Round 10 Questions: Should Bunnies be worried? Will Storm machine conk out? Who'll watch Dogs v Knights?

By Paul Suttor / Expert

Rain looks like putting something of a dampener on Magic Round but the three-day festival in Brisbane is throwing up plenty of talking points for all 16 teams in attendance.

Parramatta and Brisbane have breathed new life into the competition over the past few weeks – the Eels proved a Storm v Panthers grand final was not a fait accompli with their stirring 22-20 win at Penrith while the Broncos have given their fans hope that a return to the playoffs is within range with a hat-trick of wins.

The first of Brisbane’s victories over Canterbury was not as convincing but their 16-7 triumph over the Sharks and 32-12 conquest of South Sydney show there is substance to their style of play with Adam Reynolds calling the shots.

Here are the big questions facing all 16 teams for Magic Round

Friday

Bulldogs v Knights at Suncorp Stadium, 6pm (AEST)

Can Bulldogs really be favourites? The bookmakers have given Canterbury a slight edge in head-to-head markets for this game but it would be impossible to gamble responsibly on this one. Both teams have shown immaculate ability to clutch defeat from the jaws of victory this year. It could be 0-0 with 10 to go or 34-all. Both options are in play. In an ideal world, Magic Round would open with a bang but the best you can say about this year’s scheduling is it’ll only get better after the teams 15th and 16th on the ladder decide once and for all who’s worst.

(Photo by Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images)

Can Daniel Saifiti salvage his Blues berth? Time is running out for the Newcastle front-rower to prove he should be in the NSW squad for game one on June 8. Blues selector Greg Alexander gave him a public warning a few weeks ago that he needed to improve but his form has shown nothing to suggest that shot of Brandy has had an effect.

Sea Eagles v Broncos at Suncorp Stadium, 8.05pm (AEST)

Will Sea Eagles regret giving up this home game?  Going into this season, playing the Broncos in Brisbane instead of Brookvale wouldn’t have been seen as too much of a worry but Kevin Walters’ team has found its groove. Manly thrashed Brisbane at Magic Round last year 50-6 but lost the corresponding Magic Round fixture in 2019. The Broncos have not visited Manly since 2014.

(Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

Is Patrick Carrigan ready for Origin? Billy Slater has said during the week that the Brisbane forward is on his selection radar with prop Christian Welch unavailable this year due to his torn Achilles. A torn ACL ruined his 2021 campaign and he missed a month recently with an MCL strain but he returned straight into the starting side last week with Payne Haas and Kurt Capewell out and led the pack to a dominant performances over Souths with 37 tackles and 142 running metres.

Saturday

Warriors v Rabbitohs at Suncorp Stadium, 3pm (AEST)

Can the Warriors show some ticker? There has been enough written and said about how abjectly pathetic the Warriors were in last Sunday’s capitulation at Cronulla against a 12-man line-up for more than an hour of the match, including a 10-minute stretch against 11. Tohu Harris makes his comeback from a torn ACL and his Melbourne Storm never-give-up pedigree needs to rub off on more than a few of his teammates.

Should Rabbitohs fans be worried? Cameron Murray and Latrell Mitchell are out for a few weeks, Cody Walker’s form is scratchy at best and they dropped to ninth with a 4-5 record after last week’s 32-12 drubbing from Brisbane. They make more errors per game than any other team at 14.1, which supports the common feeling that their once silky smooth attacking machine is looking decidedly clunky under new coach Jason Demetriou. They’re more conservative this year too, making the most one-pass hit-ups per game (81.9) in the NRL.

Titans v Dragons at Suncorp Stadium, 5.30pm (AEST)

Are Titans compounding their earlier error with Kieran Foran signing? Letting Jamal Fogarty go to Canberra was a mistake, it was like trying to hit the fast-forward button on their young side’s development – halves Toby Sexton and AJ Brimson, and fullback Jayden Campbell are players of the future but they could have used Fogarty in their squad this year to guide them along. By the time Foran arrives next year, those three will be much further along in learning the tools of the trade at NRL level and Foran should only be needed as a bench utility. So if the Titans have forked out the $750,000 they have reportedly given the veteran Sea Eagle for a two-year deal, it could be creating another problem down the track.

(Photo by Matt Roberts/Getty Images)

Will Dragons fix their defence? They missed more tackles per game (36.2) than any other team and they are second-worst for line breaks conceded at 5.7 (although, strangely, Parramatta are worse with 6.2). St George Illawarra skipper Ben Hunt is playing strongly in attack but he’s missed more tackles (44) than anyone else in 2022.

Storm v Panthers at Suncorp Stadium, 7.45pm (AEST)

Can Meaney become next Hynes? When Ryan Papenhuyzen missed a couple of months last season, Melbourne’s machine barely skipper a beat with Nicho Hynes thriving at the back. Nick Meaney has the chance to emulate that over the next month at least due to Papenhuyzen’s knee and hamstring woes. Don’t be surprised if the Storm win this one and are still on top of the ladder when Papenhuyzen returns.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Can Panthers isolate Storm’s back three? Xavier Coates shouldn’t expect too many kicks to head his way on Saturday night but new fullback Nick Meaney and winger Dean Ieremia will be tested by Nathan Cleary’s array of bombs, torpedoes and other kicks which haven’t yet been given a military theme.

Sunday

Sharks v Raiders at Suncorp Stadium, 1.50pm (AEST)

Should Sharks re-sign Matt Moylan? The veteran five-eighth’s form improved last year when it looked like he might not get another contract and he’s been solid in 2022 to outperform the bargain basement one-year deal he signed. The Sharks would love to be able to keep him keen with another lean contract but he’ll be in a position to at least demand a two-season extension.

Matt Moylan (Brett Hemmings/Getty Images)

Have the Raiders got another Dragons jinx happening? The Raiders’ six-year stretch when they kept beating St George Illawarra became the stuff of legend but Canberra have quietly built up a similar streak against Cronulla. The Green Machine has won their past seven games against the Sharks. The only other time in the NRL era that they have had a better run against a rival club was their nine-game sequence against the Red V from 2008 to 2013.

Roosters v Eels at Suncorp Stadium, 4.05pm (AEST)

Can Roosters get off to a better start? The Sydney side has outscored its opposition in the second half each time in the past six rounds so Trent Robinson’s troops are certainly fit. But the Roosters have conceded a couple of upset losses in that stretch to the Dragons and the Bulldogs. It should go without saying that it could be curtains if they give the in-form Eels the early jump on Sunday.

Why haven’t the Eels re-signed Ryan Matterson already? It’s highly unusual in the current marketplace but Matterson is off contract at season’s end. A legit free agent, not a November 1 negotiator a year out, he could sign anywhere next year. With the Dolphins coming into the competition and sadly in need of elite talent, what’s taking the Eels so long to lock him away? They’ve already lost Reed Mahoney, Isaiah Papali’i, Oregon Kaufusi, Ray Stone and Marate Niukore sign elsewhere for 2023 so there should be no lack of forward roster spots and cash to splash.

Tigers v Cowboys at Suncorp Stadium, 6.25pm (AEST)

Should Tigers persist with Oliver Gildart? The English international has struggled to adapt to the physicality of the NRL in his debut season Down Under. Gildart is at the top of the league for two unwanted categories – most try causes (13) and line breaks conceded at 14 alongside another centre, Morgan Harper, who has lost his place for a few weeks at Manly due to his defensive deficiencies.

(Photo by Albert Perez/Getty Images)

How many Cowboys should be in Maroons team? Valentine Holmes is probably their only certainty, on a wing. Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow, Murray Taulagi, Reuben Cotter and Jeremiah Nanai have been mentioned as other possible selections. “Hammer” should get a centre berth but Taulagi will probably miss out on the other wing spot to Storm flyer Xavier Coates, Cotter is unlikely to get a bench utility berth ahead of incumbent Ben Hunt while Nanai still has a bunch of more seasoned second-rowers ahead of him in Kurt Capewell, Felise Kaufusi and Jai Arrow in his path even though David Fifita and Jaydn Su’A are injured.

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-05-12T10:02:28+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Fighting his way back. Is #18 for Broncos against Manly this round.

2022-05-12T08:42:33+00:00

dogs

Guest


Whatever happened to Brenko Lee? Great 2020 with the storm then nowhere to be seen. I thought he went to the Broncos. Is he injured? retired? or just out of form?

2022-05-12T06:46:44+00:00

beachart

Roar Rookie


— COMMENT DELETED —

2022-05-12T06:36:42+00:00

dogs

Guest


Only bummer this weekend is no Thursday game tonight. Hunt's missed tackles are a concern, but I guess there's some context. Other teams should be running a lot at him, blunt him and you've blunted the dragons. Also, his desperation puts him in some not-great defensive positions where some of his team mates would just treat is somebody else's problem. But if you get there, you want to make it stick. (although from memory in the 2020 GF, Jerome Hughs seemed to be using the "make myself a speed bump" approach in dealing with Kikau - lots of contact, but not a lot of actual tackles) Didn't Cotter play dummy half in in the all stars matches? Although I guess Hunt covers that for QLD. Be interesting to see if Hess returns to Origin as a middle, the move seems to have suited him. My tips: - Dogs, tipping with my heart, who really knows - Many, a close one, DCE compared to Reynolds should be interesting - Bunnys, easy - Dragons, I'm underwhelmed by the Titans these days - Panthers, their line speed and forcing tackles backwards is too good - Sharks, not sure, Kennedy and Ramien are big outs, and moving Hynes is not ideal - Eels, the Chooks will come good, but think its still a month or so off - Cowboys, but think it'll be close

2022-05-12T04:32:00+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Hi mushi. Exactly. Arghh it makes my brain hurt. Lol

2022-05-12T04:11:34+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Hi EJ and Pete. I with you. Some new kid, lol it takes a season to get up to speed I think at least.

2022-05-12T02:54:39+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


They play in the QRL don't they?

2022-05-12T02:33:43+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


:laughing: :laughing: I was actually thinking of Olam as they were only weak in the centres last year. Maybe those two can have a chat...

2022-05-12T02:30:22+00:00

eagleJack

Roar Guru


I'm with you Pete. A case of the media building up a player to be something they clearly aren't. Always easier to do when said player isn't playing.

2022-05-12T02:26:59+00:00

eagleJack

Roar Guru


"Will Sea Eagles regret giving up this home game"? Not sure I really understand this talking point. I mean it's Magic Round so every side has given up their home game. Manly would be playing at Suncorp this weekend whether they chose to or not.

2022-05-12T02:08:49+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


Given the Dogs are averaging 10 points per game, i would venture it unlikely it will be 34-34 with 10 to go. Titans signing Foran (presuming it is circa $400K) is a good signing, if he has teaching abaility. He has experience, whether he is good at passing on what he has learned, none of us would know. I think Brimson ends up at fullback at the Titans. Campbell can do some neat things, but he isn't big enough to be a long term fullback, IMO As critical as anyone can be about the Eels roster management, i think it was fair to hold off negotiations with Matterson. His for the last 3 weeks has been brilliant though but is that just a case of him getting into negotiation time? He is also one more concussion away from having to have serious questions about his ongoing career. but either way, the Eels have cast away Nikore, Papalii and Stone. They can't just keep letting back rowers walk out the door (while retaining Lane!) I was looking to tip the Roosters this week, but if the conditions are going to be slippery, that doesn't suit their all out attack/high error rate approach and probably swings things back in Parra's favour.

2022-05-12T01:42:18+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


Is PNG in Queensland? Ask Xavier Coates.

2022-05-12T01:01:22+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


Pat is good, he was always destined to be but he would want to keep up his form and this weekend will be a good test. He might bring good energy off the bench. I wouldn’t be surprised to see Munster drop to FB on Sat night. They were trialling him in the role at the start of the season and I reckon he brings a bit more attacking threat. Souths should get this done. The Warriors have resumed the old ‘cannot possibly back them’ state of play. Looking forward to a big weekend of footy. Personally i think Sunday might be the best overall day. Let’s hope the liver keeps up.

2022-05-12T00:07:43+00:00

DP Schaefer

Roar Rookie


Hard round to tip maybe. Plenty of coin tosses and most matches should be close with the rain also halting blowouts. Getting in early but Marooon forwards have a strong group to pick from. Backs;- DCE, (back up Hunt) Munster (b/u AJ) Centres: Gagai & Homes (b/u Hammer) Wings: Coates, Feldt (b/u Hammer, Homes, Lee) FB: Ponga (b/u AJ) #14, Hunt/ AJ That’s looking pretty darn good with more depth in form than last year or two, especially in the centres. Is PNG in Queensland??

2022-05-12T00:04:27+00:00

steveng

Roar Rookie


Q: “Should Bunnies be worried?” A: yes most certainly as and if they don’t win and beat the Warriors “its all over red rover” as they will end up at best, in the mid bottom 8 like in 2016, 2017 when consecutively they ended up 12th, as I can’t see them competing in the top 8 in 2022. This round is a very hard tipping round and there will be some surprising results. My picks, Dogs just, Broncs easy, and with the Bunnies, gee this one is a tossup but Bunnies (as they are a rabble in 2022 and without Murray its even a worse rabble and it will be very hard to watch) Dragons, Storm just and a great game, Sharks, Eels for sure and the Cows for sure.

2022-05-12T00:01:00+00:00

Pete

Guest


I don't understand the narrative around Jamal Fogarty at the moment. The way he's been made out you would think he's some gun first grader who's been playing for 10 years. He hasn't even played 50 games and I wouldn't say he's anything better than a solid first grader. Foran is, and always will be, a much better player than Fogarty is. Some reports have said the deal is 750k a year and others have said its around 400k. If they have signed him on 750k a year that's too much IMO however if his salary is closer to 400k a year I think it's a very good signing for the Titans.

2022-05-11T23:44:27+00:00

varun sharma

Roar Rookie


Yes Pat Carrigan is ready for origin.

2022-05-11T22:03:50+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


Hopefully, Manly get a shiny new stadium soon and start playing the Broncos in Sydney. One or two of the teams who are plodding at the moment are likely to fire up pretty soon and start claiming a few scalps.

2022-05-11T22:03:34+00:00

3 R M

Roar Rookie


Big game for the cowboys, the last game late on Sunday it will be a challenge for our young team to stay focused over the weekend. The tigers 2nd row is one of their strong points and with one of them coming to the cows next year, our 2 gems will be tested here with the tigers second rowers keen to make a point. Who knows what Billy and his team will do with selection as most were affected when Mal took the sword to the squad in 06. So he could go against the grain and select on merit or do the usual Qld way of, if you did well before you get picked again + a strategic pick for the future. I can see Nanai as 18th man. Taulagi is close but Coates is left wing so probably not. Val will play either centre or wing on opposing sides of the field. Hammer is an incumbent, is not starting atm but could jag right wing. Cotter could quite possibly play 80 at starting prop in origin he is that fit.. it's a big factor, it's a massive step up as well as he is not even 100kg. Luki as well for a smoky, as he can impact both sides of the ball from the bench. Billy will be looking for high work rate, low errors, good tackle efficiency and ticker then impact so a lot of the cows players fit this, there is just not that many places up for grabs.

Read more at The Roar