With a turbulent first season in the books, it’s over to the APL to get football back on track

By asanchez / Roar Guru

So, it’s been a while, a long time between drinks as they say, but as the latest A-League season came to a close last night, I just had to share some ideas and thoughts on this platform.

This season has had its ups and downs, but the game has a lot of work to do before the next season comes around. Some things need urgent attention and can be sorted pretty quickly, others will take some time, but are super important, and need to be done.

Here’s my take on the issues football faces at the moment.

Scrap the cap

This topic is a never-ending saga, but this really needs to go, as it’s now stifling the potential growth of our bigger clubs, and the entire league as a whole. If some of our bigger clubs want to spend $15 million-$20 million on their wage budgets, simply because they can, then so be it.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Allowing this to happen also helps to make our football clubs more competitive in Asia, and more recognised overseas.

The APL has to mandate minimum 27-man squads, and the minimum wages per player (as per their age) which is already in place through the CBA automatically dictates the minimum spend on salaries for all the clubs, so we don’t have clubs spending over $10 million and some spending under $1 million on wages.

Domestic transfer system

This has been much talked about recently, and it looks like it’s finally happening, but apparently not yet for the A-League clubs, which is ridiculous. This needs to be opened up to the entire market, including the A-League clubs, as this will bring a whole new domestic football economy.

So clubs like CCM or Wellington can cash in on some young players if they wish, to one of the bigger clubs in the competition, plus other loans, transfers etc can all happen, and extra money will circulate throughout the league. The FA could even take a 2 per cent or 3 per cent cut out of all transfers as a fee.

National second division

This needs to happen ASAP, and it needs to start later in 2022 or in 2023 at the latest. I understand the fact that we may not be ready for a full promotion and relegation for a while, but we do need more than 12 clubs in the league, so promotion needs to come from here.

The day of brand new clubs started out of thin air are gone. We could bring in the next 4-6 clubs from the NSD.

However, in the medium to long term, we really need to sort out the relegation component. The APL clubs need to understand that by not allowing relegation from the AL, just because the owners have paid some ridiculous fees to buy some of these clubs in the last decade, is holding the game back massively.

Promotion/relegation needs to be open to all, and even though some may lose in the short term, the entire sport wins in the long term, together with our national team.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Football infrastructure

It’s been great to see the Matildas get a new home at La Trobe in Victoria recently, and Melbourne City open up a new training base at Dandenong. This is where our sport lags behind the rest by a long way. Particularly at a local level, much ground has been made up in the last few years in most states, but many local clubs still need better facilities.

At the A-League level, most clubs now have proper stadiums to play out of, except for Brisbane Roar and Western United. The latter will break ground on their training facility shortly, which will deliver a 5000-seat stadium, which isn’t for the A-League side, but they can actually use that as soon as it’s ready in about 12 months’ time.

The Roar are a huge concern overall, with their owners really letting their fans down over the last five years, while they also now have to work out where to play out of long term.

Melbourne City can use AAMI Park for now, but you’d love for their mega-rich owners to start coming up with some plans for a small stadium out at Dandenong, which is where they’re now based. If this was to ever happen, this would capture the vast majority of the Melbourne geography in terms of where the three clubs play at.

Victory in the CBD and inner suburbs, Western out at Tarneit and western suburbs and City taking in Dandenong and the southeast.

A-League clubs all need their own proper training facilities. Case in point – Melbourne Victory, who after 16 years of success on and off the park, are still looking for a location to establish a training base, and an academy.

Scheduling

This must improve next season, evidently. Hopefully with heavy COVID restrictions and state border closures now a thing of the past, a better schedule should work wonders next season, alongside some decent marketing, which is exactly what the league needs again.

I know marquee players have become a hot topic again, but in my opinion, they’ve always been hit and miss, and give no guarantees of a return. Only Alessandro Del Piero and Dwight Yorke have had the impact that the APL is looking for, in terms of getting instant recognition, bigger gates at grounds, and being regularly in the media spotlight.

Other lesser-known marquee players have done very well on field, but have not had that same impact off it.

The in-game ads are a disgrace, and will single-handedly kill off whatever small but rusted-on group of fans the league still has, and has managed to hang onto during some very tumultuous times. These must be stopped next season at all costs.

They can run banner advertising for most of the game if need be, but the sport is a continuous game, with sometimes only a handful of goal opportunities for the entire 90 minutes, which cannot be missed, so this has to stop immediately.

Another part of the scheduling I would change is the Australia Cup final dates. I’d play the two semi-finals of the Australia Cup the weekend after the A-League Grand Final, and then the final the following weekend, making it the last game of the year. And make the A-League sides play from the Round of 64 onwards, with a fully open draw, meaning more games for all teams.

Ideally, a 16-18 team league gives us 30-34 league games, plus the Australia Cup, and a future Super Cup, which also has to happen.

(Photo by Mark Evans/Getty Images)

Technology

The Paramount+ app needs work immediately. If you can’t give the football loving public, or any other interested people, the opportunity to pause, rewind, or start over a live game of football, then the broadcaster just isn’t caring or bothering to listen to their clients! Clients who can do this very same thing on apps like Optus Sport, Stan, Bein Sports, Kayo and pretty much every other platform out there.

Also, the fact that people like myself, who are football mad, but have young kids, cannot watch the entire game just after the final whistle is also a huge issue. Surely we don’t need to wait 12 hours to watch a game we’ve just missed, while not being able to rewind or start over during. This is just primitive stuff, and the APL along with Paramount need to sort this out ASAP.

Ticket pricing

A pressure point in any marketing plan, and to succeed you just have to get this one right, particularly if you’re still trying to grow the product. If it’s not priced right, then you are just not giving yourself the best chance of success, and it may actually have the adverse effect on some people.

Now, I understand some grounds may cost a lot to play out of, but I see many GA ticket prices around the league being well over $40 per game, now this is just too much. The APL is better off bringing in a $30 max GA ticket price league-wide, and heavily subsiding that, rather than paying some overseas-based older players, who simply will not have the desired impact on field.

The All-Stars concept

I’d normally hate this, but I’m afraid it is here to stay. If the visit by Barca is anything to go by, these are a success. They get guaranteed good crowds, good ratings, and increase the overall interest in the game. They attract football casuals, Eurosnobs and non-football people, which is what the sport needs.

They should take these games around the country, pack out different stadiums, against world-class opposition. It’s now up to the APL to attract those people to their local A-League games. This is a gimmick, but a very much-needed one at this moment.

These are my points on what needs to be done, and most of it could be done by next season.

Roarers, do you agree or disagree?

What do you think needs to change or improve?

The Crowd Says:

2022-06-02T12:47:30+00:00

Bludger

Guest


Quite right sir! Question is how did the writers 'sustain their injuries'? Too much alcohol no doubt.

2022-06-02T02:57:41+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


The owners were lobbying hoping the Olympics might offer something, but the decision to rebuild The Gabba blindsided everyone and the legacy will go to AFL/Cricket and not football. There is a question over whether the Bakries are “uninvestable” so will never get any help - they are certainly toxic in a growing number of fans so that’s possible.

2022-06-02T00:24:14+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


of course I agree Roar needs a central stadium in Brisbane. I don't know what Roar are doing but I do expect that they lobby the city, State and Federal governments, and the FA and FQ lobby with them. I know that the RSA did some work a few years ago with the club, on a stadium (ask Waz), and personally, I have written to State and Federal ministers several times over the years. I quite like Dolphins, easy to access despite the complaints, good seating and very decent pricing. It needs a roof all round and quite obviously, with our changing weather, we need a covered stadium. The only way to fix Roar's issue, which by the way is not such a big deal relatively speaking as their crowd figures are among the best in the league (esp when you take out derbies and finals), is to win games. I guarantee you that if Roar win regularly and challenge for trophies, location and attendance will not be issues.

2022-06-02T00:11:02+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


There are way too many Roar fans saying exactly what you are saying BR fan, without ever giving any supporting facts.

2022-06-01T23:25:23+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


QLD stadiums seem to like to ripoff their tenants don't they. With the inclusion of the Dolphins into the NRL it'll make the availability for Redcliff and somewhat Suncorp even tighter too. But you hit the nail on the head at the bottom, where's the funding to build something half decent for the Roar. Are the owners lobbying or looking at potential sites...

2022-06-01T13:59:11+00:00

TheSecretScout

Roar Guru


Signed a pre contract last year, so got zilch

2022-06-01T13:29:57+00:00

Football Fan

Roar Rookie


Lionheart, do you not agree that Brisbane Roar need to be based in Brisbane and not Redcliffe? I understand the Redcliffe stadium costs way less than Suncorp and they probably would have gone broke if they stayed at Suncorp. I think the Roar and Football Queensland should really focus their efforts in lobbying the Qld government to building a 15k stadium in Brisbane, maybe renovate Perry Park, that can then be used as a headquarters for Football Qld and the Roar. BTW that Redcliffe stadium is so cheap looking anyway. How much would it possibly cost to build a 12K stadium of that quality for the Roar anyway? A drop in the ocean when you consider how much they're spending for the Olympics which will benefit cricket and AFL yet again.

2022-06-01T12:57:33+00:00

Football Fan

Roar Rookie


Hey TheSecretScout, do you know if Adelaide got anything for Yengi or did he leave a a free agent?

2022-06-01T12:43:34+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


I actually find Dolphin easy to get to because of the drive and it’s easy to park at. But it’s obvious fans haven’t taken to it in the way the club had probably hoped and the rumoured split of games between Suncorp and Dolphin next season is probably their idea of a compromise. Victory fans never seemed to like the split between two stadiums and I suspect we won’t either. I’m getting fed up of posting this - but why isn’t Stade de Perry a 10k stadium??

2022-06-01T12:39:01+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


“The problem is there are too many contributors on this forum who think they are in the know” …. are you talking about yourself because you’re presenting your opinion as facts mate :laughing:

2022-06-01T12:35:50+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


“And I think Brisbane should bite the bullet and move back to Suncorp. They’ve had no problem averaging 15k over the years and I think that’s good enough in that stadium” The problem with that is: 1: Cost - the rent was crippling the club 2: Availability - for large parts of the football season the stadium is unavailable due to concerts 3: Pitch - the pitch quality was bloody awful, mainly due to concerts. The real question imo is why Dolphin has had money to build a 10k stadium, Union gets money for a 10k stadium, AFL gets money for a 10k stadium at Springfield, Netball/NBL get a new complex and football gets …. sweet FA!?!

2022-06-01T11:15:25+00:00

Saffi

Roar Rookie


Interesting suggestions asanchez, My thoughts are: Keep the salary cap. It keeps the A League under some control. Introduce a second division on part -time wages. Entry to A League is $5m paid to the departing A League side as compensation plus $3m minimum to show you won’t collapse within your first two years. New A League teams from Canberra and Wollongong. They stay for a minimum 3 years while We sort out the second div. (by the way these new clubs have ready available rectangular grounds!). Get rid of VAR. cost savings. Domestic transfer fees payable for non -A League team recruitment/transfers. Advertise the game. Not sbs (those viewers know soccer) and not seven (it’s an AFL station). Sell the game properly. Increase the A League Women’s game. It’s a tremendous growth opportunity with THE WOMENs WORLD CUP here for gods sake. Ticket pricing, all star internationals, game scheduling and broadcasting issues will all be resolved if the above actions can be successfully implemented.

2022-05-31T08:20:17+00:00

pacman

Roar Rookie


Bludger, a couple of years ago on this site I suggested each state's NPL winners and runners up play off for promotion to the A League. Very few were in favour. Too hard.

2022-05-31T00:52:53+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


Yeah Redcliff isn't a suitable long-term option for Brisbane Roar, so what's their plan?? Have the owners stated what they're going to do in this regard... I think with a a better schedule, less midweek matches and better times we'll be able to test how much Brisbane supporters actually like going to Redcliff as we shouldn't judge any team for the season we just had with attendances. But my gut feel is they're slowly losing their supporter base who would just find it too hard or inconvenient going that far north out of the city to watch their team play. It's what's happened to SydFC over the 4 yrs at Kogarah, as time went on more and more fans just got sick of going that far out of the way. Which I'm extremely relieved to be heading back to Moore Park next season. And I think Brisbane should bite the bullet and move back to Suncorp. They've had no problem averaging 15k over the years and I think that's good enough in that stadium.

2022-05-31T00:46:19+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


It's actually surprising and embarrassing that the biggest club in the league (MV) don't have proper facilities and are not close to acquiring and building anything. Near the city is a nice to have, but they have to be realistic, SydFC's training based and HQ is based in Macquarie Park which is almost 20km from Allianz Stadium. Wanderers HQ and training is also almost 20km from their home ground. That's the nature of city based teams, land ain't cheap and lot's of it is already taken so MV should just get on with it.

2022-05-31T00:30:55+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


I'd almost be disappointed if we weren't bending the rules. :happy: How easy would it be to pay the VISA players additional money straight into their international bank accounts. Playing by the rules in terms of salary caps are for suckers, especially considering their are so many legal loopholes anyway.

2022-05-30T23:28:02+00:00

Lazza

Guest


If we're going to get rid of the salary cap why not get one of the owners to challenge it in court? It would be fun to watch the AFL and NRL go into full panic mode.

2022-05-30T09:08:26+00:00

Bludger

Guest


Are we talking a semi pro 2nd division or fully pro? After growing up with the NSL, where we had pretty much this system in the 1980s I think people are very naive. It is just trying the same things and expecting a different result. Why not just have the state leagues as a '2nd division' and have a transfer system that is fair for all? But having these community clubs up against fully pro franchises I just don't think the systems are compatible. NSL's old clubs had DECADES to work it out. They never made it to even fully pro status. Go to Europe if you want promotion and relegation and see just how well it works.

AUTHOR

2022-05-30T08:03:59+00:00

asanchez

Roar Guru


I reckon even a 5k capacity stadium is good for them at this stage. Get that joint built ASAP, and then pack that out every week, and use this to lobby govt for extra funding. They don't need 15k seats tomorrow, but maybe in 5 years time. I dont think the size of the stadiums are the issue, their location, access and a rectangular ground are more important at this stage. The stadiums that Adelaide, Perth and the Mariners play out of are perfect in all those facets. There's a really good podcast with Michael Zappone (A to Z) where he interviews Brendan Schwab, and he gives his views on expansion, and lobbying governments, which I completely agree with. In a nutshell he says that we don't deserve anything, and have to build everything from the ground up, and grow organically, eventually growing to a level where governments can no longer ignore it.

2022-05-30T07:27:33+00:00

NoMates

Roar Rookie


Maybe let Adelaide, Perth and Roar play in the Singapore league and bring in Auckland, Tassie and Canberra as replacements.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar