Each AFL team's burning question after Round 15

By Doran Smith / Roar Guru

Without questions being asked there isn’t any way of evolving and adapting to improve.

No team is perfect so it was an interesting exercise: what’s the burning question for each AFL team in season 2021 based on their Round 15 performance?

Adelaide Crows: are the Crows a good team?
The Crows are building something. They could’ve beaten the Blues in order to keep their slight hopes of playing finals alive. It was an honourable loss against the Blues.

They played some good footy and were up for the fight, even though they didn’t get the four points.

Brisbane Lions: did the Lions play the game like it was a grand final?
There’s no doubt that the Lions put everything into the game, which was reflected by Lachie Neale shaking off an injured shoulder; it’s a marathon, not a sprint. They beat the Cats comprehensively.

Carlton Blues: is the review going to be a good decision?
The review could be the catalyst for a resurgent Blues if their Round 15 performance is anything to go by.

They showed plenty of character and it’s great to see that they may be keeping David Teague as coach for the foreseeable future. On the surface, the fact that they won in Round 15 indicates that the review should be positive.

Collingwood Magpies: how was Robert Harvey’s audition for the job on a permanent basis?
It was okay; the Magpies were extremely competitive. The result of the game was impacted by a free kick given against Brayden Maynard and a subsequent 50 metre penalty that was deemed by many people to be a dubious free kick.

Essendon Bombers: can Essendon be a dark horse?
There’s no doubt that if the Bombers string some wins together that they can be a dark horse.

They play a fantastic brand of footy; they were just unfortunate to come up against a Demons team with a ruthless and organised defence. The Bombers only lost the game by 11 points.

Fremantle Dockers: are Fremantle in the mix?
The Dockers are definitely in the conversation when it comes to teams that can play finals. They won against the Magpies without their captain, Nat Fyfe.

Geelong Cats: are the Cats flexible enough?
Some people may take it as a one-off. There’s no doubt that Mitch Duncan is a massive loss for them.

Gold Coast Suns: how’s the Suns’ morale?
Despite the fact they lost to the bottom of the ladder Kangaroos, the fact is that the Suns played for their coach and performed admirably.

Stuart Dew (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)

Greater Western Sydney Giants: is the Giants’ recruiting really that good?
There’s no doubt that the Giants have deficiencies. They definitely need to recruit at least one more key defender as they are relying heavily of Nick Haynes in that department. There’s no doubt they need to make alterations to their list.

Hawthorn Hawks: have Hawthorn underachieved based on their Round 15 performance?
The Hawks have definitely underachieved from a win-loss perspective, but there’s plenty to be positive about for the Hawks coaching staff, players and fans.

There’s no doubt that they have a good mix between youth and experience and given the way they played in Round 15, they should be higher on the AFL ladder than second last. Despite that, there’s a lot to look forward to.

Melbourne Demons: are the Demons too reliant on their defence?
The Demons rely heavily on Steven May and Jake Lever, just to name a couple of defenders. Their defence is difficult to dissect for opposition teams. That’s all it boils down to.

North Melbourne Kangaroos: is there light at the end of the tunnel?
When you look at the likes of Nick Larkey and Cameron Zurhaar, you have to say yes.

Despite that, they lost a game that appeared to be unlosable. Clearly, the influence of Robbie Tarrant, who has come back from injury, has added to the group and they are more resilient.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Port Adelaide Power: are they contenders?
The Power allowed Lance Franklin to give the Swans more than a glimmer of hope in the final quarter; there’s still some work to do. They definitely had a better structure with Scott Lycett in the ruck, who kicked what proved to be the match-winning goal.

Richmond Tigers: is it all over for the Tigers?
Judging the Tigers on their Round 15 performance, they won’t feature in finals. They were disjointed and they don’t have the depth to cover for their injuries. There’s plenty of concerns for them; their severe loss to a Saints team out of form may not an aberration.

St Kilda Saints: is Brett Ratten the right man for the job?
There’s no arguing that Ratten is the man to take the Saints forward, despite their current predicament; it’s highly unlikely they will play finals this season, but the players played for him in what proved to be an upset win against the Tigers.

Sydney Swans: Buddy brilliant!
There was one player, Lance ‘Buddy’ Franklin, who nearly willed the Swans over the line in the final quarter. The fact is that the Swans lost a game that would’ve nearly ensured that they play finals in season 2021.

There’s plenty of excuses that can be made, because of the current circumstances. At the end of the day, the game could be a season-defining game, because they showed immense character, despite losing the game to the Power.

West Coast Eagles: are the Eagles going backwards?
From an outsider’s perspective, it would appear as if the Eagles are off the pace. They actually went backwards against the Bulldogs in Round 15.

The Eagles came up against an exceptional team, so it’s a wait and see, but there’s plenty of work to do to regain the synergy and game plan viable for them to make the top eight.

Western Bulldogs: will the Bulldogs transcend footy?
The manner in which the Bulldogs played in Round 15 showed what an outstanding system and style of footy they are playing; it’s mesmerising and hypnotic.

It looks as if they know where the next player is and effortlessly handle the ball. They played in a manner that people who don’t follow footy may take an interest in!

The Crowd Says:

2021-06-29T09:35:17+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


That's okay - - just being picky. Kinda torn watching........we don't really need "W"s; kinda like the idea of a #1 draft pick but in reality #2 or #3 is still pretty good and reduces pressure. Very happy with our progress - - and just want the kids managed through the year. Larkey and Zurhaar are actually coming good in their own right - - in recent years they were at their most dangerous with Brown as a valid #1 forward. Obviously Larkey is growing up - - but we're using the forward structure a smidge better but still one tall short - - even when pushing Goldie or Xerri deep forward. Very happy with Tarryn Thomas - - lost a lot of development last year with his ankle. Hoping very much for Garner to return again now after his rolled ankle and finish off the year ready to hit next year off a full pre-season. Backline is interesting - - McKay coming along great; Walker a bit of a stop gap - and Tarrant near the end. Clearly Corr and Bonar need to get right.....probably give up on 2021.

2021-06-29T00:43:53+00:00

Bangkokpussey

Roar Rookie


I think Mitch Duncan's loss is underestimated. From memory he missed at least the first 4 or five matches. Geelong was 3W and 2L and probably should have been 4 and 1. He is not the whole reason but is the hardest Geelong midfielder to replace IMO.

2021-06-28T10:37:29+00:00

Charlie Keegan

Roar Guru


Melbourne are playing like a Paul Roos coached side. They aggressive flood back when the flow of play is against them and there was about two or three holding the ball calls in front of goal last weekend.

2021-06-28T08:58:02+00:00

Mr Right

Roar Rookie


No doubt the Hawks have underachieved. They were easily beaten by both North & the Suns. Their disposal has been horrendous in various games. The best outcome going forward would to be more competitive against the top teams, a few wins & an early draft pick.

AUTHOR

2021-06-28T06:02:04+00:00

Doran Smith

Roar Guru


Sorry I left out the word ('nearly') "lost a game." I wasn't negative at all. I praised Larkey, Zurhaar and Tarrant. There's some slight improvement and as stated "light at the end of the tunnel."

2021-06-28T05:32:49+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


Ah.....just reading through - as a North Supporter...........and kinda feeling you've gone more negative on us than you ought to: "Despite that, they lost a game that appeared to be unlosable. Clearly, the influence of Robbie Tarrant, who has come back from injury, has added to the group and they are more resilient." Not sure a "win" counts as losing a game. Just sayin'. I'm not really looking for too much credit but wouldn't mind just that smidge of credit.

2021-06-28T04:18:30+00:00

Roger of Sydney

Roar Rookie


I thought the Swans controlled more of the game than Port. We lost it in the rain in the second quarter with multiple inside 50's and multiple dropped marks. We really miss the speed of Dave Warner and Heeney looked like he as injured or off with the fairies. A wasted opportunity and now the pressure is on

2021-06-28T01:34:52+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


The Blues have Freo this week, then Geelong, Collingwood, North, St Kilda and the Suns in Melbourne before finishing with Port away and GWS at home - you would have to say we would start strong favourites against North and the Suns and getting 2 wins from Freo, Pies and Saints wouldn't be impossible (especially if C Curnow comes back). As for pre-season expectations - I reckon we are probably 2 games behind where I hoped to be (losing to Collingwood and blowing a good lead against the Bulldogs really hurt) but given it was clear every side above the Blues last year apart from Collingwood had improved their lists it was always going to be a tough ask to make finals.

2021-06-28T01:12:09+00:00

Ben Elvy

Roar Rookie


Still below par based on expectations at season start? Good to have something to cheer about but doubling wins by season end is another thing

2021-06-28T01:11:08+00:00

Ben Elvy

Roar Rookie


Inspired v inspiring? That Q4 tackle in the goal square was fairly inspiring. As a Sydney-sider, I was surprised to hear non-core fans talking about that instead of the upcoming Origin game. That’s inspirational!

2021-06-27T23:53:18+00:00

Macca

Roar Rookie


I can't see the review at Carlton being a bad thing but given the blues fixture going forward I wouldn't be surprised to see them end up on 9 or 10 wins for the year which is hardly a disasterous season.

2021-06-27T23:29:35+00:00

fabian gulino

Roar Rookie


The Gold Coast sun's are going fast to a deadend. Every year they get early wins and everything is looking Rosie.then 2nd half of the season comes along and they then put the cue in the rack and expect the AFL to bail them out again. They have to stand up and start thinking of finals.they have a very strong core of players.

2021-06-27T22:56:56+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


"Buddy Brilliant"- Buddy is an absolute star. At the start of the season when I heard Swans don't need Buddy I laughed.... Wonder whether those people are thinking otherwise now? Without Buddy on the weekend, the Swans lose by 4-6 goals.

2021-06-27T22:31:57+00:00

The Sports Lover

Roar Rookie


I was very impressed with the Swans. I was at the game and the Swans were courageous. Port had their hands full all night as the Swans kept swarming. On another point, I’m surprised at the hype surrounding Buddy’s Q4 goals. Yes, he did his job but I wouldn’t say he “ ….inspired….” the fight back.

2021-06-27T20:39:14+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


“the fact is that the Suns played for their coach and performed admirably‘ Interesting observation. I thought they looked woeful. Disinterested and sub-standard in the skills department.

Read more at The Roar