Newcastle's greatest NRL team

By The Boss / Roar Guru

The Newcastle Knights are winners of two premierships and were a key player in the Super League war. They have been one of the most supported and followed teams in the NRL, and this is their greatest team.

1. Kalyn Ponga
Three caps for Queensland
The precocious kid born in Western Australia who was a golf champion in New Zealand has set the Knights’ attack on fire (like his hair colour) ever since he joined the team. His sidestepping, all-around passing and kicking skills give them something the Knights haven’t had at fullback.

2. Timana Tahu
Five caps for Australia, 12 for NSW
Tahu was a tall, physically gifted outside back who was pound-for-pound of the strongest players ever. Tahu could use his power and pace to dominate his opponents and was just as good in defence. These skills made him become a dual-international.

3. Matt Gidley
17 caps for Australia, 11 for NSW
Gidley was a fine attacking player who used his big step and one-handed offload to set up his winger. He was strong and a very dangerous ball runner. Gidley was a force whenever he was on his game.

His signature Gidley-flick made him every winger’s best friend as he set them up for a myriad of tries.

4. Adam MacDougall
11 caps for Australia, 11 for NSW
Mad Dog played exactly like his nickname. His hard running style and famous trash talk mad him a very arduous to go up against. His signature feud with Wendell Sailor highlighted his tenacious playstyle.

5. Akuila Uate
Five caps for Australia, eight for Fiji, five for NSW, three-time winger of the year, RLIF winger of the year
Uate is a stocky, super strong and very fast winger. He has been a cult hero for the Knights where he has scored 109 tries.

Close to the line Uate could barge over multiple defenders to score, but he is also good for picking up metres while getting out of his own half. He was the best winger in the world from 2010-2012.

6. Matthew Johns
Eight caps for Australia, four for NSW
Known for his post-football career antics, Johns was unfortunately overshadowed by his brother, but he was a really smart player and punched above his weight. He was a great foil in the halves with his brother.

7. Andrew Johns
23 caps for Australia, 23 for NSW, three-time Dally M Medal winner, four-time halfback of the year, five-time RLW player of the year, two-time Golden Boot winner, Clive Churchill Medal winner
Andrew Johns is the greatest halfback ever and is featured in debates about the best to ever play the game. Johns had it all as a player – a pinpoint kicking game and the inventor of the banana kick. A famous double pump dummy.

He could throw long spirals to his teammates, his incredible defence was rare and his overall toughness made him an Immortal.

(Tony Feder/Getty Images)

8. Tony Butterfield
One cap for NSW
Part of their first-ever team and player number two in their history. He was such a key player in the Knights’ engine room who made plenty of metres and was a great club man – a type of player wanted in any team.

9. Danny Buderus
24 caps for Australia, 21 for NSW, Dally M Medal winner, three-time hooker of the year, Brad Fittler Medal winner
Buderus was the do it all hooker. He made great darts from dummy half that put lots of pressure on the defensive line.

One of the greatest hookers to ever play, Buderus exemplified what it meant to be a Newcastle Knight. That he was the captain of NSW showed his leadership and importance.

10. Paul Harragon
14 caps for Australia, 20 for NSW, prop of the year
Chief was a ruthless, damaging prop who played with no fear whatsoever. The rampaging runs and massive hits changed the momentum of games to his side.

His heated rivalry with Mark Carroll is an indication of how he played the game.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

11. Steve Simpson
Seven caps for Australia, 13 for NSW
Simpson’s career was riddled with injuries which stopped him from reaching his potential. He long and lanky frame made him awkward to tackle and he had a handy offload.

12. Ben Kennedy
16 caps for Australia, 13 for NSW, two-time lock of the year
One of the finest back-rowers in the game in his prime, Kennedy excelled at busting the line on the edge or offloading the ball at will, which won him multiple representative appearances. His performance in the 2001 grand final was one the main reasons why Newcastle won the game.

13. Marc Granville
Part of the first team, Granville was the heart and soul of the Knights. He was incredibly fit, which made him a very productive player.

Bench
Kurt Gidley, Mark Sargent, Adam Muir and Daniel Saifiti.

Newcastle have compiled a dangerous squad. The hard running backrowers Simpson and Kennedy provide great punch and offloading in the edges. The dynamic Ponga will have opponents on alert as he can step right around anyone. The backs all really strong ball carriers, with Matt Gidley laying in tries with his famous flick.

The conductor will be Andrew Johns. His presence alone always gives his team a chance to win – he can kick opponents to death or will take the line on and break a game wide open.

Newcastle will be a nightmare to play against and these Knights are going to be hard to beat.

The Crowd Says:

2021-08-06T12:41:53+00:00

Matthew brooks

Guest


Robbie O'Davis the Clive Churchill medalist of 1997 how did you forget to mention that guy?

2020-11-09T23:15:18+00:00

CostaG

Roar Rookie


I forgot. Jamie Ainscough. Could carve them up.

2020-11-09T23:12:55+00:00

CostaG

Roar Rookie


Good choice. I would have added Tony Kemp in the mix. Gutsy player.

2020-11-09T00:33:10+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Hi Tom, I did think of Reilly’s tough style, but I think Ryan’s tougher. The stuff he did with his bulldogs, the ruthless 84 grand final, the brutal tryless grand final, the tigers he had in late 80’s were hard as again. This ‘greats’ team of forwards would have Ryan in his element.

2020-11-06T20:53:09+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Definitely Robbie O for mine. You pick greatest ever for their career achievements, not for their potential.

2020-11-06T20:45:44+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Better then Brisbane, bulldogs, manly also? Teams that had multiple premierships. Ok

2020-11-06T11:33:04+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Ponga has been playing for 5 minutes. O'Davis definitely better as he stood up in big games and was tougher.

2020-11-06T11:16:36+00:00

Remy

Guest


Ponga is the Knights best fullback, Robbie O'Davis was never focus point of an attack. Give Ponga , Johns and he will be out of this world.

2020-11-06T11:14:44+00:00

Joe Carter

Guest


Ponga over Belcher, Johns over Stuart, Buderus over Walters, Tahu/Uate over Noa, Harragon over Papali

2020-11-06T10:53:32+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


Let's not forget NFL code swapper Greg Smith. Stats here https://www.rugbyleagueproject.org/players/greg-smith/summary.html It's a tough call, but he probably shades Andrew Johns at half.

2020-11-06T10:16:24+00:00

Mr Right

Roar Rookie


Better than that great Canberra side?

2020-11-06T10:09:50+00:00

Mr Right

Roar Rookie


There is only one Boss & his name is Bruce Springsteen. What a load of poppycock. Kalyn Ponga hasn't even played 50 games for this great club & you are stating he is the greatest Newcastle fullback of all time? Are you seriously omitting Robbie O'Davis from the GOAT title or is this just click bait?

2020-11-06T09:38:52+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


That's a seriously good team.

2020-11-06T09:36:00+00:00

Matt Wilkinson

Guest


Totally agree... Robbie O is one of the greatest Knights of all time!( Ponga might be one dart, but definitely not yet)

2020-11-06T07:47:37+00:00

Joe Carter

Guest


I’m a Panthers fan, and I really think this is the best team the author has listed so far . Johns is the best halfback ever , Buderus 2nd best hooker ever, Harragon top 5 all time prop. Ponga immensely talented Fullback , the outside backs were all best in the world at one stage . Also Ben Kennedy finest second rower of his generation . Add in the jack of all trades Kurt Gidley off the bench and this team is unbeatable.

2020-11-06T06:28:46+00:00

Tom G

Roar Rookie


Mal Reilly for sure.. there was coincidence that the knights were a tough and uncompromising side when he was in charge

2020-11-06T06:26:10+00:00

Tom G

Roar Rookie


Not sure that Ponga has done enough yet to edge Robbie O’Davis in this side. Excellent forward pack. Good to see Tony Butterfield a hard as nails prop and a top bloke.. very underrated

2020-11-06T03:55:46+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


No mention of Bill Peden or Jarrod Mullen? Not saying they'd be in the starting XIII, but certainly Peden at least would not be the worst off the bench

2020-11-06T03:21:37+00:00

Paper

Guest


Don’t think Robbie O ‘Davis had a year as good as Ponga did 2018, Ponga never had the luxury of playing neither Buderus , Johns , Kennedy , Tahu and Gidley.

2020-11-06T02:02:00+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Hi Glen. I was thinking hagan. Same sorts of stats for 5/8 as johns. But they think johns for the cohesion with his brother.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar