Rugby World Cup final: England player ratings

By Daniel Szabo / Roar Guru

England have been denied a third Rugby World Cup victory after going down to South Africa 32-12 in the 2019 tournament final.

It was a tough night at the office for England, who arguably came into this game as favourites after a dominant win over the All Blacks in their semi-final last week.

Here’s how the England players fared individually.

Mako Vunipola – 4
He was completely out of his depth at scrum time up against Frans Malherbe and didn’t do much in general play, making just one each of tackles and runs.

Jamie George – 6
Tried hard. He made five tackles and had two carries and threw well at the line out. He came off after 59 minutes.

Kyle Sinckler – 2
Sinckler ws knocked out in just the second minute after copping some friendly fire from teammate Maro Itoje. he wasn’t seen again after that.

Maro Itoje – 6.5
He topped the tackle count with 16 and just one miss after playing the entire 80, and was one of England’s better players.

(Photo by Adam Davy/PA Images via Getty Images)

Courtney Lawes – 6
He struggled for impact but tried hard with four tackles and nine runs for 35m. He came off after 40 minutes.

Tom Curry – 7
Another of England’s better performers. Curry an the most metres of any forward in his team with 46m from nine runs.

Sam Underhill – 6.5
He recorded seven tackles plus four runs for 22m. Didn’t let anyone down.

Billy Vunipola – 7
He tried his absolute guts out with 15 runs and five tackles and tried to spark his team with some offloads. He looked threatening at times.

Ben Youngs – 6.5
Youngs had a decent night with the boot, kicking for 219m (the most on the ground), but wasn’t as impactful in attack as he has been in recent weeks against Australia and New Zealand.

George Ford – 4.5
A night to forget for the English flyhalf. He made a few mistakes, including kicking out on the full in the 27th minute which put his team on the back foot. Ford failed to set up chances for his outside men and was replaced after 49 minutes.

Jonny May – 6
50m from just four runs is a pretty good return. he didn’t get many good attacking opportunities close to the line.

Owen Farrell – 5
He scored all 12 of his side’s points but failed to spark the England attack in general play. He tried hard but was ultimately ineffective.

Manu Tuilagi – 5.5
Big Manu made nine runs for 53m and two tackle busts and was underutilised in my opinion. A player like him should be the focal point of a side’s attack – it felt like he was more of an afterthought to the England brain trust in this game.

Anthony Watson – 5
One of the few England players who looked a handful with the ball in hand, but didn’t get the opportunities out wide he would have liked.

Elliot Daly – 4.5
He made two crucial errors that put England on the back foot and couldn’t find a way to chime into the England attack. A night to forget.

Luke Cowan-Dickie – 4.5
Came on in the 61st minute and had minimal impact.

Joe Marler – 4
Marler came on in the 45th minute to counter the onslaught of Steven Kitshoff and Vincent Koch in the front row for South Africa. He wasn’t able to slow them down.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Dan Cole – 5
He came on much earlier than expected when starting hooker Jamie George went off with concussion. Threw well at the line out for the most part, but wasn’t able to get himself into the game.

George Kruis – 5
Kruis played the entire second half and made two runs and three tackles but had plenty of work to do at the breakdown.

Mark Wilson – 4
He ame on in the 59th minute for Sam Underhill but wasn’t sighted much.

Ben Spencer – 2
He came on in the 75th minute when the result was already gone for his team and had minimal involvement.

Henry Slade – 4
Slade entered the match in the 49th minute to replace Ford with the result still hanging in the balance but wasn’t able to spark his team’s attack.

Jonathan Joseph – 3
He came on in the 69th minute and had minimal involvement.

There you have it, Roarers. What are your thoughts on how the England players fared? Let us know in the comments below.

The Crowd Says:

2019-11-05T13:37:30+00:00

mick stemotions

Guest


Dan Cole threw well at the lineout? i bet that`s news to him.

2019-11-04T07:45:43+00:00

Richard

Guest


I think you need to proof read before you publish.

2019-11-03T05:47:25+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


England is a very physical team, but they needed to play more of a Brighton Beach ball game. Don’t trade haymakers with Mike Tyson.

2019-11-03T05:21:20+00:00

Jersey

Guest


Itoje was probably England’s best. 7.5 Ben Youngs was completely outplayed by Faff. 4.5

2019-11-03T05:14:11+00:00

Nick

Guest


I thought Cole was a prop? Didn’t he come on to replace Sinckler? That was a major (early) turning point in the match.

2019-11-03T04:33:13+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


I think you're still right, it was just sloppy phrasing by the author.

2019-11-03T04:26:29+00:00

SandBox

Roar Guru


Good point. No idea then

2019-11-03T04:01:57+00:00

rebel

Roar Guru


Four times, lost three.

2019-11-03T03:13:18+00:00

Bobbo7

Guest


I thought a couple of these English players were better than McCaw? Not so it seems. And the dummy spit by not wearing their medals. I am very happy SA won it.

2019-11-03T03:11:33+00:00

SandBox

Roar Guru


Think he was referring to making the finals three times

2019-11-03T02:11:27+00:00

Perthstayer

Roar Rookie


Harsh on Marler. Improved scrum and won scrum penalty. SA secondary shove was technically excellent. Pack was actually lighter.

2019-11-03T01:13:36+00:00

Vince Martin

Roar Rookie


Pretty accurate ratings - maybe a bit generous to the English forwards who were absolutely smashed technically and physically by the SA 8 ( or should I say the SA 14.!)

2019-11-03T00:36:02+00:00

KiwiHaydn

Roar Rookie


Different day, same old inconsistent England. Pretenders.

2019-11-03T00:17:47+00:00

Malotru

Roar Rookie


Manu Tuilagi couldn't run out of sight in a week (he is a big bloke though).

2019-11-02T23:30:01+00:00

Oblonsky‘s Other Pun

Roar Guru


Did we overrate some of the English players? I’ve never thought much of the English front row in the set piece (although they were brilliant last week), and they were given a hiding by the South Africans. Also think that Eddie was punished in thinking he could turn a generalist skilled player into a world class fullback (Kurtley Beale anyone?). That said, play this match again tomorrow and it may be a totally different result, so maybe I am being unfair on the English players, who had a fantastic tournament.

2019-11-02T23:25:36+00:00

Harrison

Roar Rookie


Denied a third rugby World Cup win? When did they get their second...

Read more at The Roar