'Laughable': Root's blame game starts civil war with Morgan, 'perfect' Ponting wanted as England coach

By Tony Harper / Editor

Australian legend Ricky Ponting has been raised as an ideal candidate to revitalise England’s shambolic Test team, while Joe Root finds himself in a civil war with England’s white ball skipper Eoin Morgan.

After England’s 4-0 Ashes humiliation captain laid the blame on domestic cricket in the country, claiming the priority had shifted away from first class cricket to focus on T20 and the Hundred.

That statement has rattled Morgan who describedg Root’s comments as “laughable”.

Speaking to UK radio station talkSPORT, Morgan said the Test team was “always been the priority” and rejected notions Root had not been given the tools to succeed because the T20 and 50-over sides had been prioritised.

“People who use that as an excuse don’t watch cricket,” Morgan said. “Test match cricket has always been the priority — it’s the format for our elite players.

“Obviously, times at the moment have been tough down in Australia during the Ashes but they always are — we’ve lost the last two series there 4-0. It’s laughable to point the finger at the Hundred. The Hundred is an unbelievable success.”

n the aftermath of the Hobart defeat, Root said he wanted to continue to lead the Test team. He also backed under fire coach Chris Silverwood.

Instead Root argued that English domestic cricket schedules needed an overhaul with more focus on first-class cricket in the height of summer, which is dominated by white-ball formats.

He added county cricket was not preparing players for the demands of the international game.

Morgan strongly disagreed.

“Our formats in county cricket and the Hundred, in the way they are structured, are exactly the same as Australia’s,” Morgan said.

“People need something to blame so they’ll point at probably the furthest point to reality because nobody wants to say, ‘You know what, we’ve not had the prep we’d have liked, we probably haven’t played as well as we’d have liked and we’ve lost.’ That happens in all formats, but I stress Test-match cricket has always been the priority.”

(Photo by Michael Steele/Getty Images)

England’s rest and rotation policy in Australia has also come under scrutiny but Morgan says he has the same issues to face.

“As a white-ball group, we’ve gone on tours and played in series at home where we haven’t had our full-strength side available,” he said. “That’s been a theme for a number of years now.

“Obviously, Test matches take priority and always do. For the majority of my career, white-ball cricket was an afterthought — 95 per cent of the time was spent around planning and prep for Test-match cricket and then when we got to a World Cup it was like, ‘Well if we do well then great, but if we don’t, it’s fine.’ ”

While Chris Silverwood also wants to carry on as coach, his reign is starting to look untenable.

There have been further inside reports of the Ashes debacle appearing in the UK media overnight, all painting a picture of an unstructured rabble.

His assistant, Graham Thorpe, is reportedly facing the sack after being behind the camera as police broke up an all night drinking party including Root, James Anderson, Nathan Lyon and Travis Head.

England cricket authorities were said to be furious over Thorpe’s role in taking the video and the fact it was posted on social media.

It has also been reported by the Daily Mail and the Guardian that the Tasmanian police were called over claims that Thorpe was smoking indoors which is against the law.

The Daily Mail’s report goes onto state that Thorpe is highly unlikely to remain in his position as England head coach, following what was a dismal tour on the playing side of things.

Meanwhile, two former England players – Nasser Hussain and David Lloyd – have called for Ricky Ponting to be given the job of replacing Silverwood.

Ponting is one name linked with potentially replacing Justin Langer as Australia’s coach while Trevor Bayliss – who coaching England from 2015-19 is another.

“I like Ricky Ponting. Everything I see about him impresses me,” Hussain said.

“He might not have a lot of international coaching experience but he’s got a great cricket brain. There are a few out there — unfortunately, not many of them English.

“Justin Langer might be available soon, too, so you never know! I would just about stay with Joe Root.”

Lloyd said he would stick with Silverwood in the short term but agreed with Ponting as next man in.

“If Ponting is available he’d be perfect. He cares about cricket and cricketers, he knows the game inside out and has gravitas.”

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2022-01-20T01:54:38+00:00

David Abbey

Guest


I had the privilege of umpiring some of your grass root teams in the West of England Premier league ( mainly Somerset, Gloucester and Devon counties) in 2019. All one day or T20 games. School cricket only private schools. 18 counties producing 360 average over entitled under performing 1st class players. Compare with 120 hardened for test cricket state cricketers in Sheffield shield. Is that enough for the ECB to get better ?

2022-01-19T23:29:16+00:00

Peter

Roar Rookie


Indeed. These speculations are always presented as if they’re presidential appointments that you can’t decline.

2022-01-19T21:26:33+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


Your not wrong there. Did I see you saying you were agreeing with Don . Surely you're mistaken . :happy:

2022-01-19T14:07:54+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


Rossie Lyon for me.

2022-01-19T12:05:44+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


For one season, with the entire English Cricket marketing budget as we came out of lockdown and with the bonus of watching some women’s cricket, yes.

2022-01-19T12:02:37+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Strauss needs to take Giles’ role. Red ball coach should be Kirsten. He wanted the job originally but refused it if required to coach all formats. I don’t care who coached their white ball teams - maybe Collingwood?

2022-01-19T12:00:10+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Exactly. His comments on timing are disingenuous in the extreme.

2022-01-19T11:58:40+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


This is unedifying. England cricket eating itself in public. I had liked Morgan but this is BS. Their calendar may look similar to ours (which needs fixing) with the hit and giggle book-ended by red ball stuff but that doesn’t make it right. They’ve also got two 3 hour tournaments which is at least one too many. Morgan knows it but is happy to toss Root under the bus to retain primacy for his format. Not pretty

2022-01-19T10:20:18+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


President Patrick Cummins

2022-01-19T10:19:28+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


I wish I could play golf even half as good as Ricky Ponting.

2022-01-19T10:18:17+00:00

Once Upon a Time on the Roar

Roar Guru


He'd have been a hopping mad Irishman!

2022-01-19T09:37:27+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


"I think they are just pie in the sky speculating who would do a good job". I think he would too - it's odd how I didn't think him that bright as a player and captain (he made some dunderheaded mistakes batting and was a bit stubborn at times) but since then his comments have been pretty insightful. And he definitely has the mana to do it.

2022-01-19T09:35:23+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


I didn't know that about Strauss. Just looked it up, very sad.

2022-01-19T07:44:36+00:00

Brett Allen

Guest


And yet Australia has won 5 World Cups, 2 Champions Trophies & a World T20. Concentrate on producing great red ball cricketers and you’ll produce great red ball AND white ball cricketers.

2022-01-19T07:38:34+00:00

Brett Allen

Guest


Dear England, Fix your archaic domestic structure first. 18 1st class counties is at least 10 too many. Secondly, quit your fascination with coaches, they can’t help your players. Only tougher domestic first class cricket can do that. Thirdly, you need to completely re-evaluate your views towards spinners. Pick who you think your best spinner is, be it Leach, Bess, Crane or Parkinson, and then stick with him, FOR EVERY TEST !!!! The only way they’ll improve is to keep picking them and using them as attacking weapons, not as defensive options. Finally, whoever you pick to be captain, he must be in charge, not the coach or anybody else, the captain. It’s the only way a cricket team works. You’re welcome Australia

2022-01-19T06:56:44+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


Plenty of golf courses and dog tracks in the UK . He's a shoe in . Poms started going downhill when they got rid of Trevor Bayliss.

2022-01-19T05:55:19+00:00

Akitas

Roar Rookie


Pretty obvious that Morgan's comments are designed to ensure his area does not get less attention.

2022-01-19T05:48:32+00:00

Linphoma

Guest


Remember before Bayliss got the gig some pundits were raving Dizzy was a lock-in? How come not a peep from anyone for Dizzy this time? They still rate him at (the disgraced) Yorkshire.

2022-01-19T05:25:51+00:00

CW Moss

Roar Rookie


That never stopped them. Their best were RSA.

2022-01-19T05:21:26+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


Morgan isn’t even English

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar