For the sake of argument, what constitutes a sport?

By StuMac / Roar Rookie

Over many years now, myself, and a number of work friends, acquaintances and colleagues, have taken part in robust debate on the subject of just what constitutes a sport.

These ‘discussions’ have normally resulted in all participants agreeing to disagree on the exact definitions, and almost always conclude with all involved turning on yours truly. How did it come to this?

Well, the advent of pay-TV, and subsequent free-to-air dedicated sports channels has seen an exponential rise in the number of events broadcast under the umbrella of ‘sports’.

Whereas these ‘events’ would generally once be classified as nothing more than glorified recreation, this explosion in television coverage has allowed them to be broadcast to the general public under the guise of sporting competition, when really they are simply a way of filling the gaps between when the real sports commence.

I say enough is enough. As a way of drawing a line in the sand (and also to save me having to repeat myself), I have decided to outline, once and for all, the key criteria for why some activities should be correctly labeled sports, and others should be labeled anything but.

This criteria should provide the proverbial ‘final nail in the coffin’ for any further discussion on the matter.

While I would not be so brazen as to suggest that this list of criteria is absolute, I do believe that it provides a clear set of measures, against which all physical activities can be judged accordingly.

(Photo by Lisa Blumenfeld/Getty Images)

So, without further ado, here it is:

1. A sport is not something that can be subjectively judged, i.e points awarded from a particular range, based on a group of people’s opinion who have been deemed eligible to judge.

2. A sport is not something that has the sole intention of maiming the other participants, i.e boxing, martial arts, UFC or any other event where people attempt to inflict intentional damage on each other.

3. A sport needs to involve a range of actions which require not only specific hand-eye coordination but also multiple skills used at the same time, i.e running, throwing, kicking, catching, hitting etc.

4. A sport is not something that exists for the sole purpose of gambling, i.e horse racing.

5. A sport does not rely on external factors beyond the participants control to determine the result, i.e motor-racing of any kind, whereby mechanical failure, as opposed to individual skill level, generally influence the outcome.

6. A sport is not something which determines the fastest over a distance, who can lift the most, who can jump the highest, or who can throw the furthest. These are simply activities.

7. A sport does require some level of physical fitness, is generally played outdoors and does contain the risk of injury through over training or over exertion during its participation. Yes, darts and billiards: I am looking in your direction…

8. A sport is not something you can do while consuming alcohol or smoking cigarettes. Oh, darts and billiards, are you still here?

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

9. A sport generally does not end in the letters ‘ing’. For example, swimming, running, cycling, skiing, etc.

These are simply recreational activities. And no, putting them altogether does not create some kind of loophole in the rules. Yes, triathlon, decathlon, pentathlon and anything essentially ending in ‘thlon’, you’re not fooling anybody.

10. A sport needs to involve the scoring of points through either placing a ball or similar shaped object into a net, over a net, in a hole, towards a boundary, over a line, through a goal, over a fence, or into a specified playing area as set down by the rules.

Depending on the sport, this can be via the use of equipment (sticks, bats, racquets etc.), or through the specified appropriate parts of human anatomy.

11. A sport is something that can be used in the context of, “Let’s go have a game of x”, or “Do you want to play x?”.

Now, some of the more antagonistic among you, may suggest that any number of board games could be added in to complete these sentences. If so, then please let me direct you to points 7 and 8.

So, there you have it. The final drizzle of chocolate sauce, on top of the cherry, on top of the cream, sitting on top of the cookies and cream cheesecake that is my argument. A clear and indisputable list that essentially provides the final word on what has been one of the longest-running and most passionate discussion topics known to man.

And before you all start typing feverishly, or pushing your chairs back ready to pay me a little visit, I ask that you just take a couple of minutes to let my points wash over you. If you do this, I believe you will finally see things the way they are meant to be seen.

I now leave you to ponder how these revelations will forever change the way you watch sport both now, and into the future.

The Crowd Says:

2021-08-27T01:36:00+00:00

Striderflynn

Guest


So you mean to say that my wife's messing with my head is not actually a sport?

2021-08-24T23:05:43+00:00

Stu W

Guest


Brilliant, no sports here to see! Enjoy what you enjoy.

2021-08-23T15:09:16+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


To mark the boundary line! :silly:

2021-08-23T15:05:05+00:00

Ruairidh MacDonald

Roar Rookie


Why does a line need to be drawn?

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T09:14:15+00:00

StuMac

Roar Rookie


Nope. Please see Rule 9.

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T09:10:55+00:00

StuMac

Roar Rookie


Well it’s not like I worked on it for weeks or devoted an Honours degree on the topic, it has just always been an interesting topic to me, and has always created robust discussion whenever it is raised. Sure, it is my perception or interpretation, and doesn’t take away from the fact that those activities that are not sports (by my ‘definition’) certainly require talent, fitness, practise, technique etc, it’s just that a line needs to be drawn somewhere. But hey, it’s just a bit of fun.

AUTHOR

2021-08-23T09:02:00+00:00

StuMac

Roar Rookie


Well, I am not sure we should hold the Olympics up as being the bastion of all that is right. I mean they recognise chess and bridge as being ‘sports’. Can’t wait for Hungry Hungry Hippos to be a demonstration ‘sport’ in 2040….

2021-08-23T04:34:39+00:00

The Big T

Guest


I think it's hilarious that so many people feel so strongly about this topic and that as the king on the top of that heap you thought to write this article StuMac! I think you've built the rules to make ball sports the only acceptable activities to be called 'sports'. I bet you're a card carrying member of an AFL or NRL team aren't you Stumac? Which is fine, just a guess on my part. For my 2 cents worth, I think any activity that makes one person strive to beat another at any given physical endeavour should be called a sport. I prefer when the technology element is taken out but at the end of the day, it's someone's choice to participate in a 'sport' that is more difficult to win because of the additional non-human factors. Good article summing up a favourite office banter topic!

2021-08-23T02:56:11+00:00

Georgia Jeffrey

Guest


Is cycling a sport?

2021-08-23T02:52:42+00:00

Georgia Jeffrey

Guest


Good job mate, love the work :thumbup:

2021-08-23T01:38:04+00:00

George

Guest


No wonder everyone turns on you about this StuMac You're trying to make rules for others' perceptions based on your own perceptions. Good luck with that. Your article also disputes international definitions of sports. The Olympics has it all wrong according to you. Hmmm

2021-08-23T01:04:50+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


You’ve defined ball sports, well done.

2021-08-22T15:09:58+00:00

James Green

Roar Rookie


Dunno. I guess I tend to the Red Symons definition of whether it fits into one of the three Fs: fleeing, fighting or flouncing. Also, upon re-reading the list, it seems your definition is basically: does it involve a ball or ball like object? Rule 10 would basically be rule one and no need for the rest of the rules.

2021-08-22T09:33:27+00:00

Ruairidh MacDonald

Roar Rookie


On the one hand, I agree with some of your rules (1, sort of 4, 5). One the other hand, it makes me ask: why bother? And I don't mean it personally, because I've also drawn up my own set of rules (no subjectivity, only human powered, technology can't make a significant difference, must involve some fatigue/exertion), I mean it in relation to the general thought-exercise. Why bother trying to create such strict, theoretical delineations for things if it's just talk, if nothing depends on it? There's a whole bunch of things: some things are more similar to these things than those things, what's the point of creating a set of rules just to let us say these things are "things" but those things aren't "things"? Is it to say that your set of "things" is better than all the other non-"things"? I think that's subconsciously I did when I created my rules, what about you?

AUTHOR

2021-08-22T09:10:34+00:00

StuMac

Roar Rookie


No, no loophole there. Karate and similar activities would be cancelled out due to Rule 10. ;-)

2021-08-22T03:58:13+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


You're not allowed to main your opponent in karate. At the Olympics, one participant was disqualified for knocking his opponent out. Is this a loophole for rule 2?

2021-08-22T03:23:01+00:00

Campbell Ross

Roar Rookie


This is a wonderful topic to bring up at a dinner party. Sport is simple - two participants/teams aim to score a point by controlling a common object (usually a ball) that belongs to neither team, into a scoring zone. A list of 'competitions' include all athletics and swimming disciplines, or anything where the opponents are simply comparing 'times' or 'weights' etc. I love the topic and have caused many arguments over it. Good stuff all 'round!

2021-08-22T00:44:46+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


could you be any more sanctimonious?

AUTHOR

2021-08-22T00:26:53+00:00

StuMac

Roar Rookie


Nope. Not related to what happened in Sydney at all.

2021-08-21T23:12:33+00:00

BLACKTOWN

Roar Rookie


Is this whole article about the 2 horses that died yesterday ar Sydney if so just write about that.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar