The NRL must even up the magic round disadvantage

By Scott Pryde / Expert

Magic round, if treated properly by the NRL, has the potential to be one of the greatest annual showcases for the competition. But right now, there is a glaring issue smacking it in the face.

Apart from the fact there is a contract with the Queensland government to ensure it won’t be leaving Brisbane anytime soon, it is grossly unfair on half the clubs who have to lose a home game to the concept.

Now, it is most certainly for the greater good of the game, and even more so if the NRL begin to use it as a promotional tool in areas without great strength in the future, taking it to places like Perth, Melbourne or even potential New Zealand cities earmarked for further expansion.

While the contract means that won’t be happening anytime soon, the first iteration of the weekend-long event saw good crowds at Brisbane’s Suncorp Stadium across all four days, and the truncation of the format to three days should keep crowds up this year, although worries over booking travel when state borders could close at the drop of a hat may impact the final numbers.

Regardless, the format of magic round undoubtedly works and should be a major boost for the tourism of an area, with NRL fans packing their bags to watch all 16 teams in one go.

It’s an opportunity that was never afforded before the beginning of the magic round, and is very unique to the weekend.

However, there is a problem with magic round. The fact of the matter is, for it to happen, and for it to be the success it is, eight teams have to give up one of their 12 home games.

While it might not be any skin off the nose for a team like the Sea Eagles, who have been taking a game per year to Brisbane for a lot longer than the magic round concept, it potentially is for plenty of other Sydney-based teams, or even the North Queensland Cowboys, who surely would prefer to play a home game in Townsville – not that they are the listed home team this Saturday, but the point still stands.

(Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

The problem is that realistically magic round is never going to be expanded beyond more than one per season, so as long as it exists, there will always be the disadvantage of having to take a game to Brisbane for eight clubs and potentially more if expansion hits the jackpot in coming years.

But there is a way to fix this, all the while knocking out two birds with one stone.

Country round.

The sport of rugby league, if some are to be believed, has a major problem in the country, with a lack of games played there, and teams on the brink across many of the competitions in the regional areas of both New South Wales and Queensland.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

So, instead of letting some clubs have 12 games at their nominated home ground, or indeed grounds, and some being forced to ship one way for magic round, those clubs who don’t have a magic round home game could then have a country round home game. This evens it out and would ensure every team has a maximum of 11 home games, while every club will also either play away in the country round or magic round.

The timing of the country round would be outside of the Origin window too, probably at the back-end of the season as the weather starts to get nicer, making for pleasant conditions if fans from the city want to have a weekend away.

The limited country games that do happen are all talked of highly by players, coaches and fans, and taking games to areas without much top-flight rugby league would be an ideal way to grow the game in the regions.

(Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

It also allows clubs to give back to the game, spending days in the area before the weekend and organising coaching clinics or open training sessions among other odds and ends.

By playing an away game in country round every second year, clubs would also be able to visit different areas while having areas they also focus on for their home games.

And it must be acknowledged that some clubs do already take games to the bush year in and year out, but the bottom line is it doesn’t happen nearly enough.

Areas like Coffs Harbour, Port Macquarie, Wagga Wagga, Albury and Orange in New South Wales and Toowoomba, Cairns, Mackay and Rockhampton in Queensland all have suitable stadiums to hold games. Meanwhile, a team like the Warriors could explore potential expansion areas in New Zealand, and the Storm could go around the state of Victoria or even take a game to Tasmania as an expansion option, noting the benefit in a venture like that not necessarily meaning it would have to be in a purely regional area.

Considering a team like the Broncos, Titans or Knights never play games in the country, this would be a great way to force the point and implore them to give back to the grassroots of the game in areas not strictly considered their own.

Magic round might be here to stay, but it’s pivotal the NRL give back to the bush and iron out the unfair advantage created by an entire round at one venue, and country round is the ideal two birds with one stone solution as we gear up for eight games in three days in Brisbane this weekend.

The Crowd Says:

2021-05-15T08:14:43+00:00

Ronald McLeay

Guest


these new rules , I know are to protect players but it has spoiled the game as a thrilling watch and the referees have been inconsistent. Each referee seems to have their own view of how the rules are read. very disappointed

2021-05-15T07:10:17+00:00

Benny

Roar Rookie


I'd love to see an FA cup style competition be brought in with the chance for local clubs to take on NRL clubs.

2021-05-14T23:05:11+00:00

Mick Simmonds

Guest


“Considering a team like the Broncos, Titans or Knights never play games in the country”. The Titans are playing in Coffs?

2021-05-14T09:24:22+00:00

Flexis

Roar Rookie


Definitely. Do you want regional games to cover the majority of the season, or three days? Starved fans will take any opportunity to see a game. There is a rainbow of jerseys in the crowd at these matches. Risking taking that away for one weekend in a confined geographical area would be a terrible outcome.

2021-05-14T08:31:34+00:00

Gray-Hand

Roar Rookie


Why don’t you offer to audit the Roosters books“ You throw down that challenge as if every NRL fan wouldn’t love to get their hands on the Roosters financial records.

2021-05-14T07:48:27+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


Lang Park - or Suncorp, is a sort of a home ground for the Sea Eagles anyway. They’ve played there a hell of a lot, and their rep players have been extra used to it. Actually Manly go Ok at Suncorp, and down the road at Robina against the GC. I can still remember Manly being beaten by GC at Brookie a few years ago, in a year when GC were a pack of bums. I’m happy to see Manly play at these grounds, and also up at Townsville. They seem to concentrate when in Qld.

2021-05-14T07:13:51+00:00

Rob

Guest


QEII was at Mt Gravatt

2021-05-14T05:27:33+00:00

zonecadet

Roar Rookie


Not sure, they do accept a lot of odd scheduling from the NRL however, from a business standpoint I wouldn't think teams outside of Sydney would really want to lose the revenue from a home game without compensation (I'm guessing there is some sort of cash trade off here) but is it good for their fans to have one less home game to attend?

2021-05-14T05:01:23+00:00

Philbert

Guest


Gladly. But to do it properly, I would need the Roosters to declare in the books all the undeclared cash in hand and under the table payments they've kept off the books....see the problem I'll have?

2021-05-14T03:23:14+00:00

Mango Jack

Roar Guru


Brisbane has its flaws but pretty sure it's worth more than $2M

2021-05-14T02:40:58+00:00

KenW

Roar Rookie


To go back 1 step, are we all settled that Magic Round is a great promotional concept? It went pretty good the first time, and this year you've probably got people very keen to travel. So it's going to feel fresh again this time and hopefully posts strong numbers. My expectation is that it will probably fizzle out in a few years once the novelty wears out though - would be happy to be wrong however. I just think the SL version works precisely because of League's smaller profile and community feel there, compared to NSW/QLD where it's by far the biggest fish in the pond, free-to-air, every backpage, etc.

2021-05-14T02:37:20+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


“Outside the cap”. Why don’t you offer to audit the Roosters books as in your esteemed opinion, they are the only team that continually breaches the cap. I’m sure with your “advanced mathematical skills”, the matter would be resolved however you would then have to find something else to whinge about.

2021-05-14T02:24:32+00:00

KenW

Roar Rookie


I suppose it makes sense for them on a few levels. They have 1 home ground - well loved by the faithful but small (not big gatetakings) and the condition of it is the butt of jokes. By taking home games away they surely make some more money and they get to make Brookvale games a bit more rare - which makes them more special for the local fans too.

2021-05-14T02:10:21+00:00

Pilferer

Roar Rookie


Is this one of those satire articles? Sydney based teams don't have to travel for most of their games, away games are still home games

2021-05-14T01:55:00+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


Cronulla home game. They had scheduled 2 games in Coffs, but the rd 4 game got moved back to Sydney

2021-05-14T01:50:16+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


Magic round was stolen from the Super League https://coupler.foxsports.com.au/api/v1/article/amp/the-nrl-wants-to-introduce-a-magic-round-where-every-game-is-played-at-the-one-stadium/news-story/4e28cb0f8bdb20cb81b3a883c2b325e9

2021-05-14T01:49:13+00:00

Mr Booze

Guest


Thoughts on Dylan Walker pleading guilty this morning, FT?

2021-05-14T01:37:52+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


And I know how busy a Westfield carpark can get on the weekend! Although isn't it usually cheaper on a Sunday?

2021-05-14T01:34:59+00:00

Bear

Guest


Souths and Penrith play at Dubbo next weekend the game has been a sellout for weeks with over 10000 tickets sold

2021-05-14T01:34:41+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


:silly:

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar