Is the Panthers vs Knights this weekend a grand final preview? Well, no, but...

By Joe Frost / Editor

Saturday afternoon sees our first top-of-the-table clash of the NRL season, as the first-placed Knights take on the second-placed Panthers.

Obviously it’s very, very early to put much store in a 1 vs 2 match-up but this is shaping to be a cracking game.

Fears the Panthers may suffer from a premiership hangover have thus far been unfounded, with the reigning champions bursting out of the blocks to smash Manly 28-6 in the season opener, then easing past the Dragons 20-16 last Friday.

All this without their main man, Nathan Cleary, who will again be absent this weekend after the club decided to rest him for the first three weeks of the season to help heal his troublesome shoulder.

In his absence, back-up half Sean O’Sullivan has been fantastic, but Cleary’s co-captain, Isaah Yeo, has really stood up, claiming the full complement of six Dally M points to date.

That has him equal top of the leader board for the game’s highest individual honour, with just one other player having been awarded the full three points in both his games to date.

That’d be Newcastle five-eighth Jake Clifford.

The Knights spent the pre-season with their own halfback troubles, Mitchell Pearce having secured a release to head to France, apparently leaving Newcastle destined to tumble out of finals contention, such was his importance.

(Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

But Clifford was having none of it and has been the side’s dominant half, terrifying fullbacks with his booming boot, leading his side in kick chases, and continuing to develop his running game.

His forcing James Tedesco into the error that led to the Knights’ first try against the Roosters in Round 1 may have been helped by a wild bounce, but – as the good gentlemen of the Bay 53 podcast pointed out – Clifford’s effort to chase his own monster kick and apply pressure was a classic example of the harder you work the luckier you get.

And that’s just one example. He’s been in the thick of most good things his side have achieved, showing that the club didn’t need a ‘new Pearce’ because they had identified the future of their halves when they first signed Clifford from the Cowboys at the end of 2020.

As for the man who’s actually wearing the No.7 jersey, Adam Clune, he’s had a tremendous couple of games, setting up two tries against the Tigers on the weekend in the kind of showing that has surely put to bed any lingering questions over whether Luke Brooks might jag a release from Concord and make his way to the Hunter.

Simply put, Clune was the far superior player on Sunday and is paid about one-sixth of what Brooks commands. I think we’re done here.

But it’s difficult to dwell on how well the club’s halves have been playing because both games so far have been won on the back of excellent team performances.

Dane Gagai has transformed the Knights’ right edge from disaster to deadly, his combination with Dom Young already netting four tries, while Bradman Best and Enari Tuala mean the left still has plenty of oomph.

Jacob Saifiti has picked up where he left off last season – in which he won the club’s player of the year award – Tyson Frizell will be back in a Blues jumper come Origin time if he maintains his form, and Chris Randall is averaging 40 tackles a game at 100 per cent efficiency, has a handy kicking game and has shown flashes of attacking flair that mean Jayden Brailey’s absence has thus far been almost unnoticed.

Tyson Frizell (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

But on that line of thinking, perhaps most impressive is the fact the Knights have been without so many of their star players.

Along with Brailey, Origin prop and pack leader Daniel Saifiti has yet to lace up his boots this year, same with experienced forward Sauaso Sue, the club’s first-choice wingers Hymel Hunt and Edrick Lee (Eddie’s last game was for Queensland, so yes, he’s still a first-choice winger), the versatile Brodie Jones and Jack Johns, and back-up fullback Bailey Hodgson.

And they really needed a fill-in custodian on the weekend, as Kalyn Ponga was pulled from the line-up prior to kick-off with a knee injury, as was former Kangaroo and Origin prop David Klemmer.

The entire first-choice front row, fullback and wingers were missing, along with four handy squad players – who are pretty damn important to have fit and ready if you’re missing six of your starters.

But it made no real difference, as Newcastle hammered the Tigers 26-4, in a showing that the club’s ‘next man up’ mentality that coach Adam O’Brien has sought to instil from his days at Melbourne is finally starting to work.

That said, the Panthers are not the Tigers.

It remains to be seen just how bad the injuries to the above-mentioned players are, with rumours that Ponga and Saifiti may sit out this weekend as well, in what would be a significant blow to hopes of a red and blue boilover in Bathurst.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Penrith have their own issues however, with Cleary – as mentioned above – at least another week away from a return, while Brian To’o and Moses Leota are on the long-term injured list, and there is a cloud over James Fisher-Harris.

Regardless of the outs, the people of Bathurst will be treated to a fantastic arvo of footy as the best two teams of the first two weeks of the comp go toe-to-toe in a game that – barring a blowout win for either the Broncos or Storm, who are also undefeated – should decide who will be atop the ladder at the end of Round 3.

The Crowd Says:

2022-03-25T04:56:32+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


No : :laughing:

2022-03-25T03:25:36+00:00

Rob

Guest


Are you homeless Andrew? LOL

2022-03-23T23:40:04+00:00

Rob

Guest


Clifford was always getting put in the passenger seat. Fair enough when Thurston and Morgan were there but unfortunately they put Drinkwater straight over him? The Knights and Ponga knew the right time to get him on board. He went to the Knights for a opportunity to be the leading half. If Payten had his way I’m sure Clifford and Dearden would both be in the Cowboys system.

2022-03-23T06:16:03+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Overall 6/9 @Carrington Pk, but have lost the last 2/3. Not to mention, when Panthers sat down in the off-season and submitted to the NRL which game they wanted to play at Bathurst, the Knights game was meant to be money for jam.

2022-03-23T04:07:04+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Sounds like you boys willbe bunking in a hostel after the game then. I think the Sharks will win by about 10 points.

2022-03-23T02:05:54+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


If Latrell Mitchell was playing there would have been. Plus Reynolds played with a groin strain which affected his kicking, especially the last sideline conversion which he always kicks from the left sideline and the field goal late in the game. Finally, Cody Walker's pass selection on THAT pass. A short pass to Gagai in a gaping hole with AJ in support and Souths score. Have I covered all my bases DPS? :silly:

2022-03-22T11:52:52+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


All stories of unrealised dreams and hope....

2022-03-22T11:50:45+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Bet you had a different GF winner though :stoked:

2022-03-22T06:30:08+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


I hate to say it, but Panthers are going to be found out soon enough. You can’t have Fisher-Harris, Leota, To’o, and Cleary out and still win against most teams. Add Burton to the outs from last year. The run through brick walls strategy through the finals series, is not the way to go through the regular season. We’re half busted now. We’ll be fully busted inside two months. Such a skilful team with so many attacking options, yet hell bent on smashing themselves to pieces. Would be nice to finish top 4 like in ‘04, but thinking we’ll look more like last year’s Roosters by then.

2022-03-22T02:38:48+00:00

Malo

Guest


No Pearce was the answer to their success. Plus A Johns coaching them. Genius moves. Top 6 for sure.

2022-03-22T01:42:01+00:00

Larry1950

Guest


I was saying it early last season so I’m not a ‘johnny come lately’ but every time Clifford goes around he makes you wonder why the cowboys lacked faith in him & eventually let him go for Dearden who is a manufactured half, not a natural. Clifford plays like footballer, not an autonomic athlete & was a Qld U20 player in a decent squad so the cowboys just needed to persist with him & let him find his feet. Also a bigger body defensively & wouldn’t be out of place in a Qld side if Munster was unavailable. Seems to be playing with freedom under O’brien so that’s a vote of confidence for him.

2022-03-22T01:34:06+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Not too concerned there souvalis. Tago is a strong defender and strong ball runner. I suspect Taylan May will get the other wing spot. I would have already had him in for Staines anyway. Another good defender and strong runner of the ball ( and he can fight , well at least against one of those Lussick boys !!) . If Kaylan plays, he still prefers running the other side of the park. My big concern is the middle of the ruck . If Fish is out, and Leota is already out and possibly Sorensen too, it puts a lot of strain on Yeo & Api to keep that big Knights pack at bay.

2022-03-22T01:07:03+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Knights, Dragons and Eels do seem to dominate the articles.

2022-03-22T01:05:27+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


I'd imagine the Knights will just be happy to get away from Bathurst with less drama than the last time they visited about 15 years ago.... when it cost them a local junior prop who went on to play 200 NRL games

2022-03-22T01:04:35+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Over on the left it’s probably going to be rookie Tago and rookie winger on Gagai, man mountain and hopefully seal the deal Kalyn.. getting them at a good time.

2022-03-22T00:45:32+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


They do this every year. I don't think they have gotten it right once. Yet, I did tip the Rabbitohs vs Panthers GF and Panthers for minor premiers from the start of the year. So it IS possible. :silly:

2022-03-22T00:36:04+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


The Knights seem to be playing as if they've been written off by many and aren't feeling the pressure. It's good to see and hopefully, it will last but often the dark horse types tighten up a bit when they get lots of good press.

2022-03-22T00:25:53+00:00

Hard Yards

Roar Rookie


Well I am a betting man, because I go to sleep each night. So I might just do that . I do like the Dragons this weekend, Might just be a trip to the fish markets for Cronulla I reckon.

2022-03-22T00:01:28+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Too many missing from both teams to make this match a forecast GF preview , but so far both sides have started well and it should be a close game. Panthers generally go well at Bathurst in front of their country fans , but the Knights are travelling well with increasing confidence.

2022-03-21T22:37:21+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


Put your house on Saints to beat the Sharks this week HY, they're specials.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar