The third Test between Australia and India sits in the balance after two days, but it could have been oh-so different if not for another middle-order collapse, triggered by another shocking shot from former keeper Matthew Wade.
Australia were just rebuilding back to a position of strength at 3-232 before Wade’s wicket, where he charged down the track to Ravindra Jadeja, got hopelessly off balance and out of position and proceeded to sky the ball to mid-on for a simple catch to be taken by Jasprit Bumrah.
The hosts lost three for 23 and six for 83 before a last-wicket partnership of 23 between Josh Hazlewood and Steve Smith got them to a total of 338, which, for what its worth, could still prove to be well below par.
With three days of 98 overs left to play and not a great deal more rain forecast, there is still every chance of this Test reaching a result too, so it’s likely Australia’s middle-order collapse on Friday could come back to haunt them before this one is all said and done.
But back to Wade.
He was, as mentioned, just getting into his innings, rebuilding away with former skipper Steve Smith, who went on to make a classy 131 before being run out on a direct hit by Jadeja, who continues to go from strength to strength in all aspects of his game across all formats.
But with Wade on 13 and already riding his luck on numerous sweep shots into short leg Hanuma Vihari, he came charging down the track to a ball that wasn’t there to hit. It didn’t stop Wade from going through with it, and right there was the embodiment of what not to do when you’re in the position the Aussies were in yesterday.
Instead of adjusting his shot and playing a solid defensive stroke or just padding it away, he continued with the shot that was never on and paid the price with his wicket.
Unfortunately for Wade, it’s a trend that is becoming all too regular in the whites against the red ball, with stars followed by a lapse of concentration and with poor shots littering his summer thus far and, frankly, much of his Test career.
While Australia will be grateful for the role he took in moving to the top of the order during the first two Tests – and, to be fair, he did a better job than the actual opener alongside him and maybe better than could have been expected – but it wasn’t enough, and all of his innings have finished with poor shots rather than bowlers working him over.
It’d be fair to say Jasprit Bumrah worked him over in Adelaide with no intent being shown by either Wade or opening partner Joe Burns, but the shot he played in the first innings of the Boxing Day Test was just as woeful as he looked to take Ravichandran Ashwin on across the line only to get another top edge in a similar fashion to yesterday’s dismissal.
The other two dismissals have both been LBW, with Wade almost trying to force the pace, moving across his stumps and finding space in the leg side.
While Wade’s positive intent has been a staple of Australia’s limited-overs sides and would pass muster most of the time at No. 7, it doesn’t when you’ve reinvented yourself as a batsman.
Worse than that are the positions he has got himself out in: 1-16 in Adelaide, 2-35, 4-98 in Melbourne and now yesterday’s shoddy dismissal right when Australia needed to be pushing for a par score.
At 33 years of age the selection of Wade is becoming tougher and tougher to justify. Some will point to his Test average of 31, which is an unfair reflection given how much time he has spent as a keeper batting with the tail.
But on closer inspection he is averaging only 33 since his recall to the Test team, including 29 against New Zealand last summer and 33 in the away Ashes. As a top-six batsman, that isn’t close to good enough.
Some will also point to the calibre of replacements available, and as Cameron Green struggles to adapt to Test cricket – apart from a gutsy second dig in Melbourne – there may be a point there, but the story of Travis Head presents a curious case.
Head was dropped for the Sydney Test for many of the same reasons we’re now talking about Wade.
Whether it’s playing dumb shots, not having the temperament to bat for long periods of time, not being able to play the game situation or losing concentration at crucial junctions, the excuses used to drop Head could easily be written under a different heading for Wade.
The difference between the two is that in his 19 Tests Head averages almost 40. It’s a world above Wade, and while his scores this summer were miserable against a strong Indian bowling attack, he already has two centuries and seven 50s from his 31 Test innings.
Sure, he has a tendency to throw things away, but when compared to Wade he is superior in every statistic, including age, with Head being only 27 and coming into the prime years of his career when run output for the national team should only improve.
With Will Pucovski seemingly likely to be locked in at the top of the order following his splendid half-century on debut, the middle order is an open race, with Green no certainty of locking up his spot in the long term.
Wade may get one more Test, and I don’t claim to have all the answers given Head’s run of form, but if the South Australian is going to be excused from the team for those reasons, it’s high time the selectors start to apply the same blowtorch to a 33-year-old who, while not going anywhere against the white ball, might be facing numbered days in the Test team.
For now, though, the bowlers will resume the fight today, and getting an early wicket will be pivotal after they were met with an Ajinkya Rahane and Cheteshwar Pujara stonewalling last night.
You just have to sit back and wonder how different this Test would be if Wade hadn’t played that shot and didn’t get himself out right when his country needed him to stick around.
bowledover
Roar Rookie
Usman has a been a little off the bowl in longer format... but, if you have Ussie in and I still rate him, he needs to be in your top three. Id like to see Pattinson and Jhye Richardson also used. I am not sold on Carey, I reckon we should get Inglis in the squad.
Kim Hughes 1980
Roar Rookie
Green and Pucoski should be given at least half a dozen tests. The reasons? They have more talent than most and they are very young. They are the future so we must persist with them. Guys like Wade are not the future
Kim Hughes 1980
Roar Rookie
Wade is not a top 6 test batsman. Pucovski at 5 and Harris to open in the next test Paine out and Wade to keep and bat at 7 Cummins to captain
Manuel
Guest
That’s how M Hussey came along too. Through the one dayers. Even R Ponting took a while to find his feet.
jammel
Guest
Yep, Head > Wade atm IMO. Carey to be in the squad as a second keeper, reserve batsman over Wade going forward. Wade did a great job filling in as opener - but for mine he isn't in the top 8-10 batsmen in Australia. Things look good for Australia at the moment - Green has a lot of potential, but WPuc looked very good. He will likely be around for a long time.
jammel
Guest
Australia's best XI for mine in Test cricket is the following - I am keen to see Pattinson play more (ideally in place of a recently way-ward Starc). Warner Pucovski Labuchagne Smith Khawaja (or Head realistically in the longer term). I do still think that UTK is in the top 5 or 6 batsmen in Australia rn Green (he has everything needed to succeed - looks so much better than MMarsh in a high pressure environment IMO) Paine C+ (time to start thinking about Carey as part of a succession plan?) Pattinson (or Starc if he regains form) Cummins - awesome Lyon Hazlewood - awesome Reserves: Starc/Pattinson, J Richardson, Head, Maxwell, Carey
jammel
Guest
Yep - Maxwell would be a great option. The only guy we have in the middle order who could come in and play a Gilchrist (or Pant)-style innings, as we saw today from R Pant! More opportunities for Maxi in the red ball game!! He is a better bat than Harris Wade MMarsh........
Peter Farrar
Roar Pro
Given Wade's achievements at Shield level I'd hoped he may have achieved more. His willingness to take a blow to the body from the ball worries me in that it suggets he doesn't have a full range of effective shots on offer and has to resort to risking injury. Getting shot selection right remains a challenge for him, although I cut some slack for him whilst an opener and in an unfamiliar role. I'm sure he'll be retained for the Brisbane test but if he doesn't score there, he will begin to experience the scrutiny Joe Burns did.
Cadfael
Roar Guru
He was fined.
Cadfael
Roar Guru
Because it could ber taken as umpire abuse which could easily see a fine or suspension.
Steele
Roar Rookie
I just think with a weak number five and rookie number six, we can’t forget Paine is a 1980’s standard keeper batsman. We should be pushing for a keeper that can average 40. That’s the world standard. Yes good with the gloves, but he hasn’t registered a single ton yet and we’ve needed him to a few times. Cummins or Lyon can lead, they ain’t getting dropped any time soon.
Ben Palliyaguru
Roar Rookie
Head is the future. I'd play him over Wade in the fourth test
Micko
Roar Rookie
Oh, and should note that Glen Jakovich was a star forward in the WAFL for South Freo, then changed into a Centre Half Back for West Coast in the AFL.
Micko
Roar Rookie
Jacob Dragovich was one of their best players in last year’s premiership year. The breakthrough 1997 premiership year saw a bizarre thing where Peter Sumich (an AFL full forward) played as a key defender, and Jon Dorotich (an AFL full back) played as a key forward! Outside Fremantle Oval is a statue of John Gerovich taken from a famous photo of a screamer of a mark he was renowned for often taking. :thumbup:
Micko
Roar Rookie
Not the sharpest bloke around is he?
Micko
Roar Rookie
Never been the sharpest tool around our mate Wade! :silly:
matth
Roar Guru
Warner was not really fit for this test, but we were a little bit desperate
matth
Roar Guru
You had me until Carey for Paine. Paine is our leader and definitely a better keeper and his batting is fine for a seven
matth
Roar Guru
As an eye player, Maxi’s eye isn’t going to get any better from here. This has been a 5 to 7 year opportunity missed.
MCPC
Roar Rookie
If you’re reeling off big scores nobody is temporary. Make a enough runs & selectors simply cannot drop you. Wade must be absolutely kicking himself. If he just plays like an opener there & lets Smith tear it up he’ll just scratch his way through to a solid score. Instead he goes for the Party Trick !