Celebrating NRL history and what's still to come

By Jacks / Roar Guru

I generally try and maintain a pretty level head and remain objective when it comes to talking about the game as well as my team, the Eastern Suburb Roosters.

This article will walk both sides of that line, but I think every supporter earns that right after a grand final win to have a crack.

The game was fantastic, dour, tough, brutal and tight. Way too stressful for me.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Canberra Raiders and Ricky Stuart should be proud of their year. I have always had a softish spot for Ricky after the 2002 win and I hope they are able to take advantage of their window, though I am glad they didn’t on Sunday night.

Jack Wighton was fantastic as a big, hard running half. He’s old school in the mould of Laurie Daley, Brad Fittler and Trent Barrett. This is a guy the Raiders can build around and create a new generation of legends. He clearly deserved the Churchill Medal – he was outstanding, I was at a pub in Warrnambool to watch the game and so couldn’t hear the sound, but I was really sad to hear that Roosters fans were booing him. I hope they feel a bit of shame when they think back on that. Just really classless stuff.

Canberra just need another point of attack, and maybe George Williams will provide that next year, time will tell. They have the makings of a special team, and I hope they’re able to take advantage of it, because the NRL looks pretty open in 2020.

Raiders players, staff and fans should be really proud of their team – they were a bit of a laughing stock last year, and the transformation this year is really quite amazing. They are a tough footy team with a lot to like about the way they play the game, and with the likes of Jarrod Croker and Sia Solia in the club, it is obvious they will make their club and community better.

(Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

The Roosters had to work so hard to win that game. The defence in the second half was immense and won the match without a doubt. The ability to just keep turning up was amazing. Trent Robinson is now the greatest Roosters coach in history, going past the late Jack Gibson. He has won three grand finals in his short career, and who is to say he won’t win more. With him being a young coach, he has time on his side to chase Gibson and Bennett’s record. Is he now a Roosters coach or a career coach? Time will tell.

Boyd Cordner, Jake Friend, Daniel Tupou, Jared Waerea-Hargreaves and Mitchell Aubusson are now three-time premiership winners and will all go down in Roosters folklore as all-time greats. Their loyalty, work and drive over the last ten years has been the key to the club and is what everything else has been built around. I grew up in the same sort of area as Mitch Aubusson and everyone I have met who knows him or played with or against him speaks so highly of him. He deserves to become the most capped Rooster of all time next year.

James Tedesco and Cooper Cronk are just incredible, perhaps two of the greatest signings for the Roosters of all time, ahead of the likes of Jack Gibson, Brad Fittler, Sonny Bill Williams and Gus Gould. Cronk is all class and the Storm should be proud of the men they have helped shape and grow. Cronk is what our players should aspire to be like.

I feel very lucky he would choose to risk his reputation and move away from something so familiar to join my club and make it better by bringing everything he has to the team. He retires a legend, having won four grand finals. He is somewhat difficult to rank in the conversation of all-time greats. Is he now ahead of the likes of Cameron Smith, Greg Inglis or Johnathan Thurston? I don’t know.

(Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

James Tedesco is well on his way to creating one of the all-time great careers a dual premiership winner, Dally M winner, and Brad Fittler and Wally Lewis medal winner. He has quite the CV. He could become New South Wales’s greatest ever Origin fullback, and his club career is going from strength to strength.

This team now belongs with some of the greatest teams to play this game. The early 1990s Raiders, the 1992-93 Broncos, the Bulldogs and Eels of the 80s and the 1974-75 Roosters. This current Roosters squad now belongs with these teams, and history will forever link them.

The Roosters are the team of the decade, with the Storm not too far behind. Both clubs have been incredibly dominant over the last ten or so years and the rivalry is one that I hope can continue to build.

Finally I will put my two cents in on the refereeing controversy, because everyone else has. The trainer thing is a weird rule, one I don’t understand, but it has been clear. The NRL should change this and move on. Either Canberra should have got the scrum or it should have been a changeover – whichever, really. I still think Luke Keary should have got a penalty – the six again call is something I still can’t believe, and I’m not sure if I have seen something similar in any sport.

I don’t really have an issue with the decision – I thought it hit Croker Roosters ball – but the way referee Ben Cummins got there was clearly wrong,

I don’t know what the game should do in this situation. Should it take the earpieces out so he hasn’t got three or four voices in his ear? Do we go back to one referee? The NRL needs to be proactive here and let fans know that this error of procedure won’t happen again.

As a Roosters fan I don’t think the call cost the Raiders the game – they had 20-odd play-the-balls in the Roosters 20 compared to one for the Roosters, so they had more than enough chances. I think the Raiders lost a chance to win the game, and that happens in every game every year through referee calls, good defence, poor attack, a dropped ball or Will Chambers not seeing Cronk unmarked on the inside. It’s rough for the Raiders, and I have nothing but respect for the game they played. I hope they break through to win it soon.

But whatever your opinion, the 2019 NRL grand final will at least be remembered.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-12T11:42:12+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


It wouldn't've taken a huge effort to kick a field goal if the referee didn't signal 6 to go. This is a good example of why referees aren't allowed to change their decision. I thought you'd be a Canterbury fan. The spell-checker objected to me leaving the 'u' out of Canterbury.

2019-10-12T03:46:33+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Roosters will fall back into the pack next year. The hunger wont be there

2019-10-11T06:48:29+00:00

Mike

Roar Rookie


Nice Article

AUTHOR

2019-10-11T00:27:26+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


Cronk is a big loss clearly. But keary taking the reigns with flannagan coming in isn't the worst result. Hopefully for the roosters sake next yr it's just Cronk and tetevano who are not there for next yr. The year after will be a lot more challenging

2019-10-10T22:38:40+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Much depends on what happens to your squad too, in terms of 2020 premiership favouritism. Both the Roosters & Raiders need to blood a new half back and it will possibly be harder for you guys, given the greater impact Cronk had on games compared to Sezar ( I thought he was a passenger in a lot of games). It also depends on whether your players get better offers elsewhere and decide to move. If you can do a Storm and shed a few guys, like Glasby, but keep your core, at worst I reckon you and the Raiders should share top billing.

AUTHOR

2019-10-10T08:35:09+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


I think the 3 clubs to make a run next yr would be Canberra I'll have some faith, Panthers I like Cleary running the show and the Sharks winning some games they should have this yr and being a tough team to beat. With the Roosters and storm being up there to but I am not sure either can win it again.

2019-10-10T07:44:21+00:00

Pickett

Roar Rookie


Nice article

2019-10-10T07:06:04+00:00

Dogs Boddy

Roar Rookie


Great article Jacks. Firstly congratulations on the win, it was a mighty effort by your boys and thoroughly deserved. Controversy aside, the Roosters had that game by the scruff all night and it would have taken a huge effort to overcome them. The Raiders were good, but not good enough. I really like the way you have come at this, a lot of people tend to forget this is just a sporting contest and should be something we enjoy. As to next season, well it's a brave man to predict anything with this lot. There are certainly 3-4 clubs that really put on the show this season, and it will be interesting to see how they take that into next year. Souths have some issues, Manly showed promise, If the Sharks can get everyone on the park for an extended period they have a shot, the Storm are always a threat but if Smith hangs up the boots it could be interesting, Raiders have been so inconsistent season to season it's hard to tell, Parra were a surprise this year but can they back up. I think I will just enjoy the cricket and pick this back up again in March / April next year. Thanks again for an article that is not just ref bashing.

AUTHOR

2019-10-10T05:04:01+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


Yeah agree for sure those seem to be the 4 keys with a mix of luck as well. I think the Raiders should start as faves for next yr IMO new 7 is a concern but if they keep Bateman they should be hungry and ready to go one better. But there is always someone ready to shock everyone, I mean who saw the Raiders in the gf to begin with. I don't mind the Panthers chances have a 7 with 5 origin games so I think they will improve a bit for mine.

2019-10-10T04:02:05+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


The really competitive teams have 4 things going for them IMO - a solid administration, a good coach, a good squad and at least one natural leader. Your boys have all of these things,especially leaders, Canberra and the Storm both have them, but every other side has at least one failing, mostly with the coaches. In the case of my Mighty Dragons, we have an inept Board & a coach who can't get the best out of this squad. You named Penrith as a possible, but Cleary isn't a great coach and who's their leader, comparable to Cordner, JWH, Keary, Tedesco, Hodgson Wighton, Smith or Munster? If/when other teams sort out these issues, THEN they'll contend, but for some, including my boys, there's going to be a ton of pain before that happens.

AUTHOR

2019-10-10T03:27:27+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


Yeah atm looking at it there are just average or below average with Canberra, Roosters, Storm and maybe souths depending on what Surgess does. But really the Panthers could get the jump on everyone the way it is atm. Giving Cleary the keys decent pack they could be a danger. IMO Canberra is in a wide open window currently and if they don’t take advantage it could take a long time for them to get back into a premiership window.

2019-10-10T01:39:12+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


nope, I misread something I looked up Jacks. You're right about the Storm. I too don't see an outstanding side, but sadly, do see plenty of teams that are mediocre at best and dead ordinary at worst. It might make for a close comp, but I suspect we might go through a period of mediocrity as old stars retire ( Smith Cronk, Inglis, etc), until they're replaced. Right now, There's only a few left, Tedesco, JAC, Cook, maybe Wighton?

AUTHOR

2019-10-10T01:29:31+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


I really do think the comp is wide open next year, maybe because I don't atm see an outstanding team and can't see the roosters doing a 3 peat. Storm won in 12 and 17. Before that was the titles that were stripped? Unless I made a mistake.

2019-10-09T23:58:17+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


To be honest I didn't see the article until a comment popped up about the article. Part of it could be where these articles are positioned on the site.

2019-10-09T23:35:43+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


hi Jacks, it's good to see a Roosters fan acknowledging how well the Raiders have gone this year. It's easy to dismiss the other team in the euphoria of winning a premiership, but you wrote well about a team that has plenty of upside, as the Americans would say. There were a couple of things I queried. "the NRL looks pretty open in 2020." Do you really think so? First of all, as Politis came out and said, your boys are ripe for the picking by other Clubs with money to spend, so hanging onto this team is going to be a challenge. Assuming you can, I can't see anyone outside the Roosters, Storm or Raiders being genuine contenders any time soon. Souths window of opportunity is rapidly closing and all the other Clubs have serious issues they need to deal with. The comp is weak, as highlighted by the 50 point hiding the Broncos copped from Parra, followed by their 30 point hiding against the Storm. You also suggested the Roosters were the team of the decade, ahead of the Storm. I think you're being very generous to your side. Since 2011, the Storm have never finished worse than 6th, and have 3 premierships to show for it. The Roosters too have won 3 premierships but had 3 seasons where they finished 11th, 13th and 15th. Both great teams, but the Storm have the edge IMO.

2019-10-09T20:40:31+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


Good article and well balanced. The lack of comments shows why journalists don't write this sort of article much at all. Plenty on the Roar call for the NRl commentators and journalists to stop being negative but where is the interest in the alternative? It's not there.

AUTHOR

2019-10-08T21:14:50+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


Not the part of the article I thought anyone would focus on tbh. It still says Eastern Suburbs on the license and I one day hope that they decide to change the marketing decision and go back to Easts but I won't hold my breath.

2019-10-08T19:19:32+00:00

Max power

Guest


“as well as my team, the Eastern Suburb Roosters“ I’m sorry but Easts left the competition 24 years ago. Because no one in the east participated in RL the roosters decided to call themselves Sydney. A fitting name as the insular people in the east think the world revolves around Bondi and that the western suburbs begin at Anzac parade

Read more at The Roar