What a balanced All Black loose forward trio can deliver

By Highlander / Roar Guru

Archimedes said give me a lever long enough and a fulcrum to place it on and I shall move the world.

It took until the end of year tour and coming up against a weakened Wales for the All Black coaching team to accept that setting a similar rock solid platform should take precedence over the long range hit and run tactics which have dominated selection and game plans in 2021.

Wales were certainly impacted, more from injuries than the Test window issue, but they started a strong tight five missing the late withdrawal of Ken Owens, while Ross Moriarty and Aaron Wainwright. In the back row, Ethan Blackadder and Dalton Papalii were well covered from a Test caps perspective.

Taking this head on, there was a clear change of mindset from the All Blacks on Saturday, hard at set piece, super hard at the breakdown, and to use the cliché, earn the right to go wide, and they did.

The selection of Papalii and Blackadder in tandem consigned to the bin the ideological shoehorning into the trio of the wide-ranging loose forward, one which was horribly but predictably exposed against the World Cup holders at both breakdown and tackle time, and the tandem hard at the ruck on-ballers and big hitting tacklers showed what we had been missing the rest of this year.

Dalton Papalii was perfect in his tackle count again with the noticeable tweak in style, unlike prior outings in the 7 shirt where he played more like a blindside, this time we saw him playing more Cane-like, out in front of the line, pressuring the Welsh 9 and 10, making his tackles on the other side of the gain line and creative with ball-in-hand.

Add to this the perpetual motion of workhorse and serial pest, Ethan Blackadder, and the darkness had a platform to play off that was unrivalled this year.

But most importantly, they looked like a partnership, at ruck time, in support running and in re-setting the post at ruck-time, they looked to be in sync.

By my count at least two of the loose forwards arrived together at no fewer than 18 offensive rucks in that first half, another big step up from the rugby championship. Ruck defence wasn’t perfect, but it was a whole lot better than of late.

Worth a mention here for Ardie Savea, he joined in selectively at ruck and tackle time with his two flankers, but the single most important element was his ability to stay in structure.

With Papalii and Blackadder dominating at tackle time and on the ground, it would be easy to wander, but Savea stayed narrow, made all his key runs in the early part of this game straight into the teeth of the defence, ( 6 runs for 32 metres in the first half), only popping up out in the tram tracks with the razzle dazzle stuff once the hour mark had passed and gainline was firmly under control.

With a firm base to play off and keeping connection with those around him, Ardie is almost unstoppable.

The TJ Peranara try was an excellent example of this coordinated gain line focused loose forward trio.

From 2.52 on the clip we see a Blackadder gain line carry, Papalii arrives for the cleanout and Savea gets the final carry and off load for the halfback to go over. (What isn’t on the tape is one prior carry and offensive cleanout from Blackadder and Papalii respectively)

Balance and combinations are always more important than individual skills in the back row, and we saw some really promising signs from this trio as a combination.

The remaining forwards were clearly on a mission of sorts, Wyn Jones et al would not have been expecting the scrum squeeze that came their way, Sam Whitelock demonstrated why his absence in Australia had such an impact, both at offensive and defensive lineouts, while the workload of the front row across the park was a real step in the right direction.

With dominance up front TJP got a free ride at halfback, Beauden Barrett was unmolested as he ran free and rest of the back-line chimed in, in what was largely a low error display.

(Photo by Joe Allison/Getty Images)

Barrett’s first intercept was an excellent example of defence forcing the error out of Gareth Anscombe.

Stop this clip at the 17-second mark and you can see where the pressure comes from.

Codie Taylor has played the openside flanker role off the back of the lineout and pressured Anscombe, Papalii has the narrow runner covered, Havalii has taken the two out runner leaving Barrett free to drift into the gap and pick the pass off.

A couple of closing observations, I am increasingly liking the defence of Anton Leinart-Brown and if he is to be the man that we build that backline defence around lets make sure he is not moved. I was sent an interesting snippet last week, Conrad Smith played 94 Tests, starting in 90 – how many times did he wear the 12 shirt?

Not once is my correspondent’s assertion, and he is a normally reliable source, so no more shuffling. If he is to be our centre – anoint him, and leave him there, and solve for 12 separately.

I for one am hoping that two recent trends can be consigned to history on this tour.

We have no need for the wide playing flanker in a pack that has Dane Coles/Codie Taylor, Ardie Savea and Brodie Retallick, and neither Beauden Barrett or Richie Mo’unga need a second play maker in the side if we have Aaron Smith/Brad Weber and the back three which started this test.

They are a distraction and unbalance the side to the overall detriment. Time to bin both these theories and see how we go against Ireland and France.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2021-11-03T20:37:53+00:00

Francisco Roldan

Roar Rookie


Hi Highlander, good tracking on these men ...! They are truly remarkable and make a difference in every gesture that involves them in the game. I recognize your mention of blackadder's discomfort with the ball as I saw him run sideways and hesitantly on two occasions, with no expectations of territorial gain. The NZL breakdown maintains his stature, at least relative to TRCH2021 (94% effective). But he keeps ruck penalties in better perspective. I think that the dynamics of the game, its speed, is a goal to be overcome permanently and is the main "asset" that the AABB have. Greetings.

2021-11-02T00:12:55+00:00

Buk

Roar Rookie


Havili a very talented footballer, but you are really missing a big 12 or 13 who, when the defence is tight, can cart the ball upfield effectively, or at least hold his own, in the manner of Nonu or SB Williams. I think expecting Havili to do that close quarter stuff effectively is unfair, given his weight. Mounga or Barrett, & Lienart-Brown, are all relative lightweights. Also a shortcoming in the Wallabies when Kerevi is absent; I would recall Kuridrani as a like-for-like replacement, despite is Super form dipping. Clogged midfield defences are a frequent fact of life in the current game.

2021-11-01T21:20:32+00:00

Pinetree

Roar Rookie


I really thought PUJ was unlucky to not get more game time. and I think they probably value Proctors off the ball work more, which puts up a conundrum deciding best ball in hand player vs best good positioning and off the ball work player This is obviously only my speculation, but I think the AB coaches have told PUJ to work on his off the ball game and positioning to get back into consideration. I think C Clarke is in the same boat. Both those players offer so much power, and I think they just need develop a more rounded game, and they will be very good players.

2021-11-01T21:12:40+00:00

Tony

Guest


Re Taine Welsh - Because it wasnt an AB !!!

2021-11-01T20:54:10+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


Well written and bang on with all points. It’ll mean some good players won’t get a lot of game time but that’s always been the AB way and I see no need to change it. Feel sorry for a player like DMac. Good but not good enough - bad luck

AUTHOR

2021-11-01T20:26:50+00:00

Highlander

Roar Guru


SA used that tactic this year

AUTHOR

2021-11-01T20:25:28+00:00

Highlander

Roar Guru


I am firmly in the Jacobson camp, and he is a specialist 6, who is used to playing in tandem with Cane. Don’t think anything changes if he plays vs Wales There is some real competition for spots now, esp when Cane is back next year.

AUTHOR

2021-11-01T20:21:45+00:00

Highlander

Roar Guru


He can look a little cumbersome , he got caught calling for help on an openside post when he should have closed the gap himself, but he is still a newbie after all, so both he and Papalii are going to make errors. Wainwright and Moriaty are no mugs – 70 cpas between them, but our combo did great in comparison. But that engine, he just keeps pushing.

2021-11-01T20:09:11+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@HL The Wales result was what I expected and I see you like the backrow combo used. I just feel sorry for Jacobson - such as great player who can't get a run with ABs. He's be one of the first picked in any WB team. Do you think Jacobson at no 6 would have made any difference to the Wales score line ??

2021-11-01T13:41:52+00:00

PapanuiPirate

Roar Pro


Wasn’t TJs defensive role fascinating GP? I’m not sure I have ever seen it’s like, having the halfback shoot up and disrupt the shorter passing channels. Not sure I saw him make a tackle with the maneuver but it certainly seemed to really spook the Welsh attack.

2021-11-01T12:52:15+00:00

Bill Shut

Roar Rookie


The main personnel issue against the Boks was that Whitelock was missing

2021-11-01T12:47:08+00:00

Bill Shut

Roar Rookie


I think some packs can live with SA, but they rarely get dominated. Then again, a side like France or NZ only needs parity at best as they generally have a more lethal backline, and counterattacking ability than what SA display.

2021-11-01T12:40:42+00:00

Bill Shut

Roar Rookie


The commentators if at the match will no doubt have access to some free drinks which is proven to affect driving skills amongst other things.

2021-11-01T12:38:40+00:00

Bill Shut

Roar Rookie


Samisoni Taukei’aho just gets better and better! Whitelock made an incredible difference to the lineout.

2021-11-01T12:33:45+00:00

Bill Shut

Roar Rookie


Fair comment, however, NZ has often tried to do things to stay ahead of the pack, and at the moment we are in the pack and not ahead.

2021-11-01T11:48:28+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


Blackadder reminds me of a young McCaw, some errors but work rate strong and understands the game and his role. He will only get better which is exciting and loves the hard graft again like McCaw.

2021-11-01T11:40:44+00:00

Armtwister

Roar Rookie


I agree Jeff, Blackadder also weighs in at 111kg which imo is a pretty handy all round package.

2021-11-01T10:53:57+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Bit late to this sorry Highlander, and I haven't read the comments so pls excuse me if it's repeating what anyone else might have said, but your observations about Papalii's role in defence are very well made - particularly when we throw in TJ Perenara's contribution as well. That's something I saw earlier this year when the Blues visited Melbourne, with Finlay Christie terrorising the Rebels' inside backs inside backs in a very obviously pre-planned, offensive - defensive strategy. There was one moment in the 2nd half of this match when Blackadder looked a bit cumbersome and awkward with the ball, but if that's the worst of it, we've got nothing to complain about re this loose forward combo.

2021-11-01T09:54:51+00:00

Faith

Roar Rookie


Superb stuff, Highlander - thanls for showing the evidence on how and why this loosie combo worked.

2021-11-01T08:46:10+00:00

Spew_81

Roar Rookie


It also allows the first five to hold the ball longer (and seek the gap, or a miracle pass longer) as they can offload, to the second five, at the last second. If the second five is a unit they can take the last second pass and still make advantage line. If the second five is smaller they are more likely to get smashed, as a result of the last second offload from the first five.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar