Spin pair Adam Zampa and Ashton Agar have been key to Australia’s T20 resurgence so it was odd to see captain Aaron Finch seemingly lose faith in them as the Aussies were beaten by New Zealand on Monday.
Zampa and Agar sent down just five overs combined as Finch instead employed part-timers Glenn Maxwell and Marcus Stoinis, with Australia using a whopping seven bowlers.
It was a surprising move by Finch after Australia made a commanding start, reducing the Kiwis to 3-19. Particularly so given the strong faith the skipper has previously shown in this spin combo.
Zampa and Agar have consistently choked the run rate in the middle overs over the past two years, helping Australia earn an excellent T20 record in that period of 11 wins and 6 losses.
Agar was crowned Australia’s T20 Player of the Year for 2020, and owns a sensational career record, averaging 21 with the ball at a miserly economy rate of 6.94 runs per over.
Zampa, meanwhile, is probably Australia’s most valuable T20 bowler. He rarely gets collared, regularly troubles world-class batsmen, and displays uncommon calm under pressure.
Adam Zampa. (Photo by Gareth Copley/Getty Images for ECB)
Zampa and Agar are the world’s number 5 and 6 ranked T20 bowlers, respectively, further highlighting the impact they’ve had on this format in recent times.
Since he took over in mid-2018, Australian coach Justin Langer has built the T20 attack around that pair. Zampa and Agar have been the only constants in this bowling unit since then, with Australia churning through no less than 12 fast bowlers.
Mitchell Starc, Pat Cummins, Andrew Tye, Jason Behrendorff, Billy Stanlake, Josh Hazlewood, Daniel Sams, Nathan Coulter-Nile, Kane Richardson, Jhye Richardson, Sean Abbott, and Jack Wildermuth all have had a T20 run under Langer.
Australia’s pace group has changed so frequently that the bedrock provided by Zampa and Agar has been invaluable.
Despite the heavy focus on the impact of swing in Monday’s first T20 in Christchurch, it was spin that finished off Australia. Quality Kiwi slow bowlers Ish Sodhi and Mitchell Santner combined for five wickets.
Sodhi and Santner exposed Australia’s longstanding middle order weakness against spin. Australia have, for some time now, been unable to settle on a five-six batting combination because most of the candidates labour against spin.
Matthew Wade has been good up top in T20Is but clueless down lower, averaging 12 at a strike rate of 94 from his 24 matches batting in the middle order.
Fellow keeper-batsman Alex Carey has barely been better, averaging 12 at a strike rate of 117 from his 26 T20Is in the middle order.
Ben McDermott and Ashton Turner have also struggled in that role, albeit from fewer matches.
Then there’s Marcus Stoinis. Similar to Wade and Carey, Stoinis is far better suited to the top order. All three prefer to arrive at the crease with the field up and pace on the ball. Starting against spin exposes them.
Stoinis, again, looked shaky versus spin in his brief innings of 8 (11) on Monday.
As he is not competent at rotating the strike against slow bowlers, Stoinis leans heavily on boundaries.
That can work in the BBL. Against higher quality international spinners, however, manufacturing boundaries from good balls is a risky endeavour.
Yet Australia have kept playing the likes of Stoinis, Wade and Carey in middle order roles that patently didn’t suit them.
In this series they had a perfect opportunity to trial, in that role, someone who relishes facing spin. Josh Philippe is more versatile, assured and destructive against slow bowlers than any of Stoinis, Wade or Carey.
That is why Australia should be trialling Philippe in the middle order against the Kiwis. Instead they played him at first drop, despite already having a logjam of batsmen competing for top order spots – Aaron Finch, David Warner, Steve Smith, Glenn Maxwell, Wade and Stoinis.
If Australia continue to play Philippe up top, and Stoinis down low, they could waste a gilded chance to address their middle order problem ahead of this year’s World Cup.
At Christchurch, New Zealand won the spin battle.
Now Australia need to triumph in the spin war.
Ace
Roar Rookie
Middle order again. Two ducks. Not getting the good starts maybe a factor because the middle feel a little too cautious ?? I don't have the stats to hand but after 10 overs against India and Kiwis would Australia have a hundred on the board. Perhaps one match but overall?
Ian
Roar Rookie
I don't wish to sound like a nark (difficult for me but I do try!) but does anyone really care about this series? Any credibility it had was lost for me when Australia didn't send their full strength side after the South African series was cancelled.
Paul
Roar Guru
Ronan makes some excellent points. In this format, I get the impression skippers often go on gut feel, when they make decisions about who should bowl when, to keep up that level of uncertainty. I wonder if Finch isn't currently suffering from a bellyache? With his guts playing up, maybe he's struggling to come up with the right combinations. Certainly Agar & Zampa should bowl out between overs 7 and 16, unless they've been collared.
JamesH
Roar Guru
Spot on. You can't bring a guy in for his first international series and bat him in a position where he's rarely batted domestically. He was picked as a top order bat on the back of an exceptional BBL. Finch is a far better (and proven) candidate to drop down. We also need to remember that Smith (when he returns) is well suited to that middle overs role against spin. He's also shown that he can come in and score quickly enough from ball one.
Riccardo
Roar Rookie
The spinner quotient, like the teams themselves are pretty evenly matched. I'd like to see the Black Caps have more of a collective contribution with the blade however. Reckon this series may be tight but if I had to tip it would be the Black Caps at home, especially as Australia is missing Cummins and Smith. Pity this is not Test duty... sigh...
Brian
Guest
World Cup wise maybe consider Smith at No 5?
redbackfan
Roar Rookie
phillipe , maybe surprisingly, statistically actually even less of a T20 6 hitter than wade, stoinis and carey. not sure he is a lower order solution . mcdermott a chance but i dont think anyone is going to reliably come in the lower order and save the day. its nearly always about the top 4 and thats where the best batsmen will need to be
TJ
Guest
I agree that Stoinis shouldn't bat in the middle order but I think Philippe should be kept up the top. He's still young and all his success has come at the top of the order. Might be a bit unfair on him to put him in an unfamiliar position in his first few games for Australia. I'd like to see Finch drop down to 5-6 as he's had success batting their in the past (albeit from a small sample size). Would love to see this batting lineup for the next game but it's probably pretty unlikely that it happens. Wade Phillipe McDermott Maxwell Finch Marsh
The Late News
Roar Rookie
Ronan...I tend to agree with you on this one!