How changes in the game of cricket make me wonder what the future holds

By Peter Farrar / Roar Pro

I was sitting up watching the West Indies playing England. Blanket drawn up to my neck on a freezing Melbourne evening, coffee almost as cold as that bed I’d crawl into later.

I was finding it difficult adjusting to the sight of those empty stands at Old Trafford. Seat after unfilled seat. Voices at times emerged from somewhere during the telecast. From the fielders now and then. Perhaps an over excited groundsman calling out. Or maybe it was the buzz of dubbed in voices like the murmuring ghosts of people who once took their place in those rows.

We were after all becoming conditioned to empty stands, having experienced them during the AFL season. Eventually crowd noises were added to our AFL. (Cheering and applause only, no booing allowed).

I’ve seen a comment when it was suggested there wasn’t much difference between the empty seats during the series in England and our own Sheffield Shield games. It was difficult not to smile during the telecast when David ‘Bumble’ Lloyd stood at the back of a stand, providing commentary on his passion for train spotting (reminiscent perhaps of Bill Lawry’s fascination with pigeon racing).

But for me those empty seats were the most profound change in cricket I have witnessed.

Over the years we’ve certainly seen significant change. There’s the reduction of eight balls to six during overs. Shorter boundaries with the installation of ropes. The addition of shorter versions of the game. The width of cricket bats widening. Helmets being worn. Drop in pitches.

Tour/ warm up matches becoming less important. Neutral umpires. Limits per over on the number of short pitched deliveries. Night Test matches. The use of sports psychologists. For a sport so closely linked to tradition, we’ve seen a lot of change.

Only a couple of weeks ago I thought we might be witnessing a particularly significant development. The return of the West Indies to prominence, following their first Test victory in England.

Perhaps they did show enough to suggest their comeback as a real force remains a possibility, although every time before a new series involving them, I never fail to speculate whether their brilliance of the 1980s will finally once again be on show.

Jason Holder (Photo credit should read Randy Brooks/AFP via Getty Images)

As our next season approaches I contemplate the changes we may see. As raised by others on The Roar, how will our domestic season work? Can we expect the players to form hubs? While it’s early days, one can’t help but feel Shield games are unlikely to be scheduled in Melbourne.

Without a domestic season how will our fringe players make a case for being chosen for the Test squad? How else will Marcus Harris put himself back on the selector’s radar? What other way can Wil Pucovski demonstrate he is tracking towards our national team?

Peter Hanscomb will need strong Sheffield Shield performances to restate his claims for the national side. And I think we’d all breathe a little easier if opener Joe Burns had a couple of solid innings under his belt before the first Test.

Let’s also not forget Usman Khawaja, seen by many as no longer part of the future of the national team. If he’s to change that perception, he needs to perform in the domestic competition.

Meanwhile, once Afghanistan and India arrive, they will be likely to isolate. Quite possibly India in particular will bring a large number of players. That will enable intra team matches if the Cricket Australia XI games (or whichever sides would be used) are unavailable.

Even if there is a Test match at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, I doubt we’ll be attending. We’ll instead be sitting in our lounge rooms, appealing and signalling boundaries from the couch. There’ll be no ice cream vendors to shout at or cardboard boxes of limp chips to burn the roofs of our mouths on.

We may find that our Test matches follow a similar arrangement seen in England.

The second and third Test were played at the same venue, Old Trafford. The first Test against Pakistan is also scheduled there. This makes sense although there must be challenges in preparation and maintenance of the ground being used in this way.

During the third Test I saw a ball hit a worn section of the pitch used for the second Test, dangerously rearing up. Using pitches for the Sheffield Shield before a Test no doubt brings similar issues although test matches are a day longer and with two played so close to each other must create problems for the playing surface.

With the second and third Tests against Pakistan at the Rose Bowl it will again be interesting how the ground holds up with those matches scheduled so close together.

New sponsor logos, rule updates and the dropping and promotion of players will always be part of cricket. But I hope the same can’t be said for those endless rows of empty seats and either the dubbed in crowd sounds, or the silence around them.

The Crowd Says:

2020-08-05T04:09:33+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


That's for sure.... Lots of things I am disliking around the pandemic right now but just have to adjust.. What other choice really.

2020-08-05T01:58:22+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


We usually only get until 7.30am on Boxing Day in the West!

AUTHOR

2020-08-05T01:28:53+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


All I can add Just Nuisance is I'd rather that the cricket is on TV to empty seats than no cricket at all. But you're right, there's definitely something missing. I'd say atmosphere.

AUTHOR

2020-08-05T01:25:54+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


If the Boxing Day test is in Perth over here in the Eastern states we can get a sleep in after the excesses of Christmas Day.

2020-08-05T00:59:19+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Like it. I miss the WACA, despite never having been there.

2020-08-04T09:30:45+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


During the 1990s South Africa toured the West Indies.. A public spat between the WI board and its players spilt over into the public domain leading to a boycott by fans of the match. It was surreal watching a full International played out in front of empty stands.. Little did I realize that 20 or so years later I would be witnessing it again.. It didn’t work for me then and I’m afraid it doesn’t today either.

2020-08-04T07:35:04+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Maybe. Can't even remember that match to be honest.

2020-08-04T06:18:45+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


It scares me too. At least we can enforce a quarantine on players returning (which will take another 14 days off their participation in the domestic season) and after the IPL we know they can afford the hotel charges.

2020-08-04T06:10:58+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


As a hypothetical, if Melbourne and Sydney had tough restrictions in place later in the year (hopefully the situation in Sydney improves and that doesn't happen, but as a hypothetical), how about the major sport administrators come together and agree: - NRL Grand Final in Brisbane - AFL Grand Final in Adelaide - Boxing Day Test in Perth May, for a time, alleviate some of the bugbears those States have re never hosting any of those marquee events. Revert back to BAU come 2021.

2020-08-04T06:03:37+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


That first Test was great.

2020-08-04T06:03:03+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Changes to the game itself that have made the game worse for me firstly are the reduction of the "strike zone" in cricket. I use a baseball term on purpose as the limit on short balls and the areas where wides are called being brought in further and further means batsmen/women can easily focus on hitting in a certain area, knowing that most if not all balls are going to be there. This is clearly a big issue to me in one day cricket but you can see the effects in FC cricket as well. It makes it a lot easier to power hit. Add in the bats being thicker and lighter, boundaries not only being smaller but the surface being perfectly maintained as well. I still say that if you waked out into the middle of the Gabba and hit the ball along the ground and then did the same at a local suburban ground of similar size it would much easier to reach the boundary at the Gabba. Then we have the pitches which we all know have for a long time now have had little life in them. Credit where it is due in the last few years we have seen a bit of life in the strips again. Then we also have the Kookaburra balls with just do nothing. Look at the difference in the Shield we used Dukes for half a season. The Dukes move around at right angles compared the the Kookaburra balls. All this has made batting very easy compared to earlier times and yet the standing of batting is so low that most players still only have middling averages but the good ones are very high. Not only in one day cricket do we have players teeing off most of the game because they know where the ball is going to be bowled and it is not going to do much but even in Test cricket we are seeing it at times. We have lost that intimidation factor that made the game so gripping. Batsmen just battling to stay out there of even avoid getting hurt before maybe getting their eye in and making some runs. The focus on T20 cricket will destroy the game in the end in my opinion. We have T20 cricket because One Dayers were too long and boring and now we are already talking about T20 cricket being boring or too long at times, what then? We can't go to T10. The game has to have confidence in the game itself and stop trying to invent new versions. Inventing new versions just shows everyone the game itself does think much of our own game. WE already have two new versions trotted out in the last two years.

2020-08-04T05:53:34+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


You're right of course, crowds can really add that special something to games, but credit to the players for still really putting in, even though they're playing to pretty much empty stadiums.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T05:42:04+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


Thanks Dave. It looks likely to me we will see a test scheduled somewhere else to replace Melbourne. I know it is early days but that at least allows people to probably be able to go. Mind you the word is that the tennis will go ahead without crowds in Melbs.

2020-08-04T05:38:50+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I think players are already thinking about that, as are CA and the other Boards, given the types of clauses they have included in contracts about playing in non-Board sanctioned events. I've no issue with the IPL moving dates Matt, but that venue scares me and it should scare the players. The UAE has had over 60,000 cases and more than 350 deaths. Mind you, CA is still seriously thinking about the Aussies touring England

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T05:38:16+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


Sure, although I believe the roar of an involved crowd is hard to beat in creating atmosphere and tension. I don't mean the slurred chanting of fifty drunks in the second session but even on television you can see the collective leaping up and cheering of people. Watching the West Indies playing England it struck me how much that was missing with all those empty seats.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T05:34:55+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


That sunk to a low the day Ian Healy started reading out a promotion of The Block. Just awful.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T05:32:52+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


Yes, Jones might threaten to chuck someone in a chaff bag and have them towed out to sea. Again.

AUTHOR

2020-08-04T05:31:34+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


Very possible Micko. Interesting to speculate what sized crowd there would be.

2020-08-04T03:53:26+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Was it 2015? I remember it was the West Indies. They did struggle.

2020-08-04T03:47:08+00:00

Realist

Guest


India would never agree to it because they have no hope of being competitive in Perth. It could be a massacre of India over there.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar