The competitive advantage making Melbourne an AFL premiership sleeper

By Cameron Rose / Expert

Two rounds into the AFL season, we have seen some thrilling football played.

Key forwards are kicking goals, particularly the golden oldies – hands up if you had written off Taylor Walker, Jack Riewoldt and Josh Kennedy after they had all looked finished at stages last season? They currently occupy the top three spots in the Coleman medal race.

It’s also great to see the next generation getting among the goals – Ben King, Harry McKay, Oscar Allen and Aaron Naugton have all impressed, and gee willikers does Logan McDonald look every inch a future gun.

We are certainly seeing faster ball movement and whether it is the rules themselves or the coaching mindset they have inspired is probably up for debate. Either way, it can only be a good thing.

The above has all been discussed around the various media platforms covering the game, but there is one facet of the game that has perhaps snuck under the radar.

With such an increase in inside 50s, intercept marking has become more important than it ever has been. And it has been mightily important for years.

Richmond has Dustin Martin, of course, but has won three of the last four premierships with players like Nick Vlastuin, Dylan Grimes, David Astbury, Nathan Broad, Noah Balta and Alex Rance all adept at cutting off attacking forays in the air and working harmoniously while doing so.

The only other flag won in that time was by West Coast, and Jeremy McGovern and Tom Barrass need no introduction given their marking exploits are well established. Shannon Hurn and Brad Sheppard are often underrated in this area too.

Shannon Hurn (Photo by Will Russell/AFL Media/Getty Images)

Melbourne has started 2-0 against worthy rivals not because of slick ball movement, high skill, or a multi-faceted forward-line. In fact, they struggled in those areas at times against Fremantle and St Kilda.

What the Demons have done better than any other team in the early stages of the season is control the air in defence. Jake Lever and Steven May sit second and third in the league for intercept marks after two rounds, with 17 between them. Adam Tomlinson and Max Gawn have taken another six each to be just outside the top ten.

So while Melbourne have basically broken even in the inside-50 count in their two games, and have been just okay at converting their chances, they have denied the opposition easy scores with their phalanx of talls in the back half by either cutting them off or forcing them into poorer positions to take shots.

The Tigers lead the league in inside 50s, but haven’t been able to convert that to scores the same way Port and Sydney have. Changkuoth Jiath and Blake Hardwick had a field day cutting them off on Sunday. They’ll have to find a way around Tom McCartin this week, who has started the season well.

The Power have had Aliir Aliir dominating the airwaves so far, with support from Tom Clurey and Ryan Burton, all in the top 20 for intercept marks. We know how good Tom Jonas is in this area as well. So while they have only played what will likely be the bottom two sides, they are well placed against all-comers when the big potatoes come.

Of course, pressure through the midfield and denying the opposition easy transition goes a long way. Carlton have Jacob Weitering and Liam Jones, who are both strong in the air, but there was only so much they could do against Richmond’s 75 inside 50s or the ease at which Collingwood cut a swathe through the middle of the ground.

Of the other supposed contenders, Brisbane and Greater Western Sydney have had defences well down on their expected output, particularly in the air. Harris Andrews, against high expectations, has been off his game and Jack Payne is limited at best, while we haven’t seen the best of Nick Haynes, Phil Davis and Sam Taylor at the Giants. Both teams are 0-2.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Quicker ball movement, easier transition and more inside 50s is obviously going to lead to more scoring opportunities around the competition. It therefore stands to reason that countering them is where a competitive advantage will lie for those that can do it more successfully than others.

Very early days, but Melbourne is the team leading the way in this area.

Mark them down as a sleeper for the premiership if opposition coaches can’t figure out a way to nullify their advantage.

The Crowd Says:

2021-04-02T01:59:44+00:00

Mooty

Roar Rookie


They do the same every year, build their supporters hopes up, then do a disappearing act in winter. I’ve got long suffering mates who are already talking in the negative, waiting for the collapse of form

2021-04-01T03:23:09+00:00

DEESNUTSRBIG

Guest


Its about to be 3-0. Dees will beat GWS easily. Then we have the Cats without the Dangerman and the Hawks.

2021-04-01T02:42:48+00:00

fieldy69

Roar Rookie


Dees fan here and I agree with intercepts in defense and control of the ball across the field. Tomlinson and Jetta in particular have played their parts. Also, our conversion rate into the forward 50 has also improved. While its only round 3 I wouldn't have banked on 2 wins and a very good chance against GWS this Sunday. Our pressure has also impressed, particularly against Saints who made that a feature in 2020.

2021-03-31T14:03:07+00:00

Lukey Miller

Guest


CHOCCO!

AUTHOR

2021-03-31T12:18:13+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


To my mind, a gun is not going to cease being a gun because of some rule tweaks, but it may be the next tier or two down that struggle to adapt. Which is the same point as your opening. To me, the intercept marking dominance of some has been as much a standout as the ball movement.

2021-03-31T10:49:30+00:00

George Apps

Roar Rookie


Every year there are upsets galore for the first five or six rounds until things settle, so I'm against reading too much into the form of teams after two games!

2021-03-31T08:55:39+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Yeah Petracca has entered the conversation of 'next best midfielders behind Dusty' now, in the group with Fyfe, Bont and Danger (Cripps has fallen out of this). He's very creative and he's more reliable than those players at kicking for goal. Doesn't have the same power and marking ability though, but he's brilliant.

2021-03-31T08:48:09+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Agreed Cam. I don't think our delivery and targeted area inside 50 is the problem, as much as our next kick. We keep missing very gettable goals these past few years. Sides who convert well - like Dusty (sorry, Richmond) :silly: - are successful, because of the scoreboard pressure.

2021-03-31T08:41:20+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Gee whiz, you're struggling if you're totally dependent on blokes who didn't play much last year and are missing again this year. :laughing:

2021-03-31T08:33:38+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


They’ve beaten the teams they needed to beat

2021-03-31T08:32:11+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Being very hard on brayshaw there, he finished third in the Brownlow in 2018. Langdon has started to improve, he spent the entirety of the weekend on the wing and didn’t come to the bench. That is impressive. Viney has been well down on his best but can get back there

2021-03-31T07:10:31+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


I don't think he will be for much longer. Meek and Darcy will be there all year in the ruck and Darcy, Fyfe, Sturt, Treacy, Logue are all ahead of Lobb up forward ( Logue is the big one. He is not needed in defence and will do a Naughton up front). Rory has never scored more than 16 in a season as a forward and is too easily shifted off the ball in the ruck. Good depth player.

2021-03-31T07:02:01+00:00

Puntroad

Roar Rookie


A facsimile of a facsimile of a sketch drawn by a blind man. Maybe. He’s got a long way to go.

2021-03-31T06:33:21+00:00

DarwinDee

Guest


Melbourne were missing plenty from their best line up in both rounds as well - Viney in rd 1, Harmes in rd 2, Melksham, Hibbard, Brown, Weiderman both rounds...

2021-03-31T06:26:06+00:00

DarwinDee

Guest


Yup I'm a long time Dees man and no way do I trust them - Melbourne could win 10 of their first 11 and still find a way to miss the 8.

2021-03-31T05:57:49+00:00

Kick to Kick

Guest


Interesting argument. Maybe something to it in that the new marking rule disadvantages defences so the best defenders become more valuable. Steven May, Darcy Moore, Aliir Aliir have looked impressive. However I heard an analyst in a live round 1 commentary ( may have been David King) arguing that intercept defenders who rely on the ball being bombed in long or high will need to adjust. If the new rule means the ball is coming in more quickly, flatter and faster to leading forwards who have more space, defenders who base their game on leaving their man to intercept will be found out because man on man defending, sticking close your opponent becomes the only way to stop scoring. I don’t really know who is right. It will only really shake down after more games.

2021-03-31T04:24:55+00:00

Naughty's Headband

Roar Rookie


I agree. He's that horrible modernism known as a hybrid, ala Leigh Matthews.

AUTHOR

2021-03-31T03:14:14+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


Petracca is a genuine game-shaper now, regardless of his mid-forward mix. He can make things happen from traffic in a way that no-one else can at Melbourne, and is similar to, yes, Dusty.

AUTHOR

2021-03-31T03:13:06+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


Enjoyable commentary. Yes, Jackson looks terribly awkward with his ball drop, and Jetta looks a different player this year after being awful last season. Lever has some terribly forgettable moments last year where he shirked it a couple of times, but seems back to his best.

AUTHOR

2021-03-31T03:10:58+00:00

Cameron Rose

Expert


I thought Taberner has been pretty good actually. Melbourne has beaten two teams that were largely expected to finish in that middle third of the ladder or so, so it's a huge start.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar