Can this NSW team win back the Origin shield?

By Angus Nicholls / Roar Rookie

Last year in historic fashion, Queensland’s ‘worst ever team’ defeated a New South Wales squad that was hotly tipped to clean sweep the Maroons.

With Queensland showcasing a never-say-die effort and true footy passion, NSW fans must often wonder how their players didn’t turn up. This pressure has been transferred to NSW Blues coach Brad Fittler, who has come under fire for his team selections.

It wasn’t the quality of the players that caused the issue with NSW fans. However, it was Fittler’s decision to choose players in unusual positions, such as the Dally M player of the year Jack Wighton (a five-eighth by trade) and Dally M fullback of the year Clinton Gutherson (a fullback for Parramatta) as his first-choice centres.

These decisions led to quite the uproar after their series loss and with Fittler’s job on the line fans will be wondering if he sticks to his ‘best players available’ selection choice or picks players off their natural positions.

1. James Tedesco
He is the first name on the team sheet and should be captain. James Tedesco is an incredible player and leader. His support play, experience and ability to organise a defence will be a key factor in deciding if NSW win or lose this series.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

2. Josh Addo-Carr
Addo-Carr is another experienced player and incredible squad personality. His finishing ability and raw speed give NSW an option out wide that won’t disappoint. Addo-Carr will look to add to his ten tries in the Origin arena.

3. Tom Trbojevic
He is in career-best form, putting up insane numbers for his club side Manly. He is a personal favourite of Fittler and an out-and-out footy player. Trbojevic won’t let NSW down.

4. Latrell Mitchell
A contentious decision for many, is this the year Mitchell returns to the Origin arena? His ability to break a game open puts him in front of the other centre options, though Fittler will have to learn to control Mitchell’s brain snaps if the Rabbitohs’ star man is to have an effective series.

5. Daniel Tupou
Tupou is a class defender and a tall body, and Fittler will feel comfortable having him battling in the air against Xavier Coates. A strong runner of the ball and an experienced big-game player, Tupou checks all the right boxes.

6. Jarome Luai
The Panthers’ combination in the halves seems to be one of the easier choices with Luai and Nathan Cleary dominating the league. With this combination, NSW might have a pairing they can use for a long time.

7. Nathan Cleary
Cleary has been one of the best if not the best player in the NRL this season and his kicking and game management will be crucial if NSW want to win the series this year.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

8. Payne Haas 
The Broncos’ metre eater starts in one of the two props spots and will bring enthusiasm to a pack that was beaten last year. Haas will look to reignite his battle with Tino Fa’asuamaleaui. He is potentially in doubt with a knee injury suffered against the Storm on Thursday night.

9. Damien Cook
Cook has some competition for his Blues jersey this year owing to his own poor form and Api Koroisau’s combinations with the aforementioned halves paring. However, Cook always seems to step into gear for the Blues and his own representative combinations with Tedesco and Cleary push him over the line.

10. Junior Paulo
Joining Payne Haas in the front row is the Parramatta wrecking ball Junior Paulo. Looking to set the tone early, these two big men bring energy that NSW desperately needs to compete with the Maroons’ pack.

11. Ryan Matterson
Perhaps one of the luckier inclusions in the squad, due to a mixture of injury and suspension, Matterson is bought into the starting pack. Solid run lines and edge defence put Matterson as a solid replacement for the suspended Angus Crichton.

12. Tyson Frizell
Frizell is a performer and a constant threat for the Blues, be that from his damaging runs or consistent effort, he is one of the few players whose club form you don’t consider. Frizell will do the job in the second row for NSW.

13. Jake Trbojevic
The oldest of the Trbojevic brothers, Jake’s ball-playing ability and defensive acumen are a key cog to this NSW machine and his link-up play with brother Tom will be one of the many dangerous combinations NSW can utilise.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

14. Jack Wighton
Wighton’s versatility places the Raiders’ star man in the 14 jersey, with options to come on across the park and bring a big body off the bench. He has the potential to cause some real problems off the bench.

15. Isaah Yeo
The Penrith lock came into Game 3 last year at centre when Gutherson was moved to cover Tedesco. This year Yeo should have the ability to come off the bench and bring in another dangerous combination with Cleary and Luai.

16. Tevita Pangai Jr
An outside bet for many, however Pangai has been playing excellent footy in an improving Broncos side and his X-factor off the bench can overturn games. Pangai is also known for making personal battles with his opposite. Expect plenty of passion from the big man off the bench.

17. Daniel Saifiti
The Newcastle enforcer rounds out the bench and forms an explosive prop rotation alongside both Haas and Paulo. Saifiti has been consistent for the Blues and adds another big body to NSW’s pack.

18. Clint Gutherson
The Eels captain is versatile and did play out of position last year, however his body isn’t as big as Wighton’s while he also has less Origin experience, so he loses out on the 14 jumper.

This group of players are unlucky to miss out due to a number of reasons and will definitely be considered options for Fittler if Game 1 doesn’t go according to the Blues’ plan: Brian To’o, Reagan Campbell-Gillard (who will be moved to bench with Saifiti starting if Haas is out), Ryan Papenhuyzen, Cameron Murray, Liam Martin, Stephen Crichton and Angus Crichton.

The Crowd Says:

2021-05-30T09:34:07+00:00

Chilli

Roar Rookie


I will take walker over both of them bloke. Outstanding footballer. It’s a bad joke if wighton gets the nod anywhere in front of Cody mate. Lui is good but doesn’t have the class of Cody yet.. which is on full display every time the Panthers score if you watch him. Poor form!!

2021-05-30T09:03:38+00:00

Jason

Roar Rookie


The bookies seem to think it will be a big NSW win :)

2021-05-30T07:28:07+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


The issue for Mitchell is attitudinal. When he's on, he's outstanding but as the author says, he has brain fades. I'm sure Walker's in consideration, but I guess it's where he is on the pecking order.

2021-05-30T06:45:06+00:00

Bunney

Roar Rookie


I don't understand how much flak Fittler has copped for selecting Wighton as a centre. Sure, he didn't play great, and missed a number of tackles, but the dominant narrative that explains the misses as due to him playing out of position is a crock. Firstly, heaps of 5/8's have successfully moved to the centres for periods - Fittler himself and Laurie Daley, Brent Kenny, and this season, Matt Burton. Secondly, Wighton started life as a centre! Grew up a centre and played his first few seasons as centre, even making City vs Country teams as centre. Thirdly, Tom Turbo is a lock for right side centre and Latrell is fave for left side. Both fullbacks. Hmmmm.

2021-05-30T05:19:33+00:00

Joey

Guest


Pretty clear that when QRL make a demand, the NRL buckles.

2021-05-30T03:41:46+00:00

Graham

Guest


Game 1 will be pretty important for the blues since QLD are without Papali and Kaufusi and perhaps a few others If QLD play their full forward pack it could be something to behold on their day

AUTHOR

2021-05-30T03:18:52+00:00

Angus Nicholls

Roar Rookie


Hey guys, really like the discussion and how people are making their own teams! adds even more thoughts to my head! It will certainly be interesting to see how game 1 pans out!

AUTHOR

2021-05-30T03:17:27+00:00

Angus Nicholls

Roar Rookie


Realistically the Luai decsion comes as a two parter. I think Cleary will play his best with his halves partner and Cleary playing well is the difference between this NSW team winning or them looking a shambles. The second is Luai himself brings alot of energy into a halves dressing room that doesn't seem to have it. Last year there was major criticism given to Walker and Keary and i feel like it might be time for a shake up. {also not saying the criticism wasn't warranted or that Luai won't get any} Again I agree that NSW need to stop the chop and change. It will be this series where they decide on their longterm partner for Cleary. Paulo is one of those players where he can bring so much from the first whistle or off the bench. Origin is won on strong forwards and the battle of the pack and that's why i want Paulo to start, to win that battle early and let the creative juices of Luai and Cleary flow. Finucane is unfortunately looking a-lot like surplus. still would be solid to have in the overall squad/in camp however a run of things would have to go his way to get selected.

2021-05-30T03:15:18+00:00

Chilli

Roar Rookie


Crichton over Latrell??… I’m bias mate but as much as Crichton is a good young player no doubt, he has a way to go before he can lace his shoes with the likes of Latrell & Trjbovic I also don’t understand why Walker is not half or 14 locked in no argument. He is quite obviously one of the top players in the NRL and has been incredible all season. Cleary still hasn’t dominated origin yet but we keep picking players around him… I have no doubt of his ability at all mind you but facts are facts.

AUTHOR

2021-05-30T03:08:54+00:00

Angus Nicholls

Roar Rookie


I have always felt Klemmer should be picked but as you said whilst Freddy is the coach I can't see it happening. I am a big fan of the way the Frizell plays origin, he seems to really knuckle down whilst in that Blues jersey. Wightons bigger body and experience makes the 14 choice very hard however if Luai doesn't impact the game in the way expect Wighton can fill that role more than sufficiently. I picked Yeo just on my decision to have Luai and Cleary so that Panthers combo. Murray could easily be selected. The TPJ pick was my favourite as he also has a personal vendetta against another player. It's happened every-time he has played Fifita and i think he is a risk well worth taking.

2021-05-30T03:01:38+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


I'm hoping Freddy sees sense and leaves Mitchell out. There's at least one centre (Crichton) playing in position and at least as well. The problem for Freddy if Cleary doesn't come good is simple; who do they choose instead? As you say, he really needs to step up when the Maroons stick it to the Blues - and they will.

AUTHOR

2021-05-30T03:01:37+00:00

Angus Nicholls

Roar Rookie


Cody was a very close second for 18th man however it comes down to versatility for me and Gutho can play nearly everywhere!

AUTHOR

2021-05-30T02:59:53+00:00

Angus Nicholls

Roar Rookie


Without a doubt the Melbourne game venue will be a big talking point. If it is played in Townsville NSW will have a big mountain to climb.

2021-05-30T02:51:08+00:00

Kerry Hanson

Guest


I remember in one of the games last year that Fizzle was MIA almost the whole game . He’s unstoppable when he’s unstoppable, but seems to be unstartable a lot if the time .

2021-05-30T02:47:49+00:00

Kerry Hanson

Guest


Mitchell is a fair weather bully . He goes MIA when it’s trench warfare , and origin nearly always is . I’d put my house in it that he will go missing when he’s needed the most . As far as Cleary is concerned, if he doesn’t step up this year and take control when NSW are up against it , he will be Mitchell Pearce 2.0.

2021-05-30T02:44:04+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


Not a bad team except for Mitchell. Until he has an attitude alteration and gets over his laziness he shouldn't even be on the long list. Crichton or Burton for the other centre spot. You are being generous to Tyson Frizell giving him a place in the team. He's the bloke who bludged for Saints then left because he wants to win a premiership with Newcastle, but he's a bludger at the Knights as well.

2021-05-30T02:10:09+00:00

Lance Boil

Roar Rookie


The first whistle hasn't been blown and the sulking has already started!

2021-05-30T01:41:04+00:00

Succhi

Roar Rookie


I just had a look at the possible QLD team - going to be a close series. Key factor will be where that Melbourne game is played.

2021-05-30T01:16:42+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


There's no way Latrell Mitchell should get a game ahead of Crichton. The fact the author thinks Freddy needs "to learn to control his brain snaps" says it all. The other issue some of these guys need to deal with is the intensity and we've seen already that Cleary has struggled with that. I think he's a better player now but not sure how Luai would cope. Sure he's a great attacking player but his defence would be something the Maroons would target forsure.

2021-05-30T01:14:22+00:00

farkurnell

Roar Rookie


TB I like this team except the bench - Jack and TPV ,although great in attack there defence is suss.I much pefer Gutho and either Finucane, RCG or Murray

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar