Why it's not all doom and gloom for the Wallabies

By Nicholas Bishop / Expert

On the rugby field, Australia has at least come back to being Australia again. It wasn’t good enough to beat Wales at the Principality stadium on Sunday morning (AEDT), but it should have been.

Many of the nuts and bolts of the Wallaby machine were working much more smoothly than they were earlier in the tour.

Head coach Dave Rennie was quite within his rights to criticise another sub-standard refereeing performance, this time by Scottish official Mike Adamson. Adamson had already correctly yellow-carded Kurtley Beale for slapping down a Welsh pass in the first half, then he rewarded the same action by centre Nick Tompkins with a seven pointer in the second:

As Rennie summarised the event afterwards: “Nick Tompkins slashes the ball down in open play and somehow they say it didn’t go forward when he’s facing forward.

“They get seven points out of it instead of getting a yellow card and us getting a penalty. There were lots of decisions today I’m not going to go into but I felt they had a massive bearing on the game.”

The ball goes straight down to ground off one hand with no attempt being made to catch it. That is a knock-on in the universal lingua franca of rugby anywhere on Earth, and even Tompkins had the honesty to shake his head at his sheer good fortune after the try had been awarded.

The incident was a neat capsule of the game as a whole. Australia played most of the rugby, but Wales stayed afloat on the back of decisions which had given them (rightly) anywhere between a one and a two-man advantage for most of the match.

The Wallabies did, indeed, save their best for the last dance on tour. In last week’s Coaches Corner I illustrated just how far they had fallen away from the carrying principles which had provided the platform for their success in the Rugby Championship:

Player Average carries per game Average metres per game
Samu Kerevi (12) 13 117
Marika Koroibete (11) 9 74
Rob Valetini (8) 8 53
Michael Hooper (7) 6 41

Over the first two tour games against Scotland and England, those figures had dropped away dramatically:

Player Average carries per game Average metres per game
Hunter Paisami (12) 9 62
Tom Wright (11) 6 42
Rob Valetini (8) 3 21
Michael Hooper (7) 2 20

In the game at Cardiff, all were restored to something like normality:

Player Average carries per game Average metres per game
Hunter Paisami (12) 13 108
Filipo Daugunu (11) 10 81
Rob Leota (6) 9 36
Pete Samu (7) 4 15

Add a Michael Hooper into those stats, and you have the raw ingredients for a winning performance, even in the absence of Samu Kerevi and Marika Koroibete – and without Bobby Valetini for the bulk of the game.

The possession stats were not quite as impressive as Ireland’s in their win over New Zealand in Dublin the previous week, but they were getting there fast: the balance of territory and possession was in Australia’s favour (52% and 53% respectively) despite the absence of their combative number 8, and the Wallabies enjoyed 16 minutes of attack – up from 13 minutes over the previous two weeks.

An average of 66 carries for 430 metres against England and Scotland rose to 112 for 672 metres versus Wales; the proportion of lightning-quick (0-3 second) breakdown ball climbed from 49% to 55%, while the 92% ruck retention rate was back up to 95%. These were all good signs which energised Australia’s play with ball in hand.

The Wallabies were excellent on attack when it mattered, setting up a steady stream of positive attacking pictures after three phases of play, even with only 14 men on the field in the second period:

Australia targeted the Wales inside centre Uilisi Halaholo with success throughout the match – Halaholo tends to defend off-balance and bite on the first move he sees. On this occasion Len Ikitau is able to stand him up and fade outside to make good initial yardage. A long pass by Nic White brings play back into midfield on second phase on terms favourable to the attack:

The primary attacking trigger throughout the second half was the that little arc run off the base by White. Here it is used to commit Halaholo to the threat of Pete Samu on the short ball and create space for James O’Connor to run into behind him.

Nearly all of Australia’s best attacking work with one man less was kick-started by movement off 9, and the use of the blind-side wing and number 6 Rob Leota (who had a prodigious game fulfilling both his own role, and that of Bobby Valetini) on the first couple of phases:

Leota has hardly returned to terra firma from winning the original lineout ball when he’s back in the think of the action, carrying well across the gain-line on second phase. As the shot widens, Australia are in position A1, with their entire back-line available for attack on third phase.

This time it is Tate McDermott running the switch play with Daugunu, with Leota again doing the heavy lifting in contact on the following phase.

The two Wallaby tries in the second half brought all of the threads of their attacking play to satisfying fruition:

On this occasion Hunter Paisami cuts the line from a great throw over the top of the lineout from the hand of Folau Fainga’a, with White and Leota combining on the short switch phase thereafter. In contrast to the third phase failures against England, the Wallabies had exactly the pictures they wanted versus Wales:

Again, Australia is playing with a full deck of backs (minus Paisami) on the wide-side. Again, it is Halaholo, biting early on the threat of Kurtley Beale to the outside, who sets himself up for the step inside by the Wallaby full-back. Nic White finished the move by scoring under the sticks.

One of the most satisfying developments for Dave Rennie and his coaches has been the steady growth of Hunter Paisami into the yawning hole left by Samu Kerevi at number 12. His left-to-right passing will still need work, but it is in fine fettle going in the other direction:

Paisami shortened the distance to the forward pod in front of him, and consequently balanced the threat of run and pass more effectively against Wales:

Another improvement in Australian play occurred off the bench, where the Wallabies were able to get Will Skelton into the game more consistently compared to his involvement versus Scotland and England. Skelton had four carries for 15 metres, made four tackles on defence, had one critical breakdown steal and 15 ruck attendances in his 27 minutes of action.

He obliterated Johnny McNicholl at the one-man cleanout prior to Filipo Daugunu’s scoring play in the left-hand corner:

Summary
It may not have been a day of brilliant uninterrupted sunshine – it never is in Wales at this dark turning of the year – but there were enough chinks of light in Cardiff to encourage Dave Rennie and his staff that they are on the right track, despite three defeats in a row on the end-of-year tour.

Australia returned to what they are good at – keeping the ball and manipulating the defence over a number of phases – and set up a succession of positive attacking scenarios on third phase, even after Bobby Valetini had been sent from the field.

Make no mistake, there have been positives on a difficult tour with key absences providing many of the headlines – Quade Cooper, Samu Kerevi, Marika Koroibete and Reece Hodge in the backs, Michael Hooper for the last game and a half in the forwards.

The lineout has been a clear improvement from the Rugby Championship (89% up from 82%, with over 20% of the opposition throw stolen) and the European-based second rows have shown that they can add value. There has been development at number 6, where Rob Leota took the carrying game by the scruff of its neck versus Wales after Valetini left for his early bath. Hunter Paisami has grown steadily into the role at number 12 as Samu Kerevi’s deputy.

While Dave Rennie will be aware that his Wallabies are still too dependent on the presence of key individuals for comfort, they saved their best for last, and left U.K shores on a high note.

Welsh folk hero Max Boyce sang at the opening ceremony of the 1999 World Cup, of technological wizardry in the brand spanking-new sliding roof: “They say it’s got a sliding roof, that slowly walks away… they’ll slide it back when Wales attack, so God can watch us play”.

If anyone caught the attention of the Divine at Cardiff, it was the Wallabies, and they won that World Cup hosted by Wales at the turn of the millennium. Australia will be a realistic chance do the same in France 24 years later.

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2021-11-30T18:20:22+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


They don't 'get a go' if they don't prove themselves at the level below internationals mate... And Pone has yet to prove his scrumming ability at SR level, that's why he isn't picked. People with some experience understand that, and I've no doubt Pone knows it too... Go away and get some :thumbup:

2021-11-28T23:13:48+00:00

GJ

Roar Rookie


An opinion isn’t support mate. Support is testing the theory in practice, which can only happen if guys like pone get a go. Rest just speculation. Traded OS player points with you ages ago and on that one you were wrong based on results. That’s why we debate… Slipper not a great scrummager but best of the bunch outside of TT and he had to play most of the game rather than half time replacement. Had plenty of scrum training and playing thanks mate including with Cameron Lillicrap.

2021-11-28T10:32:09+00:00

Marshy

Guest


Agree with this NB. It’s extremely short sighted. If not completely discriminatory (if we want to go there!).

2021-11-27T05:56:14+00:00

Rugby Heaven

Roar Rookie


Yet again another great article Nick! I learn more about the rules with every read. Very controversial as I can see while chewing through the multitude of awesome comments here. As bitter as it is, I just think overall that the Wallabies still need to be better as to put it beyond the referee. And to that, this tour was a real tester. Moreover, a team learns more from its loses than its victories, so even though I don’t quite think they deserved it, I’m sure the group will be better for the 3-0 effort in Europe. Two narrow and highly controversial losses on tour so I do agree that the Wallabies are relatively well placed going forward. I will concede that the ref did paint himself into a corner for at least not packing a scrum after the cynical Tompkins effort (everyone stopped playing) considering that he just issued a yellow to Beale where he could have just given a penalty (there was cover for the attackers). I’m not absolutely disagreeing with Beale’s yellow card, but that is the precedent that the ref set so he needed to continue that precedent. Later, watching the Tompkins effort in real time I was sure the ref was going to pull it up as a result. But the way the rub of the green was going I had this sick feeling in my stomach that he was going to let it slide. Well, the rest is history. Yes, let’s discuss refereeing, but let’s make discipline our primary focus going forward. To better days!

2021-11-26T08:10:38+00:00

Tim J

Roar Rookie


Totally agree Faith :thumbup:

2021-11-25T20:28:12+00:00

DaneS

Roar Rookie


That’s just not true though Nick. You could watch hours upon hours of rugby without seeing a similar incident. In 30 years of watching I don’t ever recall seeing one where a knockdown that went backwards was given as a knock on. I can’t see any mention of it by Nigel either, he just talks about the Valentini / Thomas cards

2021-11-25T17:34:48+00:00

Bluesfan


PI sides like Samoa and Tonga are going to roll some serious teams. Probably not during between the WC, but in WC year and when they can get all their squad together, well you will be a brave man to roll out your B side to face. Great for a Kiwi fan, effectively having 3 teams (AB, Tonga and Samoa) to support given ex AB's in the teams and that effectively majority of the team will be NZ born. Do wonder over time however if this may force NZ to start picking from off-shore, because when we see Piatutu, Luatua and Feikatoa playing on International stage again - maybe make them realize that for some of the AB weaknesses their are AB's who could fill those slots/issues.

2021-11-25T14:50:52+00:00

The Ferret

Roar Rookie


You are correct that having a stronger Japan (and overall having more Competitive teams) is excellent for the game. But at what cost? WR must tread carefully here as so that they don’t start to look like the NRL(it will be hard to get that bad) or allow T2 and T3 National teams to be nothing more than imports/mercenaries just to make them More competitive. Personally I think Japan is cutting the line very close to being that team.

2021-11-25T14:36:44+00:00

Faith

Roar Rookie


After ABs humiliation in the last two games NV recovered from Rassie trauma and resurfaced lol ...

2021-11-25T14:23:38+00:00

Faith

Roar Rookie


France went right thro the middle which they never really do that consistently but after Ireland, Tier 1 teams have realised the Boks way works against the ABs

2021-11-25T14:22:04+00:00

Faith

Roar Rookie


Rugby is a sport of innovation and then being found out and then recycling. ABs were fund out in RWC 2019 not to mention BILs series and they are still trying the same thing ... and I'm not sure Foster is a good enough coach to come up with his own plan like Hansen did after Ted.

2021-11-25T12:49:54+00:00

Faith

Roar Rookie


The final game against France and then this one seems to prove that ...

AUTHOR

2021-11-25T12:47:44+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


30 seconds on youtube and you can find them , also tap up Nigel Owens comments in the Telegraph...

2021-11-25T11:04:28+00:00

hogie

Roar Rookie


For me I have no issue with either the Valetini red or Beale yellow. For me the issue is consistency in the match and based off these decisions the decisions then made for the Tompkins try and Gareth Thomas yellow card. Both of which have been called out as incorrect by Nigel Owens.

2021-11-25T10:46:06+00:00

Pom in exile

Roar Rookie


I’m not suggesting that they are, but I don’t pick the squad…mores the pity. :silly:

2021-11-25T09:08:56+00:00

DaneS

Roar Rookie


Yup, it's quite clear. Doesn't have to be a link or an embedded video, there are plenty of games on youtube, stan etc. , just let me know of an example and I'll find it

AUTHOR

2021-11-25T08:50:11+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Maybe not, but he qualifies by ethnic origin and under the new rules, and he would def improve their team and therefore, increase the quality of the international game as a whole...

AUTHOR

2021-11-25T08:48:36+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


Cannot provide a connect to vid because forum doesn't allow it. Clear?

AUTHOR

2021-11-25T08:47:56+00:00

Nicholas Bishop

Expert


You cannot provide a vide0 l1nk on the forum because they are auto moderated out... Try it and you'll see - and don't jump to conclusions!

2021-11-25T08:32:10+00:00

DaneS

Roar Rookie


Just one would do... You know I'm starting to think that if the rules say a slap back isn't a knock on, and nobody can find a precedent saying otherwise, that maybe a few people owe Mike Adamson an apology

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar