The Test match world XI

By Patrick / Roar Pro

As the sporting world takes a break in the middle of a global pandemic, sports lovers are finding other ways to pursue their passion; reliving classic matches, hypothesising about makeshift season details and constructing hypothetical line-ups.

From a cricket perspective, the ultimate hypothetical line-up is the world XI. The ICC names a team of the year every calendar year, and the concept of a world XI has been pursued in the past, with an ODI side put together to take on Australia.

This article will select the current Test world XI, but with a twist. Only one player can be selected from each nation.

The concept has inherent challenges. Many star players will be overlooked for an equally successful teammate, and sometimes a country’s best player will miss out in the name of team balance. So for what it’s worth, here is the current Test world XI.

Azhar Ali (Pakistan): 78 Tests, 5919 runs at 42.58, 16 centuries
Whilst the majority of Azhar Ali’s 78 Tests have been spent at number three, he opens the batting in this side given the plethora of middle-order options available.

The Pakistani captain has opened the batting on 37 occasions in Test cricket, averaging 45.76 in the position, with four centuries, including his top score of 302 not out.

In addition to his triple century, Azhar has two double hundreds, and two scores of 157 in Test cricket, reflecting his ability to play long innings – the hallmark of a good Test opener.

He provides an experienced option at the top of the order, having compiled a strong record over a number of years.

Dimuth Karunaratne (Sri Lanka): 66 Tests, 4524 runs at 36.78, nine centuries
Sri Lanka’s current Test Captain Dimuth Karunaratne takes the second opening position, having performed consistently at the top of the order at Test level.

Karunaratne has been one of his country’s best batsman in recent years, scoring 527 runs at 35.13 in the 2019 calendar year, 743 runs at 46.43 in 2018 and 1031 runs at 39.65 in 2017.

While many top batsmen struggle on deteriorating pitches, Karunaratne averages 38.01 in the second innings with five centuries. Indeed, he is the only batsmen in this team to average more in the second innings than the first.

Regarded as a leader within Sri Lankan cricket, the left-handed opener was made captain of Sri Lanka’s ODI side last year, despite not having played the format internationally for four years.

Kane Williamson (captain, New Zealand): 80 Tests, 6476 runs at 50.99, 21 centuries
Coming in at number three is New Zealand’s captain, Kane Williamson. A genuine star of global cricket, Williamson ranked fourth in the ICC Test batting rankings.

(Photo by Alex Davidson/Getty Images)

The New Zealander has averaged over 50 in all but one of his last six completed calendar years, falling short in 2016 when he averaged 47.06.

Williamson is renowned as a humble leader, with a calm temperament, and has led his team to 18 wins in his 32 matches in charge with just six losses.

He averages 54.2 as captain with eight centuries and has been chosen to lead this side.

Steve Smith (Australia): 73 Tests, 7227 runs at 62.84, 26 centuries
Unsurprisingly, the world number one Test batsman Steve Smith represents Australia, having averaged 73.42 since his return from a year-long suspension.

Smith’s ability to maintain an average above 60 is virtually unrivalled in the modern game, with others who have achieved the feat doing so in a much smaller sample size.

The former Australian captain is considered by many to be the best since Don Bradman, and played a pivotal role in Australia retaining the Ashes last year, scoring 774 runs at 110.57 with three centuries.

In an era where Australia has struggled in overseas conditions, Smith has averaged 60 in India and 59.55 in England. In fact, Bangladesh is the only country where he averages below 40; a place where he has played just two Tests.

(Mike Egerton/PA Images via Getty Images)

Virat Kohli (India): 86 Tests, 7240 runs at 53.62, 27 centuries
Another self-explanatory selection is that of Virat Kohli, who has performed with distinction from the very beginning of his Test career.

Kohli debuted in 2011, averaged 49.21 in 2012, and hasn’t averaged under 40 in a completed calendar year since.

Indeed, of the ten years in which Kohli has played Test cricket, he has scored multiple centuries in eight of them, reflecting a remarkable consistency across the best part of a decade. He has multiple centuries against every opponent and has scored hundreds in every country except Bangladesh, where he has only played one Test.

Whilst Kohli prefers to bat at number four, the Indian captain has been pushed down to number five in this star-studded team.

Ben Stokes (England): 63 Tests, 4056 runs at 36.54, nine centuries. 147 wickets at 32.68
Ben Stokes has always been a valuable cricketer. He’s a match-winner, capable of pulling off an extraordinary innings, and he is able to contribute with both bat and ball.

In 2019 however, Stokes took his game to another level, finding greater consistency with the bat. After averaging 26.85 in his ten Tests in 2018, the all-rounder averaged 45.61 in 2019, and has averaged 53.8 in three Tests so far this year.

A naturally gifted hitter, Stokes is remarkably adaptable, able to bat slowly when required. His remarkable performance to claim victory in the Headingley Ashes Test was a testament to this, as he batted slowly on Day 4 before hitting eight sixes in an innings of 135 not out.

Stokes has been selected as an all-rounder ahead of a sixth specialist batsman given the quality of this team’s top five. He performs the fifth bowler role well, having taken 147 wickets in his 63 Tests with a bowling average in the low 30s.

(Photo by Gareth Copley/Getty Images)

Mushfiqur Rahim (wk, Bangladesh): 70 Tests, 4413 runs at 36.77, seven centuries. 104 catches, 15 stumpings
In the absence of the suspended Shakib al-Hasan, wicketkeeper-batsman Mushfiqur Rahim is the best man to represent Bangladesh in this side.

Now playing as a specialist batsman, Rahim has spent considerable time behind the stumps at Test level, keeping in 55 of his 70 Tests.

An accomplished batsman with seven Test centuries, including three doubles, the Bangladesh keeper has averaged 37 when wearing the gloves in Test cricket – marginally higher than his overall Test average.

With many selecting Rahim to keep in their Test team of the decade, he comfortably earns a place in the world XI.

Jason Holder (West Indies): 40 Tests, 1898 runs at 32.72, three centuries. 106 wickets at 26.37
The world’s number one ranked Test all-rounder, Jason Holder, comes in at number eight.

Handed the captaincy after just eight Tests, Holder has been a revelation for the West Indies, performing with bat and ball in an otherwise unstable side.

Whilst he took some time to settle into the captaincy, Holder’s last two years have been fantastic. He averaged 37.33 in 2018 with the bat, and 49.14 in 2019, headlined by an unbeaten score of 202 against England.

After an indifferent start to his Test career with the ball, the West Indian has taken 53 wickets at 14.23 in his last 11 Tests, placing him among the premier seam bowlers in world cricket.

Rashid Khan (Afghanistan): Four Tests, 23 wickets at 21.08
The world’s best T20 bowler, Rashid Khan remains relatively unproven at Test level with only eight first-class matches to his name.

However, in the limited opportunities he has had so far, the Afghan spinner has performed well, taking 23 wickets in just four Tests.

Concerningly, Khan struggled in Tests against India and the West Indies, with the majority of his wickets coming against comparatively weak sides in Ireland and Bangladesh. But with such a small sample size, it’s hard to be too critical.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Whilst he may be a somewhat speculative pick, given his bowling style is heavily oriented towards the white-ball game, Rashid’s bright start to his Test career rewards him with a position ahead of his Afghani teammates.

Tim Murtagh (Ireland): Three Tests, 13 wickets at 16.38
Irish veteran Tim Murtagh earns his place in the side, having taken 13 wickets in his first three Test matches.

Murtagh tore England apart at Lord’s last July, taking 5/13 in the first innings as England were bowled out for just 85.

While his side may be new to Test cricket, Murtagh is an experienced cricketer, having played 180 first-class matches for Middlesex, taking 695 wickets at 24.12.

Whilst he may not be required at number 10, the Irish seamer also offers a handy option with the bat, averaging 18.95 at the first-class level with 11 50s.

Kagiso Rabada (South Africa): 43 Tests, 197 wickets at 22.95
At the age of just 24, Kagiso Rabada is already nearing 200 Test wickets at an exceptional average of 22.95.

(AP Photo/Matt Dunham)

Entering his sixth year of international cricket, the South African speedster has taken over 50 wickets in two separate calendar years, claiming 57 in 2017 and 52 in 2018.

In 2018, Rabada became the youngest player to reach number one in the ICC Test bowling rankings. He was also the youngest player to reach 100 Test wickets.

With the retirements of legendary compatriots in recent years, Rabada is now the clear leader of South Africa’s bowling attack, using a combination of skill, pace and an aggressive demeanour to unsettle opponents.

The Crowd Says:

2020-04-14T11:53:55+00:00

Mamun

Guest


:thumbup:

2020-04-07T05:00:07+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


What a fun exercise. Certainly makes you think. Personally, I would probably go down a slightly more balance team option, but sticking with the absolute locks. Afghanistan- Rashid Khan- Arguments to be made he's the best spinner in the world at the moment. Australia- Cummins for me. I see the argument for Smith, but right now Pat our best player. You could make arguments Marnus is pushing Smith for number 2. Bangas- Al Hasan (by the length of Flemington straight) England- Stokes or Root India- Kohli or Bumrah. I'm going Kohli to offset Cummins. Ireland- Kevin O'Brien. New Zealand- Williamson, Watling or Wagner Pakistan- Babar Azam for me. But if you need a opening bat, Ali. South Africa- De Kock or Rabada depending on which way you go. Sri Lanka- Karunaratne stand out choice West Indies- Holder 1st choice- Kraigg Braithwaite Second option. Zimbabwe- Take your pick Craig Ervine, Brendan Taylor or Kyle Jarvis. So here we go, my best XI DeKock (wk) (SA) Karunaratne (SRI) Williamson (NZ) Kohli (IND) Azam (PAK) Stokes (ENG) Al-Hasan (BAN) Holder (WI) Cummins (AUS) Khan (AFG) Jarvis (ZIM) O'Brien (IRE) 12th Man

2020-04-07T04:04:38+00:00

BL

Guest


Sensational batting line up, sure to be let down by the selected bowlers me thinks.

2020-04-06T07:14:21+00:00

Darren

Guest


Have they heard of Marcus Labuschagne?

2020-04-05T22:58:08+00:00

ASFP

Guest


No, bat Brendan Taylor or Sean Williams at 5. They’re both perfectly capable. Either that or drop Holder for Cummins and bring Braithwaite in for Smith

2020-04-05T22:36:04+00:00

Matt

Guest


Reckon the bloke with the most Test wickets by a seamer in the history of the game might sneak in. ????

2020-04-05T12:16:37+00:00

Ian campbell

Guest


Cummins and kohli ..No bumrah .No smith

2020-04-05T09:01:25+00:00

13th Man

Roar Rookie


Interesting concept Id go with Karunaratne Hope Smith Kohli Stokes O'Brien Rahim (wk) Rashid Rabada Boult Naseem Shah

2020-04-04T06:53:05+00:00

AREH

Roar Guru


This really gets one thinking! Gone a little different... 1. Karunaratne 2. Azhar Ali 3. Smith 4. Kohli 5. Stokes 6. Al-Hasan 7. Watling 8. Holder 9. Rashid Khan 10. Rabada 11. Murtagh

2020-04-04T01:17:19+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


Don't forget Monde "All Hand" Zondeki.

2020-04-04T00:47:02+00:00

Sgt Pepperoni

Roar Rookie


Classic Reminds me of the nickname of rugby player Billy Twelvetrees who was called '36'

2020-04-03T23:49:27+00:00

badmanners

Roar Rookie


I just love Tim Murtagh’s nick name “Dial M”. As in “Dial M for Murtagh” :stoked:

2020-04-03T23:30:04+00:00

Brian

Guest


B Taylor Karunaratne Williamson Kohli Azam Stokes Rahim Holder Cummins R Khan Rabada

2020-04-03T07:31:17+00:00

dancingmongoose

Roar Rookie


Cool concept, although I will criticise the selection of Murtagh, not a bad pick but he retired from international cricket to continue playing county cricket as a local player

2020-04-03T07:18:24+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


Oops - 2 Indians. Doh

2020-04-03T07:16:36+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


Brendan Taylor at 3 might struggle but this is a stronger bowling attack. Azhar Ali (Pak) Dimuth Karunaratne (SL) Brendan Taylor (Zimbabwe) Steve Smith (Aus) Virat Kohli (India) Mushriqur Rahim (Bang) wk Ben Stokes (England) Ravi Jadeja (India) Jason Holder (WI) c Neil Wagner (NZ) Kagiso Rabada (SA)

2020-04-03T06:46:42+00:00

Peter85

Roar Rookie


First man picked: Jason Holder - highest ranked all-rounder (1), highest ranked WI batsman (35), highest ranked WI bowler (3). Toss-ups based on team balance: Smith/Cummins and Williamson/Wagner. Smith and Cummins both are ranked #1 in their respective fields. Williamson is #4 and Wagner #2. Smith's lead over Williamson is greater than Cummins over Wagner. My starting point is Smith and Wagner, subject to change. Virat Kholi and Kagiso Rabada are in. They rank significantly higher than their teammates. I lack some openers, Dimuth Karunaratne is the highest runs scorer for Sri Lanka over the last three years at 41, Matthews has a slightly better average at 43 but played less games and there are fewer middle order spots. Their bowlers don't really excite me. Babar Azam is Pakistans best batsman over the last three years, in both runs and average. Rashid Khan is Afghanistans best bowler by far and none of the batsmen stand out. 4 tests is a small sample however Khan has shown his class across T20 leagues around the world. I am missing an opener, a wicketkeeper and a lower order batsman/all-rounder. With England, Bangladesh, Zimbabwe and Ireland to go. Bangladesh has Tamim Iqbal averaging just under 40, which is slightly lower than that of Shakib Al Hasan and Mushfiqur Rahim at 42. Bairstow has scored the most runs as a keeper over the last 3 years, he is English and now the call is a keeper from Zimbabwe/Ireland and Stokes or the best remaining batsman from the remaining countries and Bairstow. I will go with Craig Ervine, averaging 42 over his last 11 tests (4 years) over Kevin O'Brien averaging 50 in his 3 tests. 1. Karunaratne 2. Iqbal 3. Smith 4. Kholi 5. Azam 6. Ervine 7. Bairstow 8. Holder 9. Khan 10. Wagner 11. Rabada There you have it, 3 of the top 5 bowlers, 3 of the top 5 batsman. The top ranked T20 bowler and some guys to fill in the roles that are needed. My least favorite pick is Bairstow. Foakes is probably the easiest replacement, but doesnt have the volume of performance. Watling or de Kock have knock on effects of Stokes or Root in, swap Smith for Cummins and I can't not pick Smith. Bairstow provides the least amount of comprimise.

2020-04-03T06:08:09+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


It's been 15 years since England won the '05 Ashes and although we thrashed them in the following series, they won '09, thrashed us in 2010/11 and also won away in India during that approximate time. It all fell apart for them in about 2013, so I'd say England had one of their best teams ever from about '03 to '13 - certainly as good as the team they had in the mid-80s anyway. Fully agree with the Sri Lankan side really coming into their own from the mid '90s. Their test side was never in the class of the great Australian, West Indian and South African sides, but their ODI side in the '90s was amazing and I used to live it when they came to Australia for the old Tri Series.

2020-04-03T05:22:07+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Windies certainly the tragedy. I did say England in the last 20 years. Maybe it’s only 17 or 18. 30 years is a rough number. I’d say Sri Lanka were better 25 years ago - Muralitharan, Vaas, da Silva, Jayasuriya, Ranatunga etc. Fair point about SA - they were perhaps best team in the world over ten years to 2018 but they’ve taken a big dive since 2018 following departure of a few big names.

2020-04-03T04:20:08+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


I dunno, England was quite strong ten to fifteen years ago, but even this side is still better than their team from 30 years ago... I also don't think Sri Lanka was much chop as a test side thirty years ago... maybe 20 years ago, but not in 1990. And that's a bit rough on South Africa, they've had a world class team until about a year or two ago. I sort of agree with you about Pakistan, relative to the rest of the cricketing world, their teams in the '80s and '90s were much stronger than recent teams, but they still produce some world class cricketers. The tragedy of world cricket is the prolonged decline/decay of the Windies. If each nation put together their greatest XI's of all time, the Windies and Australia would be far and away the best two teams. Sadly I don't think the Windies will ever produce another player to get into that all time XI.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar