlight 2 seasons ago.

2019-06-25T13:20:40+00:00

Beach

Roar Rookie


He's actually a right-winger, Jordan

2019-06-25T13:20:01+00:00

Beach

Roar Rookie


As a Roar supporter I am seriously underwhelmed by Fowlers recruitment. Frankly it looks horrible. I'm bracing myself for a second battle for the spoon with CCM

2019-06-25T13:16:32+00:00

Beach

Roar Rookie


Waz, do yourself a favour and drop the lol. You're not 13

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar